Share

cover art for The confusing last night of Karlie Guse

Triggered - The True Crime Podcast

The confusing last night of Karlie Guse

Season 2, Ep. 175
•

Sixteen year old Karlie Guse smoked a joint at a party, spent the night terrified that her own family was going to kill her, and by morning she had walked out the front door and vanished. She left her phone, her glasses, and her money behind. This week: the case, the recording nobody has heard, and the science that suggests it was never really about the weed at all.


Follow us: linktr.ee/triggeredthepodcast


KARLIE IS STILL MISSING.


Karlie Lain Guse was 16 years old. 5'7", 110 pounds, dark blonde hair, blue eyes, left nostril pierced. Last seen walking south along Highway 6 in Chalfant Valley, Mono County, California on the morning of October 13th, 2018, wearing a white t-shirt, grey sweatpants or jeans, and Vans.

She would be 24 today.

The FBI is offering a reward for information leading to her location.

Mono County Sheriff's Office: 760-932-5678

Email: karliegusetips@monosheriff.org

FBI Sacramento: 916-746-7000

All tips can remain anonymous.

Make sure to follow us on social media and check out everywhere you can listen at linktr.ee/triggeredthepodcast


Contact us at triggeredthepodcast.444@gmail.com

More episodes

View all episodes

  • 209. 'Til Death | Tom Randolph

    50:04||Season 3, Ep. 209
    12 Seats: The Lindsay Clancy Trial | TICKETS AVAILABLE: https://www.triggeredthepodcast.com/twelve-seats/p/lindsay-clancy-trial-mock-juryIt’s May 8, 2008, three days before Mother’s Day. Tom Randolph and his wife Sharon come home early from date night in Las Vegas. Minutes later, Tom is on the phone with 911. Sharon has been shot, there’s a masked man in the house, and Tom has shot him. The intruder turns out to be Mike Miller, the handyman Tom took under his wing.It looks like the worst night of a grieving husband’s life. Then detectives start walking the house, and the story Tom keeps telling doesn’t match what they find: a hallway with no blood, a ski mask that was never worn, and hundreds of phone calls that make no sense between a man and his handyman.This week on Triggered, we follow the investigation as it falls apart one clue at a time. It takes us through two trials, a death sentence that got thrown out, and a past that Sharon never knew about.Poor Tom. Right?🎧 Listen to Triggered wherever you get your podcasts: linktr.ee/triggeredthepodcast💬 Join the Chaos Crew (free Discord): https://discord.gg/YuEWjMzkJN ⭐ Become an Inner Circle member on Supercast: triggeredthepod.supercast.com🌐 triggeredthepodcast.com
  • 208. No body, No crime? | Suzanne Simpson

    49:11||Season 3, Ep. 208
    On October 6, 2024, Suzanne Simpson went to a party at an exclusive club in Alamo Heights, Texas. She never came home. Suzanne was a 51-year-old luxury realtor and mother of four in Olmos Park. Within days, her husband Brad was behind bars. Investigators allege that in the hours after she vanished, Brad bought cement, trash bags and disinfectant, and drove his truck near a waste facility. They say her DNA turned up on a motorized saw he’s accused of hiding. Searchers went through landfills across several counties, but Suzanne has never been found.Two years later, Brad Simpson is charged with murder and has pleaded not guilty. His defence argues there can’t be a murder case without a body. Prosecutors disagree.This week we cover the night at The Argyle, the neighbour who saw a struggle and heard screams, the business partner with an AK-47 hidden in his wall, and the warning Suzanne allegedly gave about where to look if she ever went missing.Brad Simpson is presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.🎧 Listen to Triggered wherever you get your podcasts: linktr.ee/triggeredthepodcast💬 Join the Chaos Crew (free Discord): https://discord.gg/YuEWjMzkJN⭐ Become an Inner Circle member on Supercast: triggeredthepod.supercast.com🌐 triggeredthepodcast.com
  • 207. The Gold King | Sir Harry Oakes

    01:01:55||Season 3, Ep. 207
    In 1911, Harry Oakes showed up in Kirkland Lake, Ontario, with about two dollars in his pocket. Years later, he was one of the richest men in the British Empire. Then, on a stormy night in July 1943, someone killed him in his bed in Nassau, set his body on fire, and scattered feathers over him.His best friend was sleeping eighteen feet away and says he heard nothing. The former King of England took over the investigation and flew in two Miami detectives who forgot their fingerprint kits. Then they arrested Harry’s playboy son-in-law, a “Count” who wasn’t really a Count.He was acquitted, and nobody else was ever charged. So this week, you’re the detective. We walk through the evidence, the botched investigation, the trial, and five suspects, from the best friend to the Mob. Then you tell us who did it.🎧 Listen to Triggered wherever you get your podcasts: linktr.ee/triggeredthepodcast💬 Join the Chaos Crew (free Discord): https://discord.gg/YuEWjMzkJN ⭐ Become an Inner Circle member on Supercast: triggeredthepod.supercast.com🌐 triggeredthepodcast.com
  • 206. On Three | Skylar Neese

    01:06:07||Season 3, Ep. 206
    Skylar Neese was 16, funny, fiercely loyal, and inseparable from her two best friends. On July 6, 2012, she slipped out of her family’s apartment in Star City, West Virginia, to hang out with them.She never came home.For months, the girls who were with her that night helped search for her. They posted about missing her and comforted her parents. Police first treated Skylar as a runaway, which meant no Amber Alert ever went out. The truth only came out when one of those friends finally broke.This week we get into one of the most chilling betrayals in modern true crime. We cover the friendship that went wrong, the months of lies, and the confession that blew the case open. We also talk about Skylar’s Law, the change her parents fought for so no other family would be left waiting the way they were. Plus, we have the latest on where Rachel Shoaf and Shelia Eddy are now, after another parole denial this year.Content warning: This episode discusses the murder of a teenager and includes descriptions of violence.🎧 Listen to Triggered wherever you get your podcasts: linktr.ee/triggeredthepodcast💬 Join the Chaos Crew (free Discord): https://discord.gg/YuEWjMzkJN ⭐ Become an Inner Circle member on Supercast: triggeredthepod.supercast.com🌐 triggeredthepodcast.com
  • 205. The Canadian Prophet | The Ant Hill Kids Cult

    01:01:57||Season 3, Ep. 205
    **BANTER SKIP: If you would like to skip right to the episode, being at the 12 minute mark.**In 1977, a charismatic Seventh-day Adventist convert named Roch Thériault started calling himself Moïse, Moses, and convinced a group of young Quebecers to follow him into the wilderness to wait for the end of the world. The apocalypse never came.What came instead was twelve years of control, punishment, and “healing” rituals performed with no medical training, first on a Gaspé mountainside and later in the Kawarthas near Burnt River, Ontario.This week, Chantal walks Ashley through the rise and fall of the Ant Hill Kids. We cover the death of a two-year-old, the system’s repeated failures to step in, the death of Solange Boilard on a kitchen table, and the courage of Gabrielle Lavallée, the survivor whose escape finally brought the prophet down.⚠️ Content warning: this episode contains discussion of child abuse, sexual abuse, torture, mutilation, and graphic medical descriptions. Please listen with care.🎧 Listen to Triggered wherever you get your podcasts: linktr.ee/triggeredthepodcast💬 Join the Chaos Crew (free Discord): https://discord.gg/YuEWjMzkJN ⭐ Become an Inner Circle member on Supercast: triggeredthepod.supercast.com🌐 triggeredthepodcast.com
  • 204. The Chimney | Joshua Maddux

    01:13:20||Season 3, Ep. 204
    Welcome to Season 3 of Triggered!In May 2008, 18-year-old Joshua Maddux told his sister he was going for a walk and left their home in Woodland Park, Colorado. He never came back.For seven years his family held onto hope. Josh was brilliant, creative and a gifted musician, and they told themselves he might be out there somewhere, living his life.Then, in August 2015, a demolition crew started tearing down an abandoned cabin less than a mile from the Maddux home. When they reached the stone chimney, they found him.Josh was folded inside the narrow flue with his knees above his head, wearing only a thermal shirt. The rest of his clothes and his shoes were found beside the fireplace. The coroner ruled his death an accident: a teenager who tried to get into an empty cabin through the chimney and got stuck. But the cabin’s owner doesn’t believe it, and neither do many of the people who have looked closely at this case.Why would anyone take off their clothes and then climb down a chimney? How did nobody notice for seven years? And was this really a tragic mistake, or something much darker?🎧 Listen to Triggered wherever you get your podcasts: linktr.ee/triggeredthepodcast💬 Join the Chaos Crew (free Discord): https://discord.gg/YuEWjMzkJN ⭐ Become an Inner Circle member on Supercast: triggeredthepod.supercast.com🌐 triggeredthepodcast.com
  • 203. 3:15 AM | The DeFeo Murders

    01:20:29||Season 2, Ep. 203
    3:15AMOn November 13, 1974, a young man ran into a bar on Long Island begging for help, saying his parents had been shot. When police arrived, they found six members of the DeFeo family dead in their beds, all lying face down, with no signs of a struggle. A day later, the story fell apart.This week, Chantal walks Ashley through the DeFeo murders: the troubled oldest son, the fake mob hit, the confession, and the “voices” defence. Then we head back to the house for the 28 days the next family claimed to have lived through: flies in December, a priest told to get out, a little girl’s invisible friend with red eyes, and a man who woke up at 3:15 every single night.Was it demons, drugs, or a story cooked up over a lot of bottles of wine? We pick sides.🎧 Listen to Triggered wherever you get your podcasts: linktr.ee/triggeredthepodcast💬 Join the Chaos Crew (free Discord): https://discord.gg/YuEWjMzkJN ⭐ Become an Inner Circle member on Supercast: triggeredthepod.supercast.com🌐 triggeredthepodcast.com
  • 202. I almost got kidnapped OMFG | April Millsap

    01:05:31||Season 2, Ep. 202
    In July 2014, 14-year-old April Millsap set out on her usual evening walk with her dog Penny along the Macomb Orchard Trail in Armada, Michigan. It was a small town, a familiar path, a routine she’d done nearly every night. She never made it home. Hours later, Penny led two joggers to April’s body in a ditch just off the trail. Before she died, April sent a text that would haunt everyone who read it: “I almost got kidnapped OMFG.”This week we walk through April’s last evening, the man on the motorcycle witnesses saw her talking to, and the trail of evidence (cell phone pings, a shoe print, a helmet, and an ex-girlfriend’s testimony) that led investigators to James VanCallis Jr. No DNA, no confession, and a killer who still insists he was framed. We get into how prosecutors built their case, what a jury decided, and the mother who looked her daughter’s killer in the eye and told him exactly what he took.Justice for April. 💜🎧 Listen to Triggered wherever you get your podcasts: linktr.ee/triggeredthepodcast💬 Join the Chaos Crew (free Discord): https://discord.gg/YuEWjMzkJN ⭐ Become an Inner Circle member on Supercast: triggeredthepod.supercast.com🌐 triggeredthepodcast.com
  • 201. Invisible Men | The Matamoros Cult Murders

    01:08:38||Season 2, Ep. 201
    Spring break, 1989. University of Texas pre-med student Mark Kilroy crosses the border into Matamoros, Mexico, for a night of bar hopping with his friends. By morning, he’s gone.What his family uncovers is something no one could have imagined: a charismatic, Miami-born fortune teller named Adolfo de Jesús Constanzo, who convinced Mexican drug traffickers that human sacrifice would make them bulletproof and invisible to police. At his side was Sara Aldrete, an honour roll college student living a double life as his high priestess, La Madrina.This week, Chantal walks Ashley through the story of the Narcosatanists: a remote desert ranch, an iron cauldron, a man who drove straight through a police checkpoint because he believed no one could see him, and a final standoff in Mexico City that ended exactly the way the Godfather wanted.Content warning: this episode discusses ritual murder, mutilation, and drug violence.🎧 Listen to Triggered wherever you get your podcasts: linktr.ee/triggeredthepodcast💬 Join the Chaos Crew (free Discord): https://discord.gg/YuEWjMzkJN ⭐ Become an Inner Circle member on Supercast: triggeredthepod.supercast.com🌐 triggeredthepodcast.com