Share

cover art for Ep 58: How to Give Gen Z Employees Feedback That Actually Lands

The Gen Mess with Tess

Ep 58: How to Give Gen Z Employees Feedback That Actually Lands

You gave the feedback carefully. You were constructive. You even thought through every word. And they still shut down.


If you're a manager or HR leader wondering why feedback conversations keep going sideways, this episode is the one you've been waiting for.


Tess Brigham breaks down the neuroscience of why feedback feels like a threat, why Gen Z is particularly activated by it (hint: it makes complete psychological sense), and why the feedback models most leaders were trained on were built for a different era.


You'll walk away with a completely different understanding of what's happening in that room and three concrete shifts you can make starting with your very next conversation.


In this episode:
  • Why the brain experiences feedback as a social threat, and what that means for your employees
  • David Rock's SCARF model and the five psychological domains a single feedback conversation can trigger simultaneously
  • Why Gen Z carries a higher baseline of anxiety into these conversations than any previous generation, and why that's not the same as being fragile
  • The critical difference between feedback landing as information versus landing as a verdict
  • Why technically correct feedback still fails when the environment isn't psychologically safe
  • Three shifts to make right now: establishing safety first, separating behavior from identity, and giving space to process
  • The fourth shift most managers skip, and why it changes everything

CHAPTER TIMESTAMPS

00:00 — The feedback conversation that went sideways — and the question every manager has

01:00 — "Can't they just take feedback like an adult?" — naming what nobody says out loud

01:45 — The neuroscience: why feedback is a threat, not just information

02:27 — The SCARF model: the five domains your brain monitors for safety

03:30 — What a single feedback conversation triggers simultaneously in the brain

04:45 — Why this hits Gen Z harder — and why it's not about fragility

05:30 — How social media turned their adolescence into a constant performance evaluation

06:15 — Graduating into a pandemic: what Gen Z never got from their first jobs

07:00 — When criticism lands as a verdict, not information

07:45 — A real client story: the five-minute feedback that caused four days of dread

09:00 — Why the old feedback playbook is quietly breaking down

09:28 — The broken assumptions behind the feedback sandwich and annual reviews

11:00 — Three shifts to make starting with your next conversation

11:15 — Shift 1: Establish safety before you say anything critical

13:00 — Shift 2: Separate behavior from identity — out loud, every single time

14:30 — Shift 3: Give them time and space to process before expecting a response

16:20 — Why "closing" a feedback conversation is the wrong instinct

17:30 — The fourth shift: check your own nervous system before you walk in

19:00 — Why walking in frustrated defeats the entire conversation

20:00 — The bottom line: what managers who are getting this right actually understand

21:00 — Free resources: the Gen Z Playbook + related episodes


Download Tess's free Gen Z Playbook at TessBrigham.com.


Related episodes:

Episode 52 (Why Gen Z Keeps Asking Questions at Work)

Episode 47 (The Manager Effect | Why Your Boss Impacts Your Mental Health More Than You Think with Ashley Herd)

More episodes

View all episodes

  • Ep 57: AI in the Workplace - Will AI Replace Jobs? with Erin Turnmeyer

    45:08|
    Is AI really replacing jobs, or are we misunderstanding AI's role at work?In this episode of The Gen Mess with Tess, Tess Brigham sits down with People Operations executive Erin Turnmeyer to break down what leaders, employees, and organizations are getting wrong about AI in the workplace.With 15+ years of experience building talent systems, including time at the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, Erin brings a data-driven perspective on how AI, automation, and analytics are reshaping work.💡 In this episode, we cover:Why AI is a force multiplier, not a replacementThe real reason companies are making AI-related layoffsWhat tasks should (and should NOT) be automatedHow to use AI without losing the human element at workWhy resume screening with AI can backfirePractical ways to start using AI without feeling overwhelmedHow early-career professionals can stand out in an AI-driven worldIf you’ve been feeling anxious, confused, or curious about AI, this conversation will help you rethink what’s actually happening—and how to adapt without fear.Whether you’re a leader, job seeker, or just trying to keep up with the future of work, this episode will give you clarity and practical takeaways.Timestamps00:00 – Intro: “Fixing the mess vs living in it”00:42 – Meet Erin Turnmeyer (People Ops + AI perspective)01:05 – From chem bio weapons analyst → HR leader03:10 – What people get wrong about AI at work04:00 – “AI is a force multiplier, not a replacement”05:00 – Fear-based headlines & why they’re misleading06:00 – Why fear blocks people from learning AI07:30 – How companies fail at AI adoption08:15 – Real example: teaching AI internally at work09:30 – What AI should NOT replace (human touchpoints)10:30 – What to automate vs keep human11:10 – Why AI resume screening is flawed13:00 – Smart ways to use AI in recruiting (without bias)15:00 – Removing “administrative weight” from work16:00 – Will AI lead to layoffs—or growth?17:00 – The real opportunity: 20% more strategic thinking18:10 – Why companies must allow time to learn AI19:20 – Advice for early-career professionals20:00 – Using AI as a daily learning coach21:30 – Don’t outsource your thinking23:00 – Could AI finally deliver work-life balance?24:00 – The 4-day workweek conversation25:00 – Real-world AI use cases (healthcare, systems, etc.)26:00 – What happens to jobs AI can fully replace?27:00 – What actually gets someone hired today28:00 – Why AI-generated resumes are hurting candidates30:00 – How to use AI correctly for resumes32:00 – Training AI to sound like you34:00 – Spotting AI-generated applications instantly35:00 – How young professionals can “train” AI on themselves37:00 – Using AI as a thinking partner (not a cheerleader)38:00 – Trust but verify: why sources matter40:00 – First step: how to start using AI today41:00 – Unexpected tip: use AI for shopping decisions43:00 – Final thoughts + where to find ErinConnect with Tess at tessbrigham.comSubscribe to Erin's Substack, AI for Human Operators, at hrai.substack.com
  • Ep 56: Why Work Feels So Personal (Part 2) Early Career Stress: What Young Professionals Are Really Experiencing

    09:33|
    No one really warns you how psychologically hard early career can be.You learn how to write a resume, interview, and get hired, but almost no one explains what it feels like once you’re inside the workplace. You're being evaluated constantly, questioning yourself, guessing the rules, and trying to build confidence without experience.In this episode of The Gen Mess with Tess, Tess Brigham explains why the beginning of your career can feel so mentally intense, and why that experience is often misunderstood. She breaks down the psychological weight of uncertainty, self-doubt, comparison, unclear expectations, and why many young professionals incorrectly assume they are the problem when they are often responding normally to a demanding environment.Tess also addresses something leaders need to hear clearly: being early career does not mean someone should tolerate unhealthy behavior, poor emotional regulation, or unclear leadership.This is Part 2 of Tess’s solo series on the psychology of work and why younger employees need more clarity, not more criticism.Chapter Timestamps00:00 Why early career hits harder than expected01:05 Learning who you are while being evaluated02:20 Why young professionals internalize stress03:05 High expectations, low control, constant comparison04:20 Why unclear environments create self-doubt04:50 What young employees should never normalize05:30 Why yelling at work should not be accepted06:15 Discomfort vs unhealthy environments06:50 How to separate mistakes from identity07:40 What leaders owe early-career employees Be sure to subscribe so you never miss a weekly episode. To learn more, or to Shop available resources, visit tessbrigham.com
  • Ep 55: 3 Ways to Take Back Your Morning Routine with Movement, Mindfulness, and Mastery with Amy Landino

    52:02|
    Think you're not a morning person? Think again.This week, Tess sits down with Amy Landino, bestselling author, content creator, and founder of Vlog Boss Studios. Together, they blow up everything you think you know about morning routines, productivity, and what it actually means to start your day on your own terms.Amy's newly expanded book, Good Morning, Good Life, isn't about waking up at 5am or turning your morning into an Instagram aesthetic. It's about reclaiming ownership of your day before the world gets a vote, and her simple three-bucket framework (Movement, Mindfulness, and Mastery) makes that possible for anyone, in any season of life.Tess and Amy also get into the messy generational stuff: why Millennials were conditioned to believe "work harder" was always the answer, why a six-figure business might actually be the wrong goal, and the moment Amy told her dad she'd already made $90K that year and watched him go completely speechless.In this episode:Why your morning routine is probably built around someone else's agendaThe key difference between starting your day "on offense" vs. "on defense"Amy's three-bucket framework: Movement, Mindfulness & Mastery explained simplyThe real reason you're "not a morning person" (it's not what you think)Why a six-figure business might be the worst goal you're chasing right nowThe Millennial financial reality: student loans, a broken housing market, and boomer advice that no longer appliesHow self-compassion and accountability actually work together, not against each otherAmy Landino's book Good Morning, Good Life is available now. DM Amy on Instagram @AmyLandino the word "Tess" to receive her free Extraordinary Action Framework.CHAPTER TIMESTAMPS00:00 — Welcome & Amy Landino introduction01:00 — Amy's origin story: moving out at 18 and the "there's gotta be a better way" mindset04:00 — The wedding video that started everything — and how YouTube changed her life07:00 — What people get wrong about morning routines (hint: Instagram flex culture)09:30 — Checking email vs. checking your goals: offense vs. defense12:00 — Why you apologize for not replying fast enough — and why you need to stop13:15 — Is Good Morning, Good Life the Gen Z version of Miracle Morning? Tess makes the case16:45 — The three-bucket framework: Movement, Mindfulness & Mastery19:20 — Tess's morning confession: sitting with her dogs, and finally giving herself permission21:00 — "I'm not a morning person" — the #1 objection, completely reframed24:00 — "But I have kids" — excuse #2, and Amy's surprisingly honest answer28:45 — The Extraordinary Action Framework: DM Amy on Instagram to get it free29:20 — Self-compassion + accountability: why they're not opposites33:45 — Screw "realistic" — why shooting for the unrealistic actually makes sense34:45 — Hot take: Why Amy tells clients with six-figure businesses to just go get a job40:00 — Generational spotlight: Millennials as the internet's guinea pigs42:30 — Student loans, the housing market, and what Millennials actually inherited47:20 — Boomer advice vs. Millennial reality — a tension that's very, very real48:00 — The $90K moment: Amy's dad, and why the people who love you don't always know what's possible for youSUBSCRIBE to The Gen Mess with Tess podcast for weekly insights on workplace culture, generational challenges, and relationship advice.
  • Ep 54: Why Work Feels So Personal (Part 1) The Psychology Behind Stress, Feedback, and Gen Z at Work

    10:36|
    Why does one vague comment from your boss stay in your head all day? Why does being left off a meeting invite suddenly feel personal? Why can work feel emotionally exhausting even when you’re technically “doing fine”?In this episode of The Gen Mess with Tess, Tess Brigham explains why work is never just about tasks, productivity, or performance—it’s psychological.From feedback and comparison to belonging, safety, and identity, Tess breaks down what’s happening beneath the surface when work stress feels bigger than the moment itself. She also explains why so many leaders misread performance issues that are actually clarity issues, communication issues, or nervous-system responses.If you’ve ever replayed a Slack message, questioned yourself after feedback, or wondered why Gen Z seems to experience work differently, this episode explains why.This is part 1 of a 2-part solo series on the emotional reality of work, leadership, and what younger employees are actually experiencing in today’s workplace. Part 2 will be published next week. Chapter Timestamps00:00 Why work is more psychological than most people realize01:10 Why your brain treats work stress like threat02:20 Why vague feedback feels personal03:15 Work, identity, and self-worth04:10 Why comparison intensifies workplace anxiety04:45 What leaders misunderstand about Gen Z retention06:00 Why Gen Z isn’t “too sensitive”07:10 Communication problems are often anxiety problems08:05 Why retention is a mental health issue09:00 The key question leaders should ask instead visit tessbrigham.com to learn more
  • Ep 53: How High Achievers Burn Out Twice: Stress, Joy at Work, and What Leaders Still Get Wrong with Amy Leneker

    53:34|
    In Episode 53 of The Gen Mess with Tess, Tess Brigham sits down with Amy Leneker, founder and CEO of the Center for Joyful Work, to explore why burnout keeps happening even to highly successful leaders who know better.Amy has helped more than 100,000 leaders and teams, including Fortune 100 companies, rethink leadership, workplace stress, and employee well-being. A former public policy executive and recovering workaholic, Amy shares how burning out twice forced her to confront the internal patterns that kept driving overwork, achievement, and chronic stress.Together, Tess and Amy unpack why burnout is not simply about workload; it is often tied to identity, workplace systems, leadership culture, and the stories people tell themselves about success.This conversation explores:why high performers often confuse overworking with worthhow burnout can repeat even after changing jobswhat workplace stress is doing to leadership pipelineswhy younger employees are redefining ambitionhow Gen Z experiences stress differently at workwhy recognition and appreciation matter more than many leaders realizethe three conditions that create joy at work: meaning, mattering, and momentumhow AI may force a new era of critical thinking in leadershipAmy also shares findings from her national workforce research showing that employees increasingly need joy at work to perform well, yet many leaders still operate inside systems that reward exhaustion instead of sustainability.For HR leaders, managers, and executives, this episode offers a practical framework for understanding employee burnout, generational tension, workplace stress, leadership development, and what healthy ambition may need to look like next.If your organization is asking why employees are disengaged, overwhelmed, or pulling back from leadership, this conversation explains what may be underneath it.Chapters with Timestamps00:00 – Why Amy Leneker Burned Out Twice02:14 – The Stress Story High Achievers Carry04:12 – Why Leadership Still Rewards Burnout06:45 – Why Joy Belongs in the Future of Leadership08:21 – Gen Z, Stress, and New Definitions of Work11:52 – Are Younger Workers Redefining Ambition?16:15 – The Three Conditions That Create Joy at Work20:23 – Why Gen Z Needs Appreciation More Than Leaders Think25:36 – The Exercise That Changed Amy’s Career31:13 – Parenting, Leadership, and Invisible Overwork35:01 – Why Workplace Systems Keep Breaking People40:13 – AI, Critical Thinking, and the Future of Work
  • Ep 52: Why Gen Z Keeps Asking Questions at Work

    15:35|
    In Episode 52 of The Gen Mess with Tess, Tess explores one of the most misunderstood workplace dynamics right now: why younger employees keep asking for transparency, and why many leaders misread that as entitlement.While transparency is often described as a Gen Z workplace preference, Tess argues it is something much deeper: a psychological response to growing up in a world where trust has become increasingly fragile.From financial instability and public institutional failures to social media fabrication, layoffs over Zoom, and the rise of AI, younger workers have developed a sharper need to understand what is real, what is changing, and what leaders are not saying.In this episode, Tess explains why transparency is no longer just a communication style. and is now the foundation of trust in modern organizations.Why Gen Z’s questions are often about safety, not defianceHow uncertainty activates worst-case thinking in the brainWhy silence from leadership often increases workplace anxietyThe difference between transparency and oversharingHow honesty improves motivation, engagement, and retentionWhy every generation benefits when leaders communicate clearlyFor HR leaders and managers, this episode offers a practical lens on why communication gaps create disengagement — and why explaining reality clearly may be one of the most powerful leadership tools available today.Because in today’s workplace, transparency is not a bonus. It is how trust gets built.Chapters with Timestamps00:00 – Why Transparency Keeps Coming Up in Every Workplace Conversation 02:20 – Why Gen Z Grew Up Distrusting Systems 04:38 – What the Brain Does When Information Is Missing 06:15 – Why Transparency Matters More Than Perfection 07:04 – A CEO’s Silence During Uncertainty 08:45 – How Honesty Calms the Nervous System 09:26 – Why Motivation Drops When Trust Is Unclear 10:45 – Transparency vs Oversharing 11:46 – Why Every Generation Needs More Clarity 13:10 – The Leadership Advantage of Honest Communication 14:04 – Final Takeaway: Transparency Rebuilds Trust
  • Ep 51: Why Fast Growth Breaks Company Culture

    59:10|
    In Episode 51 of The Gen Mess with Tess, Tess is joined by Corrine Ishio, founder of My Working Soul, to explore a challenge many fast-growing companies face but rarely talk about: scaling the business faster than the culture can keep up.When organizations grow quickly, hiring often becomes reactive. Leaders focus on roles and results, while the human side of the company quietly gets lost. The result? Misalignment, disengagement, and teams that no longer feel connected to the mission that once energized them.Corrine shares her perspective from years working in talent, recruiting, and HR; helping founders and leadership teams rethink how they hire, communicate, and define culture during periods of rapid growth.In this conversation, Tess and Corrine explore:Why companies struggle to maintain culture as they scaleThe complicated role HR plays between employees and leadershipHow generational misunderstandings shape today’s workplaceWhy Gen Z communication patterns are confusing many managersThe influence of social media on workplace behavior and identityWhy purpose is becoming central to work in the AI eraThey also discuss how leaders can create healthier workplaces by focusing less on rigid definitions of culture and more on communication, self-awareness, and intentional hiring. Because when companies grow quickly, it’s easy to forget the most important part of any organization: the humans building it.Chapters (Timestamps)00:00 – Introduction to Corrine Ishio & My Working Soul 01:05 – Corrine’s Path Into HR & Human-Centered Work 04:00 – What HR Actually Does (vs. what people think it does) 07:00 – Why HR Often Feels Stuck Between Employees & Companies 11:00 – The “Human” Lens Inside Business Operations 13:00 – The Meaning Behind “My Working Soul” 17:00 – Why Culture Breaks When Companies Grow Quickly 20:30 – What a Healthy Workplace Actually Looks Like 23:00 – Communication Differences Across Generations 29:30 – Why Younger Workers Are Often Misunderstood 34:30 – Purpose, Work, and the AI Era 38:30 – Are Younger Employees Harder to Manage? 43:00 – Millennials, Social Media, and Cultural Fragmentation 49:00 – Safety, Identity, and the Digital Workplace
  • Ep 50: Let Go of the Outcome

    18:50|
    In Episode 50 of The Gen Mess with Tess, Tess explores a dynamic that quietly derails high performers at every level: the moment work starts to feel like a test.When every meeting feels evaluative and every decision feels like it determines your worth, anxiety rises, and performance often drops. Tess unpacks why this happens and why the solution isn’t caring less, but redefining what actually belongs to you.Drawing from her clinical work with emerging leaders, she breaks down:Why over-focusing on outcomes increases anxiety and self-consciousnessThe psychological difference between effort and approvalHow new managers get stuck trying to predict reactionsWhy Gen Z struggles uniquely in a metrics-driven cultureThe mindset shift that restores confidence, clarity, and flowFrom a first-time manager learning to lead without control, to unexpected lessons from Olympic figure skating and competitive design, Tess illustrates one central truth:Your job is the effort. The outcome was never yours to manage.For HR leaders and executives, this episode is also a leadership lens. When organizations unintentionally create constant evaluation environments, employees tighten up — and innovation suffers. If you’re navigating pressure, perfectionism, or performance anxiety — this episode will help you rethink control and reconnect with your best work.Chapters with Timestamps00:00 – Welcome: When Work Starts to Feel Like a Test 02:00 – Why Anxiety Increases When Outcomes Feel Personal 04:30 – What “Letting Go of the Outcome” Actually Means 06:00 – Effort vs. Approval: The Critical Distinction 07:30 – Case Study: Brittany’s Transition to Management 11:00 – The Office Hours Experiment 13:30 – Changing Your Relationship to Response 15:30 – Performance Pressure & Young Professionals 18:00 – The Gen Z Metrics Trap 21:00 – Why Measured Lives Create Outcome Attachment 23:30 – Flow State & Releasing Control 26:00 – Care Deeply About What’s Yours 28:30 – Final Reflection: Own the Effort, Release the Rest