Share

cover art for 913 Eisen's Vow

Roleplay Rescue

913 Eisen's Vow

Season 9, Ep. 13
•

In April 1975, a scant 13 months after the publication of Dungeons & Dragons, Gary Gygax asked Sandy Eisen a question that elicited a response which I think many modern gamers would find surprising. Writing in Europa Issue 6-8, at the end of his second article on “How to set up your Dungeons & Dragons campaign”, Gygax picks up on a comment from an earlier issue of the ‘zine in which Eisen had stated that D&D was not really as open-ended as it seemed to be. Gygax wanted to know why Eisen felt this way and so he did the thing that good creatives do: he asked Eisen why. The reply Eisen gave ignited a debate which we, some 45 years on, have forgotten. This came to be known as Eisen's Vow.


Roleplay Rescue Details:

Roleplay Rescue Theme Song and incidental music by TJ Drennon.

Voice Message: anchor.fm/rpgrescue/message

Email: hello@rpgrescue.com

Patreon: patreon.com/rpgrescue 

Blog: roleplayrescue.com 

MeWe Group: mewe.com/join/roleplayrescue (or search "Roleplay Rescue")

Buy Che Webster a Coffee: ko-fi.com/cwebster

More episodes

View all episodes

  • 2. The Someday Game

    23:26||Season 19, Ep. 2
    Is there a game you’ve been wanting to run for years – maybe even decades – that’s never quite made it to the table? What is it that keeps stopping you? And should you be building it anyway, before you’ve even got a group to play it?For over 40 years, Traveller has been the itch I never quite manage to scratch. This time I dig into why it keeps stalling, revisit some wise words from Bob Loftin of SAFCOcast, and go back to the books to work out what actually draws me in – before sharing a very rough first draft of a high concept inspired by the Bronze Age Collapse. Plus, Jason Hobbs sets the record straight on where “Depression Lies” really came from.Thanks to Jason for the Discord message, and to Bob for the interview from Season 11. Links:Gaming Desires 2020 (blog post, Jan 2020): http://roleplayrescue.com/2020/01/19/gaming-desires-2020/ S11E9 Traveller With Bob Loftin (17 Sep 2022): https://shows.acast.com/roleplayrescue/episodes/traveller-with-bob-loftin SAFCOcast (Bob Loftin):https://safcocast.com Random Screed (Jason Hobbs): https://creators.spotify.com/pod/profile/jason-hobbs/ Arbiter of Worlds (Alexander Macris): https://arbiterofworlds.substack.com/aboutRoleplay Rescue Details:Voice Message:speakpipe.com/roleplayrescuePatreon:patreon.com/rpgrescue Email:roleplayrescue@pm.meBlog:roleplayrescue.com Bluesky Social:https://bsky.app/profile/ubiquitousrat.bsky.socialLogo and artwork by MJ Hiblen:https://www.patreon.com/MJHiblenART/Merch? --> T-Shirts by Roleplay Rescue | TeePublic
  • 1. Depression Lies

    26:33||Season 19, Ep. 1
    What do you do when your own head tells you the game is doomed? What if the evidence says otherwise, and you still can't hear it? And what happens if, just this once, you don't pull the plug?Roleplay Rescue is back for Season 19, just ahead of the show’s 8th anniversary. After a week of (constructively) critical feedback, a player leaving, and a 2am voice telling me to hang up my hat, I take a hard look at the "Flaky GM" reflex that’s killed so many of my campaigns. With Carol Vivyan’s Unhelpful Thinking Habits sheet in hand and the Sentinel weighing the evidence, this time I’m not quitting.Thanks to Jason Hobbs and the players in my Karameikos campaign for inspiring me to get back to the mic.Oh, and it's PHQ-9, not PDQ-9... that's what you get when you don't script your episode.Game on!Links:Random Screed (Jason Hobbs): https://creators.spotify.com/pod/profile/jason-hobbs/Hobbs & Friends of the OSR: https://open.spotify.com/show/3Z06uW61ALuwkhymBytQ2C?si=66bafcc4281d49eaUnhelpful Thinking Habits (Carol Vivyan, 2009): https://www.getselfhelp.co.uk/unhelpful.htmOur RPR Discord is via Patreon (see below).Roleplay Rescue Details:Voice Message:speakpipe.com/roleplayrescuePatreon:patreon.com/rpgrescue Email:roleplayrescue@pm.meBlog:roleplayrescue.com Bluesky Social:https://bsky.app/profile/ubiquitousrat.bsky.socialLogo and artwork by MJ Hiblen:https://www.patreon.com/MJHiblenART/Merch? --> T-Shirts by Roleplay Rescue | TeePublic
  • 7. Evil Jeff... The Notes Behind the Screen

    01:03:40||Season 18, Ep. 7
    Welcome to the Summer Conversations, a short series of podcasts in which I welcome a guest who brings their own topic of interest and we have a chat. The recordings are done in under one hour, barely edited, and released without fanfare.Episode 7: The Notes Behind the Screen — Campaign Journals in the Digital AgeHow do you keep six years of campaign lore from collapsing into chaos? Che and Evil Jeff compare notes — literally — on how they organise their RPG material. Jeff walks through his Obsidian setup for local, linked note-taking, while Che shares his journey from Campaign Logger to Gemini Notebook and LLM-assisted session writeups. Along the way they tackle NPC management, reaction rolls, extracting material from sourcebooks, and the elephant in the room: can AI tools help you run a better game without selling your data to the highest bidder? From pen-and-paper purists to encrypted digital workflows — this one's for every GM who's ever lost a crucial detail in a folder they can't find.Big thanks to Evil Jeff for raising the question.Game on!Roleplay Rescue Details:Voice Message:speakpipe.com/roleplayrescuePatreon:patreon.com/rpgrescue Email:roleplayrescue@pm.meBlogroleplayrescue.com Bluesky Social:https://bsky.app/profile/ubiquitousrat.bsky.socialMerchandise via TeePublic:https://tee.pub/lic/kpgigrK23l4Logo and artwork by MJ Hiblen:https://www.patreon.com/MJHiblenART/
  • 6. Jon McNally... Playing Well With Others

    01:02:36||Season 18, Ep. 6
    Welcome to the Summer Conversations, a short series of podcasts in which I welcome a guest who brings their own topic of interest and we have a chat. The recordings are done in under one hour, barely edited, and released without fanfare.Episode 6: Playing Well With Others — The Art of a Long-Running TableHow do you keep a six-player campaign going for six years without burning out? John McNally joins Che to talk about what makes a table thrive over the long haul — regular attendance, genuine fellowship, and players who show up for each other, not just for loot. We dig into the qualities of good players (listen more than you roll, engage the shared world, not just the mechanisms), how vulnerability can deepen your GMing without spilling into real-life drama, and the "mask" that separates in-character emotion from out-of-table relationships. From backyard Friday Night Fantasy sessions to knowing when newer players don't need perfect rules to tell great stories — this is the wrap-up episode, and it's about the people at your table, not the game itself.Thanks to Jon for coming on the show!Game on!Roleplay Rescue Details:Voice Message:speakpipe.com/roleplayrescuePatreon:patreon.com/rpgrescue Email:roleplayrescue@pm.meBlogroleplayrescue.com Bluesky Social:https://bsky.app/profile/ubiquitousrat.bsky.socialLogo and artwork by MJ Hiblen:https://www.patreon.com/MJHiblenART/
  • 5. Alex Marsh... Faith at the Table

    01:03:30||Season 18, Ep. 5
    Welcome to the Summer Conversations, a short series of podcasts in which I welcome a guest who brings their own topic of interest and we have a chat. The recordings are done in under one hour, barely edited, and released without fanfare.Episode 5: Faith at the Table — Religion, Belief, and the Spiritual in RPGsWhat happens when your real-world faith walks through the door of your game? Alex Marsh joins Che for a conversation that goes deep — from how D&D's cleric class handles the divine to Ars Magica's unflinching take on medieval Christianity and RuneQuest's living paganism. Along the way, Che opens up about his own journey from atheism to Orthodox Christianity and how that shapes the way he builds religion into his worlds. No superficial flavour text here — this is about making faith feel real, messy, and woven into the bones of your setting. Pentacles optional.Thanks to Alex for coming on the show!Game on!Roleplay Rescue Details:Voice Message:speakpipe.com/roleplayrescuePatreon:patreon.com/rpgrescue Email:roleplayrescue@pm.meBlogroleplayrescue.com Bluesky Social:https://bsky.app/profile/ubiquitousrat.bsky.socialLogo and artwork by MJ Hiblen:https://www.patreon.com/MJHiblenART/
  • 4. Brian McKay... Building a Gaming Club That Lasts

    50:45||Season 18, Ep. 4
    Welcome to the Summer Conversations, a short series of podcasts in which I welcome a guest who brings their own topic of interest and we have a chat. The recordings are done in under one hour, barely edited, and released without fanfare.Episode 4: Finding Your Table — Building a Gaming Club That LastsHow do you grow a tabletop community from twenty strangers into seventy-one paying members with two regular game nights? Brian McKay joins Che to share how the Northside Adventure Gamers Association in Brisbane pulled it off — incorporating as a nonprofit, securing a permanent home in a state school library, and running tables across everything from D&D 5e to Cthulhu to Dungeon Crawl Classics. Plus: managing player flow between tables, keeping table identities intact, and why finding your own space changes everything about how people show up at the game. This one's for anyone who's dreamed of building more than just a campaign — this is about building a home for other players too.Big thanks to Brian for coming on the show!NAGA Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/NorthsideAdventureGamersNAGA Public listing of games: https://public.naga.net.au/NAGA website to log in and book games: https://login.naga.net.au/index.php#Game on!Roleplay Rescue Details:Voice Message:speakpipe.com/roleplayrescuePatreon:patreon.com/rpgrescue Email:roleplayrescue@pm.meBlogroleplayrescue.com Bluesky Social:https://bsky.app/profile/ubiquitousrat.bsky.socialLogo and artwork by MJ Hiblen:https://www.patreon.com/MJHiblenART/
  • 3. Jason Connerley... Solo Skirmish!

    54:28||Season 18, Ep. 3
    Welcome to the Summer Conversations, a short series of podcasts in which I welcome a guest who brings their own topic of interest and we have a chat. The recordings are done in under one hour, barely edited, and released without fanfare.Episode 3: Solo Skirmish — Where Wargaming Meets RoleplayingEver wished you could scratch that RPG itch without rounding up a whole group? Jason joins Che to explore how skirmish wargames like Five Parsecs from Home bridge the gap between solo tabletop gaming and full roleplaying. From programmed enemy "AI" that frees you to focus on your own character, to persistent worlds and character development in a lighter package — this is a conversation about what happens when the old wargaming DNA in RPGs resurfaces as something you can play alone at your kitchen table. Perfect for busy schedules, quiet nights, or sparking ideas for your next campaign.Game on!Roleplay Rescue Details:Voice Message:speakpipe.com/roleplayrescuePatreon:patreon.com/rpgrescue Email:roleplayrescue@pm.meBlogroleplayrescue.com Bluesky Social:https://bsky.app/profile/ubiquitousrat.bsky.socialLogo and artwork by MJ Hiblen:https://www.patreon.com/MJHiblenART/
  • 2. Patrick Mullen... Steal This Idea!

    59:53||Season 18, Ep. 2
    Welcome to the Summer Conversations, a short series of podcasts in which I welcome a guest who brings their own topic of interest and we have a chat. The recordings are done in under one hour, barely edited, and released without fanfare.Episode 2: Steal This Idea — How to Create Original Worlds Without Losing Your MindWhat does it mean to "steal" from your inspirations instead of copying them? Pat Mullen joins Che to unpack Baudrillard's concept of simulcra and pastiche, arguing that mature creators should adapt rather than imitate. From adapting Dashiell Hammett's Red Harvest for a Star Trek campaign to building worlds that feel organically lived-in rather than assembled from IP fragments, this conversation digs into how research, historical accuracy, and deep immersion create authenticity. No pastiche, no shortcuts — just worlds that breathe.Big thanks to Patrick Mullen of GURPStalk for coming on the show.Game on!Roleplay Rescue Details:Voice Message:speakpipe.com/roleplayrescuePatreon:patreon.com/rpgrescue Email:roleplayrescue@pm.meBlogroleplayrescue.com Bluesky Social:https://bsky.app/profile/ubiquitousrat.bsky.socialLogo and artwork by MJ Hiblen:https://www.patreon.com/MJHiblenART/
  • 1. Arlen Walker on... Big Battles in RPG

    01:01:20||Season 18, Ep. 1
    Welcome to the Summer Conversations, a short series of podcasts in which I welcome a guest who brings their own topic of interest and we have a chat. The recordings are done in under one hour, barely edited, and released without fanfare. Episode 1: Running Big Battles Without Losing Your PlayersHow do you run a battlefield with hundreds of combatants without turning your RPG session into a war game? Che and Arlen explore strategies for scaling combat beyond the usual skirmish, from positioning players as specialist units and scouts to using historical battles like Hastings as inspiration. Plus: keeping player agency alive when the stakes are army-sized, crafting authentic chaos through limited information, and letting strategy—not dice rolls—decide the fate of empires.Big thanks to Arlen Walker of Live From Pellam's Wasteland. Game on!Roleplay Rescue Details:Voice Message:speakpipe.com/roleplayrescuePatreon:patreon.com/rpgrescue Email:roleplayrescue@pm.meBlogroleplayrescue.com Bluesky Social:https://bsky.app/profile/ubiquitousrat.bsky.socialLogo and artwork by MJ Hiblen:https://www.patreon.com/MJHiblenART/