Share

cover art for Prometheus (2012)

Review It Yourself

Prometheus (2012)

Sarah is back! She and Sean finally discuss one of their oddly favourite films, Prometheus (2012).


Discussion Points:

-Sean likes this film, but can see it's faults.

-Sarah really appreciates the story's set-up and the unusual landscape.

-The film's aesthetics and themes versus the execution and uneven tone.

-Sarah loves films where people grapple with their faith.

-Sarah's recollections of watching the med-pod scene.

-The incredibly awful line reads.

-Sarah loved the well-rounded character of Doctor Elizabeth Shaw.

-Sean and Sarah discuss Alien: Romulus (2024).


Raised Questions:

-Is this film trying to insult your intelligence?

-Does every tie-in with the Alien franchise weaken the direction that Prometheus was trying to take?

-Is the script "too hand-hold-y"?

-Does the film feel over-edited to you?

-Is the crew of 17 too big?

-Why does humanity seek answers?

-Is the script "too ham-hocked"?

-Is David infatuated with Elizabeth Shaw?

-Why doesn't Idris Elba's character do anything until the end?

-What happens if Archaeologists find the Engineer's robe?


Time Stamps:

0:06 Welcome to Review It Yourself

1:23 The Long-Awaited Prometheus Review

7:21 The Film's Opening and Visuals

12:38 Themes of Creation and Faith

16:18 Exploring the Characters and Their Dynamics

20:59 The Engineers and Their Significance

25:59 The Unfolding of the Plot

29:33 The Role of David and AI Commentary

32:41 Critique of Character Development

34:51 Action vs. Atmosphere in Storytelling

35:50 The Philosophical Questions Raised

37:03 The Flaws and Strengths of Prometheus

44:43 Love, Relationships, and Their Portrayal

49:01 Conclusion: A Mixed Bag of Ideas

1:14:10 Character Introductions

1:15:23 David's Understanding of Love

1:20:58 Quarantine Procedures

1:23:42 The Importance of Emotional Reactions

1:29:30 The Horrors of Creation

1:30:27 Themes of Control and Gender

1:37:48 The Nature of Faith

1:47:18 The Engineers' Intentions

1:52:39 The Final Confrontation

1:58:08 The Complexity of Faith

2:09:14 A Mixed Bag of Themes

2:18:17 The Implications of Scientific Discovery

2:20:14 The Value of Long-Form Discussions


Thanks for Listening!


Find us here: 

X: @YourselfReview

Instagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ReviewItYourself⁠

More episodes

View all episodes

  • Gladiator II (2024): Sean's Initial Thoughts

    01:18|
    In this initial thoughts review, Sean messages Sarah straight after seeing Gladiator II in cinemas.Has Sean ever sounded this positive?Thanks for Listening!Find us here: X: @YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ReviewItYourself⁠
  • Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World (2003)

    02:01:36|
    Huzzah! Sean continues to recommend some of his favourite films to Sarah. Next Up: Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World. "This ship is our home. This ship is England!".Discussion Points:-The Did You Even F**king Watch This Film? returns.-Sarah's disgraceful lack of nautical knowledge.-Sarah and Sean discuss the rich characters, anchored by the performances of Russell Crowe and Paul Bettany.-Why Sarah isn't "fully sold" on Russell Crowe.-Whether or not we get too many films based in the Twentieth Century.-Sean tries to put the film into historical context.-The idea of having a Jonah onboard.-The importance of the class system if you're English.Raised Questions:-How had Sarah never seen this?-Why didn't we get any sequels?-Was this film badly promoted?-Are some people just not suited to lead?-Did you recognise that actor from 'Shameless'?-Why does Sean say certain words poshly?-Are we too fixated on "Now"?-Do men need to be governed?-Is it true that he would pun would pick a pocket?-Would you trust any of your friends to help you operate on yourself?Chapters1:03 Introduction to Master and Commander2:21 The Royal Navy2:56 Debating Historical Accuracy4:09 Marketing and Reception Issues5:31 Misleading Film Descriptions7:30 Character Depth and Development11:56 The Role of Trailers13:11 The Impact of Historical Context18:43 Exploring the Ship's Dynamics20:43 The Importance of Leadership22:33 The Nature of Naval Warfare25:04 The Complexity of Relationships26:29 The Emotional Weight of Loss29:31 Class Dynamics onboard34:13 The Tension of Decision-Making37:47 The Symbolism of Superstitions42:31 Themes of Friendship and Loyalty43:19 The Balance of Power and Respect47:47 The Philosophical Undertones52:06 The Intersection of Science and Warfare59:52 The Struggles of Life at Sea1:01:23 Tensions on the Ship1:22:12 The Battle Begins1:40:45 Reflections on Victory1:51:28 Did You Even F**king Watch The Film?1:59:26 Looking Ahead to Future EpisodesThanks for Listening!Find us here: X: @YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ReviewItYourself⁠
  • Preview It Yourself 6: Warfare, 28 Years Later, and Lilo & Stitch

    43:06|
    Sean and Sarah return with the sixth episode of the Preview It Yourself side series. They watch and discuss the trailers for 28 Years Later, Warfare and the live-action remake of Lilo & Stitch.Discussion Points:-Sarah nearly leaves less than two minutes in.-Sean tries to warn Sarah of the truly horrific trailer she is about to watch.-Sarah wonders how the 28 Years Later looks so similar to 28 Days Later (2002).-Adam Driver.-There's a serious "Hunchback of Notre Dame"-based misunderstanding.-Sean was trying to think of Rupert Everett's name.Raised Questions:-Why do Sean and Sarah enjoy apocalyptic films so much?-Have studios lost the art of making trailers?-What film isn't improved by Adam Driver?-Why does Lilo & Stitch look cheap?-Would you watch Nicholas Cage as Frollo?Chapters:0:04 Introduction 3:15 Trailer Reactions Begin-28 Years Later11:43 Discussing A24's "Warfare"21:01 Previewing Lilo & Stitch's Disturbing New Trailer31:34 Disney's Live-Action Remake Discussion39:54 Closing Thoughts and FarewellFilm Recommendation:-13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi (2016), by Michael Bay.Thanks for Listening!Find us here: X: @YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ReviewItYourself⁠
  • Frequency (2000)

    01:42:45|
    Sean introduces Sarah to another hidden gem, that she's never seen: Frequency (2000). "A great film about family, that's not a family-friendly film".Discussion Points:-The difficult-to-explain plot of the film.-The similarities between Frequency and Field of Dreams (1989).-Sean mentions Bill from 'Bill Reads Bad Reviews' and the planned reviews that never were.-Sarah and Sean dive into what the critics thought of this film in “Open up and swallow some dubious reviews" section! With hilarious results!-Sean wonders what happened to American pride in films.Raised Questions:-Did you spot Michael Cera?-How well did Sarah watch this film?-Are they called the Northern Lights because the North is superior?-What happened to father and son films?-What's happened to male role models in cinema?-Why is baseball so special to Americans?-Have Sean and Sarah found the horniest online film review ever?Chapters0:05 Introduction to Frequency39:24 Interconnected Lives41:41 The Impact of Choices46:34 Realistic Consequences50:32 Conclusion: A Well-Woven Tale52:24 Characters in Crisis54:45 The Weight of Choices56:39 Family Connections57:54 The Trap is Set1:00:53 Tension Builds1:03:03 Different Perspectives1:05:25 Critiquing the Critics1:16:49 Reactions to Frequency1:24:07 Final Thoughts on the Film1:27.30 The Horniest Film Review Ever?1:41:24 Conclusion and FarewellThanks for Listening!Find us here: X: @YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ReviewItYourself⁠
  • Defend It Yourself 25: Spider-Man 3 (2007) with Matthew Dawson, Creator of 'Mortalverse DC'

    58:18|
    Find yourself some shade hot legs, and listen to this web-tastic review.Defend It Yourself 25 finds Sean joined by Matthew Dawson, the creator of 'Mortalverse DC' Audio Dramas, who comes to defend his favourite maligned film: Spider-Man 3 (2007).Discussion Points:-Matthew explains why this film has "a special place in his heart".-Sean tries not to moan about modern comic book films.-The common complaints about this film, including villains and tone. -Emo Peter Parker.-Sean thinks this is Kirsten Dunst's best MJ performance.-Matthew and Sean both loved the characters in the film, and how much you connect with them throughout the Raimi Spider-Man trilogy.-Sean has an issue with an omelette and some cookies.Raised Questions:-Is this film iconic or infamous?-Is this film going through a re-appraisal?-Does this film have too many villains?-What are Sean's complaints about the New Green Goblin's costume?-Is Peter's ego the biggest villain in the film?-Did a change in tone from the previous films affect the initial reaction?Chapters:0:07 Introduction to Spider-Man 30:19 Defending the "Meme-tastic" Film1:36 Revisiting Villain Issues3:23 The Rise of Spider-Man 3?5:20 Special Effects and CGI6:11 Plot Lines and Character Arcs9:18 Emo Peter and Tone Shifts10:40 The Complexities of Relationships12:15 The Music of Spider-Man 316:33 The Cancelled Spider-Man 421:43 A Reflection on Nostalgia23:54 The Meaning of Forgiveness27:25 The Impact of Superhero Films32:48 Closing Thoughts on Spider-Man 334:12 Promoting the Mortal Verse56:24 Wrapping Up and Future PlansThanks for Listening!Find us here: X: @YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ReviewItYourself⁠
  • Rush Hour 3 (2007) with Steve from 'The Decision Reel'

    01:13:39|
    Steve from The Decision Reel returns to finish the Rush Hour series. Has the charm worn off by this third instalment?Check out The Decision Reel here: https://www.thedecisionreel.com/Discussion Points:-The curse of the third film in a trilogy.-Tangents include Jurassic Park 3, The Big Bang Theory, Friends, Stranger Things and The Batman.-Sean puts the boot into the Jurassic World sequel, even though he loved "Battle of Big Rock" (2019).-Steve hasn't seen "No Time To Die" (2021) , so Sean channels his inner Alan Partridge and describes the film's plot.-"It's going to happen fellas": Sean and Steve take time out for a Public Health Announcement.-Sean and Steve clash over Honey Wheat Bread.-Sean is astonished that people eat Garlic Bread with soup. Raised Questions:-Is this film a little tired?-Can Chris Pratt act?-How many names would you want tattooing on your back?-Why were there loads of films set in France around the mid-to-late 2000s?-Is Carry On (2024) the next Die Hard film?-Is it better to watch shows on terrestrial television at a specific time and day of the week?-Is everyone laughing at America and England?-Can you get chicken wings in England?-Are they brothers?Sean Recommends:-The West Wing (1999-2006).Time Stamps2:30 Trilogies and Their Pitfalls4:00 Jurassic Park Comparisons6:00 Lost Potential in Jurassic World10:00 Rush Hour's Unique Appeal11:00 The First and Only Rush Hour18:00 Political Incorrectness in Comedy22:00 The Magic of Buddy Cop Films24:00 Lee and Carter's Dynamic30:00 The Humour in Cultural Differences36:00 The Return of Familiar Characters38:00The Importance of Entertainment42:00 The State of Modern Film46:00 Nostalgia for Scheduled Programming49:00 The Allure of Themed Events52:00 Food Preferences and Cultural Differences56:00 The Humour of Misunderstandings58:00 The Connection to Waterworld1:03.00 The Emotional Climax1:09:00 A Tired Formula1:10:30 The Decision Reel's OfferingsThanks for Listening!Find us here: X: @YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ReviewItYourself⁠
  • 'No Hero But No Coward: J. Bruce Ismay' with Clifford Ismay

    01:03:10|
    Sean is joined by author of 'Understanding J. Bruce Ismay: The True Story of the Man They Called The Coward of Titanic', Clifford Ismay, to look into J. Bruce Ismay.Bruce Ismay was the Chairman of The White Star Line, who became infamous for getting into a lifeboat and surviving the sinking of the Titanic. But are things as one-sided as people think?Listen in to this riveting discussion as Cliff and Sean bring their own insights into the debate.They discuss:-Thomas Henry Ismay and his relationship with his son, Bruce.-Parental expectations.-Bruce Ismay's introverted personality and how it ended up working against the public's perception of him, both before and after the Titanic tragedy.-Myths around Bruce and Captain Smith.-The impact of TV and film depictions of real-life people on public memory.-The cultural impact of Titanic (1997).-The "ram-shackle" evacuation of Titanic.-How surprisingly quickly the attacks on Ismay's character began.-The bravery of Titanic's Engineers and Postmen.Raised Questions:-Who did Cliff really want to write a book about?-Did you know that Bruce's Dad was a world-renowned businessman and self-made man?-Are we all a product of our parents?-Did Bruce's façade alienate people around him?-Has Bruce Ismay been portrayed factually and fairly?-What was the last song played by Titanic's band?-Can we ever corroborate Ismay's version of events?-Do the Public and the Press love a villain when a disaster occurs?-Does the sacrifice of wider Titanic's crew get forgotten?Correction:-It was Lifeboat number 13, which almost had Lifeboat number 15 dropped on it.-Enclosed A Deck Promenade* not "Enclosed Boat Deck" as Sean put it.Further Reading:-Understanding J. Bruce Ismay: The True Story of the Man They Called 'The Coward of Titanic' (The History Press, 2022) by Clifford Ismay.-How To Survive the Titanic; or The Sinking of J. Bruce Ismay (Bloomsbury, 2011) by Frances Wilson.-The Triumvirate: Captain Edward J. Smith, Bruce Ismay, Thomas Andrews and the Sinking of Titanic (The History Press, 2024) by George Behe.Chapters:0:32 Introduction1:17 The Power of Film3:24 J. Bruce Ismay's Perception4:48 Thomas Ismay: A Legacy6:45 Father and Son Dynamics10:33 The Politics of Perception12:49 Portrayals of Bruce Ismay15:48 The Myths of Titanic17:51 The Last Moments21:42 Lifeboat Decisions23:53 The Reality of Survival26:29 The Impact of Inquiry29:02 The Press and Public Perception34:45 The Legacy of Bruce Ismay38:09 Life After Titanic44:35 New Perspectives on History48:17 The Real Heroes of Titanic51:45 Unfinished Stories of Titanic56:59 Future Works and CollaborationsThanks for Listening!Find us here: X: @YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ReviewItYourself⁠
  • Doctor Who Twenty Years Later: Rose (2005)

    01:43:46|
    Sean and Sarah discuss Doctor Who Series One 'Rose' and whether it holds up twenty years later.Discussion Points:-How Sean and Sarah both found the series.-The casting of Billie Piper.-What Christopher Eccleston's second series could have been like.-The break-neck speed of this episode!-The relationship between Rose and her Mam.-The uneven tone in the first few episodes.-THAT 'oner' shot!-Sean and Sarah discuss escapism.-Sarah is perturbed and a 'tad miffed' by the current state of Doctor Who.Raised Questions:-Was this debut episodes successful for both new and returning viewers?-Did the show become a soap opera?-What happened to this kind of natural and organic story-telling?-Have you fallen out of love with Doctor Who?-Was Rose the last working-class companion?-Are Rose Tyler and Amy Pond too similar?-Did Series One struggle to find the correct tone at times?-Did Eccleston struggle with the more comedic moments?-How many times does Sean mention The Sense Sphere?-Is the state of current Doctor Who a result of sheer incompetence or by design?-Does Doctor Who have an attitude nowadays?Chapters:0:14 Welcome to Review It Yourself1:13 Introducing Doctor Who2:37 The 2005 Revival6:11 Nostalgia and Personal Connections7:00 The New Doctor's Introduction9:01 Character Dynamics Explored12:22 The Role of Rose16:07 The Impact of Eccleston18:30 Humour Amidst Darkness21:38 Family Relationships28:09 Grounded Realism in Characters33:09 Connection to the Audience35:09 The Gritty Atmosphere39:18 Accents and Authenticity41:37 Clive and Conspiracy51:38 Balancing Tone and Humour53:53 Character Dynamics Unveiled1:00:01 The Doctor's Alien Nature1:09:29 Humour and Depth in Dialogue1:17:14 The Complexity of Companionship1:27:10 The Essence of Doctor Who1:34:03 Crafting Quality Television1:37:32 Lessons from the Past1:43:24 Reflections and FarewellsShout-Outs:-The Sense Sphere: The Doctor Who Podcast. Find It Here: www.youtube.com/@TheSenseSphereThanks for Listening!Find us here: X: @YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ReviewItYourself⁠
  • Defend It Yourself 24: Rubber (2010) with Griffin from 'Reboot Deboot Podcast'

    01:16:23|
    Defend It Yourself returns after over a year away, and it begins with an absolute beaut!Griffin from the Reboot Deboot Podcast joins Sean to defend, Rubber (2010).Find Griffin's Podcast Here: https://creators.spotify.com/pod/show/rebootdebootDiscussion Points:-Griffin thinks people need to check their tone when talking about this film.-Sean was worried what he'd been asked to watch, when he heard the title.-The DVD read-through returns.-This film is truly like nothing you've ever seen!-Sean was disappointed that the deaths weren't more inventive.-Griffin wonders why B-Movies are treated differently.-Sean and Griffin launch into a chat about the art of filmmaking, CGI, and wonder how bad films get made.Raised Questions:-Why don't Americans spell tyre properly?-Where were the body parts? -Is Rubber "unjustly denigrated"?-What did people expect from a movie about a psychopathic, telekinetic tyre?-Is Robert the Tyre just a homicidal version of the cooker from 'A Grand Day Out' (1989)?-Is Robert like Edward Scissorhands?-Were you disappointed that the audience were killed so quickly?-Why is Sean still disappointed with 'Snakes on a Plane' (2006)?Time Stamps:0:43 Welcome Back to Defend It Yourself2:07 Introducing Griffin from Reboot Deboot2:15 Defending the Film: Rubber4:07 A Love for B-Movies5:12 Is Rubber underrated?8:03 The Film's Unique Concept11:13 Comparing Rubber to Other B-Movies18:09 The Art of Filmmaking24:52 Rubber's Length and Timing29:42 Breaking the Fourth Wall32:02 Liam Neeson in the Naked Gun Reboot41:56 The Nature of Bad Movies47:52 The Subjectivity of Film53:08 The Uniqueness of Rubber1:01:20 The Ending of Rubber1:06:55 Final Thoughts on Rubber1:10:18 Where to Find Reboot Deboot1:14:40 Closing Thoughts and AcknowledgmentsThanks for Listening!Find us here: X: @YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ReviewItYourself⁠