Share

cover art for Bruce Ismay Portrayals on Film: 'Understanding J. Bruce Ismay: The True Story of the Man They Called The Coward of Titanic' (2022 Book) with Author Clifford Ismay

Review It Yourself

Bruce Ismay Portrayals on Film: 'Understanding J. Bruce Ismay: The True Story of the Man They Called The Coward of Titanic' (2022 Book) with Author Clifford Ismay

Sean is joined by author of 'Understanding J. Bruce Ismay: The True Story of the Man They Called The Coward of Titanic', Clifford Ismay, to look into J. Bruce Ismay.


Bruce Ismay was the Chairman of The White Star Line, who became infamous for getting into a lifeboat and surviving the sinking of the Titanic. But are things as one-sided as people think?


Listen in to this riveting discussion as Cliff and Sean bring their own insights into the debate.


They discuss:

-Thomas Henry Ismay and his relationship with his son, Bruce.

-Parental expectations.

-Bruce Ismay's introverted personality and how it ended up working against the public's perception of him, both before and after the Titanic tragedy.

-Myths around Bruce and Captain Smith.

-The impact of TV and film depictions of real-life people on public memory.

-The cultural impact of Titanic (1997).

-The "ram-shackle" evacuation of Titanic.

-How surprisingly quickly the attacks on Ismay's character began.

-The bravery of Titanic's Engineers and Postmen.


Raised Questions:

-Who did Cliff really want to write a book about?

-Did you know that Bruce's Dad was a world-renowned businessman and self-made man?

-Are we all a product of our parents?

-Did Bruce's façade alienate people around him?

-Has Bruce Ismay been portrayed factually and fairly?

-What was the last song played by Titanic's band?

-Can we ever corroborate Ismay's version of events?

-Do the Public and the Press love a villain when a disaster occurs?

-Does the sacrifice of wider Titanic's crew get forgotten?


Correction:

-It was Lifeboat number 13, which almost had Lifeboat number 15 dropped on it.

-Enclosed A Deck Promenade* not "Enclosed Boat Deck" as Sean put it.


Further Reading:

-Understanding J. Bruce Ismay: The True Story of the Man They Called 'The Coward of Titanic' (The History Press, 2022) by Clifford Ismay.

-How To Survive the Titanic; or The Sinking of J. Bruce Ismay (Bloomsbury, 2011) by Frances Wilson.

-The Triumvirate: Captain Edward J. Smith, Bruce Ismay, Thomas Andrews and the Sinking of Titanic (The History Press, 2024) by George Behe.


Chapters:

0:32 Introduction

1:17 The Power of Film

3:24 J. Bruce Ismay's Perception

4:48 Thomas Ismay: A Legacy

6:45 Father and Son Dynamics

10:33 The Politics of Perception

12:49 Portrayals of Bruce Ismay

15:48 The Myths of Titanic

17:51 The Last Moments

21:42 Lifeboat Decisions

23:53 The Reality of Survival

26:29 The Impact of Inquiry

29:02 The Press and Public Perception

34:45 The Legacy of Bruce Ismay

38:09 Life After Titanic

44:35 New Perspectives on History

48:17 The Real Heroes of Titanic

51:45 Unfinished Stories of Titanic

56:59 Future Works and Collaborations


Thanks for Listening!


Find us here: 

X: @YourselfReview

Instagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ReviewItYourself⁠

More episodes

View all episodes

  • Dante's Peak (1997) Part Two with co-host Sarah (We Review It At Last!)

    01:28:58|
    Volcano chaos, science ignored, and peak 90s disaster movie madness!If you love explosive disaster films, this episode dives deep into Dante's Peak and why it still erupts with tension, questionable decisions, and surprisingly sharp commentary on human behaviour under pressure.In Part Two, the hosts of Review It Yourself (Sean and Sarah) go beyond surface-level reactions and explore what really makes this film tick—from the science to the way panic spreads faster than lava. Expect a mix of humour, critique, and genuine appreciation for what works.🌋 What’s Covered in This EpisodeThis episode blends film review with real-world insights, unpacking:How disaster films portray panic, chaos, and human irrationality in crisis situationsThe frustrating (but realistic) theme of experts being ignored until it’s too lateWhy characters making bad decisions is both infuriating and essential storytellingThe role of science vs public opinion when lives are on the lineMemorable moments, performances, and classic 90s disaster tropesA discussion on what separates good filmmaking from pure spectacleThere’s also plenty of classic Review It Yourself banter, including reflections on note-taking (or lack of it), rewatches, and how nostalgia shapes our opinions.🎧 Why You Should ListenIf you enjoy:Disaster movies like Volcano, Twister, or ContagionFilm analysis with humour and honestyConversations about human psychology in extreme situationsPodcasts that are “film reviews without the faff”…this episode will absolutely deliver.📢 About Review It YourselfReview It Yourself is a film and media podcast that cuts through the noise—offering sharp, funny, and thoughtful reviews without overcomplication.Follow and connect:Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/reviewityourselfpodcast2021X / Twitter: https://twitter.com/YourselfReviewBlueSky: https://bsky.app/profile/reviewityourself.bsky.socialThreads: https://www.threads.net/@reviewityourselfpodcast2021Email: reviewityourselfpodcast@gmail.com⭐ Support the PodcastIf you enjoyed this episode:Follow / subscribe on your favourite podcast platformLeave a 5-star review on Apple Podcasts Share the episode with a fellow film fanEngage on social media and join the conversationEvery share, follow, and review helps the podcast grow and keeps new episodes coming.
  • Dante's Peak (1997) Part One with co-host Sarah (We Review It Eventually)

    01:30:04|
    Volcanoes, chaos, and 90s thrills—does Dante’s Peak still erupt today? In this explosive first part of our deep dive into Dante's Peak, Review It Yourself hosts Sean and Sarah unpack one of the most iconic disaster movies of the 90s. From molten lava to political tension, this episode blends nostalgia, film critique, and surprisingly relevant real-world themes. Tangents aside, we eventually begin reviewing the film 52 minutes in.The discussion kicks off with a look at the film’s gripping opening and its commitment to practical effects, crowds, and realism—something modern blockbusters don’t always deliver. Sean and Sarah highlight how the film balances spectacle with grounded storytelling, praising the tension-building and strong character focus that made it stand out in the disaster genre .As the episode unfolds, the conversation turns toward deeper themes—science versus politics, risk management, and how communities respond to looming catastrophe. The hosts explore the character of Harry Dalton and the film’s portrayal of experts struggling to be heard, a theme that feels just as relevant today .There’s also plenty of fun debate around classic disaster movie tropes: evacuation logistics, clogged roads, and the sheer impossibility of saving everyone when nature strikes . The group questions how realistic the film’s crisis response really is—and whether any town could truly survive such an eruption.Whether you’re a fan of 90s cinema, disaster films, or just love a passionate breakdown of movies, this episode delivers insight, humour, and a fresh perspective on a cult favourite.📚 Featured FilmDante's Peak (1997)A classic volcano disaster movie exploring resilience, science, and survival under pressure.🔥 Why You Should ListenDeep dive into a classic 90s disaster filmReal-world parallels: science vs politicsHonest discussion on disaster preparednessFun, unfiltered film chat with great guest chemistry📢 Follow & Support Review It YourselfStay connected, join the conversation, and never miss an episode:Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/reviewityourselfpodcast2021X / Twitter: https://twitter.com/YourselfReviewBlueSky: https://bsky.app/profile/reviewityourself.bsky.socialThreads: https://www.threads.net/@reviewityourselfpodcast2021Email: reviewityourselfpodcast@gmail.com💬 Got a film you want reviewed? Reach out via social media or email!⭐ Support the podcast:If you enjoyed this episode, follow, subscribe, and leave a review on your podcast platform—especially on Apple Podcasts to help more listeners discover the show. Sharing the episode with friends is another huge way to help the podcast grow.Part One is just the beginning—subscribe now so you don’t miss the next instalment as the eruption truly begins 🌋
  • JFK Director's Cut (1991) Part Two with Author Fraser McCallum and co-host Sarah

    01:33:14|
    Conspiracies, cinema, and political paranoia collide in Oliver Stone’s controversial JFK epic.In this second part of our deep dive into Oliver Stone’s landmark political thriller JFK (1991) – Director’s Cut, hosts Sean and Sarah continue their conversation with returning guest Fraser McCallum. The discussion moves beyond the basics of the film and into the deeper cultural and cinematic impact of one of the most debated movies ever made.Fraser returns to the show to talk about a film he considers one of his favourite movies of all time, exploring why JFK continues to provoke debate decades after its release.Together, the panel examine how Stone’s film blends investigative drama, political commentary, and conspiracy thriller storytelling to recreate Jim Garrison’s controversial investigation into the assassination of President John F. Kennedy. The conversation looks at how the film presents competing perspectives and contradictory narratives, reflecting the complexity surrounding the historical event itself.Part Two of the discussion expands into wider themes about political corruption on-screen, the evolution of Hollywood filmmaking, and the changing landscape of serious adult drama. The hosts and Fraser explore how films like JFK once occupied a major place in mainstream cinema and why similar ambitious political films are rarer today.The episode also explores how the film’s legacy extends beyond entertainment, shaping how audiences think about political conspiracies, historical truth, and the power of cinema to influence public debate.In this episode we discuss:Why JFK: Director’s Cut remains one of the most controversial political films ever madeOliver Stone’s filmmaking style and narrative structureKevin Costner’s portrayal of Jim Garrison and the film’s star-studded castThe influence of JFK on conspiracy culture and political storytellingHow the film blends fact, speculation and cinematic storytellingThe decline of large-scale political dramas in modern HollywoodWhy films like JFK still shape how audiences understand historyIf you’re fascinated by political thrillers, film history, or the enduring mystery surrounding the Kennedy assassination, this episode is an essential listen.About Our Guest – Fraser McCallumFraser McCallum is a returning guest on Review It Yourself, works for the Imperial War Museum and is the author of 'Cold War Britain: Fifty years in the Shadow of the Bomb'. His deep knowledge of the Kennedy assassination and the cultural impact of Oliver Stone’s film brings a unique perspective to this discussion.Instagram: fraser_mcca11umThreads: @fraser_mcca11umFind His Book at IWM Bookshop: https://shop.iwm.org.uk/products/cold-war-britain-fifty-years-in-the-shadow-of-the-bomb?_pos=2&_sid=4d048dfe1&_ss=rFollow & Contact Review It YourselfStay connected with Review It Yourself and join the conversation about films, TV and pop culture.Instagram:https://www.instagram.com/reviewityourselfpodcast2021X / Twitter:https://twitter.com/YourselfReviewBlueSky:https://bsky.app/profile/reviewityourself.bsky.socialThreads:https://www.threads.net/@reviewityourselfpodcast2021Email:reviewityourselfpodcast@gmail.comSupport the PodcastIf you enjoy Review It Yourself, here are a few ways you can help support the show:⭐ Subscribe on your favourite podcast platform⭐ Leave a review on Apple Podcasts to help more listeners discover the show⭐ Share this episode with friends who love film discussions and deep dives⭐ Follow us on social media and join the conversationYour support helps the podcast keep producing thoughtful and entertaining film discussions.🎙️ Review It Yourself – Film Reviews Without the Faff.
  • JFK Director's Cut (1991) Part One with Author Fraser McCallum and co-host Sarah

    58:56|
    A conspiracy, a courtroom, and one film that changed political cinema forever.What happens when one of the most controversial political films ever made is given the full Director’s Cut treatment? In this episode of Review It Yourself, Sean and Sarah are joined by returning guest Fraser McCallum to explore the sprawling, provocative and endlessly debated film JFK (1991) – Director’s Cut.Part One finds Fraser returning to the podcast to discuss what he considers one of his favourite films of all time, and the conversation quickly moves beyond a simple review. Together Sean, Sarah and Fraser l dive deep into the filmmaking craft, historical context and cultural impact of Oliver Stone’s controversial political epic.The discussion explores how the film blends historical fact, speculation and cinematic storytelling to present the investigation led by New Orleans District Attorney Jim Garrison into the assassination of President John F. Kennedy. While some critics argue the film plays fast and loose with history, Fraser argues its true power lies in its ability to spark curiosity, debate and deeper research.Along the way the team unpack the film’s extraordinary ensemble cast, the remarkable editing and sound design, and the narrative structure that turns the story into something between a detective mystery and a courtroom drama. The conversation also reflects on how the film influenced public discourse around government transparency and historical truth in the years after its release.Expect a lively conversation covering:Why JFK: Director’s Cut remains one of the most debated films in political cinemaKevin Costner’s performance as Jim Garrison and the film’s incredible castThe detective-story structure that evolves into a powerful courtroom climaxThe blurred lines between history, conspiracy and storytellingHow the film helped fuel renewed public interest in the Kennedy assassinationWhether artistic storytelling can still reveal deeper truths about historyWhether you love political thrillers, historical films or big cinematic swings, this episode explores why JFK remains a landmark film more than three decades later.About Our Guest – Fraser McCallumFraser McCallum is a returning guest on Review It Yourself, works for the Imperial War Museum and is the author of 'Cold War Britain: Fifty years in the Shadow of the Bomb'. His deep knowledge of the Kennedy assassination and the cultural impact of Oliver Stone’s film brings a unique perspective to this discussion.Instagram: fraser_mcca11umThreads: @fraser_mcca11umFind His Book at IWM Bookshop: https://shop.iwm.org.uk/products/cold-war-britain-fifty-years-in-the-shadow-of-the-bomb?_pos=2&_sid=4d048dfe1&_ss=rListen to More from Review It YourselfIf you enjoyed this episode, make sure you subscribe to Review It Yourself, the podcast where we dive deep into films, TV, books and pop culture — sometimes with guests, always with strong opinions.Follow the podcast here:Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/reviewityourselfpodcast2021X / Twitter: https://twitter.com/YourselfReviewBlueSky: https://bsky.app/profile/reviewityourself.bsky.socialThreads: https://www.threads.net/@reviewityourselfpodcast2021Email: reviewityourselfpodcast@gmail.comSupport the PodcastIf you enjoy Review It Yourself, please consider supporting the show:Subscribe on your favourite podcast platformLeave a review on Apple Podcasts – it really helps new listeners discover the showShare the episode with friends who love film discussions and deep divesFollow us on social media and join the conversationYour support helps the podcast continue bringing thoughtful, entertaining and sometimes controversial discussions about the films and stories that shape culture.
  • Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981) with Ryan Walker from 'The Walk The Line Podcast'

    01:38:49|
    Why Raiders of the Lost Ark Still Defines the Perfect Adventure MovieIn this episode of Review It Yourself, we dig into one of the most iconic adventure films ever made: Raiders of the Lost Ark. Joining the show is Ryan Walker, host of The Walk The Line Podcast, for a lively and often hilarious discussion about the film that launched the legendary archaeologist Indiana Jones into pop-culture history.Together we explore why this classic directed by Steven Spielberg and starring Harrison Ford continues to influence modern cinema decades after its release. From unforgettable set pieces and practical effects to the film’s pacing, villains, and iconic moments, this episode breaks down what makes Raiders such an enduring favourite.But it wouldn’t be Review It Yourself without a few disagreements. While many fans consider Raiders the pinnacle of the original Indiana Jones trilogy, the conversation dives into whether it truly stands above entries like Temple of Doom or The Last Crusade.Along the way, we also talk about nostalgia, blockbuster storytelling, and the changing nature of heroes in modern movies.Expect passionate opinions, film geek deep dives, and plenty of laughs as we revisit one of the greatest adventure films ever made.What We Discuss In This EpisodeWhy Raiders of the Lost Ark is considered a masterpiece of adventure filmmakingThe legacy of Indiana Jones and why the character still resonates todayMemorable scenes, villains, and practical effects that defined the filmHow blockbuster storytelling has evolved since the early 1980sWhether the original Indiana Jones trilogy still holds up todayWhy practical effects often feel more impactful than modern CGIGuest: Ryan Walker – Walk The Line PodcastThis episode features Ryan Walker, host of the Walk The Line Podcast, where he explores stories, culture, and engaging conversations with a unique perspective.Follow and listen to Ryan here:Podcast: The Walk The Line PodcastSearch The Walk The Line Podcast on your favourite podcast platform.About Review It YourselfReview It Yourself is the podcast where we break down films, TV, and pop culture with honest opinions, humour, and a fresh perspective. If you enjoy deep dives into classic movies, debates about beloved franchises, and thoughtful discussion about storytelling, this is the show for you.Follow Review It YourselfStay connected and join the conversation:Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/reviewityourselfpodcast2021X / Twitter: https://twitter.com/YourselfReviewBlueSky: https://bsky.app/profile/reviewityourself.bsky.socialThreads: https://www.threads.net/@reviewityourselfpodcast2021📧 Email the show: reviewityourselfpodcast@gmail.comSupport the PodcastIf you enjoy Review It Yourself, here are a few ways you can help support the show:Follow or subscribe on your favourite podcast platformLeave a rating and review on Apple Podcasts or SpotifyShare the episode with a friend who loves moviesEngage on social media and join the discussionYour support helps more people discover the podcast and keeps the conversations going.🎧 Listen now and decide for yourself: Is Raiders of the Lost Ark truly the greatest Indiana Jones adventure, or does another film in the series deserve the crown?
  • The Dummy Detective (2025) with stars Jonathan Geffner, Deb Twiss and Ed Altman

    53:00|
    Ventriloquism, noir shadows, and murder mystery collide spectacularly.In this episode of Review It Yourself – film reviews without the faff, we step into the strange, stylish world of The Dummy Detective, a bold independent film blending classic film noir with the art of ventriloquism.Joining us are:Jonathan Geffner – Writer, producer and star, plays Detective Van Trillo, and his wooden-partner Suede.Ed Altman – Portraying enigmatic radio presenter Elliot BlackDeb Twiss – Bringing Femme Fatale Chloe Lake to lifeThis is a deep-dive conversation into independent filmmaking, character psychology, creative persistence, and the fine line between illusion and reality.Inside The Dummy Detective (2025)The Dummy Detective is no ordinary murder mystery. Fusing noir atmosphere with ventriloquism, the film introduces audiences to the unforgettable Van Trillo and Suede characters — creations that Jonathan Geffner developed decades ago before finally bringing them to the screen.Jonathan discusses:The 30-year journey of developing the charactersWriting and producing an independent featureThe challenges of self-financing and independent promotionBalancing humour and darkness in a noir-inspired storyEd Altman shares the unique acting challenge of portraying a ventriloquist entangled in a murder mystery — exploring themes of loneliness, dual identity, and perception.Deb Twiss reflects on playing a modern femme fatale, the strength of the script, and how layered writing allowed her to fully inhabit Chloe Lake.Together, we explore:The collaborative atmosphere on setShooting on a tight scheduleBlending classic noir influences with contemporary indie filmmakingAudience reactions and the film’s receptionWhy ambiguity is central to the story’s powerIf you’re searching for discussions on independent film, noir cinema, ventriloquism in film, murder mystery movies, indie filmmaking challenges, or actor interviews, this episode delivers.Where to WatchThe Dummy Detective (2025) is available on major streaming platforms including Amazon Prime and Tubi.Support independent cinema and experience this unique noir experiment for yourself.Connect with the GuestsJonathan GeffnerWriter, Producer & Actor – Detective Van TrilloFollow his work and updates related to The Dummy Detective via official film channels and streaming platforms.Ed AltmanActor – Elliot BlackFor professional updates and appearances, search Ed Altman via official film listings and casting platforms.Deb TwissActress – Chloe LakeFor career updates, film appearances and future projects, follow Deb Twiss through official industry listings and social media.Follow & Contact Review It YourselfWe’re a proudly independent podcast spotlighting film and television — from blockbusters to hidden indie gems.📸 Instagram:https://www.instagram.com/reviewityourselfpodcast2021🐦 X / Twitter:https://twitter.com/YourselfReview🦋 BlueSky:https://bsky.app/profile/reviewityourself.bsky.social🧵 Threads:https://www.threads.net/@reviewityourselfpodcast2021📧 Email:reviewityourselfpodcast@gmail.comHave a film to recommend? Want to appear on the show? Get in touch.Support the PodcastIf you enjoy in-depth film discussions and independent creator interviews:Subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listenLeave a 5-star review on Apple Podcasts (huge for rankings)Share this episode on social mediaRecommend Review It Yourself to fellow film loversYour support helps independent podcasts thrive.If you love noir, character-driven mysteries, and candid conversations about the realities of indie filmmaking, this is an episode you don’t want to miss.Press play, explore the mystery, and as always… Review It Yourself.
  • Deep Impact (1998) Part Two with co-host Sarah

    01:19:28|
    What happens when space exploration meets human emotion? Discover the Deep Impact effect in Part Two of our review.Deep Impact Review — A Thoughtful Dive into Humanity and the Cosmos:In this episode of Review It Yourself, we unpack the 1998 sci-fi drama Deep Impact, exploring how this disaster movie combines thrilling spectacle with emotional storytelling. More than just comets and chaos, Deep Impact asks profound questions about leadership, sacrifice, and the meaning of survival.Listeners will gain exclusive insights into what makes Deep Impact stand out from other end-of-the-world films — from its grounded realism to its compassionate portrayal of humanity under pressure. Whether you’re a film buff, a sci-fi fan, or love character-driven stories, this one’s for you.Key TakeawaysHow Deep Impact redefined the 90s disaster movie genreThe emotional core and moral dilemmas faced by its charactersBehind-the-scenes details that add depth to the film’s impactWhy its ending still resonates decades laterGuest DetailsJust the classic combo of Sean and Sarah.Follow & Contact Review It YourselfStay connected with Review It Yourself for more intelligent reviews, interviews, and deep dives into books and films:Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/reviewityourselfpodcast2021X / Twitter: https://twitter.com/YourselfReviewBlueSky: https://bsky.app/profile/reviewityourself.bsky.socialThreads: https://www.threads.net/@reviewityourselfpodcast2021Email: reviewityourselfpodcast@gmail.comFor guest enquiries, collaborations, or listener feedback, email directly — the show welcomes thoughtful discussion and future topic suggestions.Why You Should ListenThis isn’t just another movie review — it’s a smart, heartfelt exploration of how cinema mirrors our fears, hopes, and humanity. Tune in and rediscover why Deep Impact remains one of the most underrated sci-fi dramas of its time.
  • Deep Impact (1998) Part One with co-host Sarah

    01:14:43|
    What happens when space exploration meets human emotion? Discover the Deep Impact effect.Deep Impact Review — A Thoughtful Dive into Humanity and the Cosmos:In this episode of Review It Yourself, we unpack the 1998 sci-fi drama Deep Impact, exploring how this disaster movie combines thrilling spectacle with emotional storytelling. More than just comets and chaos, Deep Impact asks profound questions about leadership, sacrifice, and the meaning of survival.Listeners will gain exclusive insights into what makes Deep Impact stand out from other end-of-the-world films — from its grounded realism to its compassionate portrayal of humanity under pressure. Whether you’re a film buff, a sci-fi fan, or love character-driven stories, this one’s for you.Key TakeawaysHow Deep Impact redefined the 90s disaster movie genreThe emotional core and moral dilemmas faced by its charactersBehind-the-scenes details that add depth to the film’s impactWhy its ending still resonates decades laterGuest DetailsJust the classic combo of Sean and Sarah.Follow & Contact Review It YourselfStay connected with Review It Yourself for more intelligent reviews, interviews, and deep dives into books and films:Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/reviewityourselfpodcast2021X / Twitter: https://twitter.com/YourselfReviewBlueSky: https://bsky.app/profile/reviewityourself.bsky.socialThreads: https://www.threads.net/@reviewityourselfpodcast2021Email: reviewityourselfpodcast@gmail.comFor guest enquiries, collaborations, or listener feedback, email directly — the show welcomes thoughtful discussion and future topic suggestions.Why You Should ListenThis isn’t just another movie review — it’s a smart, heartfelt exploration of how cinema mirrors our fears, hopes, and humanity. Tune in and rediscover why Deep Impact remains one of the most underrated sci-fi dramas of its time.
  • The Book Behind The Film Nuremberg (2025): 'The Nazi and the Psychiatrist' (2013 Book) with Author & Speaker Jack El-Hai

    01:02:08|
    Inside the mind of a Nazi—and the psychiatrist who studied him.In this powerful episode of Review It Yourself, Sean sits down with acclaimed author and journalist Jack El-Hai to discuss his gripping and deeply researched book, The Nazi and the Psychiatrist.This is not just another Second World War/World War II book review. It’s a psychological investigation into evil, power, ego, and moral reckoning at the aftermath of history’s darkest chapter.A Psychological Duel at NurembergIn The Nazi and the Psychiatrist, Jack El-Hai explores the extraordinary relationship between Hermann Goering, the highest-ranking Nazi captured alive, and Douglas M. Kelley, the U.S. Army psychiatrist tasked with evaluating him during the Nuremberg Trials.During our conversation, we unpack:How Kelley psychologically assessed leading Nazi defendantsWhy Goering fascinated and manipulated those around himThe concept of the “banality of evil” in practiceThe absence of a single psychiatric diagnosis to explain atrocityThe moral and professional toll the Nuremberg experience took on KelleyWhy these questions still resonate todayJack reveals how Kelley’s pioneering psychological work challenged simplistic narratives about madness and evil — and how America struggled to process the uncomfortable conclusions.Why The Nazi and the Psychiatrist Matters NowWith the upcoming 2025 film Nuremberg renewing interest in this story, El-Hai’s book has never been more relevant.In a world still grappling with extremism, ideology, and the psychology of power, this episode asks:Are monsters born—or made?Can ordinary individuals commit extraordinary evil?What responsibility does psychology bear in interpreting history?About Our Guest: Jack El-HaiJack El-Hai is an award-winning author and journalist specialising in narrative non-fiction, medical history, crime, and ethics.📘 Featured BookThe Nazi and the Psychiatrist: Hermann Goering, Dr. Douglas M. Kelley, and a Fatal Meeting of MindsOriginally published in 2013, the book examines the psychological chess match between Goering and Kelley — and its tragic aftermath.🔎 Learn More & Connect🌐 Website: https://www.jackelhai.com🐦 Twitter/X: https://twitter.com/jackelhaiJack also discusses his ongoing commitment to telling stories rooted in justice, ethics, and the darker corners of history.If you’re interested in World War II history, the Nuremberg Trials, forensic psychology, or the moral complexity of historical biography, this book is essential reading.Why You Should Listen to This EpisodeThis episode of Review It Yourself delivers:A thoughtful, in-depth author interviewInsight into the psychology of Nazi leadershipHistorical analysis grounded in primary researchA discussion on how history is interpreted — and misinterpretedReflection on how the past informs our presentPerfect for listeners interested in:World War II historyHolocaust studiesNuremberg TrialsPsychology and ethicsHistorical biographiesFollow, Contact & Support Review It YourselfIf you value independent, honest book and film reviews without corporate spin:🎙️ Subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, and all major platforms⭐ Leave a 5-star review on Apple Podcasts — it helps more than you know📧 Email the show: reviewityourselfpodcast@gmail.com📲 Follow Review It Yourself on your favourite social media platformFind us here: Instagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021Twitter/X: @YourselfReviewThreads: reviewityourselfpodcast2021BlueSky: @reviewityourself.bsky.social‬Support the PodcastReview It Yourself is proudly independent.You can support the show by:🔁 Sharing this episode with fellow film, history and psychology enthusiasts📝 Leaving a written review on Apple Podcasts or SpotifyYour support keeps independent podcasting alive.Listen now to this compelling discussion with Jack El-Hai — and decide for yourself what The Nazi and the Psychiatrist reveals about evil, responsibility, and the human condition.