Share

cover art for Employee Reviews: Leadership for the Modern Executive featuring Erika Jefferson

Lead to Soar: Career Advice and Guidance for Ambitious Women Leaders

Employee Reviews: Leadership for the Modern Executive featuring Erika Jefferson

Season 7, Ep. 144
•

This episode dives into the controversial and widely debated topic of performance reviews within the workplace. Drawing from personal experiences and current studies, the hosts examine the effectiveness and impact of traditional performance review systems.


Episode Highlights:


The Problem with Performance Reviews: Citing studies from Gallup and SHRM, the episode begins by highlighting the general dissatisfaction with performance appraisals, described as time-consuming, demotivating, and biased.

McKinsey's Approach: Discussion on McKinsey's "up or out" performance management strategy and its implications for employee motivation and workplace culture.

Personal Anecdotes: Michelle shares her experiences and the emotional toll of administering performance reviews, critiquing the forced ranking system that fails to genuinely engage employees' potential.

Alternative Perspectives: The episode challenges traditional performance management practices, questioning their purpose and effectiveness in fostering a supportive and productive workplace environment.

Bias in Reviews: The hosts discuss research indicating gender bias in performance evaluations, where women often receive vague feedback that hinders their professional growth.

Solutions and Alternatives: The conversation shifts towards alternative methods of performance assessment, including more frequent, constructive feedback mechanisms that aim to genuinely support employee development.


Links and Resources

Gallup Study  

SHRM study reference

Lead to Soar is a podcast for ambitious women and the leaders who support them. Hosted by Michelle Redfern and Mel Butcher, it delivers evidence-based, practical advice on leadership, career progression, and closing the gender gap. Join the Lead to Soar Network at leadtosoar.network or get Michelle’s book The Leadership Compass at michelleredfern.com/book.

More episodes

View all episodes

  • 201. Should I Be the Fixer? How to Assess “Opportunities” That Might Be Glass Cliffs

    16:30||Season 9, Ep. 201
    Being asked to “fix” an underperforming team or leader can be a genuine opportunity – or a glass cliff. Michelle Redfern and Mel Butcher break down how to assess high-stakes roles, identify red flags, and determine whether you’re being set up to succeed or to take the fall. Essential guidance for ambitious women evaluating career-defining moves.

  • 200. Why LinkedIn Is No Longer Enough: Our Revised Career Advice for Ambitious Women

    45:57||Season 9, Ep. 200
    Mel and Michelle get honest about why LinkedIn is no longer enough. We rethink visibility, real networking, and the “I do not” list that protects women’s energy and careers. Fierce, practical guidance for ambitious women.

  • 199. Professional Jealousy: What Is It & How Does it Show Up?

    32:33||Season 9, Ep. 199
    In this episode, Michelle Redfern and Mel Butcher tackle a workplace issue most people experience but rarely discuss openly: professional jealousy. They walk through how jealousy shows up, how it can be weaponised through policy or gossip, and why it can have serious consequences for someone’s reputation and career if it isn’t handled well.

  • 198. The Dissenting Voice: Why Women’s Courage Will Define Leadership in the Age of AI

    33:35||Season 9, Ep. 198
    Technology is racing ahead — but courage and conscience must lead the way. In this episode, Michelle Redfern and Mel Butcher explore how women leaders can be the dissenting voices that keep ethics, empathy, and humanity at the centre of progress.

  • 197. How to Play the Long Game: A Career Strategy for Ambitious Women

    27:27||Season 9, Ep. 197
    Your future self is counting on you. In this episode, Michelle Redfern and Mel Butcher explore how ambitious women can play the long game — building strategy, visibility, and momentum that leads to real career success.

  • 196. Why Credibility PLUS Visibility Is Essential for Career Success

    19:46||Season 9, Ep. 196
    Competence alone doesn’t create credibility. Michelle and Mel reveal why visibility and credibility must work together if you want to be chosen for high-value work. They share how to talk about your achievements without the cringe, use language that lands with decision-makers, and demonstrate leadership that moves the business forward.

  • 195. From Hope to Strategy: How to Reach Your Full Potential

    26:54||Season 9, Ep. 195
    Hope is not a strategy. Michelle and Mel show you how to define your full potential, state your ambition with a business lens, and build a roadmap that aligns your moves to revenue, margin, and growth outcomes. Practical prompts and language you can use this week.

  • 194. Too Nice to Lead? How to Manage Up to an Ineffective Boss

    29:49||Season 9, Ep. 194
    In this episode of Lead to Soar, Michelle Redfern and Mel Butcher tackle a quiet but costly leadership issue: the boss who’s “too nice to lead.” They’re kind, approachable, and well-intentioned—but decisions stall, standards slip, and teams burn out.You’ll learn how to recognise this pattern, manage up with evidence and courage, and raise the standard without burning out or doing their job for them. Michelle also unpacks why organisations keep rewarding comfort over competence, and what real leadership development should look like.

  • 193. Why Being Busy and Obedient Is a Poor Strategy for Ambitious Women

    21:15||Season 9, Ep. 193
    Why being busy and obedient is a poor strategy for ambitious women. Michelle and Mel share why obedience isn’t leadership, how to ditch non-promotable tasks, and why radical accountability drives career growth.