Share

cover art for Free to Kill: Reagan Tokes

Cup of Coffee and Crime

Free to Kill: Reagan Tokes

Season 2, Ep. 14

When a 21 year old student at Ohio State University is murdered after finishing her shift, nothing could have prepared her friends and family for the shock and devastation of not only her murder but the fact that her death COULD and SHOULD have been avoided.


★ To see photos and videos of todays case head over to the Cup of Coffee and Crime Facebook Discussion Group

★ To support the show and keep me caffeinated, you are now able to Buy Me a Coffee :)



Music from #Uppbeat :

https://uppbeat.io/t/ak/midnight-stroll

License code: OCHNSIEQIVR5SLQ7

★ To see todays case photos head over to the Cup of Coffee and Crime Facebook Discussion Group

★ To support the show and keep me caffeinated, you are now able to Buy Me a Coffee :)

★ Taking a few minutes to complete a quick survey is such a huge way to help http://bit.ly/cupofcoffeeandcrime-survey




Music from #Uppbeat :

https://uppbeat.io/t/ak/midnight-stroll

License code: OCHNSIEQIVR5SLQ7

More episodes

View all episodes

  • BONUS: Killer Brothers; Ethan Austin & Paris Bennett

    15:24|
    Some questions never have answers.In this Season Break Bitesize episode, we're looking at two heartbreaking cases involving children who committed unimaginable crimes against members of their own family.First, we explore the tragic deaths of Ethan and Kaitlin Austin, a case that left investigators unable to find a clear motive and a family searching for answers they'll likely never have.Then we look at the case of Paris and Ella Bennett, where a 13-year-old admitted killing his four-year-old sister in an attempt to punish their mother, leaving experts, and those closest to him, trying to understand how a child could commit such a calculated act.Two very different cases.One haunting question.Why?
  • BONUS: Killer Wives; Darlene Gentry & Omaima Nelson

    17:13|
    Darlene Gentry looked like she had it all. A loving husband, three young children, and the kind of life that seemed picture-perfect from the outside. But when Keith Gentry was found shot in the head inside their Texas home, investigators quickly realised the danger hadn't come from a stranger. It had been living under the same roof all along.Omaima Nelson's marriage lasted just three weeks. What followed was truly disturbing. A Thanksgiving holiday that ended in violence and dismemberment.Two marriages. Two husbands. And two women whose secrets only came to light after it was far too late.This bonus episode explores the terrifying reality that sometimes the person closest to you is the person you understand the least.
  • BONUS: The Murder of Liam Smith

    21:00|
    Liam Smith was 38, a father of two, living a quiet life in Wigan, England.When he stepped outside his front door on a cold November evening and never made it back inside, nothing about it made sense.What followed revealed a brief connection that traced back years, to a single date that should have meant nothing. But somewhere along the line, the story changed. And so did the person telling it.As the investigation unfolded, a plan that had been building quietly was exposed. A version of events that became justification for murder. And a decision that would end in violence on a quiet residential street.This is a UK true crime case about control, belief, and what happens when two people convince themselves they’re entitled to act as judge, jury and executioner.
  • 20. If I Can’t Have You; Mark van Dongen

    45:00||Season 6, Ep. 20
    Mark van Dongen was twenty-nine, living in Bristol, England, and building a life he’d worked hard for.When his relationship with Berlinah Wallace began to break down, it was complicated. Drawn out. Difficult to leave.Until one night, everything changed.Mark survived what followed. But survival came at a cost that would reshape every part of his life, and raise questions that don’t have easy answers.This season finale explores what happened behind closed doors, and the decisions that turned it into one of the most complex cases the UK has seen.
  • 19. The Truth Behind the Photo; The Hart Family Murders

    36:11||Season 6, Ep. 19
    Devonte Hart was twelve when a photo of him hugging a police officer went viral.A Black child and a white police officer.A moment of connection in a time of tension.But behind that image was a very different reality.A family that appeared devoted, vocal about justice, and committed to raising six children they had adopted from the foster care system.Inside the home, there were warning signs. Reports. Concerns raised by teachers, doctors, and neighbours. Moments that didn’t quite add up, but were explained away, again and again.This episode explores the Hart family case, what was seen, what was missed, and how it ended in 2018.
  • 18. A Suitcase, A Forged Will, A Murder; Mee Kuen Chong

    39:10||Season 6, Ep. 18
    Mee Kuen "Deborah" Chong had spent decades building a quiet life in London. She was independent, deeply faithful, and known for her generosity. So when she formed a close friendship with someone from her church, there was no reason to question it.At first, it looked like support. Then guidance. Then something more.Behind closed doors, conversations about faith slowly became conversations about money. Plans were made. Trust deepened. And then, without warning, it shifted.When Deborah disappeared from her home in Wembley, the explanation didn’t quite hold. There were no sightings. No contact. No evidence she had gone anywhere at all.But there was CCTV.A suitcase.And a trail that led far away from London.A case about trust, manipulation… and the moment it’s used against you.
  • 17. A Love Triangle and a Deadly Decision: Sarah Ludemann

    30:01||Season 6, Ep. 17
    Sarah Ludemann was eighteen. Close with her family, focused on her future, and not someone who chased drama, until she met someone who brought it with him.The relationship was complicated. Then messy. Then deadly. Behind the scenes, there was someone else. Another girl who thought she was the only one.At first, it looked like typical teenage drama. Arguments. Jealousy. Messages sent in anger. Threats that, at the time, didn’t seem real. Until one night, outside a house in Florida, everything came to a head.
  • 16. Planned for Years, Undone in Days; Hatton Garden Heist

    50:04||Season 6, Ep. 16
    Hatton Garden, London’s jewellery district, is a place where, behind unmarked doors and beneath the street, millions of pounds’ worth of diamonds, gold, and cash sit locked away in safety deposit boxes. So when one of the area’s most secure vaults was breached over the Easter holiday weekend in 2015… it didn’t make sense. There were no alarms that stopped them. No immediate suspects. And no sign of forced entry above ground. As investigators began to piece the case together, they soon realised this wasn’t a fast, opportunistic robbery. It was planned. Carefully. Over years. And the people behind it weren’t who anyone expected.This episode explores the Hatton Garden heist, how it was carried out, where it went wrong, and the small decisions that ultimately led police straight to those responsible.A case about planning, confidence… and the moment it all started to unravel.
  • 15. The Story He Told; Helen Bailey

    41:30||Season 6, Ep. 15
    Helen Bailey, a successful children’s author, had rebuilt her life after the loss of her husband. She’d even found love again.But then she abruptly disappeared from her home in Hertfordshire, England. Along with her dog, Boris.According to her partner, she’d gone away for a few days. Needed space. Time to herself.But the more time passed, the less that story made sense.Helen hadn’t told anyone she was leaving. Only a note explaining her absence.There were no confirmed sightings.Full 999 call: https://youtu.be/ZsS8X4Zspr4?si=rHOZs0bEFrgGzjgJAnd the last trace of her led straight back to the place she vanished from.As the investigation unfolded, the story being told began to shift.Because Helen… and Boris… hadn’t gone anywhere at all.