Share

The Cinedicate: Film & TV Podcast
SWAPCAST - Revenge of the Jedi (1983) - The Darker Star Wars That Never Was
On this swapcast episode, The Cinedicate and WSTR Galactic Public Access delve into the tangled legacy of "Return of the Jedi," discussing the initial creative conflicts with George Lucas and Gary Kurtz. From merchandising influence that transformed fierce Wookiee warriors into cute Ewoks to recreating the light tone of the original film, journey with us as we critique character shifts, explore alternative plotlines, and ponder the impact of Gary Kurtz's vision.
What to expect from the episode:
- An in-depth critique of "Return of the Jedi," focusing on character portrayals, particularly the hosts' frustration with the Ewoks and Han Solo's development.
- A thorough discussion on George Lucas's creative decisions, including the influence of merchandise and the potential fan backlash if social media existed during the original trilogy's release.
- Engaging reflections on alternative narratives and fan edits of Star Wars, including a hypothetical "Revenge of the Jedi" screenplay and reimagined sequences involving major battles and character arcs.
Episode Chapters
00:00 Introduction
01:07 The clash between George Lucas and Gary Kurtz.
09:43 Kurtz's departure from Star Wars.
13:58 Modern Disney lacks originality.
16:54 Simplifying Return of the Jedi's Ending.
24:36 Bygone movie credits.
32:31 Revenge of the Jedi screenplay.
53:40 Emperor traps rebels with leaked Death Star information.
59:19 Return of Jedi's simultaneous battles: spiritual, space, ground.
01:05:10 Skeleton Crew initial reactions.
01:11:22 Denis Villeneuve prefers Dune over Star Wars.
01:18:19 Cantina Chat.
01:27:41 Outro.
----------
Listen to Todd on his podcast, WSTR: Galactic Public Access.
----------
More episodes
View all episodes
SWAPCAST - Starship Troopers - Satirizing Fascism and Why This Film Still Resonates
01:53:19||Season 5Suit up, citizen! On this swapcast episode, Armand Haddad teams up with WSTR’s Todd Hoffman for an interstellar deep-dive into the cult classic Starship Troopers. From its satirical skewering of militarism and propaganda to jaw-dropping practical effects that still hold up, Armand and Todd tackle everything from fascism in sci-fi to parallels in the real world. Whether you’re a first-time viewer or a longtime fan, this conversation is equal parts hilarious and thoughtful. “Would you like to know more?”What to expect from the episode:A lively, satirical deep-dive into the 1997 film Starship Troopers, including its practical effects, campy style, and how its enduring legacy has inspired modern games like Helldivers 2.Critical discussion on the film’s social and political commentary, with emphasis on its nuanced satire of fascism, militarism, and propaganda—including why this was overlooked by critics and audiences upon release.Entertaining tangents exploring parallels between the movie and real-world history, the prospect of a reboot, comparison with other sci-fi works, and reflections on related pop culture phenomena, plus updates from the hosts on their current geeky obsessions.Episode Chapters:00:00:00 Foreword00:01:22 Introduction00:03:22 Tease of News Segments00:04:22 Main Topic: Starship Troopers00:06:03 Armand's First Viewing Experience00:09:11 Satire and Misinterpretation00:11:20 Political Themes: Fascism vs. Militarism00:15:38 Propaganda & The Federation’s Poor Planning00:21:12 Character Arc: Johnny Rico00:27:38 Emotional Turning Point & False Flag Theory00:35:00 Cycle of Indoctrination and Parroting Propaganda00:38:23 Mock Newsreels & Real-World Parallels (Star Wars: Andor)00:40:24 Historical Atrocities and Media Exposure00:43:50 Tangent: UFOs, Conspiracies & Remote Viewing00:45:40 Fascism’s Seductive Nature & Liberty Trade-Off00:49:39 Good People, Evil Systems00:54:28 Reboot Talk: Would It Work Today?00:57:45 15 Fun Facts of Starship Troopers01:11:37 Star Wars News of the Week01:33:03 Cantina Chat01:43:20 Redacted Entertainment, Star Wars Celebration, & Outro----------Listen to Todd on his podcast, WSTR: Galactic Public Access.----------The Cinedicate on InstagramThe Cinedicate's Discord Community79. #179 - Companion (2025) - Artificial-Intelligence, Love, and Isolation
01:14:11||Season 5, Ep. 79On this episode of The Cinedicate, Katie and Brit from The Grindhouse Girls return to dive deep into the sci-fi thriller Companion. Together, we unpack the film’s mind-bending twists, viral marketing, killer performances by Sophie Thatcher and Jack Quaid, and why going in blind is half the fun. The conversation winds through everything from AI romance and toxic relationships to 90s nostalgia, movie theaters, and how technology shapes our connections. Whether you’re a fan of horror, sci-fi, or just great discussion, this is a spoiler-filled, hilarious, and insightful exploration you don’t want to miss.What to expect from the episode:Spirited, spoiler-filled discussion of Companion, including initial reactions, hidden twists, and the film’s clever genre-blending of sci-fi, horror, comedy, and romance tropes.Deep-dive into the film’s themes: isolation and loneliness in the digital age, incel and gender dynamics, and the evolving nature of AI and human relationships, drawing thoughtful connections to other media like Blade Runner, Stepford Wives, and Her.Lively banter on movie marketing, theatrical vs. streaming releases, generational shifts in moviegoing, and ethical dilemmas around AI companions—plus plenty of personal anecdotes, pop culture tangents, and recommendations for related films.Episode Chapters00:00 Introduction01:21 First Impressions and Why Trailers Reveal Too Much11:23 The Desire for Longer Theater Runs18:02 Companion Plot Synopsis22:28 Layers Upon Layers of Twists26:00 Iris - A Metaphor For Toxic Relationships33:13 Programming or Sentient?36:55 Younger Generation Being Taken in By The Incel Culture45:12 Always Connected, Yet Disconnected55:06 Would You Trust an A.I. Companion?01:00:26 Desiring a Helpful Robot01:03:21 Spill Oil?01:10:45 Outro----------Listen to Brit and Katie on their podcast, The Grindhouse Girls.----------The Cinedicate on InstagramThe Cinedicate's Discord Community78. #178 - The Great Muppet Caper - Jim Henson's Legacy and How Disney Fumbled The Brand
01:06:55||Season 5, Ep. 78Get ready for a nostalgia-packed dive into one of Jim Henson’s finest creations! Heather from WSTR Galactic Public Access joins in to celebrate The Great Muppet Caper, sharing childhood memories, behind-the-scenes Muppet magic, and why the Muppets’ unique blend of wit and heart still matters today. From fourth-wall-breaking genius to questionable Disney decisions, it’s an honest and hilarious exploration of why the Muppets captured our hearts. If you love the Muppets (or just clever, feel-good movies), don’t miss this one!What to expect from the episode:A lively, nostalgia-filled discussion on The Great Muppet Caper, the legacy of Jim Henson, and the Muppets’ unique brand of humor—including reflections on their enduring appeal (or lack thereof) across generationsCritical takes on Disney’s stewardship of the Muppet franchise, the struggles of adapting Muppet content for modern audiences, and missed opportunities within theme parks and merchandisingFun insights into the hallmarks of classic Muppet movies, the importance of found family and situational comedy, plus candid opinions on whether the Muppets are still relevant todayEpisode Chapters:----------Listen to Heather on her podcast, WSTR: Galactic Public Access.----------The Cinedicate on InstagramThe Cinedicate's Discord CommunitySWAPCAST - The Wicker Man (1973/2006) - Bees, Bizarre Cults, and Bad Acting
01:21:10||Season 5On this wild anniversary episode, the Grindhouse Girls team up with The Cinedicate for a deep dive into the infamously off-the-rails 2006 remake of The Wicker Man. From “not the bees!”, bear costumes, a and punch-happy Nicolas Cage, we dissect everything that makes this cult failure so bizarrely watchable (or not). Along the way, expect hilarious tangents on gender in horror, Neil LaBute’s problematic writing, and why the original Wicker Man remains untouchable. Come for the memes, stay for the incisive film analysis—and discover why sometimes it’s best to leave a classic alone.What to expect from the episode:An irreverent deep dive into both the original 1973 Wicker Man and its infamous 2006 Nicolas Cage remake, with discussions on cult cinema, gender dynamics, and themes of religion vs. paganismLively critiques of Neil LaBute’s direction and writing, exploring his controversial reputation, handling of misogyny, and how the remake diverges (and spectacularly misses the point) from the original’s folk horror brillianceEntertaining banter about Nicolas Cage’s meme-worthy performance, the most (in)famous scenes (“not the bees!”), and the joys and pains of bad movies, plus thoughtful rants on cults, horror tropes, and recommendations for folk horror fans----------Listen to Brit and Katie on their podcast, The Grindhouse Girls.----------The Cinedicate on InstagramThe Cinedicate's Discord Community77. #177 - Invincible: Season 3 - Mark's Struggles, Conquest, and What’s Next for the Series
01:00:43||Season 5, Ep. 77Suit up and dive into the chaos of Invincible Season 3 with The Cinedicate! Join us for a spoiler-packed review that battles through teen drama, jaw-dropping gore, and the cosmic consequences of Mark Grayson’s choices. From favorite character breakdowns (Battle Beast, anyone?) to heated debates about comic vs. adaptation, this episode tackles everything that makes “Invincible” outrageously addictive. Whether you’ve read every page or you’re a show-first fan, there’s something here for everyone. Don’t miss the conversation that’s as sharp—and bloody—as a Viltrumite punch!What to expect from the episode:A lively breakdown of Invincible Season 3’s big story arcs, including Mark Grayson’s evolving morality, the show’s standout battles, and major character developments like the Mark and Eve relationshipA spirited comparison between the TV adaptation and the original comic, with behind-the-scenes insights into what the show improved (and what it changed), plus a bit of comic book lore and future speculationPlenty of fun banter about fan-favorite characters, the show’s star-studded voice cast, and predictions for what’s coming next in the Invincible universe—including the much-hyped Viltrum War and spin-offs like a new Battle Beast comicEpisode Chapters:00:00 Introduction01:22 First impression of Season 308:04 Robert Kirkman's Creative Second Chances12:41 Mark Grayson: Slowly Becoming The Villain18:27 Teasing The Viltrum War22:05 Mark Grayson's Defiance27:10 Omni-Man: The Road to Redemption29:50 Rex Gets 'Sploded38:12 Robert Kirkman's Well-Written Vignettes41:33 Viewing the World Beyond Black and White46:08 Off The Fence Questions54:45 Atom Eve Cliffhanger57:29 Outro----------Listen to Hector and Ed on their podcast, ReShoot: An Amateur's Guide to Gooder Film----------The Cinedicate on InstagramThe Cinedicate's Discord Community76. #176 - Andor: Season 1 - Tony Gilroy’s Masterclass of Gritty Storytelling in Star Wars
02:19:23||Season 5, Ep. 76Join us as we dive deep into "Andor," unpacking the gritty layers of Star Wars' newest triumph. From heated discussions about the Empire's sway to exhilarating prison escapes and the complex tapestry of rebellion, this episode peels back the grand mythology to reveal compelling, grounded narratives. Experience Star Wars storytelling where politics, espionage, and the harsh realities of galactic life take the center stage. Perfect for both seasoned fans and curious newcomers, discover why "Andor" is the Game of Thrones of the Star Wars universe.What to expect from the episode:An in-depth analysis of Andor's storytelling, cinematography, and character development, highlighting its distinction from traditional Star Wars narratives by focusing on a more grounded and mature narrative.Discussions on the implications of the Death Star as a metaphor for modern geopolitical anxieties, examining its thematic significance in relation to nuclear threats and authoritarian control.Exploration of character dynamics, with a focus on Cassian Andor's role as a survivor rather than a hero, and the complex interweaving of political intrigue within the Star Wars universe, particularly through the lens of Mon Mothma's character.Episode Chapters:00:00 Introduction01:22 Andor first impressions12:56 – The Yuuzhan Vong Invasion & Existential Dread23:37 – Andor's Plot Synopsis & Rogue One Analysis34:36 – The Aldhani Heist46:38 – Racial Tension Subtext54:34 – The Galactic Empire's War Machine01:04:30 – The Imperial Prison: A Sisyphean Fate01:14:32 – ISB: Bureaucracy & Backstabbing01:24:19 – Mon Mothma: The Final Days of the Senate01:38:32 – The Beginning of the Rebel Alliance01:45:00 – Tarkin's Vendetta Against The Death Star01:53:32 – Removing The Myth in Star Wars02:04:41 – Death Star: A Metaphor for Nuclear War02:11:02 – Final Question & Outro----------The Cinedicate on InstagramThe Cinedicate's Discord Community75. #175 - Anora - A Testament to Authenticity and Vulnerability
56:18||Season 5, Ep. 75In this episode of we dive into the Oscar-winning film "Anora" with special guest Cam Lewis. Together, we unravel the shocking twists and emotional depth of Sean Baker's latest masterpiece with the raw authenticity of guerrilla filmmaking and the gripping performances that brought this film to life. Tune in for a lively discussion that highlights why "Anora" is the quintessential example of powerful, low-budget cinema that challenges both its characters and audience with its hauntingly real narrative.Episode Chapters:00:00 Introduction01:20 Anora first impressions and looking back on the Oscars13:19 Plot synopsis20:03 - Post-RomCom "Reality Check"26:13 - Parallel Escapism35:30 - Trauma Bonding & Igor's Heart of Gold38:50 - Sean Baker's wit in his writing40:50 - Anora's ending49:13 - Off The Fence55:44 - Outro----------BearSprout FilmsWatch Scones OnlineFollow Cam Lewis on Instagram----------The Cinedicate on InstagramThe Cinedicate's Discord Community74. #174 - The Gorge - A Cosmic Horror Hidden Gem
50:25||Season 5, Ep. 74Join us as we dive into the unexpected twists of the thrilling film "The Gorge," starring Miles Teller and Anya Taylor-Joy. Discover why its hauntingly beautiful visuals and engaging storytelling make it a must-watch and a hidden gem. Whether you're a fan of sci-fi, romance, or just a good story, "The Gorge" might just surprise you. Tune in for an energetic discussion filled with humor, critical insights, and a dose of cinematic debate.What to expect from the episode:Detailed discussion of the film "The Gorge," including its plot, character dynamics, and standout momentsExploration of the film's creative elements, such as its approach to cosmic horror and unique cinematographyConsideration of potential narratives, like sequels or alternative endings, while examining the influence of artistic inspirations on the movie's design and execution.Episode Chapters:00:00 Introduction01:20 First impressions07:36 Story Synopsis11:09 Secrets of WWII14:27 Drassa17:10 Secrets within The Gorge20:04 Cosmic Horror26:36 Discussing the ambiguous ending34:18 Blomkamp's District 936:04 Chappie: A Career-Killing Film39:21 Levi's Path and Future Choices41:55 Off The Fence48:24 Taking inspiration from high art----------The Cinedicate on InstagramThe Cinedicate's Discord Community73. #173 - John Carpenter's Escape From New York - Cold War Anxieties, Police-State Dread, and Kurt Russell
01:11:32||Season 5, Ep. 73Join us as we delve into John Carpenter's dystopian vision of the future, Escape from New York. Alongside Todd Hoffman from WSTR Galactic Public Access, we uncover the gritty and enigmatic world of Snake Plissken and his mission to rescue the President from a chaotic, prison-turned Manhattan. From the eerie post-apocalyptic undertones of the 80s to the uncanny parallels with today’s societal anxieties, this episode explores the film's action-packed thrills and its deeper messages about authority, chaos, and survival. Whether you’re riding along with Snake’s anti-hero vibes or pondering the impact of unchecked power, this discussion promises to keep you on the edge of your seat.What to expect from the episode:An exploration of John Carpenter's film, Escape from New York, and its contextual relevance to the societal anxieties of the 1980s, including themes of dystopia and government control.An in-depth discussion on the character of Snake Plissken and the film's portrayal of lawlessness versus authority, touching upon themes of nihilism and anti-authoritarianism.Considerations for a hypothetical modern remake, including potential directors like Neil Blomkamp, and the cultural relevance of the film's dystopian themes today.Episode Chapters:00:00 IntroductionHere are the adjusted timecodes with an added 1 minute and 14 seconds:01:14 First impressions08:30 Inciting incident & Manhattan converted into a prison18:00 Overthinking things again...24:39 Starved Crazies29:43 Christopher Nolan is a hack38:11 Dual Despotism in Dystopian Manhattan40:07 Managed Democracy47:59 Constraints creates creativity51:45 '80s Action Stars: Rebel Archetype56:13 Chaos in Pursuit of Order01:10:57 Outro----------Listen to Todd on his podcast, WSTR: Galactic Public Access.----------The Cinedicate on InstagramThe Cinedicate's Discord Community