Whitehall Sources

In this podcast episode, former Health Department Special Adviser, Ed Jones, joins Isabel Hardman - Assistant Editor of The Spectator and author of Fighting for Life - The Twelve Battles that Made Our NHS, and the Struggle for Its Future - along with Calum and Kirsty to discuss the current state of the NHS under the Labour government, focusing on Wes Streeting's recent announcements regarding reforms. They explore the implications of league tables, accountability, and the morale of NHS staff, while also considering the historical context of NHS reforms. The conversation delves into the role of consumer choice in healthcare, the importance of political capital, and the urgent need for social care reform. Ultimately, they reflect on the challenges and opportunities facing the NHS as it navigates a complex landscape of expectations and demands. Isabel critiques the lack of coherent reform despite significant funding and highlights the historical challenges the NHS has faced since its inception in 1948. The discussion also delves into the future of the NHS, emphasising the need for social care reform and addressing the mixed healthcare landscape that has emerged.

Donald Trump is set to return to the White House, having promised action on issues including immigration, the economy and the war in Ukraine. He looks likely to enjoy plenty of support for his political agenda in Congress after his Republican Party regained control of the Senate. In his victory speech, Trump vowed: "I will govern by a simple motto: Promises made, promises kept. We’re going to keep our promises." Kirsty and Calum discuss the implications.

In our first ever crossover episode with the Holyrood Sources podcast, we assess the implications of the UK Government budget.The first section of both podcasts features former advisers from across the political spectrum.The podcasts then return to their own list of guests and commentators and analysts.Search Holyrood Sources to listen to our sister podcast.GUEST LISTSTEPHEN FLYNN, SNP Westminster leader and MP for Aberdeen South; WENDY CHAMBERLAIN, Liberal Democrat Chief Whip and MP for North East Fife; HARRIET CROSS, Conservative MP for Gordon and Buchan and on the Scottish Affairs Committee; DR ZUBIR AHMED is Labour MP for Glasgow South West; Dr JEEVUN SANDHER, Labour MP for Loughborough who sits on the Treasury Committee; HEATHER IQBAL was a political adviser and media spokesperson for Chancellor Rachel Reeves for three years in opposition; ALLIE RENISON, Associate Director at SEC Newgate and former Government Business Adviser; GRAINNE GILMORE director of research & insights at Cluttons property consultants; JOÃO SOUSA, Deputy Director Fraser of Allander Institute; ALEXANDER BROWN, Westminster Correspondent for The Scotsman; CAROLINE WHEELER, Political Editor of The Sunday Times; DAVID PHILIPS, Associate Director at the Institute for Fiscal Studies, who leads on devolved and local government finance; GRAEME LITTLEJOHN, Director of Strategy and Comms for the Scotch Whisky Association

Calum Macdonald and Kirsty Buchanan discuss various pressing political issues in the UK, including prison overcrowding, the Labour Party's involvement in US elections, and the upcoming budget. Kirsty shares insights from her experience in the Ministry of Justice, emphasising the complexities of the criminal justice system and the need for reform. The conversation also touches on the political implications of Labour's actions and the fiscal strategies being employed by the government.

Calum and Kirsty discuss recent budget leaks and their implications, the ongoing political controversy surrounding Taylor Swift's concert, and reflect on the legacy of Alex Salmond following his passing. They explore the impact of Salmond on Scottish politics and the broader UK landscape, emphasising his unique ability to engage with diverse audiences and drive significant political change. The conversation also touches on the current state of the Scottish government and the challenges it faces in seizing opportunities for energy transition. Plus, the conversation delves into the upcoming UK budget, discussing the current economic context, particularly the low inflation rate, and the various tax policies being considered. The speakers analyze the political implications of these budget discussions, emphasizing the importance of public perception and the government's ability to manage expectations. They highlight the challenges faced by the government in maintaining trust and the potential impact of their decisions on economic growth.Scarlett Maguire discusses the current political landscape in the UK and the US, focusing on the challenges faced by the Labour Party under Keir Starmer and the dynamics of the upcoming US elections with Trump and Harris. The discussion highlights public perception, polling data, and the implications of key policies and events on voter sentiment.

In this episode of Whitehall Sources, Calum Macdonald and Kirsty Buchanan discuss the mounting expectations surrounding the upcoming UK budget, the implications of Sue Gray's resignation, and the unexpected twists in the Conservative leadership contest. They explore the challenges facing the party, including issues of unity and direction, and the potential impact of the leadership debates on the party's future.Jordan Urban, a senior researcher at the Institute for Government, discusses the recent political dynamics surrounding the Labour government, particularly focusing on the resignation of Sue Gray and its implications for governance. The discussion delves into the roles within Number 10, the structural challenges faced by the government, and the importance of clear direction and communication in effective governance. Urban emphasises the need for a coherent organisational structure and the impact of personal dynamics on the functioning of government, while also highlighting the challenges that lie ahead for the Labour party as they navigate their early days in power.

In this episode of Whitehall Sources, Calum Macdonald and Kirsty Buchanan delve into the current political landscape, focusing on the escalating tensions in the Middle East and the ongoing Conservative leadership contest in the UK. They analyse the speeches of the four candidates vying for leadership, discussing their strengths, weaknesses, and the implications for the party's future. The conversation highlights the complexities of international relations and domestic politics, emphasising the need for clarity in the Conservative Party's direction amidst a challenging political climate.

Calum and Kirsty are joined by Jo Tanner who's nursing some Lemsip after Labour Party Conference. We delve into the recent Labour Party conference, exploring its significance, the challenges faced by the new government, and the public's perception of their performance. Kirsty and Joe provide insights into the conference atmosphere, the handling of controversies, and the implications of key policy decisions, particularly regarding winter fuel payments. The discussion also touches on the importance of effective communication and the impact of speeches on public sentiment, culminating in a humorous reflection on a notable gaffe made during the conference speeches.

Lord Darroch, Kim Darroch, joins to discuss Sir Keir Starmer's visit to the United States. The UK's former ambassador to the US says it's significant as it is his first visit to the White House. The purpose of the visit is to discuss various international issues, including Ukraine and Gaza. There is speculation about a potential meeting between Starmer and Kamala Harris, which could create diplomatic tensions. The relationship between the UK and the US has been impacted by Brexit, but defence, security, and intelligence links remain strong. The relationship could become more strained if Donald Trump wins the presidential election. Kamala Harris has shown some differences in her approach to Israel and Ukraine compared to Biden, but overall, there is unlikely to be a significant deviation in US policy.Plus, Kirsty and Calum discuss the winter fuel payment cuts and the impact on pensioners. We explore the controversy surrounding the decision and the political implications for Keir Starmer and the Labour Party. We touch on party discipline, the handling of the policy announcement, and the upcoming budget.