Share

cover art for Practical Magic

When Harry Dumped Sally

Practical Magic

•

Get ready to dance naked in the moonlight because this week we watched Practical Magic! We discuss witches, male witches (they don't exist), and why the perfect man will always be able to flip a pancake. Will Sally and Gary stay together forever*?? (*until he ultimately dies from “natural causes.”) Listen to find out!

Join our Patreon at http://www.patreon.com/cw/whenharrydumpedsally

More episodes

View all episodes

  • Something’s Gotta Give

    01:14:02|
    Would you date a guy who is old enough to be your Grandpa?? We’re discussing that and MORE in this week's episode about Something’s Gotta Give! We talk about married men living longer, the risks of dating an artist who might use your relationship for inspiration, and why cigarettes in Paris don’t count. Will Harry and Erica stay together until death do they part? Listen to find out!
  • Together

    56:12|
    This week we’re kicking off spooky season with Together! We discuss codependence vs interdependence, the suburbs turning people weird, and why men should have bangs! Will Tim and Millie stay (fused) together forever?? Listen to find out!
  • I'm Your Man (Ich bin dein Mensch)

    01:30:31|
    Would you date a robot that was created specifically for you?? We’re talking about that and MORE in this week’s episode. It’s our first foreign language film! It’s the end of the world! It’s I’m Your Man (aka Ich bin dein Mensch)! We discuss what makes us human, people who are dating their AI, and AI pets. Will Alma and her perfect robot man Tom stay together forever?? Listen to find out!
  • Napoleon Dynamite

    42:59|
    This week we embraced Millennial cringe and watched Napoleon Dynamite! We discuss Mormons dating, how high schools are similar to prisons, and why weird girls always have weird hair. Plus how long we think Kip and LaFawnduh will stay together after the credits roll!
  • It Could Happen To You

    51:27|
    Would you share your lottery winnings with a total stranger?? We’re discussing that and MORE in this week's episode about It Could Happen To You. We talk about copaganda, the best nut, and men giving people their WORD. How long will Charlie and Yvonne stay together after the credits roll? Listen to find out!
  • Ever After

    01:06:18|
    This week we’re discovering the TRUE STORY of Cinderella, with Ever After! We talk about insults that stick with you forever, politely taking turns during a sword fight, and HISTORY. Will Danielle and Prince Henry live happily ever after?? Listen to find out!
  • Bring It On

    01:33:10|
    This week we watched Bring It On with our friend Chloe Kiester! We discuss the not so subliminal messaging we were given about our bodies in the early 2000s, siblings that have a little too much chemistry, and TWINS (are they creepy or totally normal and not weird at all??). Will Torrance and Cliff spend the rest of their lives together? Listen to find out! (And if you like it, keep listening!!!)
  • There’s Something About Mary

    47:40|
    This week we got rid of our personalities and became every man’s fantasy with There’s Something About Mary! We discuss getting your junk stuck in a zipper, jerking off before dates, and being a COOL GIRL. Will Mary be the woman of Ted’s dreams forever? Listen to find out!