Share

The Chocolate Podcast
Why Does Hershey's Chocolate Taste Like Sick?
Why does Hershey's chocolate taste like vomit? And how did Milton Hershey turn a strange-tasting milk chocolate into one of the biggest chocolate brands in the world?
In Part Two of the Hershey story, Ed Easton and Andrew Nason explore the invention of American milk chocolate, the science behind its distinctive flavour and the extraordinary decisions that transformed Milton Hershey's chocolate empire.
After selling his successful caramel business for $1 million in 1900, Milton Hershey could have retired a wealthy man. Instead, inspired by European chocolate makers and his travels with his wife, Kitty, he invested his fortune into a new ambition: making milk chocolate affordable for everyone.
But there was one problem. The Swiss had already perfected milk chocolate, and Hershey couldn't replicate their process.
We explore how Daniel Peter and Henri Nestlé helped pioneer Swiss milk chocolate, how Cadbury developed its distinctive British chocolate-making methods, and how Hershey's experiments with milk created a completely different American flavour.
At the centre of the mystery is butyric acid, a compound associated with the distinctive tangy, sometimes vomit-like smell and taste of Hershey's chocolate. But how did it end up in American chocolate, and why did this unusual flavour become so popular?
Andrew and Ed put three famous chocolate brands to the test, tasting Hershey's, Cadbury Dairy Milk and Lindt to discover what makes American, British and Swiss milk chocolate so different.
We also uncover Hershey's relationship with his wife Kitty, the influence of Cadbury's Bournville village, the origins of Hershey's Kisses and the remarkable connection between Milton Hershey and the Titanic.
From chocolate chemistry and industrial innovation to one of the most extraordinary stories in American business history, this episode reveals how Hershey changed chocolate forever.
In this episode:
- Why Hershey's chocolate tastes different from European chocolate
- The science of butyric acid and American milk chocolate
- How Swiss, British and American chocolate-making methods developed
- Milton Hershey's $1 million gamble on chocolate
- The influence of Cadbury, Nestlé and Lindt
- The story of Milton and Kitty Hershey
- The origins of Hershey's Kisses and the Titanic connection
This is Part Two of our Milton Hershey series. Watch Part One to discover how a struggling confectioner built a caramel empire before risking everything on chocolate.
Subscribe to The Chocolate Podcast for more stories exploring the history, science and extraordinary people behind the world's favourite food.
More episodes
View all episodes

6. What Happened to Reeses Peanut Butter Cups?
44:23||Season 4, Ep. 6Have Reese's Peanut Butter Cups changed, or is childhood nostalgia playing tricks on us? Even the grandson of the founder of Reese's is questioning what has happened to his grandfather's legacy.In this episode of The Chocolate Podcast, Andrew and Kitty investigate the extraordinary history of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, from their humble beginnings in 1928 to becoming one of America's most beloved chocolate brands.We uncover the remarkable story of Harry Burnett Reese, a dairy farmer and father of 16 children who worked for Milton Hershey before creating his own chocolate empire from his kitchen table.His original peanut butter cup was remarkably simple: chocolate, peanuts and sugar. So what happened?From the sugar rationing of World War II to Hershey's acquisition of Reese's in 1963, we trace the evolution of the recipe through decades of historical ingredient lists, examining the introduction of preservatives, emulsifiers, vegetable oils and additional sugars.We also explore the extraordinary marketing gamble that saw Reese's Pieces featured in Steven Spielberg's E.T., after M&M's reportedly turned down the opportunity.But perhaps the most revealing part of the Reese's story is the recent controversy surrounding Brad Reese, the founder's grandson, who publicly criticised changes to Reese's products.In this episode, we explore:The history of Reese's Peanut Butter CupsThe original 1928 Reese's recipeThe relationship between H.B. Reese and Milton HersheyHow World War II transformed the Reese's Candy CompanyHow E.T. changed the fortunes of Reese's PiecesHow Reese's ingredients have evolved over nearly 100 yearsWhat TBHQ, PGPR and other food additives doThe difference between real chocolate and compound chocolateWhy the founder's grandson is criticising Hershey'sWhether corporate ownership has compromised the quality of America's favourite chocolate brandsPart forensic food investigation and part chocolate history, this episode asks a much bigger question: is the story of Reese's a warning about what has happened to the American food industry?Have you noticed a difference in the taste of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups? Let us know in the comments.Subscribe to The Chocolate Podcast for more investigations into the history, science and secrets behind the world's most famous chocolate brands.#Reeses #ReesesPeanutButterCups #Hersheys #ChocolateHistory #FoodHistory #PeanutButter #ChocolatePodcast
5. Why Did Cadbury and Hershey Build Entire Towns?
38:22||Season 4, Ep. 5Can chocolate change the world? Milton Hershey and George Cadbury certainly believed it could.Behind two of the world's most famous chocolate brands lies an extraordinary story of philanthropy, social reform and the ambition to build a better society through chocolate.In this episode of The Chocolate Podcast, Ed Easton and Andrew Nason of Melt Chocolates explore the fascinating history of Cadbury and Hershey, two chocolate pioneers who believed their businesses could do more than simply make money.During an era of industrial poverty, overcrowded cities and poor working conditions, George Cadbury and Milton Hershey set out to create something extraordinary: communities built around their chocolate factories, designed to improve the lives of their workers and families.From Bournville, Cadbury's model village in Birmingham, to Hershey, Pennsylvania, America's famous chocolate town, we explore how two businessmen attempted to create their own versions of a chocolate utopia.But were these communities genuinely revolutionary examples of corporate philanthropy, or did they also give chocolate manufacturers extraordinary control over their workers' lives?In this episode, we explore:The remarkable history of Milton Hershey and George CadburyHow Cadbury created the Bournville model villageThe story behind Hershey, Pennsylvania, and America's chocolate townThe influence of Quaker values on the Cadbury chocolate businessHow chocolate manufacturers approached workers' welfare, housing and educationThe relationship between chocolate, philanthropy and social reformWhether businesses can genuinely create a better societyFrom the Industrial Revolution to the modern chocolate industry, this is the story of two men who wanted to build a paradise powered by chocolate.Could chocolate really save the world?Subscribe to The Chocolate Podcast for more fascinating stories about the history, science, culture and people behind chocolate.#Cadbury #Hershey #ChocolateHistory #Bournville #MiltonHershey #GeorgeCadbury #ChocolatePodcast
3. How Milton Hershey Went From Failure to Chocolate Billionaire
31:01||Season 4, Ep. 3Why does American chocolate taste so different? And how did a failed candy maker become the founder of one of the biggest chocolate companies in the world?In this episode of The Chocolate Podcast, Ed Easton and Andrew Nason uncover the extraordinary story of Milton Hershey, the man who transformed American chocolate forever.Born in 1857, Hershey grew up caught between two very different parents. His father, Henry, was an ambitious dreamer whose endless business ventures often ended in failure. His mother, Fanny, was a strict Mennonite who believed in hard work, discipline and religion. Together, their opposing personalities would shape one of America's most influential entrepreneurs.We follow Hershey through his early failures, disastrous business decisions and the unlikely discovery of a new caramel-making technique that would change his fortunes. From selling sweets on the streets of Lancaster to building a hugely successful caramel company, Hershey's journey is a story of perseverance, innovation and extraordinary ambition.But just as he finally achieves success, Hershey makes an astonishing decision. He sells his entire caramel empire after discovering something he believes will change the future of confectionery: milk chocolate.Why would a successful businessman abandon everything he'd built? And how would his next invention help explain the unusual taste of American chocolate, including the distinctive flavour associated with Hershey's?This is Part One of the Milton Hershey story, exploring the origins of Hershey's chocolate, the history of American confectionery and the family relationships that shaped the chocolate industry.Follow The Chocolate Podcast as we continue tracing the history of milk chocolate, from its earliest innovations to the global chocolate brands we know today.
2. Did M&M's Change American Chocolate Forever?
39:34||Season 4, Ep. 2How did Forrest Mars fight his way back into the family business and turn Mars into one of the most powerful companies in the world?In Part Two of the Mars story, Ed Easton and Andrew Nason are joined again by Melt’s chocolate researcher, Kitty Nason to uncover the extraordinary battle for control of the Mars chocolate empire. After the death of Frank Mars, the company didn’t simply pass to his son. Instead, Forrest found himself fighting family members, executives and competing interests for control of the business that carried his name. We follow the family power struggle that eventually pushed Forrest towards one of his most important creations: M&M’s. After approaching Hershey executive William Murrie, Forrest formed a new company, secured access to rationed chocolate during the Second World War and supplied M&M’s to the US military. The success would ultimately give him the financial power he needed to pursue control of Mars.But taking over was only the beginning. We explore Forrest’s obsessive approach to quality, his ruthless management style, the transformation of Mars into a global operation, and the extraordinary family dynamics that continued into the next generation. Even retirement couldn’t stop him: after handing Mars over to his son, he went on to establish another successful chocolate company named after his mother, Ethel M. From Mars Bars and M&M’s to pet food and Uncle Ben’s, this is the story of the ambition, rivalry and family conflict behind one of the most recognisable food companies on Earth. Follow The Chocolate Podcast for more episodes uncovering the history, science and people behind chocolate.
1. The Weird Link Between Dog Food and Mars Bars
31:15||Season 4, Ep. 1How did Mars go from a failed family candy business to the beginnings of one of the biggest chocolate companies in the world?In this episode of The Chocolate Podcast, Ed Easton and Andrew Nason are joined by Melt’s Kitty to uncover the extraordinary story of Frank Mars and Forrest Mars, the father and son behind the Mars chocolate empire. From making candy at home and failed early businesses to a family feud that would transform the chocolate industry, the story of Mars is far stranger than you might expect. We trace the creation of the Milky Way and Mars Bar, discover why the American Milky Way is completely different from the British one, and follow Forrest Mars from a Chicago prison to Yale, Swiss chocolate factories, Cadbury and, eventually, Slough, where he began building his own chocolate empire.Along the way, we explore the birth of the modern candy bar, the industrialisation of chocolate, Mars's surprising move into pet food, and the bitter relationship between Frank and Forrest that ultimately left Forrest frozen out of the family company after his father's death.And that's only the first half of the story.Next episode: What happens when Forrest Mars returns to America determined to take control of the company that bears his name?Follow The Chocolate Podcast for more stories exploring the history, science and people behind chocolate.Topics: Mars chocolate history, Mars Bar history, Milky Way chocolate, Forrest Mars, Frank Mars, history of chocolate, chocolate industry, candy bar history, Mars Incorporated, British chocolate history.
11. The Villain of El Dorado | Lope de Aguirre
45:35||Season 3, Ep. 11In this episode of The Chocolate Podcast, Andrew & Ed Easton roleplay and discuss the life of Lope de Aguirre, a Basque conquistador who fought for Spain in Peru, who was publicly whipped for mistreating indigenous people, hunted down and murdered Judge Esquivel, then joined an El Dorado expedition led by Pedro de Ursúa. Aguirre helps overthrow and kill Ursúa, installs Fernando de Guzmán as a figurehead prince, then betrays and kills Guzmán and others, imposes paranoid rules, and writes a manifesto-style letter rebelling against King Philip II and the Spanish monopoly system. After seizing Margarita Island and committing further brutality, his force dwindles through desertion as Spain offers pardons; surrounded in Venezuela, Aguirre kills his daughter to prevent her capture, is shot by his own men, beheaded, and displayed. We link his story to the destructive realities of the so-called Columbian Exchange and the suppression of indigenous chocolate knowledge.Subscribe to our Substack for more in-depth articles about chocolate history. https://substack.com/@meltchocolatesBrowse our chocolate collection, hand-made made by top chocolatiers in London, Notting Hill. https://meltchocolates.com/
10. Rum, Resilience, and Revolution: Henry Morgan's Last Stand Pt.3
00:00||Season 3, Ep. 10How did Captain Henry Morgan pull off one of the most audacious pirate attacks in history?In the final chapter of our story of Captain Henry Morgan, we follow the legendary privateer as he attempts the seemingly impossible: the capture of Panama City.After surviving the explosion of his own flagship, Morgan could have walked away. Instead, he assembled the largest Buccaneer force of its kind, bringing together around 2,000 English, French, Dutch, African and Caribbean fighters for an extraordinary expedition across Panama.But Panama wasn’t waiting to be attacked.The Spanish knew Morgan was coming. Forts were reinforced, soldiers prepared, routes blocked and supplies removed. To reach the city, Morgan and his men would have to capture heavily defended positions, travel down the Chagres River, cross dense rainforest and survive hunger, ambushes and disease before they could even face the Spanish army.And then there were the cows.In this episode of The Chocolate Podcast, we explore the extraordinary Battle of Panama, the disastrous Spanish cattle strategy, the mysterious fate of Panama’s silver and the combination of resilience, brutality and military ingenuity that turned Henry Morgan into a legend.We also uncover the connection to chocolate. Pirates weren’t simply hunting for chests of gold. Sugar, cacao and other valuable commodities were an important part of the Caribbean economy they were fighting over, and chocolate itself could be treasure.Finally, we follow Morgan back to England, where the man who should perhaps have been punished for attacking Panama instead found himself celebrated, knighted and ultimately transformed from pirate into politician.Was Henry Morgan a criminal, a military genius, an entrepreneur or simply the ultimate opportunist?Probably a little of all four.🍫 Explore more from Melt Chocolates: https://meltchocolates.com🎙️ Subscribe to The Chocolate Podcast and turn on notifications so you never miss a new episode.#TheChocolatePodcast #CaptainMorgan #HenryMorgan #Pirates #PirateHistory #Panama #ChocolateHistory #Cacao #CaribbeanHistory #Buccaneers #FoodHistory #MeltChocolate
9. Ruthless Criminal or Tactical Genius? Andrew & Ed Investigate Henry Morgan Pt.2
43:47||Season 3, Ep. 9The legend of Henry Morgan continues. In Part 2 of our deep dive into the life of the world’s most famous (and misunderstood) pirate, we explore the daring raids, political maneuvers, and the surprising legacy he left behind.Was Henry Morgan a ruthless criminal or a tactical genius? From the shores of Port Royal to the heart of the Spanish Empire, we unpack the history that the textbooks often leave out. If you missed the beginning of this journey, make sure to catch up on the first part of our Henry Morgan series on the Chocolate Podcast.In this video, we cover:The strategic brilliance behind Morgan's most famous battles.How a "pirate" became the Lieutenant Governor of Jamaica.The truth behind the myths of the Caribbean’s Golden Age.Connect with Chocolate Podcast:Subscribe to our Substack for more in-depth articles about chocolate history. https://substack.com/@meltchocolatesBrowse our chocolate collection, hand-made made by top chocolatiers in London, Notting Hill. https://meltchocolates.com/Follow us on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/melt_chocolates/ #HenryMorgan #PirateHistory #ChocolatePodcast #HistoryDeepDive #CaribbeanHistory #PortRoyal #TrueStory