Share

cover art for ACCIDENT GONE WRONG? | Ep 3 | Kathryn Marsh

Voices of a Killer

ACCIDENT GONE WRONG? | Ep 3 | Kathryn Marsh

Ep. 3

On this episode of Voices of a Killer, on a fateful day in 2019 in Chesterfield, Missouri, Kathryn Marsh and her boyfriend, Matthew Baker, were out drinking together. But tragedy struck when Kathryn ran over Matthew with a truck in the parking lot of a restaurant. At first, it was thought to be an accident, but as the investigation unfolded, doubts were raised about the circumstances of Matthew's death. We’ll hear about the development of Kathryn and Matthew’s relationship; the events of that tragic moment and the consequences of Kathryn’s actions.

So sit back, listen closely as, we'll seek to uncover the truth and shed light on the devastating consequences of a single moment of recklessness that led to this heartbreaking incident that has left many wondering what truly happened on that fateful day.


More information about this case:



If you enjoyed this episode then please either:


More episodes

View all episodes

  • 132. FACING THE CONSEQUENCES | Ep 82 Part 3 | Jeremiah Searles

    22:51||Ep. 132
    In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we dive into the troubling and violent story of Jeremiah Searles, a man whose life was shaped by trauma, obsession, and ultimately, murder. Jeremiah’s journey is marked by a long history of emotional turmoil; an upbringing defined by instability, time spent in boys’ homes, and struggles with anger and control. But it’s his volatile relationship with Melissa Chapman that takes center stage, culminating in a brutal act of violence that left her dead and Jeremiah facing a 30-year prison sentence.More information about this case:News about charge | Bethany man charged with kidnapping, assault and abuse of a child | KTTNNews about sentencing | Denver, Missouri man admits murdering woman during court appearance, sentenced to 30-years in prison | KTTNNews about sentencing | Man sentenced for killing woman set to testify against him | AP News Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
  • 131. BROKEN TRUST | Ep 82 Part 2 | Jeremiah Searles

    24:04||Ep. 131
    In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we dive into the troubling and violent story of Jeremiah Searles, a man whose life was shaped by trauma, obsession, and ultimately, murder. Jeremiah’s journey is marked by a long history of emotional turmoil; an upbringing defined by instability, time spent in boys’ homes, and struggles with anger and control. But it’s his volatile relationship with Melissa Chapman that takes center stage, culminating in a brutal act of violence that left her dead and Jeremiah facing a 30-year prison sentence.More information about this case:News about charge | Bethany man charged with kidnapping, assault and abuse of a child | KTTNNews about sentencing | Denver, Missouri man admits murdering woman during court appearance, sentenced to 30-years in prison | KTTNNews about sentencing | Man sentenced for killing woman set to testify against him | AP News Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
  • 130. WHO WAS IN CONTROL? | Ep 82 Part 1 | Jeremiah Searles

    25:56||Ep. 130
    In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we dive into the troubling and violent story of Jeremiah Searles, a man whose life was shaped by trauma, obsession, and ultimately, murder. Jeremiah’s journey is marked by a long history of emotional turmoil; an upbringing defined by instability, time spent in boys’ homes, and struggles with anger and control. But it’s his volatile relationship with Melissa Chapman that takes center stage, culminating in a brutal act of violence that left her dead and Jeremiah facing a 30-year prison sentence.More information about this case:News about charge | Bethany man charged with kidnapping, assault and abuse of a child | KTTNNews about sentencing | Denver, Missouri man admits murdering woman during court appearance, sentenced to 30-years in prison | KTTNNews about sentencing | Man sentenced for killing woman set to testify against him | AP News Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
  • 130. Casey White | Tells the Truth after Netflix | SPECIAL FEATURE EPISODE

    01:12:11||Ep. 130
    In this Voices of a Killer EXCLUSIVE special feature interview with Casey White on Voices of a Killer, where Casey shares his story in a way never heard before. This revealing conversation goes beyond what's shown in the Netflix documentary Jailbreak: Love on the Run, offering a unique perspective straight from the source. Casey reveals NEW EVIDENCE that was NOT COVERED in the documentary. #caseywhite #vickywhite #netflix #loveontherun #jailbreak #truecrimedocumentaryBecome a MEMBER here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC08FlpLdyXS1xTdLcL4HnlQ/join
  • 129. A CHAOTIC GETAWAY ATTEMPT | Ep 81 Part 3 | Derrell Spellmeyer

    17:44||Ep. 129
    In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we explore the dark, chaotic story of Derrell Spellmeyer; a man whose descent from casual drug use spiraled into a chilling double homicide and a future spent behind bars. Derrell's story isn’t that of a hardened criminal or someone scarred by a violent past. Instead, it’s the story of a man whose life veered off course in ways he could never imagine.As we explore Derrell’s account, you’ll hear one of the most shocking confessions we’ve come across; an admission that blurs the lines between intent and intoxication, recklessness and ruthless action. Alongside him were Mandy and Garland Mitchell, two friends who unwittingly found themselves entangled in a nightmare with irreversible consequences.More information about this case:Video of news | Double homicide suspect's name heard on 911 callNews about sentencing | Judge sentences Eldon man to life in prison for murder of elderly couple | Lake of the Ozarks News | lakeexpo.comUpdate on charges | UPDATE: Charges, details emerge in Versailles double homicide | Lake of the Ozarks News | lakeexpo.comNews about the Mitchells (co-defendants) | Jefferson City couple pleads out of murder chargeAccess exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
  • 128. BRUTALLY MURERED FOR SOME PILLS | Ep 81 Part 2 | Derrell Spellmeyer

    22:45||Ep. 128
    In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we explore the dark, chaotic story of Derrell Spellmeyer; a man whose descent from casual drug use spiraled into a chilling double homicide and a future spent behind bars. Derrell's story isn’t that of a hardened criminal or someone scarred by a violent past. Instead, it’s the story of a man whose life veered off course in ways he could never imagine.As we explore Derrell’s account, you’ll hear one of the most shocking confessions we’ve come across; an admission that blurs the lines between intent and intoxication, recklessness and ruthless action. Alongside him were Mandy and Garland Mitchell, two friends who unwittingly found themselves entangled in a nightmare with irreversible consequences.More information about this case:Video of news | Double homicide suspect's name heard on 911 callNews about sentencing | Judge sentences Eldon man to life in prison for murder of elderly couple | Lake of the Ozarks News | lakeexpo.comUpdate on charges | UPDATE: Charges, details emerge in Versailles double homicide | Lake of the Ozarks News | lakeexpo.comNews about the Mitchells (co-defendants) | Jefferson City couple pleads out of murder chargeAccess exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
  • 127. A HAPPY FAMILY WITH A BROKEN CHILD | Ep 81 Part 1 | Derrell Spellmeyer

    18:46||Ep. 127
    In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we explore the dark, chaotic story of Derrell Spellmeyer; a man whose descent from casual drug use spiraled into a chilling double homicide and a future spent behind bars. Derrell's story isn’t that of a hardened criminal or someone scarred by a violent past. Instead, it’s the story of a man whose life veered off course in ways he could never imagine.As we explore Derrell’s account, you’ll hear one of the most shocking confessions we’ve come across; an admission that blurs the lines between intent and intoxication, recklessness and ruthless action. Alongside him were Mandy and Garland Mitchell, two friends who unwittingly found themselves entangled in a nightmare with irreversible consequences.More information about this case:Video of news | Double homicide suspect's name heard on 911 callNews about sentencing | Judge sentences Eldon man to life in prison for murder of elderly couple | Lake of the Ozarks News | lakeexpo.comUpdate on charges | UPDATE: Charges, details emerge in Versailles double homicide | Lake of the Ozarks News | lakeexpo.comNews about the Mitchells (co-defendants) | Jefferson City couple pleads out of murder chargeAccess exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
  • 126. BETRAYED BY JUSTICE | Ep 80 Part 3 | Crystal Denson

    16:42||Ep. 126
    In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we look into the chilling case of Crystal Denson, a woman from House Springs, Missouri, whose life took a tragic turn in December 2018. Crystal shot and killed her boyfriend, Robert "River" Williams, in what she insists was an act of self-defense. But the events of that night are far from straightforward. Was it truly an accident, or did the toxic nature of their relationship push things beyond the point of no return? This is an intense and thought-provoking episode that takes us deep into the mind of a woman trapped in a dangerous relationship.More information about this case:News about shooting | Missouri woman who reported shooting charged with murder | AP News News about charges | House Springs woman charged with murder after call to police about accidental shooting | FOX 2 News about murder | Jefferson County woman who reported accidental shooting is charged with murdering boyfriend | St Louis Post DispatchNews about shooting | Girlfriend who reported accidental shooting charged in death | FOX 2Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
  • 125. MURDERED WITH A BROKEN GUN | Ep 80 Part 2 | Crystal Denson

    16:02||Ep. 125
    In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we look into the chilling case of Crystal Denson, a woman from House Springs, Missouri, whose life took a tragic turn in December 2018. Crystal shot and killed her boyfriend, Robert "River" Williams, in what she insists was an act of self-defense. But the events of that night are far from straightforward. Was it truly an accident, or did the toxic nature of their relationship push things beyond the point of no return? This is an intense and thought-provoking episode that takes us deep into the mind of a woman trapped in a dangerous relationship.More information about this case:News about shooting | Missouri woman who reported shooting charged with murder | AP News News about charges | House Springs woman charged with murder after call to police about accidental shooting | FOX 2 News about murder | Jefferson County woman who reported accidental shooting is charged with murdering boyfriend | St Louis Post DispatchNews about shooting | Girlfriend who reported accidental shooting charged in death | FOX 2Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!

Comments