Share

Voices of a Killer
TILL DEATH DO US PART | Ep 18 | Calvin Pettey
In a chilling tale of love and betrayal, Calvin Duane Pettey’s fiance, Sandra Fugate's life was cut short just two days before she was set to walk down the aisle. Once deeply in love and excited to begin a new chapter of life, she became the victim of a crime that shattered her family and community. But how was it that Calvin ended up behind bars? The circumstances surrounding this murder led investigators on a complex journey, sifting through puzzling evidence and navigating conflicting alibis and eventually Calvin was betrayed. The betrayal didn't come from a random stranger; it was someone he knew and trusted; and to this day Calvin maintains his innocence.
More information about this case:
- News about Calvin’s Sentencing | Calvin Pettey sentenced to life in prison for killing fiancee; her family says there's no closure yet | Article | WHIG
- News about Rebecca’s Trial | Pettey murder trial: Rebecca Kirk testifies Pettey admitted to killing fiancee | Article | whig.com
- News about Rebecca’s Sentencing | Murderer's lover gets 4-year prison term for tampering with evidence in Fugate murder | WHIG
- News about the Happily Never After episode | Hannibal love triangle murder case to air on Investigation Discovery | KHQA
- Shattered Sisterhood - Happily Never After (Season 2, Episode 9) | Apple TV
Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:
- Raw interview with Calvin on: www.patreon.com/voicesofakiller
If you enjoyed this episode then please either:
- Follow, rate, and review on Apple Podcasts
- Follow and rate on Spotify
- Watch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!
- Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!
- Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
More episodes
View all episodes

102. I SHOULD’VE PROTECTED HER | Ep 72 Part 3 | Maggie Ybarra
25:10||Ep. 102Today, we will be exploring a case that shook the community of Grain Valley, Missouri. A case marked by tragedy, dark desires, and the brutal loss of a young life. We’re joined by Maggie Ybarra, a woman whose name became entwined with horror and heartbreak. In this episode, Maggie will tell her side of the story. A story that involves the tragic death of 32-year-old Kensie Aubry. Kensie’s life was cruelly cut short in a manner that defies comprehension, and her murder left an indelible scar on all who knew her. We must warn listeners that this particular episode covers topics of child sex abuse - something that is very sensitive and which some listeners may find distressing.More information about this case:News about initial finds | Human remains unearthed at a Jackson County property. Here is what we know | The Kansas City StarTimeline of the case | Timeline: How investigators found a woman's remains buried on Jackson County property | The Kansas City Star Detailed information about the case | Grain Valley couple sentenced to life in prison for woman's death | KMBCNews about Maggie’s Sentencing | Couple sentenced in horror sex fantasy chainsaw dismemberment murder of missing woman | Law&CrimeNews report featuring Kensie’s Mother | Kensie Aubry's mother using faith to find moments of comfort after daughter's murder | KSHB41Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
101. CHAINSAW DISMEMBERMENT NIGHTMARE | Ep 72 Part 2 | Maggie Ybarra
22:21||Ep. 101Today, we will be exploring a case that shook the community of Grain Valley, Missouri. A case marked by tragedy, dark desires, and the brutal loss of a young life. We’re joined by Maggie Ybarra, a woman whose name became entwined with horror and heartbreak. In this episode, Maggie will tell her side of the story. A story that involves the tragic death of 32-year-old Kensie Aubry. Kensie’s life was cruelly cut short in a manner that defies comprehension, and her murder left an indelible scar on all who knew her. We must warn listeners that this particular episode covers topics of child sex abuse - something that is very sensitive and which some listeners may find distressing.More information about this case:News about initial finds | Human remains unearthed at a Jackson County property. Here is what we know | The Kansas City StarTimeline of the case | Timeline: How investigators found a woman's remains buried on Jackson County property | The Kansas City Star Detailed information about the case | Grain Valley couple sentenced to life in prison for woman's death | KMBCNews about Maggie’s Sentencing | Couple sentenced in horror sex fantasy chainsaw dismemberment murder of missing woman | Law&CrimeNews report featuring Kensie’s Mother | Kensie Aubry's mother using faith to find moments of comfort after daughter's murder | KSHB41Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
100. HIS MURDEROUS S*XUAL DESIRES | Ep 72 Part 1 | Maggie Ybarra
20:26||Ep. 100Today, we will be exploring a case that shook the community of Grain Valley, Missouri. A case marked by tragedy, dark desires, and the brutal loss of a young life. We’re joined by Maggie Ybarra, a woman whose name became entwined with horror and heartbreak. In this episode, Maggie will tell her side of the story. A story that involves the tragic death of 32-year-old Kensie Aubry. Kensie’s life was cruelly cut short in a manner that defies comprehension, and her murder left an indelible scar on all who knew her. We must warn listeners that this particular episode covers topics of child sex abuse - something that is very sensitive and which some listeners may find distressing.More information about this case:News about initial finds | Human remains unearthed at a Jackson County property. Here is what we know | The Kansas City StarTimeline of the case | Timeline: How investigators found a woman's remains buried on Jackson County property | The Kansas City Star Detailed information about the case | Grain Valley couple sentenced to life in prison for woman's death | KMBCNews about Maggie’s Sentencing | Couple sentenced in horror sex fantasy chainsaw dismemberment murder of missing woman | Law&CrimeNews report featuring Kensie’s Mother | Kensie Aubry's mother using faith to find moments of comfort after daughter's murder | KSHB41Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
132. FACING THE CONSEQUENCES | Ep 82 Part 3 | Jeremiah Searles
22:51||Ep. 132In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we dive into the troubling and violent story of Jeremiah Searles, a man whose life was shaped by trauma, obsession, and ultimately, murder. Jeremiah’s journey is marked by a long history of emotional turmoil; an upbringing defined by instability, time spent in boys’ homes, and struggles with anger and control. But it’s his volatile relationship with Melissa Chapman that takes center stage, culminating in a brutal act of violence that left her dead and Jeremiah facing a 30-year prison sentence.More information about this case:News about charge | Bethany man charged with kidnapping, assault and abuse of a child | KTTNNews about sentencing | Denver, Missouri man admits murdering woman during court appearance, sentenced to 30-years in prison | KTTNNews about sentencing | Man sentenced for killing woman set to testify against him | AP News Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
131. BROKEN TRUST | Ep 82 Part 2 | Jeremiah Searles
24:04||Ep. 131In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we dive into the troubling and violent story of Jeremiah Searles, a man whose life was shaped by trauma, obsession, and ultimately, murder. Jeremiah’s journey is marked by a long history of emotional turmoil; an upbringing defined by instability, time spent in boys’ homes, and struggles with anger and control. But it’s his volatile relationship with Melissa Chapman that takes center stage, culminating in a brutal act of violence that left her dead and Jeremiah facing a 30-year prison sentence.More information about this case:News about charge | Bethany man charged with kidnapping, assault and abuse of a child | KTTNNews about sentencing | Denver, Missouri man admits murdering woman during court appearance, sentenced to 30-years in prison | KTTNNews about sentencing | Man sentenced for killing woman set to testify against him | AP News Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
130. WHO WAS IN CONTROL? | Ep 82 Part 1 | Jeremiah Searles
25:56||Ep. 130In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we dive into the troubling and violent story of Jeremiah Searles, a man whose life was shaped by trauma, obsession, and ultimately, murder. Jeremiah’s journey is marked by a long history of emotional turmoil; an upbringing defined by instability, time spent in boys’ homes, and struggles with anger and control. But it’s his volatile relationship with Melissa Chapman that takes center stage, culminating in a brutal act of violence that left her dead and Jeremiah facing a 30-year prison sentence.More information about this case:News about charge | Bethany man charged with kidnapping, assault and abuse of a child | KTTNNews about sentencing | Denver, Missouri man admits murdering woman during court appearance, sentenced to 30-years in prison | KTTNNews about sentencing | Man sentenced for killing woman set to testify against him | AP News Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
130. Casey White | Tells the Truth after Netflix | SPECIAL FEATURE EPISODE
01:12:11||Ep. 130In this Voices of a Killer EXCLUSIVE special feature interview with Casey White on Voices of a Killer, where Casey shares his story in a way never heard before. This revealing conversation goes beyond what's shown in the Netflix documentary Jailbreak: Love on the Run, offering a unique perspective straight from the source. Casey reveals NEW EVIDENCE that was NOT COVERED in the documentary. #caseywhite #vickywhite #netflix #loveontherun #jailbreak #truecrimedocumentaryBecome a MEMBER here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC08FlpLdyXS1xTdLcL4HnlQ/join
129. A CHAOTIC GETAWAY ATTEMPT | Ep 81 Part 3 | Derrell Spellmeyer
17:44||Ep. 129In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we explore the dark, chaotic story of Derrell Spellmeyer; a man whose descent from casual drug use spiraled into a chilling double homicide and a future spent behind bars. Derrell's story isn’t that of a hardened criminal or someone scarred by a violent past. Instead, it’s the story of a man whose life veered off course in ways he could never imagine.As we explore Derrell’s account, you’ll hear one of the most shocking confessions we’ve come across; an admission that blurs the lines between intent and intoxication, recklessness and ruthless action. Alongside him were Mandy and Garland Mitchell, two friends who unwittingly found themselves entangled in a nightmare with irreversible consequences.More information about this case:Video of news | Double homicide suspect's name heard on 911 callNews about sentencing | Judge sentences Eldon man to life in prison for murder of elderly couple | Lake of the Ozarks News | lakeexpo.comUpdate on charges | UPDATE: Charges, details emerge in Versailles double homicide | Lake of the Ozarks News | lakeexpo.comNews about the Mitchells (co-defendants) | Jefferson City couple pleads out of murder chargeAccess exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
128. BRUTALLY MURERED FOR SOME PILLS | Ep 81 Part 2 | Derrell Spellmeyer
22:45||Ep. 128In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we explore the dark, chaotic story of Derrell Spellmeyer; a man whose descent from casual drug use spiraled into a chilling double homicide and a future spent behind bars. Derrell's story isn’t that of a hardened criminal or someone scarred by a violent past. Instead, it’s the story of a man whose life veered off course in ways he could never imagine.As we explore Derrell’s account, you’ll hear one of the most shocking confessions we’ve come across; an admission that blurs the lines between intent and intoxication, recklessness and ruthless action. Alongside him were Mandy and Garland Mitchell, two friends who unwittingly found themselves entangled in a nightmare with irreversible consequences.More information about this case:Video of news | Double homicide suspect's name heard on 911 callNews about sentencing | Judge sentences Eldon man to life in prison for murder of elderly couple | Lake of the Ozarks News | lakeexpo.comUpdate on charges | UPDATE: Charges, details emerge in Versailles double homicide | Lake of the Ozarks News | lakeexpo.comNews about the Mitchells (co-defendants) | Jefferson City couple pleads out of murder chargeAccess exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!