Share

Voices of a Killer
A Heated Rage | Ep 62 Part 2 | Aaron Stimus
In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we talk to Floridian and convicted killer, Aaron Stimus. In July 2002, Aaron woke up in a hospital bed to discover that he had just survived a gunshot wound to the head and that he was being charged with first-degree murder. Today we hear Aaron’s account of that fateful summer’s evening. We’ll hear about the hostile divorce proceedings, the life-ruining painkillers, and the police oversight that culminated in one chaotic and emotionally fraught July evening. Throughout, we’ll scrutinize the plausibility of Aaron’s account. Is this a man living in denial or a man who’s been wrongfully accused of premeditated murder for the past 20 years?
More information about this case:
- Outcome of Aaron’s 2008 Appeal | Aaron Stimus v. State | Justia US Law
- Outcome of Aaron’s 2004 Appeal | Stimus v. State | FindLaw
- Article about Police Failings in the Case | Deputy loses job for nonresponse in threatening case | The Ledger
- Reflections by Julianne’s Sister-In-Law | Domestic conflicts, weapons don’t mix | BDN
- Article about the Crime| ’We did a … sloppy job’ | Florida Today
Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:
If you enjoyed this episode then please either:
- Follow, rate, and review on Apple Podcasts
- Follow and rate on Spotify
- Watch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!
- Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!
- Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
More episodes
View all episodes

102. I SHOULD’VE PROTECTED HER | Ep 72 Part 3 | Maggie Ybarra
25:10||Ep. 102Today, we will be exploring a case that shook the community of Grain Valley, Missouri. A case marked by tragedy, dark desires, and the brutal loss of a young life. We’re joined by Maggie Ybarra, a woman whose name became entwined with horror and heartbreak. In this episode, Maggie will tell her side of the story. A story that involves the tragic death of 32-year-old Kensie Aubry. Kensie’s life was cruelly cut short in a manner that defies comprehension, and her murder left an indelible scar on all who knew her. We must warn listeners that this particular episode covers topics of child sex abuse - something that is very sensitive and which some listeners may find distressing.More information about this case:News about initial finds | Human remains unearthed at a Jackson County property. Here is what we know | The Kansas City StarTimeline of the case | Timeline: How investigators found a woman's remains buried on Jackson County property | The Kansas City Star Detailed information about the case | Grain Valley couple sentenced to life in prison for woman's death | KMBCNews about Maggie’s Sentencing | Couple sentenced in horror sex fantasy chainsaw dismemberment murder of missing woman | Law&CrimeNews report featuring Kensie’s Mother | Kensie Aubry's mother using faith to find moments of comfort after daughter's murder | KSHB41Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
101. CHAINSAW DISMEMBERMENT NIGHTMARE | Ep 72 Part 2 | Maggie Ybarra
22:21||Ep. 101Today, we will be exploring a case that shook the community of Grain Valley, Missouri. A case marked by tragedy, dark desires, and the brutal loss of a young life. We’re joined by Maggie Ybarra, a woman whose name became entwined with horror and heartbreak. In this episode, Maggie will tell her side of the story. A story that involves the tragic death of 32-year-old Kensie Aubry. Kensie’s life was cruelly cut short in a manner that defies comprehension, and her murder left an indelible scar on all who knew her. We must warn listeners that this particular episode covers topics of child sex abuse - something that is very sensitive and which some listeners may find distressing.More information about this case:News about initial finds | Human remains unearthed at a Jackson County property. Here is what we know | The Kansas City StarTimeline of the case | Timeline: How investigators found a woman's remains buried on Jackson County property | The Kansas City Star Detailed information about the case | Grain Valley couple sentenced to life in prison for woman's death | KMBCNews about Maggie’s Sentencing | Couple sentenced in horror sex fantasy chainsaw dismemberment murder of missing woman | Law&CrimeNews report featuring Kensie’s Mother | Kensie Aubry's mother using faith to find moments of comfort after daughter's murder | KSHB41Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
100. HIS MURDEROUS S*XUAL DESIRES | Ep 72 Part 1 | Maggie Ybarra
20:26||Ep. 100Today, we will be exploring a case that shook the community of Grain Valley, Missouri. A case marked by tragedy, dark desires, and the brutal loss of a young life. We’re joined by Maggie Ybarra, a woman whose name became entwined with horror and heartbreak. In this episode, Maggie will tell her side of the story. A story that involves the tragic death of 32-year-old Kensie Aubry. Kensie’s life was cruelly cut short in a manner that defies comprehension, and her murder left an indelible scar on all who knew her. We must warn listeners that this particular episode covers topics of child sex abuse - something that is very sensitive and which some listeners may find distressing.More information about this case:News about initial finds | Human remains unearthed at a Jackson County property. Here is what we know | The Kansas City StarTimeline of the case | Timeline: How investigators found a woman's remains buried on Jackson County property | The Kansas City Star Detailed information about the case | Grain Valley couple sentenced to life in prison for woman's death | KMBCNews about Maggie’s Sentencing | Couple sentenced in horror sex fantasy chainsaw dismemberment murder of missing woman | Law&CrimeNews report featuring Kensie’s Mother | Kensie Aubry's mother using faith to find moments of comfort after daughter's murder | KSHB41Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
132. FACING THE CONSEQUENCES | Ep 82 Part 3 | Jeremiah Searles
22:51||Ep. 132In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we dive into the troubling and violent story of Jeremiah Searles, a man whose life was shaped by trauma, obsession, and ultimately, murder. Jeremiah’s journey is marked by a long history of emotional turmoil; an upbringing defined by instability, time spent in boys’ homes, and struggles with anger and control. But it’s his volatile relationship with Melissa Chapman that takes center stage, culminating in a brutal act of violence that left her dead and Jeremiah facing a 30-year prison sentence.More information about this case:News about charge | Bethany man charged with kidnapping, assault and abuse of a child | KTTNNews about sentencing | Denver, Missouri man admits murdering woman during court appearance, sentenced to 30-years in prison | KTTNNews about sentencing | Man sentenced for killing woman set to testify against him | AP News Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
131. BROKEN TRUST | Ep 82 Part 2 | Jeremiah Searles
24:04||Ep. 131In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we dive into the troubling and violent story of Jeremiah Searles, a man whose life was shaped by trauma, obsession, and ultimately, murder. Jeremiah’s journey is marked by a long history of emotional turmoil; an upbringing defined by instability, time spent in boys’ homes, and struggles with anger and control. But it’s his volatile relationship with Melissa Chapman that takes center stage, culminating in a brutal act of violence that left her dead and Jeremiah facing a 30-year prison sentence.More information about this case:News about charge | Bethany man charged with kidnapping, assault and abuse of a child | KTTNNews about sentencing | Denver, Missouri man admits murdering woman during court appearance, sentenced to 30-years in prison | KTTNNews about sentencing | Man sentenced for killing woman set to testify against him | AP News Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
130. WHO WAS IN CONTROL? | Ep 82 Part 1 | Jeremiah Searles
25:56||Ep. 130In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we dive into the troubling and violent story of Jeremiah Searles, a man whose life was shaped by trauma, obsession, and ultimately, murder. Jeremiah’s journey is marked by a long history of emotional turmoil; an upbringing defined by instability, time spent in boys’ homes, and struggles with anger and control. But it’s his volatile relationship with Melissa Chapman that takes center stage, culminating in a brutal act of violence that left her dead and Jeremiah facing a 30-year prison sentence.More information about this case:News about charge | Bethany man charged with kidnapping, assault and abuse of a child | KTTNNews about sentencing | Denver, Missouri man admits murdering woman during court appearance, sentenced to 30-years in prison | KTTNNews about sentencing | Man sentenced for killing woman set to testify against him | AP News Access exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
130. Casey White | Tells the Truth after Netflix | SPECIAL FEATURE EPISODE
01:12:11||Ep. 130In this Voices of a Killer EXCLUSIVE special feature interview with Casey White on Voices of a Killer, where Casey shares his story in a way never heard before. This revealing conversation goes beyond what's shown in the Netflix documentary Jailbreak: Love on the Run, offering a unique perspective straight from the source. Casey reveals NEW EVIDENCE that was NOT COVERED in the documentary. #caseywhite #vickywhite #netflix #loveontherun #jailbreak #truecrimedocumentaryBecome a MEMBER here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC08FlpLdyXS1xTdLcL4HnlQ/join
129. A CHAOTIC GETAWAY ATTEMPT | Ep 81 Part 3 | Derrell Spellmeyer
17:44||Ep. 129In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we explore the dark, chaotic story of Derrell Spellmeyer; a man whose descent from casual drug use spiraled into a chilling double homicide and a future spent behind bars. Derrell's story isn’t that of a hardened criminal or someone scarred by a violent past. Instead, it’s the story of a man whose life veered off course in ways he could never imagine.As we explore Derrell’s account, you’ll hear one of the most shocking confessions we’ve come across; an admission that blurs the lines between intent and intoxication, recklessness and ruthless action. Alongside him were Mandy and Garland Mitchell, two friends who unwittingly found themselves entangled in a nightmare with irreversible consequences.More information about this case:Video of news | Double homicide suspect's name heard on 911 callNews about sentencing | Judge sentences Eldon man to life in prison for murder of elderly couple | Lake of the Ozarks News | lakeexpo.comUpdate on charges | UPDATE: Charges, details emerge in Versailles double homicide | Lake of the Ozarks News | lakeexpo.comNews about the Mitchells (co-defendants) | Jefferson City couple pleads out of murder chargeAccess exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!
128. BRUTALLY MURERED FOR SOME PILLS | Ep 81 Part 2 | Derrell Spellmeyer
22:45||Ep. 128In this episode of Voices of a Killer, we explore the dark, chaotic story of Derrell Spellmeyer; a man whose descent from casual drug use spiraled into a chilling double homicide and a future spent behind bars. Derrell's story isn’t that of a hardened criminal or someone scarred by a violent past. Instead, it’s the story of a man whose life veered off course in ways he could never imagine.As we explore Derrell’s account, you’ll hear one of the most shocking confessions we’ve come across; an admission that blurs the lines between intent and intoxication, recklessness and ruthless action. Alongside him were Mandy and Garland Mitchell, two friends who unwittingly found themselves entangled in a nightmare with irreversible consequences.More information about this case:Video of news | Double homicide suspect's name heard on 911 callNews about sentencing | Judge sentences Eldon man to life in prison for murder of elderly couple | Lake of the Ozarks News | lakeexpo.comUpdate on charges | UPDATE: Charges, details emerge in Versailles double homicide | Lake of the Ozarks News | lakeexpo.comNews about the Mitchells (co-defendants) | Jefferson City couple pleads out of murder chargeAccess exclusive unseen and unheard material via our Patreon:www.patreon.com/voicesofakillerIf you enjoyed this episode then please either:Follow, rate, and review on Apple PodcastsFollow and rate on SpotifyWatch our videos on the Voices of a Killer YouTube Channel!Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter!Listen to more episodes via the Voices of a Killer Website!