Share
The Game Football Podcast
Rooney blues and the winners and losers of Christmas
It's a Happy New Year from Jonathan Northcroft, Martin Samuel and Gregor Robertson as they join Tom Clarke for the first 2024 edition of The Game.
It was a new year to forget for Wayne Rooney, another example of the golden generation failing in the managerial world. What is the difference between a manager and a coach and is it the same game in the Champions League or League One?
A look back at a thrilling Christmas and New Year, which young manager topped the table of festive fixtures? Finally, it’s not FA cup weekend, its FA cup week and there are some top ties to look forward to.
Timeline:
Rooney
2’ Rooney sacked at Birmingham, shocked and a reality check?
5’ took over a club doing well, a manager well liked by fans and players.
6’ he was appointed to change a culture and direction of club…can you do that in 15 matches? Gary Cook, odd decision.
8’ he was employed to take them to prem league
11’ Was Rooney set up to fail. After two games the crowd turned, but tat was because of the loss of John Eustace.
13’ Calling out players after only 3 games, not a good idea.
17’ he admires Guardiola. But he thrived with Liam Rosenior
19’ Rooney could be a manager as much as a coach. He is good with people.
21’ Vale park on a Tuesday night isn’t the Nou Camp on a champions league night.
25’ surrounded himself by young ambitious but not very experienced coaching staff.
27’ Rooney doesn’t want special treatment, he will try to reinvent himself.
31’ difference between playing and managing.
33’ He’ll be back.
Title race
36’ Great festive period for Wolves and Gary O’Neil
37’ Man City return only two adrift and with the fire back. And unaffected by AFCON.
38’ Liverpool in great shape but about to lose salah.
40’ What’s gone wrong at Arsenal? Hard to win your first title.
43’ Villa have bounced back, but are they starting to look tired?
45’ all the top teams have flaws this year. Open title race.
West Ham, Wolves and Luton
45’ Looks like Moye will get a new contract. Is peace breaking out at the London stadium?
47’ Wrong that one fixture has moved beyond the AFCON cut off date.
48’ Great back to back wins for Hatters. Ross Barkley pulling strings, adjusting to the league.
FA Cup
53’ Sunderland v Newcastle tie of the round. Newcastle look on the knees with no energy. Sunderland with new manager bounce. Could be a big game.
56’ Is Eddie Howe under pressure?
More episodes
View all episodes
Will Newcastle or Spurs win the cup? And is Potter the answer for West Ham?
01:03:07|How many Newcastle players would get in a Premier League team of the season - two, three…five?!Would any manager other than Ange Postecoglou buy a twenty-one-year-old goalkeeper on Monday and play him in a cup semi-final on Wednesday?After big results for both teams what’s next.For Arsenal, have they progressed this season or was their best chance last year?After the break how will a rejuvenated Graham Potter fare at West Ham and Martin Samuel thinks Forest could win the title…why not!?EFL Extra – Managers on the move, promotion places and the FA Cup
46:33|A must listen for fans of teams in the football league. With Stoke, Millwall, West Brom, Oxford, Hull just some of the clubs who’ve changed manager. But, will it change the table?It’s a two from five for automatic promotion in the Championship. Sheffield United are in it but they’ve had a bumpy Christmas. Across the City Could Sheffield Wednesday make a push for the play offs The Times’ Paul Hirst thinks they might… In League One is it already a three horse race at the top. Who are the lower league strikers in demand and will their be an FA Cup shock?Have Amorim's Manchester United turned a corner?
01:00:09|Manchester United were more than worthy of their draw at Anfield. Should they have won? Was this an exception or a sign of things to come? Plus, Arsenal concede a penalty for a header, Bournemouth fans are getting excited and Ange Postecoglou is still Ange Postecoglou. Join Tom Clarke, Paul Hirst, Gregor Robertson and Peter Rutzler for a dissection of the weekend's action.Title race, Chelsea’s belief, Liverpool’s contracts and Amorim’s system
01:03:31|Arsenal go within six points of Liverpool, could they make it a proper title race? Chelsea have slipped up Martin Samuel thinks it is self-inflicted and questions Enzo Maresca’s approach. But he is very impressed with the work done by Nottingham Forest, does it set a template for PSR?Why did it go wrong for Wayne Rooney? Tony Cascarino and Gregor Robertson think it could be tactics…Martin thinks the same could apply to Ruben Amorim ahead of his trip to Anfield on Sunday. Can anyone make a case for a Man Utd win…?Predictions for 2025 and are Manchester United in a relegation fight?
01:01:00|It goes from bad to worse at Old Trafford, are they really in a relegation fight? Will Amorim change his system, can he change his system? Ipswich have their first win in the Premier League this season at Portman Road; it came at the expense of a stuttering Chelsea side. Are Maresca’s problems self-inflicted ?It’s time to give Nottingham Forest enormous credit, and Nuno Espirito Santo in particular. Forest are second, will they hold on to Champions league football?Finally, Alyson Rudd, Charlotte Duncker and Gregor Robertson join Tom Clarke to offer their bold predictions for 2025.What on earth is wrong at Man City and Man Utd? Plus, Newcastle, Fulham and Forest are flying.
01:03:43|Could Manchester United be in a relegation fight? Could Manchester City finish mid table and could Fulham or Forest make the top four? It might have sounded fanciful at the start of the season, but not now.Paul Hirst, Martin Hardy and Gregor Robertson join Tom Clarke to look at a resurgent Newcastle, the two floundering Manchester clubs and predict the top four come May.A Happy Christmas for Liverpool; Bah Humbug for Spurs, United and City
01:02:51|Another pulsating game at the Tottenham stadium, another win for Liverpool another six conceded for Spurs. Is the title Liverpool’s to lose? For Ange Postecoglou is it injuries or game management?Rubin Amorim was left scratching his head as Manchester United were beaten at home - again - by Bournemouth.Across Manchester, City continue to struggle…could Pep even walk?Plus, when did Burnley beat Manchester united 6-1?Tom Clarke, Gregor Robertson, Alyson Rudd and Hamzah Khalique Loonat look back at all the weekends action.What next for Marcus Rashford? And a great League Cup line up
01:00:01|Marcus Rashford looks to be on his way out of Manchester United.A tail of a talent lost or stalled? Martin Samuel, Jonathan Northcroft and Tony Cascarino join Tom Clarke to discuss how he ended up here and what happens next for him and the club.Everton have finally secured a take over deal. Where is their true place in the pecking order - big club or a midtable club?After the break a thorough look at the League Cup and is the Community Shield a trophy – Mikel Arteta thinks so…City keep losing; Chelsea keep winning. Plus sackings and the greatest saves
56:42|If Pep Guardiola is the greatest manager of the modern era, its time for him to prove his worth.Manchester City are a “crumbling dynasty” losing again in a derby where they looked nervous throughout. While a Chelsea team with four ex City players in it and a manager honed under Guardiola are now two off the top and “having a lot of fun, playing with palpable joy.”Rubin Amorim has again showed who is in charge by dropping Marcus Rashford from the squad and has his tram playing in his patterns.Elsewhere, time to give Nottingham Forest due credit; managerial sackings and great saves.Paul hirst, Tom Allnutt, Alyson Rudd and James Gheerbrant join Tom Clarke to analyse a very busy weekend.