Share
The Game Football Podcast
Mic’d up but p***ed off. And England’s midfield conundrum
James Gheerbrant, Jonathan Northcroft and Gregor Robertson join tom Clarke to give VAR a grilling.
Does the mic’d up programme help or hinder the case for VAR in games? The team look at issues around how subjective football is, how effective current VAR is and are there other, better options to use the technology? After an inconclusive but heated debate it’s on to England’s midfield.
Bellingham and Rice seem certain starters, but who plays alongside them? Do England have a defensive midfielder, and if not, who plays instead?
Finally, Jonny recently voted in a poll asking who are currently the world’s best players…he names his top five.
Timeline
VAR
2’ VAR, are the audio releases helping or hindering
4’ Pain is not worth the gain. It is a really difficult job, but it has become farcical.
8’ Running VAR can be exhausting, in the spotlight, no clear right and wrong, walking a tightrope
Possible clips
11’ the number and detail of incidents can’t be assessed in the time allowed.
15’ modern mania to achieve perfection…in a subjective sport.
17’ timing is an issue; it takes too long the flow of the game has been affected.
20’ Has the mic’d up programme improved things or further mudded the waters.
22’ sin bins. Good idea or not? Keeping refs mics on would stop player dissent quickly.
26’ do players influence VAR by appealing and asking refs to check things.
England midfield
31’ who plays alongside Declan Rice and Jude Bellingham.
33’ the chemistry of the three is important. Southgate prizes control over everything else. Gregor thinks still Philips.
35’ can’t pick Philips or Henderson because of lack of top flight football.
37’ Trent Alexander is the answer according to Jonny.
40’ James, consider Connor Gallagher.
45’ stones, Rico Lewis, Foden Maddison. Jonny think whoever Jude wants Keep Bellingham happy.
Best players in the world
49’ Jonny voted for worlds best players. Hard to over look Premier league and England players. Haland, Rodri, Kane, Bellingham.
55’ Kane now getting the coverage he deserves.
57’ Messi still the man. What about defenders??
More episodes
View all episodes
EFL Extra: Who’s Hot, Who’s Not?
39:55|Tom Clarke is joined by Gregor Robertson as they assess the Championship, League One and League Two. Leeds, Norwich, Plymouth. Wycombe, Exeter, Port Vale and AFC Wimbledon all feature – as well as many in between. Plus a look at the many ex players taking to lower league management.Fantasy Football - better than the real thing?
57:04|Where now for England? A failed experiment; Carsley might not want it full time and is Pep waiting in the side-lines? Gregor Robertson thinks his selections were indulgent, Hamzah Khalique-Loonat thinks they should be applauded. Tom Clarke still misses Southgate.After the break a brilliant discussion about the affects of fantasy football on real football.Tom Allnutt says clubs are now banning players and staff from taking part. But why?And do fans now spend more time discussing fantasy football than ‘real’ football?Who really won…? And is Bellingham a centre forward?
57:38|Was it Man City 1-0 Premier League? Jonathan Northcroft has reappraised and thinks it could be a score draw. Martin is sticking to his guns and Gregor sees echoes of the European super league. After the break, what happened to tough players, should Bellingham play up front and Gregor once played against Andres Iniesta…it was spellbinding.Manchester City 1 - 0 Premier League: Special reaction show
23:29|Manchester City have won the first of their legal cases against the Premier League.What does it mean for City and for the rest of the Premier League? Tom Clarke, Martin Samuel, Jonathan Northcroft and Tony Cascarino explain and offer immediate reaction…Who are the real big six?
01:05:36|This could have also been called: “Why are Spurs so Spursy?” as Ange Postecoglou’s team blew a two-goal lead at Brighton. Was it the Seagulls brilliance or a Spurs implosion?Manchester United got a creditable if boring draw at Villa Park, will it be enough to turn the tide for Erik Ten Hag?Gregor Robertson is a convert to Chelsea, Alyson Rudd thinks they might even win something. Hamzah Khalique-Loonat waxes lyrical about Bukayo Saka, is he the best in the league? Tom Clarke steers the ship.Villa Rockin’ and easy does it for Liverpool, City and Arsenal
39:22|A great week for English clubs in the Champions League with four wins from four.European master Unai Emery steered Villa to a famous win over Bayern Munich – is there a better match in club football than Emery and Villa? Controlled wins for City and Liverpool and a statement win for Arsenal against PSG.Oh, and what happens to Cole Palmer when he rolls up to England camp?EFL Extra: Flying high, changing manager and lofty ambition
41:45|Our fortnightly look at the EFL. Tom Clarke and Gregor Robertson look at a flying Sheffield United, managerial changes at Stoke and the form of the promoted clubs – Oxford, Portsmouth and Derby. After the break in League One Steve Bruce has taken Blackpool from relegation zone to play offs in less than a month, what’s his secret?In League Two MK Dons and Carlisle have rolled the dice and changed manager, highlighting once again just how many teams have lofty ambition with backing to match it.Manchester United - terrible; Liverpool – untested?
01:00:55|“Manchester United look like a relic!” That is the blunt assessment of Gregor Robertson.Their rivals Liverpool are top, but it's not enough for Alyson Rudd or Hamzah Khalique Loonat who think they haven’t played anyone any good yet.Tom Clarke has a hangover but talk of Cole Palmer and Ethan Nwaneri are like a caffeine shot! Plus, is kick off a set piece? Brentford think so.Should players go on strike? And tough times for West Ham and Newcastle
01:01:38|As Rodri is ruled out could injuries decide the title? Will players go on strike this season? And will there ever be another summer without football?Plus, after yet another lacklustre display nothing seems to have changed at Manchester United. Its troubled times at West Ham and all is not well at Newcastle.Martin Samuel, Gregor Robertson and Tony Cascarino join Tom Clarke to discuss.