Share
The Game
Gunners misfire, replay rows and free pints
Gregor Robertson, Alyson Rudd and Martin Hardy join Tom Clarke to discuss why Arsenal are stumbling, who paid for the Newcastle beers and if we should re-record the whole podcast.
First up Arsenal’s blunt strike force, do they have the answer or do they need to buy. A character building win for Liverpool, but do either team have enough to trouble Man City in the league.
Martin Hardy reflects on an important result for Newcastle and Eddie Howe, and the difference a weeks rest made. For Sunderland it was a week to forget.
Finally, to replay or not to replay? It depends on who you ask, Gregor has little sympathy for elite teams setting the agenda for all of the football pyramid.
Timeline:
Arsenal v Liverpool
2’ Are wheels coming off Arsenal. Arteta has referenced a mental block around scoring.
4’ Arsenal should have bought a top class forward. Their current strikers are not top class.
5’ Are there as many top class forwards in the premier league now?
6’ Havertz a box crasher.
8’ Should Arteta be speaking out? Where will goals come from?
9’ Liverpool looked good. Still lacked a clinical edge though, but more resilience.
11’ Liverpool are a different side second half in most games. So many goals after 75mins.
13’ Both teams good, but are either good enough to finish above Man City?
14’ Nunez a handful but will he win you a title?
Wear Tyne derby
16’ crazy derby stories, ghosts, Di Canio, horses and graffiti.
19’ Sunderland were not ready for the occasion.
21’ Odd tactical choice by Michael Beale.
22’ Newcastle looked like they had had a weeks rest
24’ Why play out from the back against a team who love to press.
25’ Tripper looked back. Springboard for the rest of the season, injuries returning.
27’ Very important win for Eddie howe and Newcastle.
Weekend highlights
31’ Maidstone, penalty saves, away followings and Patrick Bamford’s worldie.
Replays
35’ Good idea of not?
36’ Removal of a replay might create teams who play for penalties. It used to be three replay’s
37’ Replay’s look likely to be dropped.
40’ We shouldn’t be changing the calendar for 16 elite teams.
42’ Replays are great for teams seeking revenue and hope. They’re not for big teams seeking a break.
43’ The problem highlights the vast financial differences between all the levels of football.
48’ Given the money on offer for one extra point in the premier league, do cups matter anymore?
50’ “Domestic football should not be shaped in the image of 6 to 8 rich elite owners.”
Transfers
53’ Where should Henderson or Mbappe go?
More episodes
View all episodes
City for the title? Chelsea chaos and end of year awards
52:19|Chelsea are through to the semi-finals of the League Cup, but behind the scenes there is more chaos. Manager Enzo Maresca is unhappy, but no one quite knows why. The fans chanted his name but are the board happy? A day in the life at Chelsea… Man City are looking ominous, could they be considered title favourites by the new year?One of their shining lights is number ten turned left back Nico O’Reilly – Jonny and Gregor think he is now England’s first choice for the World Cup. After the break 2025 awards and wishes for 2026. Tom Clarke joins Tony Cascarino, Gregor Robertson and Jonathan NorthcroftArsenal or City? Rogers or Palmer?
57:28|Arsenal are still top of the Premier League but are Manchester City favourites for the title after this weekend? City beat Palace convincingly but Arsenal wobbled against Wolves. Elsewhere Aston Villa kept up the pace and we ask - just how good is Morgan Rogers? Is he on the same level as his friend Cole Palmer?On this show we also discussed Sunderland's win against Newcastle and why the promoted side can already start planning for next season in the Premier League. And we finish with a look at the bottom of the table and the Africa Cup of Nations. Tom Clarke is joined by Gregor Robertson, Alyson Rudd and Hamzah Khalique-Loonat.Liverpool, Chelsea and Madrid prove 'Mo Money Mo Problems.'
50:25|Liverpool got a much-needed away win at Inter Milan, but their hundred million pound star striker looked lost - why? Off the pitch will Mo Salah still be a Liverpool player come January?It was a good week for English clubs in Europe with Man City beating Real Madrid and Spurs and Arsenal also winning. Are the English teams starting to dominate, is the pace and physicality of the Premier League an advantage or is the competition just not very good in the early rounds?Tony Cascarino has a hunch that Noni Madueke can play centre forwardLastly, a look ahead to the Tyne Wear derby, the first in the Premier League in ten years – who are favourites going into Sunday’s game? Tom Clarke joins Tony Cascarino, Gregor Robertson and Martin SamuelEFL Extra: Who are the ‘dangerous lurkers’ ?
37:33|Leaders Coventry suffered first defeat in sixteen games at Ipswich. Wil the result create doubt in Frank Lampard’s squad, or was it just a blip?For Ipswich the result takes them fourth in the table and a season which started falteringly is starting to gain momentum. Southampton and Sheffield Utd had dreadful starts to the season, but after managerial changes both are now looking at the playoffs – with strong squads will they makes late charges?League One remains tight but Cardiff look like they have the resources to stay at the top. Who will join them?And in League Two…Walsall, surely this season is different? Who else looks threatening?Salah’s future and brilliant Villa
52:30|Mo Salah dropped a bombshell on Saturday evening. After starting on the bench for the third game in a row he gave an incendiary interview after the match claiming to have been thrown under the bus, a scapegoat for recent poor form and said he had no relationship with coach Arne Slot. So, what happens next - will it be the end of Salah or Slot at Liverpool? Can any player be guaranteed a place in the team regardless of form as Salah seems to be suggesting? On the pitch Villa coach Unai Emery led his team to a win over Arsenal and third in the table - remarkable achievement after the start they had. Are there worrying signs for Arsenal, or were they just beaten by a better team on the day? After the break a valuable three points for Spurs and Thomas Frank, but an even more important performance; top quality at the Cottage and does Nuno like his players? Tom Allnutt, Gregor Robertson and Alyson Rudd join tom Clarke.WORLD CUP 2026 DRAW - REACTION SPECIAL
19:19|After what felt like a nine hour draw England will face Croatia, Ghana and Panama. Scotland will face Haiti, Morocco and Brazil.Is there a group of death? What are the potential routes to the final?Over to Tom Clarke, Gregor Robertson and Jonathan NorthcroftAre Arsenal the only team not in transition?
50:27|After a goal packed set of midweek fixtures what has changed? Chelsea’s title credentials were checked as a buoyant Leeds put three past them at Elland Road. Man City won but looked anything but assured. Villa are now only six points off top spot and play Arsenal at the weekend. And as for Arsenal - no change there, while others toil they won again.Elsewhere is Cristian Romero a defender or a striker and how good is Erling Haaland?Arne Slot and Liverpool continued to labour. Tony sees worrying signs as Salah, Van Dijk and Isak all struggle. But Sunderland continued to demonstrate what a well coached, well drilled side they are, taking points of Arsenal, Chelsea and Liverpool already this season. Gregor Robertson is joined by Tony Cascarino and Jonathan NorthcroftChelsea and Arsenal fight it out and Salah dropped
59:27|Arsenal went to Stamford Bridge without both first choice centre backs and took a point. Chelsea played the league leaders for sixty minutes with ten men and without their best player and took a point. Who will be happier?Liverpool finally won again and dropped Mo Salah in the process. Is this straight forward squad rotation or the beginning of a transition which doesn’t include the club legend?It’s happy times in the Northeast at the moment as Newcastle win away for the first time in over two hundred days and Sunderland come from behind to show their European credentials.And finally, it is tough times for Thomas Frank at the Tottenham Stadium. Was he right to criticise fans who booed their goalkeeper? Gregor Robertson is joined by Tom Allnutt, Martin Hardy and Alyson Rudd.Is anyone better than Arsenal?
55:44|Arsenal are dominating the Premier League and now they’re doing the same in Europe. Can they win both the big titles? Gregor Robertson thinks their success is built on a rock solid defence.Chelsea are looking equally effective in Europe; their game against Arsenal at the weekend is set up for the blues marauding wingers to take on Arsenal’s galloping full backs.It was another tough night for Spurs, but there were some encouraging signs as they at least scored three. After the break Liverpool. How deep is the crisis? The effect of the death of Diogo Jota off the pitch is incalculable, but on the pitch his and Luis Diaz sale is very apparent. Does the spending of four hundred million pounds amount to mismanagement?Tom Clarke is joined by Gregor Robertson, Pete Rutzler and tony Cascarino