Share
The Game
Champions League and jeez, referees!
Martin Samuel, James Gheerbrant and Jonathan Northcroft join Gregor Robertson for the Thursday edition of The Game.
Manchester United once again take centre stage. Free scoring, but also conceding freely too and dropping a two goal lead twice in Türkiye. Arsenal in contrast are less expansive than last year but more defensively solid, they’re also top of their group and top of the Premier League…can they possibly be under the radar?
Newcastle suffered at the hands of VAR and the team finish by discussing the attempts being made to attract more ex-players into helping VAR officiating.
A bonus section includes Martin Samuel giving his fascinating memories of Terry Venables
Timeline
Man Utd
2’ Scoring freely away from home, but conceding just as easily.
6’ Bruno Fernandes and Onana
8’ A poorly set up team, too stretched. Everton game was a warning sign. Everton had tons of shots.
10’ United have gone backwards this season, if you look at performance not result. Emotionally unstable as a team.
14’ players have to manage games, less flash and volatility. More steel sense and game management.
Newcastle
21’ ludicrous decision. But Eddie Howe’s reaction has been fantastic.
23’ Group still wide open, anything could happen.
24’ Eddie Howe has done a remarkable job
25’ the differing interpretation of the handball law between UEFA and all domestic league. Not a sustainable position.
28’ how can there be ‘a version’ of the rules…?
Arsenal
31’ what happened to boring boring Arsenal?
33’ are Arsenal under the radar. Top of the league and through as top of their Champions league group. Very effective.
35’ Rice outstanding, allows others to play. Used to be very exciting, second most goals per game last season. This season much further down, but seemingly more managed, secure.
38’ Declan Rice is rhythm guitar, and he is essential and really good.
41’ Arsenal have bounced back two season running after disappoint/frustrating ends to the previous season.
Refereeing
44’ How to overcome the accusation of bias if you’re seeking ex pros to be referees.
47’ more trust required. Ex pros have a lot to offer.
53’ something needs to change and probably will. It is now to regular.
55’ economically not viable to be a referee, takes a long time to qualify and doesn’t pay a lot. For ex players that will be problematic.
59’ can we ever foresee a top player officiating and not being called biased.
1hr it works in cricket.
Terry Venables
Why did he leave England…
More episodes
View all episodes
What is the problem with Manchester United?
55:52|Two defeats in a week, including the Manchester derby, losing a two goal lead at home for the first time in fifty years and then a young star asks to leave - the problems are mounting for Manchester United and Michael Carrick. Is it all football related or have the 'biggest club in England' still not solved their off pitch issues?Another wonderkid, Max Dowman goes from strength to strength as he scores two and looks at home for Arsenal - how long until he is a regular starter? And just what does a seventeen year old at a top club get paid?It is easy to forget but Leeds put in an impressive display to beat Newcastle on Monday night, how far can Daniel Farke's side go? And a successful European bow for Sunderland Lastly, more VAR fallout and is the Premier League suffering a talent drain?Tom Clarke is joined by jonathan Northcroft, Martin Samuel and Gregor RobertsonWho are the contenders to win the Championship?
49:20|All the latest from the Championship, League One and League Two with Tom Clarke and Gregor Robertson. Another big win for West Ham sends them top, Southampton are climbing, Swansea and West Brom are surprise packages with Wolves and Middlesbrough looking good - could they all win the Championship? Is it down to just two or three or are there outsiders who are yet to show their best?At the bottom Preston sack Heckingbottom after another defeat; could Nicky Hayen at Burnley be next?In League One Russell Martin got a huge win for Leicester City and gave an emotional interview discussing the hostility directed towards him, but will his win away at Stockport be enough to turn around an unhappy fan base at the King Power. Wycombe sack their manager Michael Duff and immediately get a win; Neil Harris works his magic at Cambridge and quickest team goal at Plymouth.In League Two are York City looking at back to back promotions and Gregor's old club Grimsby have a candidate for goal of the weekend.Plus the usual goal, moment and result of the weekend in each division.Who can stop Arsenal, Man city and VAR?
58:49|Man City and Arsenal are joint top. Huil impress at Chelsea, Spurs can't score and centre halves sometimes score absolute screamers.But sadly, the headlines are all about VAR...again. This time an 'error of judgment' is the reason Haaland's fine finish was not disallowed at Old Trafford.A quick assessment of where we're at with VAR before a look at a new attacking approach from Enzo Maresca and a lack lustre response from Man Utd.Arsenal win again, is it too early to consider an unbeaten season...if not, who beats them?Unai Emery has his work cut out at Villa, can he rebuild his team?Are Hull City over achieving or were their players just underrated?What's the best goal you've sen scored by a centre back and last but not least Tottenham play Liverpool on Tuesday in the EFL Cup is it too soon for either club to be worried...? Tom Clarke joins Alyson Rudd, James Gheerbrant Peter Rutzler."Harry Kane deserves the Ballon d'Or"
47:35|Solid home wins for Liverpool and Man City, a strong away wins for Arsenal and Villa mean the English teams have started well in Europe. Martin Samuel thinks there is no reason why all the English teams should not be qualifying for the last 16.While there are some potent front three's around, no team compares to Arsenal's defensive strength - how would Arsenal reserve team do in the Premier League?Mauricio Pochettino thinks Spurs should be award the 2016/17 title because of Chelsea's admitted rule breaches. Would that be opening Pandora's box?After the break is Harry Kane going to win the Ballon d'or? Who is he up against and does he deserve it. Is football more fun and games where there is no VAR? If it is, could it ever be ditched at the top level?Plus, football never ends, with a thrilling Chelsea six Leeds three cup win being overshadowed, are we in danger of reaching saturation point?EFL EXTRA: West Ham are back as Swansea shine
49:03|A week is a long time in the football league, and West Ham used back-to-back matches to kickstart their season with two big wins.Tom Clarke is joined by Gregor Robertson as Nuno Espirito Santo's team finally get moving in The Championship and there's more impressive results for Swansea, Middlesbrough, West Brom and Bristol City. Elsewhere the guys wonder whether Jamie Vardy's arrival is really going to be enough to save Nicky Hayen at Burnley? And Tom is upset with Wolves manager Cesar Peixoto. In League One it goes from bad to worse for Russell Martin and Leicester and it's screamers galore in League Two.Arsenal supreme, United stutter, Spurs struggle
59:37|Arsenal put on a dominate display to beat potential title rivals Chelsea. Despite going one down after only a minute the Gunners looked calm, confident and positive throughout. Was it the benefits of having a title under their belts or a new approach from Mikel Arteta? Chelsea have arguably the best attack in the league, but have they left themselves short in defence and midfield?Alexander Isak is starting to prove his worth at Liverpool, but was their win just as much about Ipswich's poor performance?A great game at Fulham as Palace won 3-2. but are Fulham "just too much fun to watch?" Could it see therm in a relegation fight?Plus, is Josh King in line for an international call up and what do Tottenham and Manchester United make of their draws...progress or cause for concern?Tom Allnutt, Gregor Robertson and Alyson Rudd join Tom ClarkeWhich teams had the best and worst transfer window?
55:21|After a crazy summer transfer window in which 3.5 billion pounds was spent and multiple 100 million transfers between English clubs - has the transfer market gone mad? Inlafted prices, last minute deals... is the Premier League an outlier, or is it the new norm for football transfers. Which club had the best window and which was the best individual transfer?Arsenal have hit the ground running, but after a promising attacking start, is it going to be the same defensive focus as last season.Plus, a look ahead to the weekends action.Gregor Robertson, Tony Cascarino and Gary Jacob join Tom ClarkeEFL EXTRA: "Wolves and Southampton look scary"
46:18|Tom Clarke and Gregor Robertson with all the latest from the Championship, League One and League Two.Wolves and Southampton already look to have so much strength in depth for Championship level "it is scary.". But it's Charlton who are top on nine points, can they keep it up...Who is the beat striker in the division? In League One Blackpool are on the front foot and Stockport look good as they get back to winning ways.Plus the South Yorkshire derby in League Two, Salford still winless and Walsall are up there...again!Hull's hopes, Tottenham's troubles and Mainoo's magic
58:32|Hull sit proudly at the top of the table. Is it a freak or have the Tigers, and the other promoted clubs been misjudged?Ipswich were thumped at Old Trafford, but their performance had many positive signs. While Man Utd looked to have rediscovered some swagger. Who shone brightest, Fernandez, Rashford or Mainoo.After the break familiar horribly memories at Spurs as they lose again - but will it be different this time? A very positivity start on Tyneside for Matthias Jaissle. Will Bradley Barcola fix any of Liverpool's problems? Plus, what is the transfer you'd most like to see happen and are Chelsea really different under Xabi Alonso?