Share

cover art for Episode 431: Real Football, MLB Trade Deadline, and More

The Underdog

Episode 431: Real Football, MLB Trade Deadline, and More

[01:09–05:39] Hall of Fame Game & Low Expectations

Chris and Matt open the show discussing the Hall of Fame game between the Chargers and Lions.


[05:40–09:08] Canton Visit & Ohio Memories

The hosts talk about the Pro Football Hall of Fame in Canton. Chris recalls visiting with family and praises Cleveland for its cultural spots and state parks.


[09:09–11:42] MLB Trade Deadline Deals

They shift to the MLB trade deadline, highlighting moves like Shane Bieber to Toronto and Mason Miller to San Diego.


[11:43–15:20] Phillies Needs & Brandon Marsh Disappointment

Matt stresses that the Phillies need a bat—possibly Steven Kwan or Luis Robert Jr. Chris questions sacrificing more of the farm system.


[15:21–17:43] Jason Werth Nostalgia & Kwan for Aidan Miller?

The guys reflect on Jason Werth’s beloved status and joke about trading top hitting prospect Aidan Miller for Kwan.


[17:44–20:22] The Simpsons Talk & Streaming Habits

They riff on The Simpsons, guessing episode counts and joking about Matt Groening’s massive Santa Monica home.


[20:23–23:22] Wrexham Valuation & McElhenney’s Name Change

The hosts marvel at how Rob McElhenney and Ryan Reynolds bought Wrexham for $2 million and have grown it to a $450 million valuation.


[23:23–27:00] Sixers Win Total Doubts & Embiid Concerns

The conversation pivots to the 76ers, where Chris doubts the team will hit their 43-win total at oddsmakers given Embiid and Paul George’s injury histories.


[27:01–29:59] Phillies Bullpen Outlook & Alvarado Ineligibility

The Phillies bullpen could be strong with Duran, Kerkering, and others—but José Alvarado’s postseason ineligibility is a setback.


[30:00–33:00] Center Field Trade Options & Justin Crawford

They consider trade options like Luis Robert Jr. and Cedric Mullins, but debate promoting Justin Crawford instead.


[33:01–35:14] Otani’s Injury & Dodgers Investment

Shohei Otani exits a game after six pitches due to cramps, prompting discussion on whether he should stop pitching altogether.


[35:15–38:04] Wyndham Championship & Golf Picks

They close with the Wyndham Championship, naming favorites like Aaron Rai (+800), Jordan Spieth (+2000), and Adam Scott.


[38:05–End] TV Updates: Happy Gilmore & Wednesday Returns

Chris and Matt talk about Sandler’s new Happy Gilmore film, Wednesday season 2's upcoming release, and Peacemaker returning August 21.


Dominate your fantasy football draft with the 2025 Fantasy Football Almanac.  The digital version is now available at a discount directly on the website: 

 

Fantasy Football Almanac - $9.97 https://thefantasyfootballalmanac.com/ 

Fantasy Football Almanac GOLD - $14.97 https://thefantasyfootballalmanac.com/ 

 

Or purchase full price on Amazon here: 

 

Fantasy Football Almanac Print and Kindle via Amazon - $14.97: https://a.co/d/3CLbFpH 

Fantasy Football Almanac GOLD Print Version via Amazon - $29.97: - https://a.co/d/9jMFTvT 

More episodes

View all episodes

  • Episode 452: Joe Schoen to Joe Shmoe

    47:02|
    00:30 – Somber Open & Music LossChris and Matt open on a heavy note, reacting to the passing of Bob Weir and reflecting on the Grateful Dead’s cultural impact, legacy preservation, and debates around musical purism versus evolution.07:48 – Ole Miss Season Fallout & CFP FrustrationConversation shifts to Ole Miss’ season ending, quarterback play inconsistencies, missed opportunities, and how fans emotionally process disappointing finishes without rewriting expectations.14:25 – College QB Draft Class Reality CheckExtended discussion on the weak quarterback class, inflated draft hype, Fernando Mendoza’s rise, Dante Moore returning to school, and why experience still matters most at the next level.21:30 – Transfer Portal Movement & NIL LandscapeBreakdown of portal additions, NIL-driven decisions, roster stacking, and how elite programs reload while mid-tier teams struggle to retain talent.27:30 – Eagles Playoff Collapse & Coaching LoyaltyDeep dive into Philadelphia’s season ending, offensive stagnation, coordinator loyalty, A.J. Brown usage debates, and why organizational stubbornness often repeats history.34:30 – NFL Coaching Carousel & QB FuturesDiscussion of John Harbaugh’s move to the Giants, Browns QB uncertainty, veteran stopgaps, and why some franchises remain undesirable despite openings.41:00 – Tech Detox, Sneakers & Everyday LifeLighter close covering phone outages, screen fatigue, sneaker pickups, Jordan 1 Low comparisons, and balancing fandom with real life.Games Discussed 07:30 – Ole Miss vs CFP OpponentPlayoff matchup framed by QB struggles, defensive lapses, and postseason pressure.21:30 – Eagles vs Playoff OpponentSeason-ending game highlighting offensive dysfunction and coaching scrutiny.43:00 – Texans vs Patriots (Playoffs)AFC matchup centered on defensive resistance and quarterback development.
  • Episode 451: CFB Semis, NFL Playoffs, and Traitors is Back!

    48:44|
    00:30 – Cold Open & Reality TV ObsessionChris and Matt skip small talk and dive straight into The Traitors US Season 4, discussing the celebrity format, casting strategy, and why hidden relationships always backfire.02:13 – Betting Reference ChangeChris explains the show’s switch to using oddsmakers for lines and props, focusing on accessibility, parlay flexibility, and cleaner UI.03:59 – Traitors Cast BreakdownThey run through the full cast, reacting to Survivor, Housewives, Big Brother, and comedy reps, highlighting Ron Funches as a standout and skepticism around Michael Rapaport.09:48 – Game Theory, Secrecy & Past Traitors LessonsDiscussion of why oversharing ruins Traitors gameplay, past examples of secret reveals gone wrong, and how early perception shapes survival.15:25 – Transition to College Football ChaosShift from TV to sports with Ole Miss momentum, transfer-portal uncertainty, NIL contracts, waivers, and why “commitments” no longer feel binding.19:02 – Transfer Portal Arms RaceBreakdown of Ole Miss, Penn State, Texas Tech, and LSU portal wins, positional needs, and how money is reshaping roster construction.26:59 – Stranger Things & TV TangentsNon-spoiler thoughts on Stranger Things, binge fatigue, violent tonal shifts, and general streaming overload.39:28 – NFL Coaching ShockwavesReaction to John Harbaugh’s firing, league reaction, demand for experienced coaches, and why timing matters more than résumé.43:11 – Eagles Roster FrustrationsDiscussion of secondary struggles, depth issues, and why certain players are better suited for special teams than defensive snaps.Games Discussed 15:48 – Ole Miss vs Miami (CFP)Playoff matchup framed around defensive line strength, QB experience, and neutral-site pressure.45:59 – Eagles vs 49ers (NFL Playoffs)Postseason clash highlighting pass-rush impact, secondary depth, and home-field atmosphere.46:19 – Rams vs Panthers (NFL Playoffs)Heavy-favorite scenario raising questions about playoff seeding balance.45:30 – Packers at BearsLate-season divisional game tied to seeding and momentum.
  • Episode 450: Something Out of a Movie

    43:52|
    00:29 – New Year Banter, Weather & Everyday ChaosChris and Matt open with New Year reflections, extreme cold vs warm climates, dog-walking struggles, golf envy, and a long tangent on sheets, blankets, sleep temperature, and aging comfort needs.06:48 – Sneaker Talk & Personal PickupsThey dive into sneakers: Nike Dunk Low “dress shoe” pack skepticism, Caitlin Clark Kobe 5 re-release, shiny shoes, and Matt’s new Grateful Dead Oregon Ducks pair. Discussion continues with retiring beat-up Jordan 1 Low UNCs, replacing them with Jordan 1 Low Chicagos, lace choices, resale prices, and StockX bidding strategy.15:02 – College Football Playoff Reaction & Ole Miss HighExtended breakdown of Ole Miss’ emotional playoff run, inspired play under Pete Golding, frustration with officiating moments, late-game chaos, portal timing, NIL realities, and why players may still leave despite success.23:58 – Coaching Paths, Age & PerspectiveConversation about Pete Golding’s age, long coaching journeys, Signetti’s decades-long grind, Kirby Smart’s youth, and why experience shapes leadership styles.30:45 – NFL Week 18 Landscape & League WeirdnessThey shift to the NFL, noting how Week 18 oddly features both playoff-level games and meaningless matchups, plus discussion on tiebreakers, draft positioning, and late-season motivation.Games Discussed31:12 – Panthers at BuccaneersNFC South game functioning like a de facto playoff with complex tiebreakers.35:22 – Seahawks at 49ersHigh-stakes NFC West matchup tied to seeding and potential byes.37:06 – Commanders at EaglesDivision finale shaped by seeding, rest decisions, and backup QB opportunity.37:33 – Bears at LionsLate-season pride game with psychological weight despite playoff disappointment.38:59 – Ravens at Steelers (SNF)Physical rivalry game closing the regular season with playoff intensity. 
  • Episode 449: Chaos Season Never Ends

    41:24|
    00:29 – Intro, Lions–Steelers Chaos & Wild NFL EndingChris and Matt react to a bizarre Lions–Steelers finish, multiple negated touchdowns, offensive pass interference confusion, DK Metcalf’s sideline incident, and how chaotic endings define late-season football.01:58 – College Football Weekend & Ole Miss HighMatt celebrates Ole Miss’ dominant win, discusses team confidence, physicality, and momentum heading into the next round.03:28 – Transfer Portal Confusion & Parody NewsBreakdown of fake transfer rumors surrounding Trinidad Chambliss, parody accounts fooling fans, and broader frustration with misinformation in college football.04:25 – NIL Reality & Player MovementThoughtful discussion on why players chase life-changing money, loyalty vs. opportunity, and why fans can’t be angry at modern transfer decisions.06:29 – Lane Kiffin, LSU Speculation & QB ComparisonsDebate over how different quarterbacks would function in Lane Kiffin’s offense, portal options, and why proven systems matter more than hype.07:49 – Penn State Fallout & Coaching DiscourseConversation about Penn State losing top talent, James Franklin’s polarizing reputation, coaching rankings, and why stability is underrated.09:00 – NIL Spending & Arch Manning ContextTalk about NIL budgets exploding, Arch Manning’s marketability, offensive line needs, and Texas’ long-term outlook.10:54 – NFL QB Tangent & Dolphins RealityQuick detour into NFL quarterback struggles, Miami’s collapse, and how tough it is to evaluate young QBs in broken systems.15:45 – Movie Talk: Romeo + JulietMatt recounts turning off Baz Luhrmann’s Romeo + Juliet after 10 minutes, anxiety-inducing editing, and re-litigating whether it’s actually romantic.21:12 – TV, Fame & Parasocial WeirdnessDiscussion on Percy Jackson’s weekly releases, Stranger Things timing, fans crossing boundaries with child actors, and the strange entitlement culture around fame.24:46 – TikTok, Algorithms & Micro-FameStories about social-media algorithms, accidental viral clips, TikTok traction for Underdog content, and why niche fame is the ideal level.33:58 – Christmas Movie DebateRanking holiday movies (Home Alone, Elf, The Santa Clause, The Grinch), arguing what counts as a Christmas movie, and ripping Red One.Games Discussed 11:58 – Ole Miss vs GeorgiaHigh-stakes College Football Playoff matchup discussed in terms of odds, offensive firepower, defensive pressure, and postseason implications.
  • Episode 448: Tua, Transfers, and Trouble

    42:08|
    00:29 – Intro, Weather & Snow Game HopesChris and Matt open with cold-weather complaints, melting snow, and disappointment over a non-snowy Eagles game despite early-morning snowfall.01:56 – Week 16 Setup, Sneaker Talk & Market CollapseChris opens oddsmakers for Week 16 and shifts into sneaker discussion: delayed Nardwuar Dunks, collapsing resale prices, Orange Lobsters, Powerpuff Dunks, and how sneaker culture has cooled alongside tighter consumer spending.05:28 – Holiday Recording Plans & Gift TalkDiscussion of Christmas scheduling, lack of major sneaker drops, Matt’s upcoming Grateful Dead Air Maxes, and Chris’s infamous Big Red Boots surviving a basement flood.08:30 – World Cup Dreams & Sponsorship PitchChris pitches brands on sponsoring a World Cup trip to Philadelphia, traffic concerns, Poland qualification hopes, and joking about Matt playing striker.11:18 – Soccer Backgrounds & Learning the GameThey reflect on late-blooming soccer fandom, Wrexham’s rise, appreciating skill gaps across leagues, and how exposure reshapes expectations.13:58 – NFL Futures, Injuries & Retirement OddsDeep dive into oddsmakers props: Andy Reid retirement speculation, Travis Kelce’s timeline, Mahomes’ injury impact, and why elite coaches rarely walk away.19:12 – Retired QB Comeback AbsurdityDiscussion of comeback odds for Cam Newton, Nick Foles, Matt Ryan, Andrew Luck (firmly no), Tom Brady (unlikely), and joke entries like Boomer Esiason and Phil Simms.24:44 – Tua’s Future & QB Carousel RealityThey examine Tua’s benching, personality shifts, concussion concerns, lack of clear starting jobs league-wide, and why Kansas City as a bridge option oddly makes sense.28:00 – Eagles Drama: Hurts, McKee & A.J. BrownPushback against Hurts benching talk, Tanner McKee discourse, injury worries, A.J. Brown’s future, chemistry questions, and Buffalo as a theoretical WR1 destination.33:48 – College Football Playoff FrustrationsOle Miss rankings debate, skepticism of expanded playoffs, Tulane matchup context, and holiday schedule juggling.37:46 – Diego Pavia Fallout & CFP StructureCriticism of post-Heisman behavior, deleted tweets, a bizarre 16-team playoff plea, and broader concerns about player maturity and optics.39:28 – NIL, Transfers & Education ConcernsThoughtful discussion on NIL benefits vs. academic harm, multi-school transfers, graduation risk, and proposing limits to protect players long-term.
  • Episode 447: Kyle Pitts on the Bench

    44:32|
    00:30 – Cold Open & Life AdminChris and Matt joke about house cleaners, laundry, first-world problems, and working around cleaners being in the house.03:54 – Week 15 Setup & Sneaker TalkTransition into Week 15 football. Chris opens oddsmakers and asks Matt about recent sneaker drops: Jalen Brunson Statue of Liberty Kobes, Sabrina 3s, Nardwuar Dunks, and the strange “Panda monium” Dunk Low.(Main Episode Continues)07:37 – Rejoin, Fantasy Football Pain & Betting MissesThey explain the recording delay, fantasy playoff disasters (Kyle Pitts explosion left on the bench), missed player-prop bets, and late-night exhaustion.11:30 – Reality TV & Movie TalkDiscussion of Traitors Canada, Canadian Bacon, and a deep dive into ranking John Candy movies (Planes, Trains & Automobiles, Uncle Buck, Cool Runnings, Spaceballs).16:25 – TV & BooksMatt reviews Percy Jackson on Disney+, Chris mentions Harry Potter audiobooks, and they touch on Greta Gerwig’s Narnia plans.18:50 – Lane Kiffin Return & Ole Miss FalloutConversation about Kiffin’s return, player NIL decisions, Chambliss’ future, LSU money, loyalty vs. stability, and playoff optics.22:55 – CFP Structure & Notre Dame DecisionDebate over automatic bids, Tulane/JMU inclusion, Notre Dame opting out, optics for players, and how playoff expansion may be inevitable.27:35 – NFL Parity & Weird StandingsThey note bizarre conference leaders, Panthers division positioning, and overall league inconsistency.NFL Games Discussed 28:50 – Saints at PanthersDivisional matchup shaping late-season standings.29:15 – Jaguars vs Opponent (13-point favorite)Discussion of Jacksonville’s surprising rise after a risky draft trade.31:35 – Colts at SeahawksFocus on 44-year-old Philip Rivers’ return and playoff desperation.34:20 – Raiders at EaglesPhilly’s offensive-line issues, Pickett starting, and limp-in playoff vibes.35:35 – Phillies Offseason Wrap-UpKyle Schwarber’s return, World Series odds via oddsmakers, and strong interest in Japanese pitcher Tatsuya Imae — notably wanting to beat, not join, the Dodgers.37:20 – ClosingFinal thoughts, optimism for roster fixes, and sign-off.
  • Episode 446: Starting DJ With a Broken Fibula

    55:05|
    00:13 – Intro & Lane Kiffin Departure FalloutChris and Matt open with the chaos surrounding Lane leaving Ole Miss, Pete Golding taking over, LSU advantages in recruiting, why Alabama may have been in play, leaked team-meeting audio, and player excitement for Golding.06:56 – Coaching Trees, Loyalty & Transfer Portal EffectsThey discuss Charlie Weis Jr. staying to coach the playoff game, Joe Judge’s role, stepping-stone programs, and the structural reasons Ole Miss will always compete with SEC giants.10:26 – Iron Bowl Madness & CFP Bracket ScenariosBreakdown of Auburn’s meltdown, how Ole Miss narrowly missed the SEC Championship, early College Football Playoff matchups, dangerous teams (Georgia, Alabama, Indiana, Texas Tech), and Penn State’s recruiting collapse.15:45 – Absurd Age-Gap Players & Local HS FootballConversation shifts to the 58-year-old D-lineman at Lycoming, La Salle’s state title run, PW memories, coaching stories, and the difficulty of developing freshman players.18:23 – Eagles Roster Talk: Slay, Secondary Issues & OffenseDebate over Darius Slay vs. Adoree Jackson, defensive struggles, coaching frustration, ugly Eagles performances, and parallels to prior seasons.20:23 – Chargers Week DiscussionHerbert’s hand injury, Monday-night scheduling fatigue, and how dangerous a wounded Chargers squad can be.23:13 – Injury Stories, Toughness & “Run It Straight”Two insane injury anecdotes, unsafe viral sports, and the dangers of youth football.32:23 – TV & Movies SegmentThoughts on Task, Slow Horses, Stranger Things, Playdate, The Promotion, Kevin James films, and holiday viewing traditions.38:56 – Living in Ohio vs. Charlotte & Seasonal LifeNostalgia for Ohio, weather preferences, neighborhood culture, museums, and why seasons matter.41:01 – Fantasy Football Pain & Cooling Off GamblingLosing streaks, injury-ruined lineups, playoff odds, and stepping away from betting.42:16 – NFL Viewership & Team PerceptionHistoric Chiefs–Cowboys ratings, divisional races, overreactions to Lamar, and Philly’s inconsistency.43:47 – “Worst Contract” Debate: Embiid vs. SaquonA detailed, spirited comparison of the two extensions, value, injuries, and fan expectations.46:45 – Ben Simmons ConversationSurprising Simmons quote about playing in Philly, how limited he is now, but how passing could still help a roster.NFL Games Mentioned20:23 – Eagles at ChargersConcerns about Herbert’s hand, Chargers’ inconsistencies, and whether Philly can rebound.52:00 – Seahawks at FalconsMatt’s “bet of the week” discussion: Seattle’s bounce-back potential and Atlanta’s struggles.
  • Episode 445: The Lane Kiffin Saga

    49:07|
    00:30 – Intro & Lane Kiffin DramaMatt vents about Lane Kiffin rumors, conflicting reports (Florida, LSU), Ole Miss’ ultimatum talk, and his frustration with message-board speculation.03:30 – Coaching Fits & Ole Miss FutureDebate on whether Kiffin stays, why LSU isn’t a good fit, Florida as a possible landing spot, Ole Miss’ rising profile, and how coaching turnover impacts recruiting and stability.07:30 – Movies & TV TalkDiscussion of Playdate, Becky, Kevin James roles, Vince Vaughn in Nonnas, emotional themes, Linda Cardellini’s underrated career, Scrubs revival details, returning cast, med-school season debate, and revisiting Ted Lasso.19:42 – Sneaker Drops & Christmas GiftsLook at the upcoming Kobe “EM China” and “University Red” releases, how Kobes feel overdone, Caitlin Clark pairs, Christmas gift hiding, sneaker pranks, and shoe-of-the-month surprises.24:58 – Eagles vs Lions Recap & Offensive ConcernsEagles’ ugly win, windy conditions, A.J. Brown’s frustration, Hurts’ demeanor, passing-game issues, slants disappearing, and media overreactions.26:54 – Eagles Identity, Defense & AdditionsImpact of Jalen Phillips, Nolan Smith, and N’Kobe Dean returning; Jordan Davis’ athleticism; needed extensions; roster crunch; and importance of veteran leadership.36:50 – League Perception & Super Bowl OddsOddsmakers placing the Rams at the top, Eagles being undervalued, and fans treating an elite team like a struggling one.40:31 – Coaching Staff ConcernsPetulo’s offense being too vanilla, need for a veteran OC, possible fits like Kellen Moore or Bill O’Brien, and lessons from the Doug Pederson era.43:53 – NFL Week 12 Lines (Timecodes Only)(All timecodes reflect start of each matchup discussion.)43:53 – Patriots vs Bengals44:54 – Steelers vs Bears45:48 – Falcons vs Saints46:22 – Eagles vs Cowboys 47:22 – Uniform TalkEagles wearing Kelly Green on the road, Cowboys sticking with white, uniform-ranking discussions, and preference between Kelly, midnight green, and black alternates.48:59 – Closing ThoughtsEagles-Cowboys importance, hopes for Week 12, and sign-off.
  • Episode 444: Scandelous

    51:48|
    00:30 – Intro & SetupChris and Matt open with banter about ghosts before previewing the week’s slate — NFL Week 11, NBA, NHL, and college football.01:06 – Sneaker Talk & AuctionsThey discuss missing out on the Caitlin Clark Kobe release and review resale prices. The hosts explore StockX’s first sneaker auction, covering notable pairs like the Nike Mag “Back to the Future,” Off-White Dunk “Syracuse,” Kobe Barcelonas, and “Chunky Dunky.”06:38 – Grateful Dead & Stranger Things CollabsChris mentions waiting for “Stranger Things” shoes to drop in price. Matt jokes about owning Grateful Dead Air Max 90s and the fluctuation of sneaker resale markets.08:55 – Upcoming Sneaker DropsThey note few notable releases left this month. “Chicago Lows” are compared to “Pandas” due to constant restocks. Matt considers asking for them for Christmas.10:28 – Fraud Story & Jail HypotheticalsThe conversation shifts to a man who defrauded Amazon for millions. They debate whether prison time would be worth $51 million (concluding no).11:44 – TV, Movies & Harry Potter AudiobooksMatt mentions To Catch a Killer with Shailene Woodley and Ben Mendelsohn. This leads to tangents about Ready Player One and Harry Potter audiobooks — including the “Thinking Hat” detail, full-cast performances, and favorite narrators.18:48 – Driving Habits & Insurance AppsChris describes State Farm’s “Drive Safe” program and savings features; Matt jokes about his “Dale Earnhardt” driving style.20:49 – NFL: Jackson Dart & Rookie DiscussionsThey discuss Jackson Dart’s offensive rookie odds (via oddsmakers) and Jameis Winston’s likability. Talk expands to the Browns’ quarterback issues, Dylan Gabriel, and Shadour Sanders.25:47 – College Football: Ole Miss, Florida & Mississippi StateOle Miss faces Florida (14-point favorites per oddsmakers). The hosts note it could be a trap game and preview next week’s Egg Bowl.28:35 – MLB: Guardians Betting ScandalThey react to Guardians pitchers accused of taking bribes and mock the small payoff amounts involved.30:29 – Parenting, LegoLand & SafetyLighthearted parenting stories, LegoLand’s child policies, and kidnapping-scare jokes lead into pet anecdotes and winter weather talk.33:37 – Frozen & Parenting HumorMatt describes watching Frozen repeatedly with his kids and balancing childcare with sanity.34:57 – NBA All-Star Format & International DominanceChris outlines the new format (Team USA vs International). They agree the global roster—Luka, Giannis, Jokic, Wemby, SGA—would dominate and call for scrapping All-Star Weekend entirely.38:15 – NBA Controversies & InjuriesThey touch on the Clippers’ turmoil, Bradley Beal’s injury, Embiid’s MRI, and Kawhi Leonard’s alleged salary-cap violation, debating appropriate punishments.44:41 – Sports Scandals & Blue ChipsThe hosts rank recent controversies (Astros, Patriots, FIFA, SMU) before joking about Blue Chips (1994) with Shaq and Penny Hardaway — noting how its once-illegal plot is now legal under NIL.