Share

cover art for The Claude Garrett Case

The Reasonable Doubt Podcast

The Claude Garrett Case

Season 1, Ep. 4

Retired Birmingham homicide detective Chris Anderson and defense attorney Fatima Silva give us a behind the scenes look into their investigation of the Claude Garrett case.  The Tennessee man was convicted of murder after prosecutors argued he locked his girlfriend in a room and set their house on fire.  But now Claude’s daughter and best friend insist he was wrongfully convicted of murder and want Chris and Fatima to join their fight.

More episodes

View all episodes

  • Trailer: Introducing The Reasonable Doubt Podcast

    00:39
    The Reasonable Doubt Podcast premieres Tuesday, March 10th. Listen to a sneak peek of the new companion podcast series to the hit ID series Reasonable Doubt. New episodes will premiere weekly.
  • 1. The Ken Middleton Murder Case

    33:45
    Retired Birmingham homicide detective Chris Anderson, and defense attorney Fatima Silva give us a behind the scenes look at their investigation into the Ken Middleton case. The Missouri man is serving a life sentence for murdering his wife, but his son and grandson are absolutely convinced it was a miscarriage of justice.
  • 2. The Celeste Beard Case

    35:25
    Retired Birmingham homicide detective Chris Anderson, and defense attorney Fatima Silva give us a behind the scenes look at their investigation into the Celeste Beard case. The Austin woman is doing life for orchestrating the murder of her rich, elderly husband. But her mother and fifth husband insist this was a grave miscarriage of justice.
  • 3. The Michael Crump Case

    32:51
    Retired Birmingham homicide detective Chris Anderson, and defense attorney Fatima Silva give us a behind the scenes look of their investigation into the Michael Crump case.  The Virginia man got convicted of murdering a drug dealer at a party- based largely on the eyewitness testimony of one visually impaired woman.
  • 5. The Warren Horinek Case

    36:54
    Retired Birmingham homicide detective Chris Anderson and defense attorney Fatima Silva give us a behind the scenes look into their investigation of the Warren Horinek  case.  The former Fort Worth police officer is convicted of murdering his wife Bonnie, an up and coming attorney.  But now two of his friends say, there was no murder- she actually killed herself.  
  • 6. The Daniel Blan Case

    32:24
    Retired Birmingham homicide detective Chris Anderson and defense attorney Fatima Silva give us a behind the scenes look into their investigation of the Daniel Blan case.  The Alabama man is serving a life sentence for the shooting death of his adoptive father.  Blan’s wife and best friend insist he’s innocent, and they’re asking Chris and Fatima to help join their fight.  
  • 7. The Tracy Fortson Case

    34:03
    Retired Birmingham homicide detective Chris Anderson and defense attorney Fatima Silva give us a behind the scenes look into their investigation of the Tracy Fortson case.  She was once a pioneer: the first female sheriff’s deputy in Oglethorpe County, Georgia.  Now, she is doing life for the brutal murder of her ex-boyfriend.  But Tracy’s mother and cousin insist she’s innocent and are asking   Chris and Fatima to join their fight.   
  • 8. The Ronnie Denny Jr. Case

    37:47
    Retired Birmingham homicide detective Chris Anderson and defense attorney Fatima Silva give us a behind the scenes look into their investigation of the Ronnie Denny Jr. case.  The rural Oklahoma drug dealer was convicted of murdering his girlfriend even though her body was never recovered, and no direct evidence tied him to her disappearance.  Now the convict’s mother and sister are pleading with Chris and Fatima to get behind their crusade to free Denny.