Share

cover art for SNP - Explosive Interview with Stewart McDonald

The Ponsonby and Massie Podcast

SNP - Explosive Interview with Stewart McDonald

Ep. 17
•

Bernard Ponsonby and Alex Massie speak to Stewart McDonald, SNP front bencher who lost his seat at the General Election ..... and he had a lot to say.


ON 2026 HOLYROOD ELECTION

25:32 MASSIE: "Do you think getting "horsed" in 2026 is now the most likely outcome of the Holyrood election?"

McDONALD: "Yes"


ON INDEPENDENCE

35:07 "The hard pause has been delivered for us whether we like that or not. That was done last Thursday and was evident in ballot boxes up and down the country".


ON LABOUR

44:38 "I've watched them closely and they're getting their act together in a way that's connecting with people.... the reality is that they're a party that's being taken seriously by voters once again. Many of whom have voted SNP, not just over the past decade but over the past 17 years we have been in government. So, we have a problem and the only way we can answer that problem is to be serious, is to be grown up, is to take hard decisions"


ON SNP CULTURE - "NOT A SERIOUS POLITCAL CULTURE"

11:38 "We've strayed. They feel we've stopped listening to them so they've stopped listening to us."

11:55 "I think we have a cultural problem within the SNP."

13:19 "A political culture that operates like that is not a serious political culture." 

14:22 "You cannot be everything to all people if you're serious about the aspiration of statehood and government."

26:56 "I'm looking at the motions we're about to debate at our upcoming party conference, one of which includes a debate on the national anthem for an independent Scotland. I mean, get real." 

27:10 MASSIE "What do you think the anthem should be?"

27:14 McDONALD "I couldn't give a monkey's."



NICOLA STURGEON

16:49 "Obviously the leader has to take a large portion of the blame .... a long term strategy there was not." 


ON SWINNEY TURNING ROUND THE SNP

31:19 "I think he wants to do it...but it will require him to be a ruthless bastard."


ON BLAMING OTHERS

44:10 "It is not the foundation and the basis of a grown up relationship with the country and too often we've thought that it is and that is sufficient."


ON THE GREENS

20:10 "Much of the damage that was done to our credibility, our reputation for good government happened during that time....... There's not much of those coalition years I will remember fondly"


NUCLEAR WEAPONS

24:18 "I don't think two years is possible.... the timescale cannot be put in place just by us." 

More episodes

View all episodes

  • 33. SALMOND & STURGEON - Part 1 Reaction & Analysis

    32:01||Ep. 33
    PART 1 - Bernard and Alex were consulted during the production of BBC Scotland's "Salmond and Sturgeon: A Troubled Union".In this episode, released directly after the documentary's broadcast, Bernard and Alex focus on part one of the two part series. They give their thoughts and analysis of both the programme and relationship between Alex Salmond and Nicola Sturgeon.SNPScottish PoliticsScottish LabourScottish ConservativesScottish LibdemsScottish GreensAlba Party

  • 32. MICHAEL MARRA - 2026 Labour victory "nowhere near a done deal"

    49:05||Ep. 32
    Labour's Shadow Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Michael Marra MSP, tells the podcastA 2026 victory for Labour in the Scottish Parliamentary Election is "nowhere near a done deal"The best case scenario is a minority Labour governmentHis political roots in family life in DundeeHe regards Anas Sarwar's transformation of Scottish Labour as "profound"Recorded at the Kilderkin pub on the Royal Mile.

  • 31. SNP CONFERENCE VERDICT - Where is the Policy Prospectus and Indy Strategy?

    34:32||Ep. 31
    In the aftermath of the SNP's Annual Conference, Bernard and Alex ask - where are the new policies and the strategy for independence that the party will need to win voters back who switched to Labour at the General Election? The need for a clear policy prospectus.The challenges of economic growth and public services. The conference talked about Independence but not the trickier subject of strategy.If the SNP and Scottish Government continue to say they cannot deliver with the powers and budget they have, Scottish Labour will say it can.

  • 30. Alex Neil - 30 year wait for Independence if SNP lose in 2026

    48:54||Ep. 30
    On the eve of the SNP Annual Conference, former Minister Alex Neil warns First Minster John Swinney to bin the "political weans" and "bring in heavyweights" as losing 2026 election will mean an independent Scotland is "in the freezer for 10-30 years"

  • 29. Should SNP Ministers Meet Israelis and Palestinians?

    39:11||Ep. 29
    Bernard Ponsonby and Alex Massie tackle the issues of the week includingFallout from SNP Minister, Angus Robertson, meeting with Israeli diplomats.Can anything be done to stem drug deaths in ScotlandThe Scottish Conservative leadership race.

  • 28. I'll Investigate Douglas Ross says Tory Leadership Hopeful, Meghan Gallacher

    46:02||Ep. 28
    Scottish Conservative leadership candidate, Meghan Gallacher, does not hold back in laying out her campaign stall.Says she'll investigate allegations that former boss and party leader, Douglas Ross, had a long term plan to dump Holyrood colleagues in favour of Westminster seat. Proposes 1p cut to Scottish Income TaxProposes a re-evaluation of Scottish Council Tax bands. Complete rebuild of the Scottish Tory party. Expresses her admiration for Margaret Thatcher who "took no sh*t"

  • 27. Labour's Paul Sweeney - 2026 Scot Parl Election "High Stakes" for Future of UK

    52:41||Ep. 27
    He's only 35 but Labour's Paul Sweeney has already been an MP and now sits as an MSP. He joined Bernard and Alex in the Press Bar in Glasgow to discuss.;2026 Scottish Parliament Election is "high stakes" in terms of determining the long term future of the UK. "I've seen How hard Anas Sarwar works" - I don't think I'd be up to the job. "My faith in the Labour tribe" was rocked by the Iraq War. "Glasgow has lost its momentum" - He wants to be a champion for the City.He's a Federalist, not a Nationalist or Unionist. Was mis-sold a youthful list vote for SNP on broken promise on student debt.

  • 26. Is the Era of SNP Austerity Upon Us?

    34:27||Ep. 26
    Bernard and Alex recapture the lost art of a leisurely political conversation over a pint in the pub - in this case Glasgow's famous journalists pub, The Press Bar. Is this the era of SNP austerity?The Winter Fuel Allowance means testNew GERS figures. We examine the state of Scotland's finances.

  • 25. I VOTED LABOUR - Former Tory MSP, Prof Adam Tomkins

    45:45||Ep. 25
    Former Tory MSP and Constitutional Law expert, Professor Adam Tomkins, joins us for a fascinating insight into the constitutional issues Scotland faces plus .... Prof Tomkins voted Labour for Blair McDougall at the General ElectionRole of Lord Advocate needs fixed - "it's extremely dangerous"He's enthused by the "boring" serious nature of Keir Starmer's new Labour administration in Westminster. Can't remember the name of the Scottish Tory Leadership frontrunner.