Share

cover art for Sir Anton Muscatelli - The Reality Scotland's Politicians Refuse to Face

The Ponsonby and Massie Podcast

Sir Anton Muscatelli - The Reality Scotland's Politicians Refuse to Face

Ep. 122
•

Sir Anton Muscatelli, President of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, academic and leading economic advisor, joins Bernard and Alex to give his view on some of the real issues that are facing Scotland but politicians seem unwilling to discuss, particularly around election time.


Scotland faces £4.8bn gap and it was hardly mentioned at the recent election.

Slower Scottish tax growth means £728m less.

What can be learned from "Manchesterism" and what can Andy Burnham's administration do for Scotland?

Does Scotland need more immigration?

Will efficiencies really save billions and will services inevitably be affected.


Focussing on UK, Scottish and Global politics, if you like other great political podcasts like The Rest is Politics, The News Agents, Newscast, Questions Time, Holyrood Sources, Planet Holyrood, The Stooshie, The Steamie, Scotcast, Americast etc etc then The Ponsonby and Massie Podcast could be a great show to add to your list of favourites.

More episodes

View all episodes

  • 121. SILLY SEASON - Can Count Binface Win Farage's Backfiring By-Election?

    49:00||Ep. 121
    It's Silly Season for the political media and, after forcing a by-election in his own seat, Nigel Farage discovered many of the parties were unwilling to play his game. Now, his most serious competition appears to be from by-election regular, Count Binface. Also, the latest on the SNP money and potential court cases, Andy Burnham swooping into Downing Street and the passing of some significant political figures in the past few days.

  • 120. HAS FARAGE CRISIS HALTED THE REFORM JUGGERNAUT?

    41:07||Ep. 120
    Bernard Ponsonby and Alex Massie look at how Nigel Farage is dealing with his first real crisis and also - is Andy Burnham making unsustainable promises before he even becomes Prime Minister?

  • 119. WHY NO INQUIRY?... and would Burnham offer Starmer the Foreign Office?

    41:07||Ep. 119
    Two main topics for Alex and Bernard this week. The proposed coronation of Andy Burnham - speculation is rife around his likely cabinet picks. Starmer was relatively successful in International affairs. Will Burnham be tempted to ask him to stay on as Foreign Secretary?Also, after the sentencing of Peter Murrell, is it sustainable for there to be no inquiry into what happened at the SNP? Does the First Minister not owe the members an explanation?

  • 118. BY ELECTION RESULTS AND VERDICT

    39:44||Ep. 118
    Andy Burnham clears the latest hurdle in his bid to become Prime Minister with a stonking by-election victory in Makerfield. The Scottish Conservative win their first Scottish by-election since 1967 after the SNP's Stephen Flynn vacated the seat to sit in the Scottish Parliament and Lara Bird holds Arbroath and Broughty Ferry for the SNP. Bernard Ponsonby and Alex Massie reflect on a momentous night and what it all means.

  • 117. 3 BIG BY ELECTIONS

    38:17||Ep. 117
    MAKERFIELDBurnham “Dicing With Political And Electoral Death”Could Makerfield Trigger Starmer’s Downfall?Reform’s Huge By-Election Test for Farage and ReformABERDEENAberdeen South Tests SNP Resilience After Murrell FalloutAberdeen South: Oil, Reform And Tactical Voting CollideARBROATHSNP’s “What Do We Have To Do To Lose?” MomentArbroath Shows Whether Scotland Is Cooling On Labour

  • SWINNEY SCANDAL STRATEGY FAILING?

    38:08|
    Ring-fenced SNP cash row returns to centre stageSean Clerkin, Wings Over Scotland, Noel Dolan, Douglas Chapman and Joanna Cherry all increasing pressure for SNP probeSwinney faces VAT questions over Murrell scandalSturgeon interview failed to kill storyMurrell fallout could hit SNP by-election hopes

  • 115. Murrell, Sturgeon & Swinney - Who Knew What, When?

    34:21||Ep. 115
    Increasingly, it looks like the scandal that has rocked the SNP will not go away. Peter Murrell's admission and subsequent conviction have led to more questions. Bernard Ponsonby and Alex Massie discuss.PONSONBY - John Swinney may need an independent inquiry into SNP governance, because a party-led response risks looking like a whitewash.MASSIE - Nicola Sturgeon’s core problem is not only “what did she know?” but “what should she have known?” as SNP leader signing off party accounts.PONSONBY - Many mainstream journalists were “asleep at the wheel” while Sean Clerkin and Stuart Campbell kept pressing questions others dismissed.MASSIE - the SNP may face an impossible choice: stand by Sturgeon or “throw her under the campervan” to draw a line under the scandal.PONSONBY - the SNP finance scandal is sensational but may not have a lasting electoral impact — unless the party mishandles the demand for answers.

  • 114. Swinney's Cabinet - Analysis & Verdict

    40:03||Ep. 114
    Swinney’s new Scottish Government is smaller, reshuffled and designed to signal seriousness about reform.Ivan McKee’s public service reform role is framed as the key test: finding billions in savings without triggering political backlash.The SNP faces a clash between pro-growth rhetoric, welfare expansion, price controls and the hard reality of Scotland’s projected budget black hole.Jenny Gilruth, Stephen Flynn, Màiri McAllan and Stephen Gethins are discussed as signs of future SNP leadership positioning.At Westminster, Andy Burnham’s by-election bid is portrayed as potentially decisive for Labour’s leadership and Keir Starmer’s future.