Share

The Overlap
The Cost of Loyalty & Another Club At Risk Of Charges? | Price of Football Fan Debate
Welcome back to The Overlap Fan Debate, brought to you by Sky Bet.
Jamie Carragher is joined by Paul Scholes and special guest and Financial Expert Kieran Maguire, as well as some of the biggest fan channels across the country.
This week’s episode is all about the Price of Football!
We kick things off with Kieran Maguire giving us a run down on the financial situation at Premier League clubs, including clubs trying to make money out of fans by raising ticket prices.
We'll get views on Manchester United under INEOS, American ownership, plus, is the disconnection between fans and clubs in the Premier League at its worst?
Finally, Kieran Maguire answers club questions, including what will happen with the Manchester City charges?
If you’re enjoying the podcast, please hit subscribe to never miss an episode, and please leave us a five-star review to help others discover the show. Thank you for listening!
00:00 - Promo
00:44 - Introduction
01:05 - Kieran Maguire on the financial situation at Premier League clubs
05:00 - Paul Scholes on ticket prices at Salford
06:21 - Liverpool Fan Gareth Roberts on the exploitation of football fans
13:50 - Adam McKola on INEOS at Manchester United
20:15 - Everton fan Baz on Everton’s new stadium and ticket prices
25:14 - Crystal Palace fan Dan Cook (HLTCO) on Palace not upping ticket prices
26:22 - Nieve Petruzziello (StuntPegg) on the disconnection from fans and their clubs
30:53 - Manchester City v Salford in the FA Cup
38:10 - Kieran Maguire on the finances of the FA Cup and where the money goes
40:30 - Debate on the FA Cup replays being scrapped
50:04 - Kieran Maguire answers club questions
More episodes
View all episodes
18. Scholes & Carra's Most Gruesome Injury Stories | The Overlap Fan Debate
42:59||Season 1, Ep. 18We’re back with another Fan Debate, brought to you by Sky Bet. This time, Paul Scholes and Jamie Carragher are joined by former Manchester United senior physio Russ Hayes. They take a deep dive into the world of football fitness, exploring injury prevention, recovery, and the vital role of physios and sports scientists. Scholsey and Carra share their own experiences, including the worst injuries they suffered and what players really think of medical staff. How hard is it to keep an injury-prone player fit? And do physios have a bigger impact on performance than we realise?If you're enjoying The Overlap Fan Debate, please hit subscribe to never miss an episode, and consider leaving us a five-star review to help others discover the show. Thank you for listening!00:00 – Promo00:49 – Introduction - Russ Hayes former Physiotherapist at Manchester United04:33 – Russ Hayes on hamstring injuries06:32 – The impact of mentality on injuries09:19 – Trying to get back from injuries early & injury prone players10:32 – Gareth Roberts on injuries at Liverpool12:30 – The relationship between managers and physios16:09 – Flav on injuries at Tottenham Hotspur20:37 – Paul Scholes on getting a blood clot in his eye22:24 – James McNicholas’s question on players wanting to play when injured25:13 – Fulham fan Sarah’s question to Russ Hayes27:31 – The Howden Report explained30:50 – Jamie Carragher’s broken leg33:33 – Newcastle fan Lee on the change in football gear36:23 – Who is to blame for injuries at a club?38:16 – The Treatment Room / The room of truth41:12 – Manchester City fan Luke on injuries17. Man Utd Lack Spirit & Is Salah Better than Ronaldo & Henry? | The Overlap Fan Debate
01:14:44||Season 1, Ep. 17Welcome back to The Overlap Fan Debate brought to you by Sky Bet - as Jamie Carragher and Paul Scholes discuss all the latest football with fans from up and down the country. Liverpool go 11 points clear, is the title already theirs? And is Mo Salah the best ever to play in the Premier League? We delve into Manchester City’s exit from the Champions League and Arsenal’s shock defeat at the weekend. Plus, who will win the race for Europe - and are things starting to turn around for Tottenham? If you're enjoying The Overlap Fan Debate, please hit subscribe to never miss an episode, and consider leaving us a five-star review to help others discover the show. Thank you for listening!00:00 - Promo01:38 - Greg Nottingham Forest Quiz04:31 - Gareth Liverpool Fan & have they won the league?09:35 - Who is the best Premier League player of all time?19:34 - James Arsenal Fan & are they out of the title race?24:55 - Luke Manchester City Fan & will they challenge next season?33:59 - McKola Manchester United fan on their struggles 49:51 - Rory Chelsea Fan on their decline in form1:01:08 - Flav Tottenham Hotspur Fan on their recent win1:04:30 - Sarah Fulham Fan & their positive season 1:07:06 - Lee Newcastle Fan & their weekend’s result1:11:23 - Greg Nottingham Forest Fan on whether they will make Europe16. Liverpool’s Contract Secrets, Tapping Up Rooney & Neymar’s Party Clause! | The Overlap Fan Debate
55:15||Season 1, Ep. 16Join Jamie Carragher, Paul Scholes, and fans for the latest episode of The Fan Debate, brought to you by Sky Bet.In this episode - we're joined by a top sports lawyer to find out how top clubs structure player deals, navigate salary caps, and stay within Financial Fair Play (FFP) and Premier League Salary Rules (PSR).The discussion also covers tapping up in football - including the time Wayne Rooney was approached by Paul Scholes!We also explore Neymar’s infamous “party clause”! Just how common are these unusual perks, and what do players negotiate behind closed doors?If you're enjoying The Overlap Fan Debate, please hit subscribe to never miss an episode, and consider leaving us a five-star review to help others discover the show. Thank you for listening!Chapters:00:00 - Promo01:04 - Arsenal Quiz with Alex04:07 - Lawyer, Author, Speaker - Daniel Geey04:50 - Understanding PSR and FFP09:21 - Liverpool Contract Renewals22:55 - Tapping Up in Football25:29 - The Haaland Deal: Long-Term Contracts30:43 - Arteta's Arsenal and PSR33:30 - Declan Rice and His Transfer to Arsenal34:31 - Agents, Salaries, and Club Strategies47:16 - Champions League and Celtic50:55 - Ludicrous Clauses and Transfers15. Amorim Under Pressure & Scholes Calls Out Arsenal! | The Overlap Fan Debate
01:04:57||Season 1, Ep. 15Join us for the latest Fan Debate brought to you by Sky Bet, where Paul Scholes and Jamie Carragher discuss all latest football news with fans from up and down the country.The episode kicks off with Tottenham's ongoing issues under Postecoglou and the impact of player injuries. What are Liverpool's priorities this season after their recent FA Cup exit?Arsenal's need for attacking talent and potential summer targets are debated. The conversation then shifts to Manchester United's struggles and tactical decisions under Rúben Amorim. Finally, the focus turns to West Ham's fresh start under Graham Potter and the improved team dynamics following Lopetegui's departure. If you're enjoying The Overlap Fan Debate, please hit subscribe to never miss an episode, and consider leaving us a five-star review to help others discover the show. Thank you for listening!00:00 Intro00:39 West Ham Quiz Challenge03:09 FA Cup Reactions and Tottenham's Performance19:58 Liverpool's Priorities and FA Cup Exit27:42 Manchester City's Confidence Amidst Charges31:32 Man City vs Real Madrid32:19 Celtic's Champions League Journey37:15 Arsenal's Struggles and Future Prospects49:10 Manchester United's Managerial Concerns57:34 West Ham's Season and Managerial ChangesGary Neville: The Triumph and Tragedy of the Busby Babes - It Was What It Was
45:21|We've got an extra treat for you this week: Gary Neville joins our football history podcast, It Was What It Was. The former Manchester United captain looks back on one of the most momentous and tragic events in football history: The Munich air disaster of 1958.Neville discusses the lasting significance of the tragedy - and how Sir Matt Busby rebuilt the club, leading them to European Cup glory just a decade after its darkest day.If you want to know more about the game’s greatest characters, matches that changed football forever, and the stories behind the bribes, the bans, and the on-pitch battles - this is the podcast for you! Join two of the world’s best football journalists - Jonathan Wilson and Rob Draper - at football university.Give it a listen - we know you'll enjoy it! And if you want to hear the next part of the Busby Babes story, it's on the It Was What It Was feed.Please subscribe to It Was What It Was and become a student of the game!14. Have Pep’s Tactic’s Expired & Slot’s Style Shift at Liverpool | Fan Debate Tactics Special
56:03||Season 1, Ep. 14Join us for the latest Fan Debate, brought to you by Sky Bet where Paul Scholes, Jamie Carragher and the fans delve into the most pressing football topics. Special guests include tactical expert and host analysts HTO from The Overlap Breakdown channel, who sheds light on current trends in the Premier League. The panel look at how tactics have evolved - from Sir Alex Ferguson's era to the influence of managers like Pep Guardiola. They explore the shifts in today's game, analyse how different clubs like Liverpool and Arsenal approach strategy, and debate the impact of managerial philosophies on team performance. If you're enjoying The Overlap Fan Debate, please hit subscribe to never miss an episode, and consider leaving us a five-star review to help others discover the show. Thank you for listening!00:00 Intro01:20 Leicester City Quiz04:07 Tactical Trends in Football10:09 Analysing Modern Football Tactics21:07 Liverpool's Tactical Evolution28:08 Arteta's Tactical Approach28:40 Martinelli's Evolution29:22 Odegaard's Struggles30:18 Arsenal's Striker Dilemma32:19 The Role of Creativity in Modern Football35:11 Everton's Football Philosophy39:39 Club Philosophies and Managerial Changes45:20 Tottenham's Style Under Postecoglou48:20 Nottingham Forest's Counter-Attacking Play53:09 Premier League's Competitive Mid-Table53:54 Conclusion and Wrap-UpThe First Ever Stick to Rugby with Martin Johnson!
01:10:08|The Six Nations is here - and we're launching a brand new show for everything rugby: Stick to Rugby, brought to you by Defender.This first-ever episode kicks off with a legendary guest: England's World Cup winning captain Martin Johnson joins regular hosts Lawrence Dallaglio, David Flatman, Katy Daley-McLean, and Tom Shanklin to discuss Grand Slams, Lions Tours and the red carpet controversy in Ireland!This is your front-row seat to everything rugby - from unforgettable moments to untold stories. We'll have brilliant guests from ex-pros to celebrity fans - and you'll get a new insight into the sport, from those who've seen it all!Please subscribe to Stick to Rugby to never miss an episode, and please consider leaving a five star review to help others find the show. Stick to Rugby is available now wherever you get your podcasts and on @TheOverlapRugby YouTube channel.13. What Next For Rashford? & Ornstein’s Transfer Insights | The Overlap Fan Debate Transfer Special
01:08:24||Season 4, Ep. 13Join us for the latest Overlap Fan Debate brought to you by Sky Bet as Paul Scholes and Jamie Carragher sit down with fans from across the country to tackle all the biggest football topics. We're also joined by David Ornstein, who shares his expert insight into the January transfer window and the latest rumours.We dive into Arsenal’s title ambitions and whether they need a centre-forward to secure the league. For Manchester United, we assess Rúben Amorim’s start and discuss the situation surrounding Marcus Rashford—has he let the club and his teammates down, and where could he end up?Chelsea’s season is under the spotlight as we question if they can still secure a Champions League spot, and we analyse Manchester City’s new signings—was Pep Guardiola unfair to start 20-year-old Khusanov at the weekend?The debate also takes us to Leicester, as we ask if they can stay up, and to Spurs, where we explore whether it’s time for a managerial change.It’s passionate, unfiltered, and packed with insight—don’t miss it and let us know your thoughts in the comments.00:00 Intro01:48 Quiz Time: Manchester City Trivia04:45 Transfer Talk with David Ornstein06:06 January Transfer Window Insights08:21 Manchester United's January Transfer Strategy10:30 Liverpool's Transfer Dilemma14:48 Arsenal's Centre-Forward Search21:02 Referee Decisions and VAR Controversies23:50 Manchester United's Squad and Rashford's Future34:15 Amorim's Vision for Man United37:26 Man City's Struggles and Transfer Decisions41:14 Chelsea's Decline and Managerial Critique49:24 Tottenham's Managerial Dilemma58:03 Everton's New Hope Under Moyes01:04:43 Leicester's Gamble with Ruud1. Gary Neville & Jill Scott Go To The Manchester Derby! | The Overlap X Barclays WSL
32:34||Season 1, Ep. 1Welcome to an exclusive episode of the Overlap in collaboration with the WSL! Gary Neville is joined by Jill Scott as he attends his first ever game in the WSL with the pair going head- to- head for the Manchester Derby. Watch them react to United rescuing Gary’s weekend by beating their local rivals 4-2! The pair talk all things WSL, the evolution of the women’s game and Gary’s hilarious ball boy story! You also do not want to miss Jill picking her combined Man City XI, which Gary insists includes players from the red half of Manchester. They both also catch up with Manchester City's Alex Greenwood and Jill’s former teammate Steph Houghton as well hat-rick hero Ella Toone as they discussed England and what it was like to play together. Stay tuned to see where Gary and Jill should visit next!