Share

cover art for Man City’s Uncertain Future, Fans Demand Punishment & Pep’s Legacy Tainted | The Overlap Fan Debate

Overlap Daily

Man City’s Uncertain Future, Fans Demand Punishment & Pep’s Legacy Tainted | The Overlap Fan Debate

•

Jamie Carragher, Stuart Pearce and football fans come together for a passionate Overlap Fan Debate, brought to you by Sky Bet, to discuss Manchester City’s case and what happens next.


From potential points deductions and relegation to questions over the club’s ownership, the panel debate what a fair punishment could look like.


City fans share their perspective, rival supporters explain their frustrations, and the discussion turns to Pep Guardiola’s legacy and the reception awaiting City at Anfield.


The Overlap Fan Debate has a new home. Search for the Overlap Fan Debate wherever you get your podcasts, hit the follow button and you'll never miss an episode.


And don't forget Overlap Daily! Starting this Friday! Brought to you by Sky Bet and Sky Vegas.


50x Trophies 🏆

565x Senior goals 🥅

515x International caps 🧢

37x Red cards 🟥

441x Yellow cards 🟨

307x Clean sheets 🧤

1x Game: Football ⚽️


Gerrard, Carragher, Redknapp, Neville, Ferguson, Hart, Schmeichel, Crossley, Sherwood, Young, Cates & Ives tackle football’s biggest stories, every weekday at 4pm. ⚽ Hit follow now so you get every episode.


00:00 - Intro


02:29 - City Charges


14:47 - What Punishment Is Fair


21:50 - Games Gone, Games Back


32:10 - Liverpool Hurt by City Case


45:50 - Pep vs Sir Alex Debate


58:28 - Newcastle Perspective on Fairness


01:08:05 - Chelsea Sanctions Debate


01:17:11 - Brighton Model vs Rules


01:24:12 - Hull Survival


01:30:10 - Leeds' Lessons on Spending

More episodes

View all episodes

  • 19. Goldbridge Meets Romesh, Declan Rice's Voice Note & United’s Impressive Comeback! | Overlap Daily

    01:19:38||Season 1, Ep. 19
    Welcome to Overlap Daily brought to you by our title partner, SKY VEGAS.Join Mark Goldbridge, Romesh Ranganathan, Jamie Redknapp and Tim Sherwood for today’s episode of Overlap Daily!Romesh reflects on winning The Traitors, his hatred for Robin van Persie while sharing his appreciation for Mark Goldbridge and his content.The team discuss whether Mikel Arteta can surpass Arsène Wenger’s Arsenal legacy, Manchester City’s charges, and a Declan Rice voice note that puts Romesh’s Arsenal fandom to the test.They also look back at Manchester United’s dramatic Champions League comeback against AS Roma.Your daily fix of football news, every weekday at 4pm.Trusted insight, lively debate, watchalongs and instant reactions to the biggest stories in the game, from some of football’s biggest names.Brought to you by The Overlap.Follow us on social - https://linktr.ee/overlapdaily0:00 - Intro3:20 - League of Their Own memories and on-set injuries10:15 - Romesh on winning The Traitors22:40 - Falling in love with Arsenal and Ian Wright34:10 - The Traitors final: Bash, James Blunt and playing as a Faithful41:30 - One Less Thing: diving and feigning injury in football48:25 - Mark Goldbridge on Manchester United’s comeback and Carrick59:45 - I’m A Celebrity 2026: Wayne Rooney and jungle fears66:30 - Arteta, Arsenal’s title chances and the Invincibles XI1:22:50 - Man City’s charges, Scott Parker at West Ham and outro
  • 18. Carrick’s Tactics vs Roma, Dewsbury-Hall Deserves Call-Up, & City Will Bounce Back | Overlap Daily

    55:08||Season 1, Ep. 18
    Welcome to Overlap Daily brought to you by our title partner, SKY VEGAS.Joe Hart and Ashley Young discuss all the biggest talking points from an action-packed weekend of football on Overlap Daily.The pair look back at Newcastle United’s clash with Everton, assessing both sides’ performances and debating whether Everton have what it takes to secure European football this season.They also turn their attention to Manchester United’s upcoming match against Roma, with high praise for Donyell Malen and why he could be one to watch. Ashley reflects on why David Moyes’ time at Old Trafford did not work out, while the pair also discuss Aston Villa’s trip to the Nou Camp.They also share their admiration for Anthony Gordon and the impact he continues to make.Your daily fix of football news, every weekday at 4pm.Trusted insight, lively debate, watchalongs and instant reactions to the biggest stories in the game, from some of football’s biggest names.Brought to you by The Overlap.Follow us on social - https://linktr.ee/overlapdaily0:00 - Intro5:00 - Everton's Performance & Newcastle's Decline13:35 - David Moyes: Everton Return & Man United Tenure20:56 - Man United vs Roma: Gasperini's Press29:03 - Michael Carrick & On-Pitch Leadership39:47 - Brighton's Form & Man City42:38 - Barcelona vs Aston Villa, Anthony Gordon & Jude Bellingham
  • 17. Liverpool ROBBED, Brighton Are a Top Team & Martinez Purposely Self-Destructing? | Overlap Daily

    01:04:08||Season 1, Ep. 17
    Welcome to Overlap Daily brought to you by our title partners, SKY BET and SKY VEGAS.Steven Gerrard and Becky Ives discuss all the talking points from an action-packed weekend of Premier League football.The former Liverpool midfielder shares his thoughts on Arsenal’s win at Anfield, Lisandro Martínez’s red card against Chelsea, and Brighton’s impressive victory over Manchester City.Your daily fix of football news, every weekday at 4pm.Trusted insight, lively debate, watchalongs and instant reactions to the biggest stories in the game, from some of football’s biggest names.Brought to you by The Overlap.Follow us on social - https://linktr.ee/overlapdaily0:00 - Intro5:08 - Liverpool 0-1 Arsenal: Defensive Masterclass & VAR Penalty Row14:37 - Chelsea vs Man United: Lisandro Martinez Red Card & Carrick's Future27:39 - Brighton Beat Man City at the Etihad34:28 - Brentford & Bournemouth: The "B Teams" Flying High42:25 - Trouble at Forest and Sunderland: Glasner & Xhaka Speak Out49:20 - Aston Villa vs Fulham: A Game of Two Halves51:42 - Spurs vs Palace: Seated Goal, Williams-Barnett & Pierre Sage Under Pressure56:14 - Champions League Week: Barcelona vs Villa & Dirk Kuyt's Fenerbahce1:00:00 - Bellingham's 50 Goals & Would Trent Return to Liverpool?
  • 16. A Manager Can Fix a Club, Carra & Goldbridge are Friends & Liverpool for Title? | Overlap Daily

    56:31||Season 1, Ep. 16
    Join Jamie Carragher, Mark Goldbridge and Becky Ives for the latest episode of Overlap Daily!Carra and Mark put their rivalry aside and become friends.The team discuss Manchester United’s issues, whether Liverpool could be in the title race, and Carra’s disagreement with Aston Villa fans.Your daily fix of football news, every weekday at 4pm.Trusted insight, lively debate, watchalongs and instant reactions to the biggest stories in the game, from some of football’s biggest names.Brought to you by The Overlap.This episode is SPONSORED by ARNE.Visit https://arneclo.comThis episode contains PAID PRODUCT PLACEMENT from Huel.Visit http://huel.com/daily and use code “DAILY” for a special offer.0:00 - Intro5:09 - Can any manager fix Man United?12:05 - Bruno Fernandes "clear-the-air" talks and the Amazon documentary19:27 - Player power: Carragher on Roy Hodgson's time at Liverpool25:49 - Liverpool vs Arsenal preview, Iraola and predictions38:08 - Six of the Best: the biggest penalty howlers49:02 - Everton, the Grealish absence and Brighton's rise
  • 15. Duncan Ferguson Makes Becky Ives and Mark Crossley Cry in Most Chaotic Episode | Overlap Daily

    01:09:12||Season 1, Ep. 15
    Welcome to Overlap Daily, brought to you by our title partners, Sky Bet.Join Becky Ives, Mark Crossley, Duncan Ferguson & Mike Keegan for a chaotic episode as Dunc ropes in the whole of Glentoran FC to help him connect to the wi-fi.Mike Keegan is once again in the studio to deliver more news from Old Trafford, where problems seem to be ever developing.Also, Mark and Becky discuss the latest round of League Cup games, as well as looking back on some of Mark’s memories from back in the day.Your daily fix of football news, every weekday at 4pm.Trusted insight, lively debate, and instant reactions to the biggest stories in the game, from some of football’s biggest names.Brought to you by The Overlap.This episode is sponsored by Sky Bet.This episode contains PAID PRODUCT PLACEMENT from ARNE.Visit https://arneclo.comThis episode contains PAID PRODUCT PLACEMENT from Huel.Visit http://huel.com/daily and use code “DAILY” for a special offer.0:00 - Intro9:11 - Max Dowman's red card and what Arteta said14:48 - Stutter penalties: striker vs goalkeeper18:34 - Everton vs Newcastle and a Fleetwood quarter-final22:31 - Games Gone, Games Back29:17 - Carabao Cup shootouts: Liverpool, Chelsea and goalkeepers44:05 - Fleetwood's giant-killing and Crossley's Oldham upset at Everton47:53 - Manchester United and the Carrick crisis with Mike Keegan58:04 - Nottingham Forest and the weekend preview
  • 14. Max Dowman's Red, Arteta's Mistake & Goldbridge & Harry Redknapp on United's Issues | Overlap Daily

    57:32||Season 1, Ep. 14
    Welcome to Overlap Daily, brought to you by our title partners, Sky Vegas.Join Jamie Redknapp, Tim Sherwood, Harry Redknapp & Mark Goldbridge as they take a look at Arsenal’s shock defeat to Fleetwood Town last night, as well as discussing Max Dowman’s sending off.Also, Mark is interrupted as news about Michael Carrick breaks, so he and the lads give their immediate reactions.And of course, there’s brilliant stories from Harry’s time as a coach, as well as his and Tim’s reactions to being mentioned in Harry Kane’s Ballon D’or acceptance speech.Your daily fix of football news, every weekday at 4pm.Trusted insight, lively debate, and instant reactions to the biggest stories in the game, from some of football’s biggest names.Brought to you by The Overlap.This episode is sponsored by Sky Vegas.This episode contains PAID PRODUCT PLACEMENT from ARNE.Visit https://arneclo.comThis episode is SPONSORED by Huel.Visit http://huel.com/daily and use code “DAILY” for a special offer.0:00 – Intro3:39 – Fleetwood knock Arsenal out of the Carabao Cup15:12 – Harry Kane wins the Ballon d'Or24:29 – Mark Goldbridge on Carrick, Bruno and Man United's owners39:38 – Should Carrick have played Bruno? The case for Unai Emery43:52 – The mystery player who threatened an own goal, and De Zerbi's Spurs51:00 – The best players Harry never signed, and Bale's hat-trick at the San Siro
  • 13. Kane's Incredible Journey, Schmeichel's Interview With United & Sympathy for Carrick | Overlap Daily

    01:15:15||Season 1, Ep. 13
    Welcome to Overlap Daily, brought to you by our title partners, Sky Vegas.Join Kelly Cates, Ashley Young & Peter Schmeichel as they react to Harry Kane winning the Ballon d'Or, and Kelly hosts a therapy session as Ashley and Peter let out their frustrations regarding Manchester United.Also, Peter Schmeichel reveals what happened when he went for an interview at his old club, and how it left him feeling irritated.Your daily fix of football news, every weekday at 4pm.Trusted insight, lively debate, and instant reactions to the biggest stories in the game, from some of football’s biggest names.Brought to you by The Overlap.This episode is sponsored by Sky Vegas.This episode contains paid product placement from ARNE.Visit https://arneclo.comThis episode contains paid product placement from Huel.Visit http://huel.com/daily and use code “DAILY” for a special offer.0:00 – Intro1:50 – Harry Kane Wins the Ballon d'Or11:03 – Did Kane Deserve It? Mbappé, Yamal and the Stats Debate19:12 – Kane's Leicester Loan and Why Hard Work Pays23:25 – Halloween Special: Phobias and Sir Alex Costumes27:59 – Ten Hag and Man United's Transfer Mistakes31:28 – Fixing Man United: Culture, Leadership and the Arteta and Emery Models50:11 – Bruno Fernandes and What It Means to Be Captain
  • 12. Manchester United Are at Rock Bottom & The Players Don't Respect Michael Carrick | Overlap Daily

    59:07||Season 1, Ep. 12
    Welcome to Overlap Daily, brought to you by our title partners, Sky Bet.Join Steven Gerrard, Becky Ives, Mark Goldbridge & Mike Keegan as they discuss the ever-deepening woes of Manchester United, Michael Carrick’s fate, and who’s to blame for all the problems at Old Trafford.Mike Keegan joins Stevie and Becky in the studio to give his insight into what’s happening at Carrington today, and Mark Goldbridge joins to give his unfiltered thoughts.Also, Stevie and Becky review this past weekend’s Premier League action, looking at Aston Villa’s brilliant victory over league leaders Manchester City, Liverpool knocking Brighton off their stride, and Spurs’ dominant display at Stamford Bridge.Your daily fix of football news, every weekday at 4pm.Trusted insight, lively debate, and instant reactions to the biggest stories in the game, from some of football’s biggest names.Brought to you by The Overlap.This episode is sponsored by Sky Bet and Sky Vegas.This episode is sponsored by ARNEVisit https://arneclo.comThis episode contains paid product placement from Huel.Visit http://huel.com/daily and use code “DAILY” for a special offer.0:00 – Intro5:31 – Man United 0-3 Bournemouth: Bournemouth's dream week8:05 – What are Man United now? Problems from top to bottom16:43 – Going through the United squad: why it needs a complete reset20:53 – Mark Goldbridge joins: INEOS, the board and the new stadium33:10 – Mike Keegan reports from Old Trafford: "a broken club"41:47 – Liverpool 2-0 Brighton: Iraola's impact, Barcola, Isak and Wirtz48:10 – Spurs beat Chelsea: De Zerbi impresses, and where was Welbeck?52:11 – Aston Villa beat Man City: Donnarumma's mistakes and Nicolas Jackson
  • 11. Goldbridge Goes in on the Glazers & Joe Hart's Man City Memories Won't be Erased | Overlap Daily

    58:12||Season 1, Ep. 11
    Welcome to Overlap Daily, brought to you by our title partners, Sky Bet.Join Mark Goldbridge and Joe Hart as they look ahead to an exciting weekend of football, chat Manchester rivalry, and discuss the latest news in football.After a well-earned holiday Mark is back in the studio, discussing the major problems at Manchester United, as well as asking Joe about his feelings on his memories from his time at Manchester City.Six of the Best with Super Six returns, as the lads try to pick the six greatest long-range Premier League goals of all time!Your daily fix of football news, every weekday at 4pm.Trusted insight, lively debate, and instant reactions to the biggest stories in the game, from some of football’s biggest names.Brought to you by The Overlap.This episode is sponsored by Sky Bet.This episode contains paid product placement from Huel.Visit http://huel.com/daily and use code “DAILY” for a special offer.This episode is sponsored by ARNEVisit https://arneclo.com0:00 - Intro2:57 - Man City's charges and the Premier League's integrity8:19 - Man United's crisis and Michael Carrick's future17:10 - Who should replace Carrick? Nagelsmann, Conte or Howe21:32 - United's ownership problem23:38 - Ranking classic goalkeeper kits29:19 - David Raya and the state of English goalkeeping37:04 - Weekend predictions: Liverpool v Brighton, Villa v City, Chelsea v Spurs52:34 - Six of the Best: goals from the halfway line58:44 - The Ballon d'Or debate and Harry Kane