Share

cover art for A Star Is Born (Josh's Version)

The Nightly

A Star Is Born (Josh's Version)

Josh Gondelman and Jacquis Neal attempt to retell A Star Is Born (2018) from memory—no notes, no fact-checking, just vibes.


What You'll Hear:


Do You Remember?: Josh walks us through Bradley Cooper’s country crooner era, Lady Gaga’s meteoric rise, and the slow unraveling in between. There are Grammys, billboards, and at least one moment that makes you want to hide behind the couch.


Pillow Fort Problems: Before the heartbreak, the insults get oddly specific. May your pillow always be warm. May a bald eagle with insomnia perch outside your window. Sweet dreams.


Festival Feelings: A love letter to San Francisco, its aggressively vertical streets, and the kind of comedy festival that feels like a reunion. Plus, a pitch for the coziest live show imaginable.


CHAPTERS

00:00 Intro & pillow fort check-in

00:40 Sleep-based insults escalate

01:41 San Francisco plans & city vibes

03:15 Smushing the hills & festival memories

05:12 The dream of a live sleep show

06:11 Do You Remember begins

09:00 Falling in love & Shallow takes off

13:02 Pop pivot, Grammys, and the unraveling

For the fully immersive, phone free light + sound experience, learn more at hatch.co. Follow us on TikTok @hatchpodcasts and YouTube.

More episodes

View all episodes

  • Band of Brothers & More Padel Peddling

    26:55|
    Matt Bragg and KP Parker swap new hobbies, old sports, and the kinds of books that keep you up just a little too late.What You’ll HearPadel Fever Continues: Matt explains his new favorite sport, complete with glass walls, mild chaos, and a business idea that got scooped just a little too fast.Reading Routines & Big Books: From audiobooks in the car to 700-page thrift store finds, they compare notes on what makes a story stick (and when it might be okay to quit).Historical Fiction & Comfort TV: A cozy wander through castles, Band of Brothers, and Friday Night Lights—with a quick detour into Matt’s brief moment as a background actor in Masters of the Air.CHAPTERS00:00 Intro & greetings00:30 Matt continues to obsess over padel03:00 Matt's padel business idea07:30 What they’re reading now14:00 Why historical fiction works16:00 Matt’s Masters of the Air cameo18:30 Friday Night Lights talk21:30 Goodnights
  • It's Time to Join a Model Airplane Club

    26:25|
    Matt Bragg and KP Parker catch up on a camping trip that leads to an unexpected fascination with model airplanes.What You’ll HearCamping meets model planes: KP’s latest trip blends campfire hangs and no-phone time with an unexpected highlight: waking up to a model airplane club and discovering a hobby that’s equal parts charming and accessible.Streaks, steps, and language learning: From daily step counts to app-driven motivation, they compare the small systems that keep habits going—and what happens when real life tests them.A very gentle World Cup primer: KP gets a crash course in soccer (football!) basics from Matt, from how teams are formed to who actually wins, with just enough detail to (maybe) make it stick.CHAPTERS00:00 Intro & camping recap01:00 Model airplane club discovery04:00 The cost and charm of niche hobbies06:00 Why camping helps you unplug08:00 Matt's caravan fantasy10:00 Streaks, steps, and motivation13:00 KP's World Cup curiosity17:00 Soccer basics (kind of)20:00 Steps, SpongeBob, and goodnights
  • Titanic Obsessions & Delightful Detergent

    22:54|
    Josh Gondelman and Wils Pelton wander from springtime joy to deep-sea curiosities and the perfect-smelling laundry.What You’ll HearSpring Fever, City Edition: The quiet magic of warmer days, blooming trees, and why every city suddenly feels like the best one on earth.The Titanic Question: A surprisingly passionate look at shipwreck fascination, space trips, and the kinds of obsessions we carry from childhood into adulthood.Laundry That Changes Your Life: A simple scent turns into an unexpectedly soothing ritual—and a gentle, sleepy sendoff.CHAPTERS00:00 Intro & greetings02:30 Stockholm ships & Titanic fascination07:30 Space trips & cultural obsessions08:30 Teenage internet deep dives10:50 The life cycle of a favorite t-shirt14:30 Maps, the Roman Empire & niche interests16:30 The best-smelling laundry discovery18:30 Ocean mist wind-down
  • Becoming a Writer & Comedy Influences

    22:59|
    Josh Gondelman and Wils Pelton trace the sometimes late-blooming path to becoming a writer and comedian.What You’ll Hear:Origin Stories: From Goosebumps-inspired childhood fiction to award-winning high school plays, Josh and Wils revisit the early moments that made writing feel possible.Comedy as a Calling: A shared love of standup, sitcoms, and joke books turns into something more serious—figuring out how to make a creative life actually work.Timing, Practice, and Patience: On being ready when the moment comes, improving little by little, and why the things you want might arrive five years later than planned.CHAPTERS00:00 Intro & greetings01:30 Childhood stories & first sparks03:50 Starting standup and finding direction05:20 Comedy influences and early obsessions06:20 Interview books and learning the craft10:00 Preparation meets opportunity11:30 The five-year delay mantra13:20 Free throws, tap dancing, and practice
  • Baby Showers, Boston & Bieberchella

    24:33|
    Josh Gondelman and Wils Pelton catch up on baby showers, Boston weekends, and a surprisingly tender take on Coachella.What You’ll HearA Weekend Close to Home: Josh shares the quiet joy of a baby shower and small, meaningful moments, while Wils reflects on their visit to Boston and the art of finding charm in a city you love... to critique.The Great AC Debate: From fans versus air conditioners to the realities of summer heat, they swap survival strategies—and consider how far they can push the season before giving in.Coachella, But Make It Personal: A listener question opens the door to Justin Bieber’s unconventional Week 1 performance, internet reactions, and a softer conversation about fame, expectations, and letting artists evolve on their own terms.CHAPTERS00:00 Intro & new nightly rhythm01:00 Baby showers and Boston trips03:00 Spring weather and New England nostalgia06:00 AC units, fans, and summer survival10:00 Coachella weekend one highlights11:30 Justin Bieber’s performance breakdown15:30 Pop star expectations and performance styles19:00 Goodnights and dreamy festival lineups
  • The Need For Fresh Air & One Giant Leap

    31:26|
    KP Parker and Matt Bragg drift from breezy beach towns to the vast, slightly confusing wonders of the moon.What You'll HearFresh Air, Open Windows: A conversation that starts seaside—gray skies, eccentric neighbors, and the quiet magic of letting the night air in. Camping vs. Matt’s Mattress: KP prepares for a night under the stars while Matt makes a strong case for indoor living. Somewhere between them: heating pads, survival gear, and the eternal question of how much comfort is too much?Moon Math & Space Myths: From Apollo 11 to Artemis II, the facts get a little fuzzy—but the curiosity is real. CHAPTERS00:00 Intro & beach town daydreams03:00 Fresh air, heating pads, and cozy debates08:30 Camping plans and comfort limits09:00 The moon, distance, and space confusion13:30 Apollo 11 and the space race17:30 What the moon smells like19:00 Craters, names, and final thoughts
  • Jonathan the Tortoise & Binky the Cat

    28:23|
    Matt Bragg and KP Parker swap stories about thrifted band tees, very patient animals, and the strange corners of the internet.What You'll Hear:Vintage Finds, Lingering Regrets: A thrifted Elton John shirt sparks a conversation about concert merch, missed chances, and why the perfect T-shirt always seems to get away.Animal News, Gently Unbelievable: A 193-year-old tortoise survives a crypto scam rumor, and a missing cat turns up 200 miles away a decade later—proof that animals have better plot lines than most of us.CHAPTERS00:00 Intro & greetings00:30 Gym errands & Elton John tee03:00 The t-shirt that got away07:30 Tortoise crypto scam explained13:20 Missing cat found after 10 years18:00 Cat sneezes & goodnights
  • Passive Aggressive Cats & SPF For All

    20:27|
    KP Parker and Matt Bragg air a few modern grievances, from mischievous pets to unexpectedly loud technology.What You’ll Hear:Pet Politics: A newly adopted cat becomes an unlikely messenger for passive-aggressive commentary, raising questions about loyalty, love, and who the cat really prefers.Too Loud to Be Relaxing: A well-meaning TV feature turns into a nightly jump scare, as peaceful nature sounds arrive at full volume and entirely the wrong moment.Small Fixes, Big Dreams: From bringing back old-school screensavers to sneaking SPF into everyday products, the solutions are simple, slightly nostalgic, and oddly satisfying.CHAPTERS00:00 Intro & greetings03:30 Matt’s cat grievance begins05:00 Passive-aggressive cat commentary09:00 KP’s TV nature sound grievance12:00 Screensavers and nostalgic tech16:00 Sunscreen in everything debate19:00 Wrapping up and goodnight
  • Costco, Lena Dunham & Coach the Dragon Slayer

    23:00|
    KP Parker and Matt Bragg discuss everything from Costco hauls to cult leaders of reality TV.Bulk Buy Bliss: Matt reports on his first-ever Costco trip, complete with impulsive purchases, life-changing appliances, and the strange joy of buying in bulk. Fame, Friendship, and Fallout: A peek into Lena Dunham’s new memoir sparks a conversation about well, Lena Dunham...and who she is. Enter the Dragon Slayer: KP introduces Matt to one of Survivor’s most unforgettable characters—a man equal parts philosopher, leader, and chaos agent—and they wonder what makes someone compelling, even when they’re "a lot."CHAPTERS00:00 Intro & greetings02:15 Naming Matt's company04:15 Matt has discovered Costco09:05 Lena Dunham memoir moment15:40 Meet the Dragon Slayer21:25 Goodnights & sign-off