Share

cover art for Goodnight, Attic Critters w/ Amanda Montell

The Nightly

Goodnight, Attic Critters w/ Amanda Montell

Amanda Montell hosts The Nightly this week and takes a call from Chris in Evanston, Illinois, who has some nighttime visitors he can't quite identify.
What You'll Hear
A very good neighborhood mystery: Amanda opens with a story about an unfamiliar Bengal cat that turned up in her yard, and the low-stakes debate over who gets to keep him.
Something's living in the attic: Chris has been hearing rustling at night from an unfinished corner of his attic, and he's torn on whether to call it in.
Raccoons, squirrels, or something friendlier: Amanda and Chris work through the likely suspects, plus a detour into ghosts, and land on the idea that a "haunting" isn't always a bad thing.
CHAPTERS
00:00 Amanda opens the show and shares a stray cat story
03:49 Chris calls in from Evanston, Illinois
04:21 Noises in the attic
10:53 A question about ghosts
15:17 Other wildlife in the neighborhood

For the fully immersive, phone free light + sound experience, learn more at hatch.co. Follow us on TikTok @hatchpodcasts and YouTube.

More episodes

View all episodes

  • Meet Dad, Hold the Clothes

    21:27|
    Josh Gondelman flies solo tonight and fields a call about love, Iceland, and the horror-slash-honor of being naked in front of your girlfriend's dad.What You'll HearUncle life, unlocked: Josh reports back from a weekend babysitting his best friend's five-year-old, and reaches a conclusion: the uncle life may be the whole life.A confession and a crisis: Caller Andi shares big romantic news, then drops the real issue — introducing her new boyfriend to Iceland's beloved, and extremely nude, bathhouse culture.A two-pronged, pants-optional plan: Josh and Andi build a strategy for easing her boyfriend into the family swim, one staggered arrival and one barefoot hangout at a time.CHAPTERS00:00 Intro + the uncle life is calling02:46 Caller Andi joins the show04:00 The big news: Andi's in love!04:15 The question: how to be nude with the in-laws?04:39 Icelandic bathing culture, explained05:44 The dilemma: meeting dad in the buff06:44 A "new and nude" relationship07:35 Priming the pump for the big reveal09:29 Josh's two-pronged plan12:24 The nude test run13:11 Andi maps out the meeting15:51 Goodnights and sign-off
  • Too Much and Too Little Clothing w/ Amanda Montell

    22:59|
    Amanda Montell talks with caller Janine about closet space and wardrobe habits.What You'll HearSleepy time toothpaste, a product that doesn't exist yet: Amanda pitches an idea she's held onto for years—a toothpaste line in bedtime flavors like chamomile and lavender, meant to avoid the alertness that comes with mint before bed.The closet space contradiction: Janine describes living in a 100-year-old house with minimal closet space and rotating her wardrobe by season. She feels she owns too many clothes and not enough at once, and struggles to part with sentimental pieces like concert T-shirts.Clothing swaps, thrift shops, and a rule for keeping clothes: Amanda describes hosting clothing swap brunches and her personal rule for what stays in her closet—she keeps only what she can picture owning. Both discuss rental subscriptions, thrift shopping, and borrowing shoes from friends instead of buying new.Tiny Jewelry Life and the pieces that matter: Janine explains her preference for small, minimal jewelry. The two compare heirloom pieces—Amanda's grandmother's garnet ring, repurposed as an engagement ring, and Janine's engagement band, set with diamonds from her husband's grandmother's watch.**CHAPTERS**00:00 Intro & greetings03:00 Janine calls in from New York05:23 Capsule wardrobes and minimalism08:10 Impulse buying and feeling like you have nothing to wear10:55 Tiny Jewelry Life philosophy14:52 Amanda's wildfire evacuation story17:07 Passing shoes on instead of donating
  • Trader Joe's Friends w/ Amanda Montell

    19:53|
    Amanda Montell and caller Katie celebrate the small moments of connection that can happen in the grocery store, from friendly checkout conversations to the surprising comfort of a familiar neighborhood market.What You’ll HearThe Checkout Line as Community: Katie shares how quick chats with grocery store cashiers—especially at Trader Joe’s—have become bright spots in her week, filled with kindness, recommendations, and genuine human connection.A Love Letter to Grocery Stores: Amanda and Katie compare favorite stores, swap stories about memorable customer service, and reflect on why simple acts of friendliness can leave a lasting impression.A Shared Taste of Home: An unexpected discovery that they both grew up near Baltimore leads to a nostalgic conversation about beloved local grocery stores, Utz chips, Old Bay, and the foods that instantly transport us back home.CHAPTERS00:00 Amanda's late-night YouTube rabbit hole06:06 Trader Joe's acts of kindness08:03 Cashiers, self-checkout, and community11:18 Discovering a shared Baltimore connection13:00 Grocery store nostalgia and hometown favorites
  • Was My Choir A Cult? w/ Amanda Montell

    22:23|
    Amanda Montell and caller Matt unpack the surprisingly blurry line between belonging and blind devotion, reflecting on a high school show choir that sometimes felt a little... cultish.What You’ll HearThe Charisma Factor: Matt revisits the magnetic show choir director who inspired fierce loyalty, unforgettable performances, and a few lingering questions about leadership and influence.Rituals, Rivalries, and Red Flags: From pre-show traditions to intense competition and an "us versus them" mindset, Amanda explores how ordinary groups can take on surprisingly cult-like dynamics.Finding Community Without Losing Yourself: Together they consider why close-knit groups can shape us for the better—and how to recognize the difference between healthy belonging and unhealthy control.CHAPTERS00:00 Amanda's sleep simplicity journey03:00 Was high school show choir a cult?09:48 Rituals that built belonging12:35 Competition and us versus them16:41 Amanda's cult rating
  • Sunday Edition: Inventing Mascots

    29:04|
    In this Sunday Edition of The Nightly, Josh Gondelman welcomes mascot designer Tom Sapp into the pillow fort for a behind-the-scenes look at the surprising art, strategy, and heart behind the characters we cheer for.What You'll HearFrom Sketchbook to Stadium: Tom shares how a career in advertising unexpectedly led him to designing iconic mascots for sports teams, schools, hospitals, and beyond—and why every great mascot starts with understanding the people it's meant to delight.More Than a Costume: From Rocky the Mountain Lion's lightning-bolt tail to comforting characters for children's hospitals, Tom explains how storytelling, thoughtful design, and unforgettable performers work together to create characters that people truly believe in.Why Kids Know Best: Josh and Tom explore the surprisingly emotional side of mascot design, why honest audience reactions matter, and the creative freedom that comes from letting ideas wander before they take shape.CHAPTERS00:00 Intro & welcoming Tom Sapp!01:19 How Tom's career in mascot design began05:06 Designing characters with purpose08:00 The origin story of Rocky the Mountain Lion12:00 Building mascot backstories & creative process14:15 Designing for children's hospitals17:08 Testing ideas with real audiences18:47 The magic of seeing mascots come alive21:00 The challenge of designing for brands and products22:39 Ending with some advice for creatives24:14 Goodnights
  • Benidorm: A Cartoonish Facsimile of Home

    25:21|
    Josh Gondelman and Matt Bragg swap vacation stories, travel quirks, and the bittersweet feeling of being so right.What You'll HearThe world's shortest victory lap: Matt wins a disagreement over a glass coffee cup...but it was probably not for the best. It's a triumph that comes with a broom.A tour of Benidorm: Matt introduces Josh to England's favorite seaside escape in Spain, where belly-busting breakfasts, poolside beers, and familiar pubs create a vacation destination unlike any other.Places that feel strangely familiar: From movie locations and famous song lyrics to grumpy train announcements and vacation nostalgia, they explore why some places feel iconic long before you ever visit.CHAPTERS00:00 Intro & greetings00:30 Matt's coffee cup disaster03:40 Plastic cups, microplastics & Bovril07:40 Pool beers and vacation mode08:45 Why Benidorm is basically England in Spain12:30 Movie locations and famous landmarks14:45 Songs that make places feel familiar17:15 Vacation expectations vs. real life19:05 Public transit personalities & customer service21:10 Good nights
  • Best Sports Mascots

    29:34|
    Josh Gondelman and Caller Haley tumble down a delightfully sleepy rabbit hole about sports mascots, hometown pride, and the creatures that somehow end up representing entire teams.What You’ll Hear:A Love Letter to Austin: Haley shares her favorite parts of life in Austin, from year-round swims at Barton Springs to dancing the night away with live music.Mascots, Explained... Sort Of: A simple question sparks a surprisingly deep conversation about coyotes, billy goats, elephants, banana slugs, and why team mascots rarely seem to match the team name.Dream Team Draft: Josh and Haley imagine the mascots they’d create from scratch, proving that armadillos and great blue herons deserve a little more time in the spotlight.CHAPTERS00:00 Intro & a memorable night of comedy06:00 Haley calls in from Austin07:30 Barton Springs, swimming, and live music11:20 The question that keeps Haley up at night12:00 Sports mascots and hometown team names13:00 Ellie the Elephant and favorite mascots14:10 The Banana Slugs of UC Santa Cruz15:30 Designing a mascot from scratch18:00 The legend of the King Cake Baby22:45 Goodnights to mascots everywhere
  • Life In A Big Family w/ Kristen Meinzer

    22:48|
    Kristen Meinzer talks to a caller about the laughter, traditions, and lifelong bonds that come with growing up in a big family.What You’ll HearThe House That Never Felt Empty: Peggy shares joyful memories of six siblings, station wagon road trips, backyard games, and family traditions that turned everyday moments into lasting stories.Growing Older Together: The conversation explores how big families evolve over time—from caring for aging parents to creating a support system that lasts long after childhood.Why Family Traditions Matter: Kristen and Peggy reflect on the rituals, inside jokes, and shared history that give families a unique culture, no matter their size.CHAPTERS00:00 Intro & themed fan cruises04:18 Growing up in a family of six kids09:15 A support system that lasts a lifetime14:24 Learning self-reliance and sharing16:07 Kristen's blended family story