Share

cover art for Rational Security: The “Happy FrAIday” Edition

The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition

Rational Security: The “Happy FrAIday” Edition

•

This week, Scott sat down with his Lawfare colleagues Kevin Frazier, Roger Parloff, and Molly Roberts to talk through some of the week’s big news in AI, including:

  • “Citizen Cain’t.” When the NAACP sued Elon Musk’s xAI under the Clean Air Act—alleging that the company built dozens of gas-fired turbines to power a data center in Mississippi without relevant air permits and exposing nearby, predominantly Black communities to harmful pollution—the Justice Department opted to do something it has never done before: it intervened in a citizen suit against a private company in order to kill it. DOJ’s motion offers two theories: first, that shutting down the turbines would threaten national security because the military relies on xAI’s Grok Gov model (including in relation to the Iran war) to secure the nation, and second, that the Constitution’s vesting of executive power in the president means private citizens cannot enforce federal law over the executive’s objection. How strong are these arguments? And what would it mean for environmental and other citizen-enforcement suits if DOJ were to prevail?
  • “Grok the Vote.” We may be living through the first true “AI elections.” In Manhattan’s NY-12 Democratic primary, more than $40 million in AI-industry and AI-safety money turned a little-known assemblyman, Alex Bores, into something of a national referendum on whether voters care about AI regulation and AI safety—though Bores ultimately lost to Micah Lasher this week. Meanwhile, overseas in Malaysia, parties are using chatbots and other AI-driven technologies to reach out to voters in new and novel ways. And just this week in Washington, a new study has concluded that frontier AI is perhaps more persuasive than ever, but also may not be as politically neutral as some suspect or one might hope. What does this all mean for democratic politics when both money and the messaging involved in our politics are increasingly shaped by AI?
  • “Kill, Kill Switch, Kill, Kill!” The government's frontier-AI "kill switch" is now ready to have its first day in court. If you recall, a few weeks ago, the Commerce Department's Bureau of Industry and Security sent Anthropic an "Is Informed" letter ordering it to suspend all access to its Fable 5 and Mythos 5 models for any foreign nationals, including its own employees. This ultimately led Anthropic to pull access to those models for everyone within hours. But this past Monday, June 22, a technology startup called Legion LegalTech filed a lawsuit against the U.S. government alleging that it has acted in a way that is unlawful and raises a number of statutory and constitutional concerns. How strong is the legal challenge, and what does it tell us about whether courts—rather than the executive—will end up defining the government's power to switch a frontier model on and off?

In object lessons, Molly sticks to the script for this week’s episode with her call-out of Erik Nitsche’s “Atoms for Peace” poster series for General Dynamics. Also inspired by this week’s theme, Kevin dives into some “light summer reading” about technology, globalization, and the law with “Rules for a Flat World,” by Gillian Hadfield. Roger, similarly, is “unwinding” with “The Winter Warriors,” by Olivier Norek, a novel about the lesser-known David vs. Goliath story of Finland taking on the Soviet Union in 1939. And Scott says enough already! He’s headed on vacation next week, and so is Rational Security. We’ll be back with a new episode and a rejuvenated Scott on July 9.

More episodes

View all episodes

  • Lawfare Daily: Attempted Assassination of Pope John Paul II During the Cold War, with Serhii Plokhy

    48:40|
    Lawfare Contributing Editor Mykhailo Soldatenko sits down with Harvard History Professor Serhii Plokhy to discuss his new book, "Killing the Pope," which tells the history of an attempted assassination of Pope John Paul II during the Cold War and related investigations, trials, and propaganda battles. The book also explores who was behind the assassination, including whether there are any signs of security services or organized crime involvement.
  • Lawfare Live: The Trials of the Trump Administration, November 13

    01:39:33|
    In a conversation on YouTube, Lawfare Editor in Chief Benjamin Wittes will sit down with Senior Editors Molly Roberts, Roger Parloff, Anna Bower, and Eric Columbus to discuss the latest litigation over Trump administration policies, including updates on the East Potomac golf course and the triumphal arch cases, the politicization of the Justice Department, a judge’s rejection of the BBC’s motion to dismiss Trump’s defamation suit, the Fourth Circuit’s ruling blocking a DOJ demand for journalists’ LinkedIn data, the D.C. Circuit’s decision protecting U.S. Agency for Global Media head Michael Abramowitz from removal, an immigration roundup, and more.You can find information on legal challenges to Trump administration actions here. And check out Lawfare’s new homepage on the litigation, new Bluesky account, and new WITOAD merch.To receive ad-free podcasts, become a Lawfare Material Supporter at www.patreon.com/lawfare. You can also support Lawfare by making a one-time donation at https://givebutter.com/lawfare-institute.
  • Lawfare Archive: Spy Writing in the Real World

    44:47|
    From April 21, 2021: Last week for the Michael V. Hayden Center for Intelligence, Policy, and International Security at George Mason University's Schar School of Policy and Government, David Priess moderated a virtual event called, "Spy Writing in the Real World." The event featured three authors of espionage fiction, two with previous experience working inside the U.S. intelligence community: Brad Thor, the #1 New York Times bestselling author of 21 thrillers; Karen Cleveland, a former CIA analyst and New York Times bestselling author of "Need to Know" and "Keep You Close"; and award-winning author and former NSA and CIA officer Alma Katsu, who had written five novels prior to her first new spy novel, "Red Widow." They talked about the spy thriller genre, their challenges within it, their research and their experience with prepublication classification review.To receive ad-free podcasts, become a Lawfare Material Supporter at www.patreon.com/lawfare. You can also support Lawfare by making a one-time donation at https://givebutter.com/lawfare-institute.
  • Lawfare Archive: Keith Whittington on the Law, Politics, and Purpose of the Impeachment Power

    47:30|
    From November 12, 2024: Jack Goldsmith sits down with Keith Whittington, David Boies Professor of Law at Yale Law School, to discuss his new book, “The Impeachment Power: The Law, Politics, and Purpose of an Extraordinary Constitutional Tool.”They discuss what the Constitution says about the impeachment power, how we should think about high crimes and misdemeanors, why impeachment shows that Congress is the preeminent branch of government, and the goals and values of impeachment. They also discuss the abuse of the impeachment power given current politics and what can be done about it, as well as whether Trump should have been convicted and disqualified in the second impeachment.
  • Rational Security: The “Nightmare on Pennsylvania Avenue” Edition

    01:25:34|
    This week, Scott sat down with his Lawfare colleagues Benjamin Wittes, Roger Parloff, and Julia Curlee to talk through the week’s big national security news stories, including: “Two Huangs Don’t Make a Right.” This past weekend, Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang admitted to an extramarital affair with Alice Huang, a former executive at a Singapore-based Nvidia customer whom U.S. intelligence has reportedly concluded was working for China’s Ministry of State Security—and whose company has been scrutinized for allegedly funneling Nvidia chips to China in violation of U.S. export controls. Nvidia’s board has launched an independent investigation, the FBI is reportedly looking into the matter, and incoming Democratic majorities are promising congressional inquiries. But the scandal is also raising hard questions for the White House, as reporting now indicates that President Trump was warned about the relationship before personally inviting Huang along on his May trip to Beijing—all while Huang was pressing the administration to loosen restrictions on chip sales to China. What does this mean for Nvidia, for U.S. export control policies, and for the AI industry that Nvidia’s chips play an indispensable part in? “Massie Destruction.” This week, lame-duck Republican Rep. Thomas Massie forced the House forced a vote on eight articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, accusing him of waging an unlawful war in Iran, pursuing extrajudicial killings through the administration’s ongoing boat strikes, and “kidnapping” Nicolás Maduro, among other charges. House Republicans rallied to successfully kill the measure through a procedural vote on Tuesday evening, but both Massie and House Democrats have suggested this might not be the last we see of this effort. Is impeachment the right tool for holding Hegseth—and the administration—accountable? And what does this effort foreshadow for the next Congress?“Arch Nemesis.” Last Thursday, the National Capital Planning Commission—chaired by a White House official and stacked with Trump appointees—voted 8-4 to give final approval to President Trump’s 250-foot “triumphal arch,” which is to be located between the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington National Cemetery and has been framed as an object central to the military defense of Washington, D.C. But barely an hour later, Judge Tanya Chutkan issued a temporary restraining order blocking construction, finding that D.C. and Virginia—who have both sued to stop the project—are likely to succeed in arguing that it requires congressional authorization under the Commemorative Works Act. Will Trump’s monument to American greatness—or, by his own account, to himself—ever get built? And what does this fight tell us about the limits on the president’s ability to remake the nation’s capital?In object lessons, Julia pulls out an old lesson on the psychology of military incompetence. Roger takes a stroll through the history of Foggy Bottom. Scott calls out an instant children’s classic that really gets kids cooking. And Ben regrets how he answered the conundrum of whether to walk to Lichtenstein. Plus, stay tuned for a bonus object lesson from producer Noam!
  • Lawfare Daily: Aya Ibrahim on Progressive Priorities for the New Democratic Congress

    01:07:52|
    Aya Ibrahim is a rising progressive thought leader and advocate in Democratic national security and economic circles. Aya is currently a Senior Fellow at the AI Now Institute, where she focuses on AI's impacts on national security. She previously worked in government on Capitol Hill, where she served as Rep. Ayanna Pressley's (D-Mass.) senior economic adviser, and in the Executive Branch. In the Biden Administration, Aya served on the National Economic Council, at the Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP), where she was the lead author of the Administration's "Blueprint for an AI Bill of Rights," and on the State Department's Policy Planning Staff. Aya joins Lawfare Contributing Editor and host of the Security Economics podcast Peter Harrell to talk about a progressive agenda for the next Congress, about AI regulation, and about U.S.-China policy. Aya and Peter also look back at things that the Biden Administration got right—and wrong—about U.S.-China competition, and they close by talking about how to balance security economics with the domestic economy. This episode is part of the Security Economics podcast series, in which Peter Harrell and guests explore the intersection of economics and national security, how countries manage their economies to support national security, and how they deploy economic tools in support of geopolitical objectives.
  • Lawfare Daily: ‘The Russian General Staff’ with Oscar Jonsson

    46:31|
    Oscar Jonsson, author of the new book “The Russian General Staff,” and an associate senior lecturer at Swedish Defence University, joins Lawfare Contributing Editor Justin Sherman to discuss the origins and evolution of the Russian General Staff, its role in the early Putin system amid reforms and power consolidation, and the General Staff’s role (or lack thereof) in Russia’s initial invasion of Ukraine in 2014. They also discuss the General Staff’s nominal command of Russia’s military intelligence agency, the GRU; Russia’s full-scale 2022 war on Ukraine; Russia’s evolving lessons from the war and what the General Staff gets right and wrong about modern warfare; and the future of Russian military thought and planning.
  • Lawfare Archive: Congressional Oversight, Post-Trump

    46:12|
    From August 18, 2023: Listeners of this podcast are probably familiar with Molly Reynolds’s work on Congress. She’s a Senior Fellow at Brookings and a Senior Editor at Lawfare—and she has a new report out at Brookings, with Naomi Maehr, on “How partisan and policy dynamics shape congressional oversight in the post-Trump era.” Molly and her team have collected an enormous amount of data over the years about how Congress conducts oversight, and the report is a thought-provoking overview of what the legislature got up to during the 117th Congress. Today on the show, Lawfare Senior Editor Quinta Jurecic talked with Molly about her report and what patterns she’s found in oversight from the 116th Congress through today. For fans of the Jan. 6 Committee’s work, they also discussed that committee’s investigation and what it does and doesn’t tell us about congressional investigations going forward.
  • Lawfare Daily: Anthropic’s Safety Mission vs. Public-Company Pressure

    54:19|
    Kevin Frazier, Director of the AI Innovation and Law Program at the University of Texas School of Law and a senior editor at Lawfare, speaks with Roberto Tallarita, assistant professor at Harvard Law School, about Anthropic's recently filed s-1 and its experiment in corporate governance. They discuss its current status as a public benefit corporation, its decision to create and empower a body of financially disinterested trustees, and its current unique class structure. Drawing on Tallarita’s research on stakeholder governance and unequal voting rights, the two also discuss what would make a commitment to safety precautions durable even when in stark tension with profit.Tallarita lays out some of his thoughts on what could come next for Anthropic in his recent article “Profit and Mission in Anthropic’s IPO.” Frazier also has recently written an analysis of Anthropic’s post-IPO governance.