Share

cover art for Prior Authorization in Health Insurance: A Needed Tool to Contain Costs or an Excessive Barrier to Needed Care?

The Health Wonk Shop

Prior Authorization in Health Insurance: A Needed Tool to Contain Costs or an Excessive Barrier to Needed Care?

Season 1, Ep. 14

Nearly 1 in 5 consumers with health insurance say their insurer delayed or denied care in the past year due to its requirements for prior authorization, a process through which insurers can require patients to obtain approval in advance before they will agree to cover specific services.


Insurers point to prior authorization as a tool to limit unnecessary and ineffective care, thereby reducing costs. However, the practice is also drawing increased scrutiny amid concerns that it creates unreasonable barriers to patients getting needed care and generates excessive paperwork burdens on doctors and other providers. Last month, federal regulators finalized new rules to govern how insurers use prior authorization in Medicare Advantage, Medicaid, the Children’s Health Insurance Program, and the Affordable Care Act’s federal Marketplace plans, while lawmakers are weighing potential broader legislation.


On February 22, a panel of four experts joined Larry Levitt, KFF’s executive vice president for health policy, for a 45-minute discussion addressing the future of prior authorization requirements in health care. The panel discussed why insurers use prior authorization, its impact on patients and providers, and how the new regulations may change current practices. They also examined the potential for further regulatory or legislative actions to address ongoing concerns.


Moderator

  • Larry Levitt, Executive Vice President for Health Policy, KFF


Panelists

  • Troyen Brennan, MD, Adjunct Professor of Health Policy and Management, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, and a former executive at CVS Caremark and Aetna
  • Fumiko ChinoMD, Radiation Oncologist, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center
  • Anna Schwamlein Howard, Principal, Policy Development, American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network
  • Kaye Pestaina, Vice President and Director of the Program on Patient and Consumer Protection, KFF


More episodes

View all episodes

  • 15. Primary Care Check Up: Why It Can Be Hard to Get an Appointment and How to Fix It

    50:06
    A panel of primary-care experts joined Larry Levitt, KFF’s executive vice president for health policy, for a discussion on the current state of primary care in the country, including the extent of the shortage, how it varies geographically and for different populations, the impact on people’s health, and what can be done to address it.
  • 13. The Health Care Workforce Under Pressure: Strikes, Shortages, and Staffing Requirements

    48:34
    Amid low unemployment and rising demand for services, today’s health care workforce is under pressure from several directions, including worker strikes; shortages of trained staff; and proposed new staffing standards for nurses and aides in nursing facilities.On November 16, a panel of three experts joined Larry Levitt, executive vice president for health policy at KFF, for a 45-minute discussion focused on the diverse challenges facing the health care workforce. The conversation touched on why and where there are worker shortages, what is driving recent strikes, how these pressures affect health systems, and how the proposed new staffing requirements could affect nursing homes. The panel also explored differences in rural and urban settings, and how the pandemic and other factors have increased burnout among health care workers.ModeratorLarry Levitt, Executive Vice President for Health Policy, KFFPanelistsGretchen Berlin, Senior Partner, McKinsey & CompanyAlice Burns, Associate Director of the Program on Medicaid and the Uninsured, KFFBianca K. Frogner, Director of the University of Washington’s Center for Health Workforce Studies, and Professor in UW’s Department of Family MedicineKFF’s virtual Health Wonk Shop series features in-depth policy discussions with experts that go beyond the news headlines to provide greater insights.
  • 12. Probing the Legal Arguments in the Drug Industry’s Challenges to Medicare Drug Price Negotiations

    44:57
    With the Biden administration’s announcement of the first 10 drugs to be negotiated for Medicare as part of the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), an array of legal challenges from the pharmaceutical industry is potentially the biggest obstacle to implementation.In court filings, individual drugmakers and the industry’s main lobbying group contend that the negotiations process is unconstitutional in a variety of ways, from violating freedom of speech to unlawful government seizure and excessive fines. They also continue to argue, as they did in the debate over the IRA, that requiring companies to negotiate the prices of drugs with the government will impede the development of new drugs.On Tuesday, September 12, two legal experts and a health policy expert joined Larry Levitt, executive vice president for health policy at KFF, for a 45-minute discussion about the legal issues underpinning these lawsuits and how they intersect with the policy goals of the legislation. ModeratorLarry Levitt, Executive Vice President for Health Policy, KFFPanelistsZachary Baron, Associate Director, Health Policy and the Law Initiative at the O’Neill Institute for National and Global Health Law at Georgetown University.Tricia Neuman, Senior Vice President and Executive Director of the Program on Medicare Policy, KFFDan Troy, Managing Director, Berkeley Research Group KFF’s virtual Health Wonk Shop series features in-depth policy discussions with experts that go beyond the news headlines to provide greater insights.
  • 11. New Weight Loss Drugs Raise Issues of Coverage, Cost, Access and Equity

    45:20
    New weight loss drugs, such as Novo Nordisk’s Ozempic and Wegovy (semaglutide) and Eli Lilly’s Mounjaro (tirzepatide), could be transformative for people who struggle with obesity and obesity-related medical conditions, but there are major questions to consider related to insurance coverage, the cost of the drugs, and who has access.Importantly, by law, the drugs cannot be covered by Medicare for weight loss and are often covered now by private insurers in limited circumstances. Manufacturers of the drugs are lobbying for broad coverage by Medicare and other payers.On August 4, three experts joined Larry Levitt, executive vice president for health policy at KFF, for a 45-minute “Health Wonk Shop” discussion about the questions surrounding what a new generation of weight loss drugs means for patients and payers:Who could benefit most from the new weight loss drugs, and what are the barriers to accessing them?What would be the impact of Congress overturning the prohibition on Medicare covering weight loss drugs?How are employers and insurers approaching coverage of the drugs given the potentially substantial costs involved?What are the broader implications of the new drugs for U.S. obesity rates and for national health spending, including on obesity-related health conditions?ModeratorLarry Levitt, Executive Vice President for Health Policy, KFFPanelistsJuliette Cubanski, PhD, Deputy Director, Program on Medicare Policy at KFFShauna Levy, MD, MS, Assistant Professor, Division of MIS/Bariatric Surgery, Tulane University School of MedicineMichael Manolakis, PharmD, PhD, Senior Vice President, Pharmacy, Aon KFF’s virtual Health Wonk Shop series features in-depth policy discussions with experts that go beyond the news headlines to provide greater insights.
  • 10. Probing the Power and Practices of Pharmacy Benefit Managers

    44:28
    Pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) are increasingly scrutinized intermediaries in the U.S. health care system, negotiating discounts on prescription medications for health insurers and employers while collecting rebates from drugmakers.Even as PBMs have taken on a larger role in drug coverage and pricing in recent decades, including through mergers with insurers, the business arrangements that shape their finances remain unusually opaque. That has led to questions about the role PBMs play in the rising cost of prescription drugs, investigations by Congress and the Federal Trade Commission into PBMs business practices, and federal and state efforts to regulate those practices and require greater transparency.On June 14, two experts joined KFF’s The Health Wonk Shop and series moderator Larry Levitt in a 45-minute discussion about the power and practices of PBMs, addressing such questions as:How do PBMs make money?What role do PBMs have in drug costs?What legislation or other reforms are being considered, and how would they affect consumers? ModeratorLarry Levitt, Executive Vice President for Health Policy, KFFPanelistsJennifer Reck, Director, Center on Drug Pricing, National Academy for State Health PolicyKaren Van Nuys, Executive Director of the Value of Life Sciences Innovation Program and Senior Fellow, University of Southern California Schaeffer Center for Health Policy and Economics KFF’s virtual Health Wonk Shop series features in-depth policy discussions with experts that go beyond the news headlines to provide greater insights.
  • 9. Medicaid Work Requirements

    43:44
    The idea of imposing work requirements in Medicaid is making a comeback in Congress and at the state level.Some House Republicans are pushing to include such a measure in any deal to raise the debt ceiling. The policy resonates with a larger message of personal responsibility, and advocates suggest that work requirements could help achieve budget savings and create a pathway to prosperity for low-income people. Opponents argue that imposing requirements will not significantly increase work since most Medicaid enrollees already work, and would just create an additional administrative barrier to maintaining Medicaid coverage.On the state level, Georgia is poised to implement work requirements in a limited expansion of Medicaid this summer after a court overturned the Biden administration’s attempt to block the move administratively. In Arkansas, the only state to have implemented work and reporting requirements, thousands of people were disenrolled for failure to comply, including some who were eligible but could not navigate the process.On Tuesday, April 25 , three experts joined series moderator Larry Levitt in a 45-minute discussion about work and reporting requirements in public programs such as Medicaid, their effects on enrollment and employment, and what we can expect on the state and federal levels regarding the future of Medicaid work requirements.ModeratorLarry Levitt, Executive Vice President for Health Policy, KFFPanelistsMadeline Guth, Senior Policy Analyst, Program on Medicaid & Uninsured, KFFHeather Hahn, Associate Vice President, Center on Labor, Human Services, and Population, Urban InstituteAngela Rachidi, Senior Fellow and Rowe Scholar, American Enterprise InstituteKFF’s virtual series, The Health Wonk Shop, features conversations with experts, diving into timely health policy issues for a deeper discussion beyond the news headlines.
  • 8. Unpacking the Controversy Over Medicare Advantage

    53:48
    Medicare Advantage is the rapidly growing private plan alternative to traditional Medicare that provides coverage to approximately half of Medicare beneficiaries.Controversy has arisen over a Biden Administration proposal for changes to payments to insurers for the coming year, including how the health risk of enrollees is captured, as well as a plan for recouping payments not supported by audits. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services estimated the payments to plans per enrollee would increase by 1% in 2024, and supporters argue the approach would help to reduce inappropriate overpayments to insurers. Critics, including the insurance industry and Republicans in Congress, contend that this represents a cut to Medicare and will lead to higher costs for beneficiaries.On Tuesday, March 21, three experts joined series moderator Larry Levitt in a 45-minute discussion on Medicare Advantage, addressing such questions as: What has driven the growth in Medicare Advantage enrollment? What are the implications of enrollment being concentrated in a few insurance firms? Is the federal government overpaying plans? What would the new rules and proposed changes do, and how would they affect beneficiaries?ModeratorLarry Levitt, Executive Vice President for Health Policy, KFFPanelistsJeannie Fuglesten Biniek, Associate Director, Program on Medicare Policy, KFFTom Kornfield, Senior Consultant, AvalereRichard Kronick, Professor of Family and Preventive Medicine and Adjunct Professor of Political Science, UC San DiegoKFF’s virtual conversation series, The Health Wonk Shop, features conversations with experts, diving into timely health policy issues for a deeper discussion beyond the news headlines.
  • 7. What’s Next for Health Policy After the Election?

    50:12
    With the November midterm elections comes changes in Congress and state legislatures. While full election results remain in flux, there is the possibility of a shift from unified Democratic control of the White House and Congress to divided power. A split in political control of the federal government raises big questions around what can be feasibly accomplished to address health policy issues in the next two years.What can we expect for legislating in the next Congress? Are there health policy areas that are ripe for bipartisan solutions to overcome gridlock? What might be targets for oversight from a Republican-led House? What further progress can the Biden Administration make on health care through executive actions?On Tuesday, November 15, two experts joined series moderator Larry Levitt in a 45-minute discussion looking at what’s ahead for health policy on the Hill, in the Administration, and in the states after the election.ModeratorLarry Levitt, Executive Vice President for Health Policy, KFFPanelistsChris Jennings, Founder & President, Jennings Policy Strategies Inc.Jennifer Young, Partner, Tarplin, Downs & Young, LLC (TDY)KFF’s virtual conversation series, The Health Wonk Shop, features conversations with experts, diving into timely health policy issues for a deeper discussion beyond the news headlines and taking questions from viewers over Zoom.