Share

cover art for E-Collar Myths: Separating Fact From Fiction

The Dog People Podcast

E-Collar Myths: Separating Fact From Fiction

Season 1, Ep. 74

Shock collars. Cruel. Lazy training. Painful. Outdated. If you've spent any time in the dog world, you've heard it all when it comes to e-collars. But how much of it is actually true, and how much is recycled myth that refuses to die?


In this episode of the e-collar mini series, Jack Laurence and dog trainer Max O'Neil bring the biggest misconceptions surrounding modern e-collars. From the idea that they're just glorified shock devices, to the belief that they're a shortcut for owners who can't be bothered to train properly, Max breaks down what's fact, what's fiction, and what's somewhere in between.


You'll hear why the technology of today is worlds apart from the tools of decades past, why so many of the loudest critics have never actually used one, and why the way an e-collar is used matters far more than the device itself.


Whether you're a sceptic, a curious owner, or someone who's been told off for even considering one, this episode will challenge what you think you know and give you the facts to make up your own mind.

Need help with your four legged best friend? get intouch with Max at downunderdogtrainer.com

More episodes

View all episodes

  • 78. Not What You Signed Up For: The Rescue Dog Breed Problem

    11:39||Season 1, Ep. 78
    Rescues do incredible work, but the breed on the listing isn't always the dog you bring home. In this episode, Jack and Max unpack why so many rescue dogs get mislabelled, what that means for unprepared owners, and how a bit of homework before adoption can save everyone a lot of heartache.Max shares a jaw-dropping story from his own experience as a trainer, turning up to help a client with what was advertised as a French bulldog, only to be greeted by a 40kg dog at the door. It's a reminder that size, energy levels, and temperament can be wildly different from what you've been told.This isn't an attack on rescue organisations, who are doing some of the most important work in the dog world. It's a call for prospective owners to ask questions, meet the dog properly, observe behaviour, and be honest with themselves about what they can handle. Because the best outcome for a rescue dog is a home that stays its home.
  • 77. Last Resort or Lifesaver? E-Collar Stories from Real Owners

    20:27||Season 1, Ep. 77
    In the final episode of our e-collar series, Jack and Max move past the theory and get into the real stories. Jack opens up about the day his own dog took off down a highway chasing a motorbike, and the decision that followed to put her on an e-collar. It wasn't a decision made lightly, and he walks through what changed, what didn't, and why he'd make the same call again.Max brings stories from his own clients. Owners who'd tried everything. Dogs whose lives were getting smaller by the week because they couldn't be trusted off lead, couldn't pass another dog without lunging, or couldn't be left alone with the family cat. Max shares what brought these owners to the e-collar, what the transition actually looked like, and how the tool reshaped not just the dogs' behaviour but the entire relationship between dog and owner.If you've spent the series wondering whether an e-collar could ever be right for your dog, this episode gives you the honest, lived-in answer that no training manual can. Real owners. Real dogs. Real change.
  • 76. Introducing E-Collar Corrections: The How and The When

    16:31||Season 1, Ep. 76
    In part two of our e-collar series, Jack and Max get into the part most owners get wrong: introducing corrections. When is your dog actually ready? What does a fair correction look like? And how do you build the foundation that makes the tool work the way it should?We cover the prerequisite skills your dog needs before a correction ever enters the picture, how to layer the stim against a known command, the difference between a correction and a reaction, and the common mistakes that turn a useful tool into a confused dog. If you have ever wondered when to make that jump from conditioning to actual corrections, this one is for you.
  • 75. The Right Way to Start E-Collar Training

    39:33||Season 1, Ep. 75
    Thinking about introducing your dog to an e-collar but not sure where to start? In this episode, Jack and Max from Down Under Dog Trainer walk you through Max's proven four-step process for introducing your dog to the e-collar the right way.Max breaks down each stage clearly, explaining what to do, what to avoid, and how to read your dog throughout the process. Whether you're considering an e-collar for off-lead reliability, recall, or general obedience, this episode gives you a solid understanding of how the introduction phase should look.A quick but important note: the e-collar is a fantastic tool when used correctly, but it's not a shortcut or a fix-all. We strongly recommend seeking guidance from a qualified, experienced professional trainer before introducing one to your dog. Used properly, it can transform your relationship with your dog. Used incorrectly, it can do real harm. Please always do your research and get hands-on professional support.
  • 73. ok lets talk E-Collars

    23:24||Season 1, Ep. 73
    Are e-collars really the cruel, outdated tools some make them out to be? In this episode, Jack and Max unpack the truth about e-collars: what they actually are, what trainers use them for, and why they can be one of the most effective ways to give your dog more freedom and you less stress.This is the first instalment of a brand new mini series all about e-collars. Over the coming episodes we'll be busting the biggest myths and misconceptions, walking you through a beginner-friendly introduction to using the device, and hearing from owners who were once firmly against the idea and now wouldn't be without one. They'll share how the e-collar transformed their walks, their dog's confidence, and their own peace of mind.Whether you're curious, sceptical, or already convinced, this series is your honest, no-nonsense guide to understanding one of the most misunderstood tools in modern dog training.
  • 72. Case Study 001 - Oreo and Tommy

    12:52||Season 1, Ep. 72
    Oreo and Tommy have lived together for over a decade. Two dogs, one home, one kennel, one sofa -- and for years, not a problem in sight. Then something shifted. Oreo, a 13-year-old cocker spaniel, started showing aggression toward Tommy, a 12-year-old beagle, around food, in their shared kennel, and over the sofa they had spent years sleeping on side by side. Their owners were confused, worried, and didn't know where to turn.Professional dog trainer Max O'Neil did.In this episode, Max takes Jack through a recent client session with Oreo and Tommy, breaking down why senior dogs can undergo real personality and behavioural changes as they age, why resource guarding can emerge or intensify in their later years, and what he is actually doing -- step by step -- to help these two old friends find their way back to each other. From managing feeding routines to rethinking shared spaces, Max walks us through the practical strategies he is putting in place and why patience, structure, and understanding what is happening inside an ageing dog's world makes all the difference.Because getting older is hard. For all of us.
  • 71. What Is Assistance Dog Puppy Raising — And Should You Do It?

    14:45||Season 1, Ep. 71
    Before you commit to a dog of your own, there's a way to get the full experience, with expert support, a clear endpoint, and the knowledge that you're changing someone's life. Raising an assistance puppy is one of the most rewarding things a dog lover can do, and the benefits go far beyond the obvious. It's the ultimate test drive for first-time dog owners, a brilliant way to figure out if your household is ready for a second dog, and an education in raising a well-rounded animal that most pet owners never get. Max and Jack break down everything you need to know about becoming a puppy raiser, what it involves, what you get out of it, and why more dog people should seriously consider it.
  • 70. Single Event Learning in Dogs Explained: The One-Time Experiences That Shape Behaviour

    10:04||Season 1, Ep. 70
    Did you know your dog can learn something permanently from a single experience? Jack and Max dig into single event learning — what it is, why dogs are wired for it, and how it affects everything from fear and phobias to fast, reliable training. Whether you're dealing with a reactive dog or just want to raise a confident one, this episode is essential listening.