Share
The Bristol Cable
The Debrief - Transparency matters: why is Bristol City Council failing on freedom of information?
It’s almost six months since the Cable asked why Bristol’s performance on FOI requests was so poor. As the city’s political system prepares to change, Alex Turner talks to Priyanka Raval about why this is important, and whether we can look forward to more open local government.
Back in autumn 2023, Bristol City Council was being scrutinised over its performance answering freedom of information (FOI) requests, by the independent regulator responsible for looking after citizens’ information rights. We made the issue our cover story, for our October print edition.
At the end of August, the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) had issued a notice telling the council it needed to do better at answering the requests. These basically give anyone the right to ask questions of the public bodies that have a bearing on our lives. We’re talking central government departments, the NHS, educational institutions – and of course, the local authorities who are in charge of many mundane – and not so mundane – parts of our day-to-day existence.It had been on the Cable’s radar for a while that Bristol sometimes seemed slower – and on occasion less helpful – at answering FOI requests than some of its peers.
And it wasn’t just reporters noticing this – some of the city’s more active residents had also previously posed tough questions as to why requests weren’t getting adequate responses. In 2021, the deputy mayor Craig Cheney had admitted a systemic problem. So it seemed natural for us to look more deeply into why it hadn’t been fixed after two years.
Six months on, the city is looking at political change as elections loom. So it seemed a good time to revisit this topic.
Why is it so important that local government is as transparent as possible – and will it become more so after May? What’s the point of FOI anyway? And do we actually know whether the council has improved its performance?
Join Alex Turner, who wrote the FOI cover story, in conversation with Debrief presenter Priyanka Raval getting into these questions and others. And with those local elections fast approaching, be sure to look out for our in-depth interviews with senior figures from all the main parties, as part of our long-running Bristol Unpacked podcast series.
More episodes
View all episodes
1. Cable Live X Bristol Transformed - Spy Cops with Tom Fowler
46:52This is the first of a short series of talks recorded at the Bristol Transformed festival 2024; a grassroots and volunteer led festival of radical politics, arts and culture for which The Bristol Cable was a media partner.Throughout this series, you’ll hear from a range of voices, including Cable journalists, talking on topics with a focus on political organising.For this talk titled Spycops, Transformed volunteer Clair Muscat sat down with self professed “anarchist bloke from newport” Tom Fowler to discuss his ongoing activism in relation to the infiltration of several activist groups by undercover police officers spanning decades.Subscribe to The Bristol Cable on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
6. Cable Live - An evening with Owen Jones
01:04:05This is a live recording of An evening with Owen Jones, recorded at Strange Brew on May 28th.In this event, cable journalist Priyanka Raval sat down with Owen Jones to discuss the general election, why he quit the Labour party, Carol Vorderman, the crisis in Palestine and what he thinks makes Bristol so unique.Subscribe to The Bristol Cable on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
7. The Debrief - General election kicks off with Matty Edwards
28:10Priyanka and Matty sit down to preview what the general election is going to look like in and around Bristol. Could Bristol produce the Green’s second ever MP? And do Labour really have a chance of winning seats of the Tories on Bristol’s outskirts?Subscribe to The Bristol Cable on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
5. Cable Live - Take Drugs Seriously with David Nutt
49:48Drug policy in the UK causes more harm than good, and it has to change. But how do we push for change, and what are the most significant issues we need to address?Join drug researcher, neuropharmacologist, and chairman of Drug Science David Nutt in discussing what a new approach to drugs could mean for our city, families, and community.David Nutt was joined by author and ex-undercover cop Neil Woods, CEO of Transform Drugs, Shoba Ram, and Bristol Cable’s Matty Edwards chaired the discussion.Subscribe to The Bristol Cable on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
3. Area in focus - The fight for the St Paul's Dentist
46:36This time in 2023, if you passed through St Paul’s on a Thursday afternoon you’d find a group of people – from primary kids to pensioners – gathered on Ashley Road to protest the closure of the local dentist. It was part of a wave of planned cuts by private health giant BUPA, affecting 85 practices.The dental practice closure made local headlines. But seven months later it was all over the national news – as it reopened under new management, with hundreds of people queueing round the block to get an NHS registration. Footage of the queues starkly illustrated the dire state of dentistry in the UK.In this episode of our Area in Focus podcast, we talk to the remarkable group of campaigners who fought for the surgery to reopen – and succeeded, meaning local people could have a community dentist again. How did they manage it? And does the story hold lessons for other campaigners – and for the public bodies and private companies who hold the power in healthcare? Subscribe to The Bristol Cable on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
6. The Debrief - Local election results 2024 with Matty Edwards
35:21Last week the Green Party seized a historic victory at Bristol's local elections, gaining 10 seats but falling just short of the 36 needed for an overall majority in the council chamber.The Greens had been expected to come out as the largest party, as eight years of Labour rule under mayor Marvin Rees came to an end – and with it the city's mayoral system of governance. But their surging support proved to be even stronger than expected, prompting emotional and jubilant scenes at election counts in Easton and Brislington on Friday evening (3 May).Now that the dust has settled after a sometimes bad-tempered campaign, Cable journalists Matty Edwards and Priyanka Raval recap what it was like covering the local election results, and unpick what it all means for the city.Subscribe to The Bristol Cable on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
4. Bristol Unpacked Election Special - Emma Edwards // Green Party
01:14:27Emma Edwards is the leader of Bristol Green Party who could well be in charge of the council for the first time after May's local elections. She chats to Neil about the Green's vision for doing politics in a more transparent and collaborative way, how they'd sort out our public transport, and whether they're ready to make the tricky transition from party of opposition to party of power.Subscribe to The Bristol Cable on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
3. Bristol Unpacked Election Special - Mark Weston // Conservative
01:08:52Neil Maggs sits down with Mark Weston, who was first elected as a councillor nearly 20 years ago, and has led the local Tory party for a decade. On the eve of the local elections, they discuss the Tories miserable national polling, the so-called 'war on motorists' being waged by Bristol City Council, and the cultural divides between Bristol's inner city and suburbs.Subscribe to The Bristol Cable on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
2. Bristol Unpacked Election Special - Jos Clark // Liberal Democrats
01:09:01Jos Clark is an experienced local councillor now leading the Lib Dems into Bristol's local elections. A party that used to have strong support in the city has seen its seats dwindle over the last decade. The critic of Marvin Rees and the mayoral system, who helped manoeuvre the referendum on introducing the new committee system, talks to Neil Maggs about libraries, Bristol's failing bus services and her prediction that Labour will take a kicking after eight years in powerSubscribe to The Bristol Cable on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.