Share

cover art for The Myths of Gaza and The End of Bibi

The Brink

The Myths of Gaza and The End of Bibi

Season 1, Ep. 52

Watch the full uncut interview HERE: https://thebrinkpodcast.substack.com/


In this episode of The Brink, Andrew and Jake are joined by Israeli author and former Knesset member Einat Wilf for a wide-ranging conversation on the future of Israel, the ideology driving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and the country's political future after Benjamin Netanyahu.


Wilf argues that the conflict has never fundamentally been about settlements, borders, or occupation, but about the refusal to accept the existence of a sovereign Jewish state. She explains why the events of October 7th reinforced this belief, examines the role of UNRWA and the so-called "right of return", and discusses whether genuine peace is possible without a fundamental shift in Palestinian political culture.


The conversation also explores Israel's rapidly changing political landscape ahead of the next election. We discuss Benjamin Netanyahu's legacy, the candidates hoping to replace him, the growing debate over military service and the ultra-Orthodox community, and why Wilf believes Israel must stop delaying difficult decisions and begin addressing its deepest structural challenges.


Finally, we examine the changing relationship between Israel and the United States, the battle over global public opinion, and why Wilf believes the war for international legitimacy has become just as important as the military conflict itself.


A fascinating discussion about Zionism, Israeli politics, and the future of one of the world's most consequential democracies.


Chapters

00:00 Introduction

04:15 The Ideology Behind Hamas

08:08 Are There Palestinian Moderates?

16:18 Is Peace Still Possible?

20:50 Israeli Extremism & The Current Government

26:19 Why Anat Wilf Changed Her Mind

32:00 Inside Israel’s Next Election

37:10 Will Netanyahu Survive?

42:56 Trump, America & Israel’s Future

48:19 Is The Netanyahu Era Coming To An End?


Don't forget to check out our merch store: https://www.thebrinkmerch.com/

More episodes

View all episodes

  • 69. Islamists, progressives, far-right: who are the real heirs to Hitler?

    49:50||Season 1, Ep. 69
    Watch the full uncut interview HERE: https://thebrinkpodcast.substack.comIn this episode of The Brink, Andrew and Jake are joined by historian Roger Moorhouse to ask what became of fascism after the Second World War, and whether its influence can still be seen in politics today.From Nazi influence in the Arab world and the rise of Islamism to Putin’s Russia and Donald Trump’s America, Roger explores which elements of fascism have survived and why the label itself may now be doing more harm than good.The conversation also turns to the populist right, political extremism and the attempts from both left and right to rewrite the legacy of Winston Churchill and the Second World War.Don't forget to check out our merch store: https://www.thebrinkmerch.com/Chapters00:00 What Is Fascism?02:26 How Fascism Became a Political Insult06:10 Racism, Antisemitism & Nazi Germany10:05 Humiliation: The Fuel of Fascism16:08 Fascism’s Influence on the Arab World20:51 Hitler, Al-Husseini & Political Islam28:02 Is Putin’s Russia Becoming Fascist?30:20 Trump & the Fascism Question40:36 Erdoğan & the Problem with the “Fascist” Label44:55 What Fascism Can Teach Us Today
  • 68. From The KGB To Gaza: How Soviet Propaganda Survived

    44:13||Season 1, Ep. 68
    Watch the full uncut interview HERE: https://thebrinkpodcast.substack.comIn this episode of The Brink, Andrew and Jake are joined by Izabella Tabarovsky to explore how some of today’s most powerful accusations against Israel have their roots in Soviet propaganda.Izabella traces claims of genocide, apartheid, and “Zionism is racism” back to Soviet campaigns designed to portray Israel as racist, colonialist, and even Nazi. She explains how these ideas spread through academia, the UN, and the global left, surviving long after the Soviet Union itself collapsed.The conversation also examines the growing overlap between the far left and far right, and why the same conspiracy theories about Israel and Jewish power are increasingly appearing across both political extremes.A fascinating discussion about Soviet propaganda, antisemitism, and why the ideas of the Cold War are still shaping the debate around Israel today.Chapters 00:00 How Soviet Propaganda Targeted Israel02:02 Where the “Genocide” Accusation Began07:01 Why Stalin Turned Against Israel12:12 How the Soviets Reinvented Anti-Semitism16:51 The Far Right Roots of Soviet Anti-Zionism22:39 Mahmoud Abbas & Soviet Propaganda28:00 Where “Zionism Is Racism” Came From33:41 How Soviet Propaganda Survived the USSR36:48 Durban, 9/11 & the New Anti-Zionism40:55 How the Far Right Adopted the Same PlaybookDon't forget to check out our merch store: https://www.thebrinkmerch.com/
  • 67. The lies we believed about jihadism after 9/11

    14:15||Season 1, Ep. 67
    In this episode of View from the Brink, Jake Wallis Simons reflects on the 25th anniversary of 9/11 and asks how the West has become increasingly confused about the difference between its friends and its enemies.Jake traces the consequences of September 11th through Afghanistan, Iraq, and the rise of jihadism, arguing that while the West fought Islamist extremism abroad, its propagandists became increasingly effective at exploiting Western institutions, social media, and the progressive left.Turning to October 7th and Israel, Jake argues that the response to the Hamas attacks exposed the scale of this information war, with misinformation spreading rapidly while sympathy for Israel collapsed.Twenty-five years after 9/11, Jake argues that the West must recover the confidence to recognise its enemies, defend its allies, and resist the propaganda designed to turn it against itself.
  • 66. Dan Hodges: Is this the slow end of Nigel Farage?

    44:22||Season 1, Ep. 66
    In this episode of The Brink, Andrew is joined by political commentator Dan Hodges for a wide-ranging conversation about Labour’s sanctions against Israel, the growing crisis inside Reform UK and why he believes Nigel Farage’s grip on the party may be approaching its end.Hodges begins by examining the political calculation behind Andy Burnham’s approach to Israel. He argues that Labour is attempting to shore up its left flank against the Greens and pro-Palestinian challengers, and explains how pressure from activists, backbenchers and senior cabinet figures previously pushed Keir Starmer towards recognising a Palestinian state.The conversation then turns to Reform and the fallout from the protests in Dover and Portsmouth. Hodges argues that the emergence of Rupert Lowe and Restore has dragged Reform away from its strategy of professionalisation and towards an increasingly populist battle for its own base, while figures including Zia Yusuf and Robert Jenrick position themselves for what could eventually become a leadership contest.Hodges also discusses the mounting scrutiny of Reform’s finances and Nigel Farage’s response to it. He argues that attempts to portray journalists and parliamentary investigations as part of an establishment conspiracy resemble the playbooks of both Donald Trump and Jeremy Corbyn, and warns that Reform’s once formidable political “force field” is beginning to break down.Finally, Hodges makes a striking prediction: Reform may have a future, but Nigel Farage may not have one at its head. With Farage increasingly divisive among the wider electorate, he assesses the potential successors and explains why a future leadership contest could ultimately come down to Zia Yusuf and Robert Jenrick.Chapters 00:00 Introductions 02:19 The Politics Behind Miliband’s Israel Sanctions07:26 Andy Burnham’s Political Strategy13:42 Why Israel Is Losing The Propaganda War19:56 The Dover Protests & Reform’s Response22:23 Has Rupert Lowe Got Inside Farage’s Head?25:08 Farage, Reform & The Populist Playbook31:02 Why Dan Hodges Is Targeting Reform38:34 What’s Really Going On With Reform’s Finances?42:45 Can Farage Copy Trump’s Playbook?
  • 65. Dover Protests, Tucker Carlson, Nick Fuentes and Britain's Right – Daniel Finkelstein

    48:03||Season 1, Ep. 65
    Watch the full uncut interview HERE: https://thebrinkpodcast.substack.comIn this episode of The Brink, Andrew and Jake are joined by Lord Daniel Finkelstein for a wide-ranging conversation about the rise of populism, the far right, and the growing threat of political extremism across Britain, Europe, and the United States.Drawing on his own family's experience of Nazism and Stalinism, Finkelstein reflects on his confrontation with Nick Fuentes and the extraordinary antisemitic abuse that followed. He examines Tucker Carlson's role in bringing once-fringe ideas towards the mainstream, and why attacks on the historical understanding of the Second World War and the Holocaust have become increasingly important to parts of the American right.Turning to Europe, the conversation explores the dramatic rise of Germany's AfD and the role immigration has played in fuelling populist politics. Finkelstein argues that mass migration was a serious political mistake and that governments must regain control, while warning that demonising people who are already British citizens risks making integration harder and pushing politics towards ethno-nationalism.The discussion also turns to Reform UK, Restore, and the battle over the future of the British right. Finkelstein explains why he believes Nigel Farage has historically drawn an important line against the far right, criticises Matt Goodwin's rhetoric on migrants, and delivers a damning assessment of Robert Jenrick's defence of Reform activists after violence at the party's conference.Finally, they examine the growing tolerance of political violence on both the left and right, the appeal of Vladimir Putin to populist movements, and whether Britain's frustration with immigration, bureaucracy, and political institutions could drive the country further towards the extremes.Don't forget to check out our merch store: https://www.thebrinkmerch.com/Chapters 00:00 Introduction02:46 Confronting Nick Fuentes07:44 Tucker Carlson & The New Right15:51 The Rise Of Europe’s Populist Right21:15 The Failure Of Mass Immigration24:39 Matt Goodwin’s “Goat Herders” Comments27:00 Immigration, Protest & Vigilantism33:03 AfD, Reform & The Far Right36:22 Farage, Reform & Ethno-Nationalism39:29 Robert Jenrick & Political Violence
  • 64. Rock ‘n' Roll's disturbing hatred of Israel - David Draiman

    41:35||Season 1, Ep. 64
    Watch the full uncut interview HERE: https://thebrinkpodcast.substack.comIn this episode of The Brink, Andrew is joined by David Draiman, frontman of Disturbed, for a deeply personal conversation about October 7th, antisemitism, Israel and why he has refused to remain silent despite the potential cost to his career.Drawing on his own experiences of antisemitism and his family's history, from grandparents who survived Auschwitz and Dachau to relatives who served in the IDF, Draiman explains why defending the Jewish people has always been central to his identity. He reflects on how October 7th transformed that fight and why the reaction that followed left him deeply concerned about the future of Jews in the West.Draiman also addresses one of the most controversial moments of his activism: writing “F*ck Hamas" on an Israeli artillery shell. He explains why he has no regrets, while also speaking candidly about Palestinian suffering, his hopes for coexistence, and his belief that Israelis and Palestinians ultimately deserve a future beyond perpetual war.Finally, Draiman reflects on the power of music after Disturbed's Hold On to Memories was played at the funeral of Shiri, Ariel, and Kfir Bibas, and on his friendship with Yarden Bibas. He explains why, whatever the professional consequences of speaking out, being able to act according to his conscience matters more than becoming "the next Metallica."Don't forget to check out our merch store: https://www.thebrinkmerch.com/Chapter 00:00 David Draiman On Speaking Up02:58 Why October 7th Changed Everything05:56 Growing Up With Anti-Semitism09:27 How Jewish Identity Shaped Disturbed16:16 Jews, Division & Survival19:43 Hollywood, Music & Israel25:49 Israel, Gaza & Legitimate Criticism33:15 Fighting Back Against Anti-Israel Narratives34:57 Why Celebrities Won’t Debate Him40:57 “I Wrote F*** Hamas”
  • 63. The Dysfunctional Department of War: Pentagon in Disarray Over Explosive Leaks

    20:17||Season 1, Ep. 63
    Watch the full uncut interview HERE: https://thebrinkpodcast.substack.comIn this episode of View from The Brink, Andrew Fox examines a growing crisis inside the Pentagon, asking whether Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth’s drive for loyalty and ideological control is beginning to undermine the military effectiveness of the United States.Andrew examines Hegseth’s transformation of the Pentagon itself, from the removal of senior military leaders and interventions in promotion decisions to restrictions on the traditional press and the undisclosed government roles given to sympathetic online influencers. Andrew asks whether a culture intended to restore discipline and merit is instead making military officers increasingly reluctant to deliver unwelcome advice.Finally, Andrew makes the case that the readiness leak should be understood as a warning about the health of civilian-military relations. If senior officers believe professional objections are being ignored or punished, he argues, the greatest danger is not disobedience but a Pentagon in which uncomfortable truths can no longer travel safely upwards…Don't forget to check out our merch store: https://www.thebrinkmerch.com/
  • 62. The Arab Case for Israel with Hussain Abdul-Hussain

    01:02:33||Season 1, Ep. 62
    Watch the full uncut interview HERE: https://thebrinkpodcast.substack.comIn this episode of The Brink, Jake is joined by Hussain Abdul-Hussain, author of The Arab Case for Israel, for a fascinating conversation about Israel, the Arab world, and why he believes peace requires a fundamental change in the way the Middle East thinks about politics, identity, and prosperity.Growing up between Saddam Hussein’s Iraq and Hezbollah-dominated Baalbek, Hussain absorbed the politics of Arab nationalism, sectarianism, and hostility towards Israel. He explains how moving to Beirut, encountering different religious communities, and eventually teaching himself Hebrew by listening to Israeli radio transformed his understanding of the Jewish state.Hussain argues that much of the Arab world has prioritised land, honour, and historical grievance over economic prosperity and individual liberty. Drawing on the UAE and the Abraham Accords, he makes the case for a different model: abandoning permanent conflict with Israel, raising living standards, and allowing political reform to emerge gradually rather than through revolution.The conversation also explores the decline of Christian and Jewish minorities across the Middle East, Hezbollah’s grip on Lebanon, the prospects for Arab-Israeli normalisation, and why Hussain believes many ordinary Arabs may be considerably more open to peace than their governments and political movements suggest.Don't forget to check out our merch store: https://www.thebrinkmerch.com/Chapters 00:00 From Hezbollah Sympathiser To Supporting Israel02:43 The Arab Case For Israel04:17 Why Hussein Changed His Mind09:13 Prosperity, Palestine & National Pride21:46 Minorities In The Muslim World28:33 Growing Up Around Hezbollah35:53 How Beirut Changed Everything38:01 Discovering The Real Israel42:52 Why Hussein Broke With The Left47:15 Can The Arab World Really Change?
  • 61. The Middle East, Zionism and The West’s New “Religion”

    01:01:13||Season 1, Ep. 61
    Watch the full uncut interview HERE: https://thebrinkpodcast.substack.comIn this episode of The Brink, Andrew and Jake are joined by bestselling historian and author Simon Sebag Montefiore for a sweeping conversation about the history of the Middle East and his new book, The Cauldron: The Making of the Modern Middle East.Sebag challenges many of the assumptions shaping today's debates about Israel, Islam, and the wider region. He explains why Islam cannot be treated as a single political or religious force, why Israel is in many ways more typical of Middle Eastern history than Western audiences realise, and how Zionism fits into a much longer history of Jewish attachment to the Holy Land.The conversation also examines what Sebag describes as the West's almost religious commitment to the two-state solution, despite the realities on the ground. From the collapse of the Ottoman Empire and the creation of modern nation-states to Turkey, Iran, and the decline of Christianity across the region, he explores how history continues to shape today's conflicts.Finally, we look at America's changing role in the Middle East and the emergence of a new geopolitical order in which conflicts from Ukraine and the Caucasus to the Horn of Africa are increasingly interconnected.Chapters 00:00 The Two-State Solution Has Become A Religion02:28 Simon Sebag Montefiore On The Brink07:25 The Truth About Islam13:37 Israel’s Crisis From Within18:50 Will Israel Survive Its Divisions?24:15 The Real History Of Zionism30:44 Why The Two-State Solution Keeps Failing32:12 The West’s Contradiction On Nationalism35:36 Does The Middle East Need America?45:37 Why Israel Isn’t Historically Exceptional