Share

The Brink
‘What would Thatcher do?’ Iran, Islam, Trump and Reform with Charles Moore
Watch the full uncut interview HERE: https://open.substack.com/pub/thebrinkpodcast/p/what-would-thatcher-do-iran-islam?r=63dafp&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true
In this episode of The Brink, we sit down with Charles Moore, former editor of The Daily Telegraph and The Spectator, and the definitive biographer of Margaret Thatcher, to examine a West in crisis.
With geopolitical tensions rising, the transatlantic alliance under strain, and Britain facing deep internal divisions, Moore offers a sweeping diagnosis of where things have gone wrong and what might come next.
The conversation begins with one of the most difficult and urgent questions facing Europe today: how Islam fits within Western societies. Moore reflects on decades of thought on the subject, arguing that the challenge is not simply demographic, but philosophical, rooted in unresolved tensions between religion, state, and pluralism. From integration and extremism to the failures of government policy, he lays out why current approaches may be empowering the wrong voices.
We then turn to British politics, where the collapse of trust in the main parties has given rise to insurgent movements on both left and right. Moore explains why this fragmentation is both understandable and dangerous, and why populist parties often diagnose problems better than they solve them.
The discussion also explores the weakening of the transatlantic relationship in the age of Trump, the rise of ideological extremes in American politics, and the growing confusion in the information age, where truth, propaganda, and narrative increasingly blur together.
This is a wide-ranging and deeply thought-provoking conversation about identity, leadership, and the future of the West.
Don't forget to check out our merch store: https://www.thebrinkmerch.com/
Chapters
00:00 Introduction
01:42 Why the Public No Longer Believes the Establishment
03:58 The Rise of Ideology Over Evidence
06:12 How Elite Institutions Became Politicised
08:47 The Media’s Role in Shaping Public Narrative
11:05 Truth vs Narrative: What Changed?
13:26 Social Media, Censorship and Information Control
15:52 The Expert Class and the Illusion of Authority
18:34 Covid, Groupthink and Institutional Failure
21:06 The Incentives That Drive Bad Decisions
23:41 Why Dissent Is Shut Down
26:12 Identity Politics and Institutional Capture
29:05 How Bureaucracies Protect Themselves
32:18 Political Leadership and Failure of Accountability
35:44 The Consequences for Democracy
39:12 Immigration, Culture and Social Fragmentation
42:36 Economic Stagnation and Policy Failure
46:18 Britain vs the United States: A Growing Divide
More episodes
View all episodes

42. “Which is worse…Piers Morgan or the BBC?” Julia Harley-Brewer on the media collapse
49:02||Season 1, Ep. 42Watch the full uncut interview HERE: https://open.substack.com/pub/thebrinkpodcast/p/the-real-reason-british-politics?r=63dafp&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=trueIn this episode of The Brink, Andrew and Jake are joined by broadcaster and journalist Julia Hartley-Brewer. The discussion begins with the mounting pressure on Keir Starmer, with Julia arguing that his leadership has exposed deeper systemic failures across British politics. From Brexit and the civil service to taxation, public services, and political leadership, we explore why trust in both Labour and the Conservatives has collapsed so dramatically.The conversation then turns to the media and the cultural establishment. Julia reflects on her career in British journalism and explains why she increasingly found herself at odds with elite opinion on issues like Brexit, lockdowns, net zero, and gender ideology. We examine whether legacy media has lost public trust and what has filled the vacuum online.A major focus of the episode is anti-Semitism and the war in Israel. Julia shares her experience visiting Israel after October 7th, including visits to the Nova festival site and communities attacked by Hamas. She explains why the trip profoundly affected her understanding of the conflict and why she believes much of the Western public has been misled about Israel by media narratives and political activism.Finally, we discuss the future of British politics, the rise of Reform, and whether the country is entering a period of deeper instability and fragmentation.Don't forget to check out our merch store: https://www.thebrinkmerch.com/Chapters 00:00 Intro 03:35 Keir Starmer and Labour07:18 What’s wrong with UK politics17:44 What a “truth-telling” PM would say23:20 Julia’s media career and outsider role30:00 Media bias and clickbait culture38:38 Extremism, antisemitism and protests41:36 Julia’s Israel trip and what Britain can learn
41. “I Was No Friend Of Israel… Then I Went There” | Claire Fox On The Collapse Of Britain
41:55||Season 1, Ep. 41Watch the full uncut interview HERE: https://open.substack.com/pub/thebrinkpodcast/p/i-was-no-friend-of-israel-then-i?r=63dafp&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=trueIn this episode of The Brink, Andrew and Jake are joined by Claire Fox for a wide-ranging conversation on Britain’s political realignment, the rise of populism, free speech, and the cultural fallout from October 7th.Fox argues that both Labour and the Conservatives have become increasingly detached from ordinary people, creating the conditions for populist movements to surge across Britain. From Brexit and the financial crash to identity politics and the decline of national pride, we explore why so many voters feel alienated from the political establishment.The discussion also examines censorship and self-censorship across universities, public institutions, and politics. Fox warns that ideological conformity and fear of social punishment are reshaping public life, while identity politics and multiculturalism have weakened a shared sense of citizenship.The conversation then turns to the aftermath of October 7th and the rise of anti-Semitism in Britain. Fox reflects on how her own views on Israel changed over time and argues that hostility toward Israel increasingly reflects a deeper crisis within Western societies themselves.A provocative and timely discussion about Britain’s future, democratic change, and the growing battle over national identity and free speech.Don't forget to check out our merch store: https://www.thebrinkmerch.com/
40. “We’ve Got to Fight Back” | Katharine Birbalsingh Sounds the Alarms
48:43||Season 1, Ep. 40Watch the full uncut interview HERE: https://open.substack.com/pub/thebrinkpodcast/p/weve-got-to-fight-back-katharine?r=63dafp&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=trueIn this episode of The Brink, Andrew and Jake are joined by Katharine Birbalsingh to discuss education, culture and the pressing crisis facing young people today.Their conversation begins with a fundamental question: what is education truly for? She warns that many in the West underestimate the profound impact schools and wider culture have on younger generations’ attitudes and behaviours.The discussion then shifts to the modern classroom. We explore how schools have become battlegrounds for broader cultural debates, influenced by political activism, ideological sway and evolving curricula. Birbalsingh contends that a shift away from discipline, tradition and moral clarity is having serious consequences for academic standards, behaviour, mental health and social cohesion.From the influence of smartphones and social media to the decline of parental authority and the rise of online radicalisation, it examines why many young people feel anxious, confused and increasingly detached. Birbalsingh stresses that without strong guidance from schools and families, children are vulnerable to harmful influences.Finally, the conversation expands to some of Britain’s most contentious issues, including identity, gender, anti-Semitism and integration. Drawing on her experience leading one of the country’s most talked-about schools, Birbalsingh offers a stark warning: unless parents and society take decisive action, these issues will continue to fester.Don't forget to check out our merch store: https://www.thebrinkmerch.com/
39. Can The West Survive Its Own Tolerance? (And can Keir Starmer survive at all?) With Daniel Hannan
46:22||Season 1, Ep. 39In this episode of The Brink, Andrew and Jake are joined by Daniel Hannan for a wide-ranging conversation on freedom, identity, and the political challenges facing Britain today.The discussion begins with a debate around freedom of worship and the place of Islam in a liberal society. We explore how questions of integration, national security, and cultural confidence are increasingly colliding in modern Britain.The conversation then turns to the deeper causes behind social division. From economic stagnation to a loss of national identity, we examine why trust in institutions has eroded and how this creates fertile ground for both extremism and political fragmentation.We also discuss the state of British politics under Keir Starmer, with a sharp critique of what Hannan describes as managerial leadership and a lack of clear direction. Finally, the conversation widens to the global stage. We examine the impact of Donald Trump on Western alliances, the growing threat posed by Iran, and the risk of nuclear proliferation in an increasingly unstable world.Watch the full uncut interview HERE: https://open.substack.com/pub/thebrinkpodcast/p/can-the-west-survive-its-own-tolerance?r=63dafp&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=trueDon't forget to check out our merch store: https://www.thebrinkmerch.com/Chapters00:00 Introduction03:52 Challenges of Integration and National Security 08:40 Historical Parallels and Integration Efforts18:48 Economic and Social Factors Influencing Extremism 26:29 Keir Starmer's Leadership and Management Style30:58 The Impact of Trump on Global Conservatism43:12 The Role of the US in British Foreign Policy
38. ‘Hezbollah is the enemy of humanity’ | Lebanese expert Makram Rabah
45:14||Season 1, Ep. 38In this episode of The Brink, Andrew is joined by Lebanese historian and political analyst Makram Rabah for a deep dive into Hezbollah, Iran’s regional influence, and the fragile state of Lebanon.The conversation explores how Hezbollah has evolved from a militant group into a dominant political and military force within Lebanon, and what that means for the country’s sovereignty. Rabah explains how Hezbollah operates not just as a proxy of Iran, but as a parallel state, shaping institutions, security, and everyday life.We examine the wider regional picture, from Iran’s strategic ambitions to the role of proxy warfare across the Middle East. Rabah argues that Lebanon has effectively become a frontline in a much larger geopolitical struggle, with consequences that extend far beyond its borders.The discussion also turns to the internal collapse of Lebanon itself. From economic breakdown to political paralysis, Rabah outlines how corruption, sectarianism, and external influence have hollowed out the state, leaving ordinary citizens to bear the cost.Finally, we ask what comes next. Is there a path back to sovereignty for Lebanon, or has the balance of power shifted too far? And what does this mean for Israel, the wider region, and the future of Western policy in the Middle East?A sharp and sobering conversation on power, proxy conflict, and the realities shaping the modern Middle East.Watch the full uncut interview HERE: https://open.substack.com/pub/thebrinkpodcast/p/hezbollah-is-the-enemy-of-humanity?r=63dafp&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=trueDon't forget to check out our merch store: https://www.thebrinkmerch.com/
37. Who’s the real winner? Air Marshal Edward Stringer on Iran, NATO & Western Decline
43:57||Season 1, Ep. 37Watch the full and ad-free interview HERE: https://open.substack.com/pub/thebrinkpodcast/p/whos-the-real-winner-air-marshal?r=63dafp&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=trueIn this episode of The Brink, Andrew and Jake are joined by Air Marshall Edward Stringer, for a timely and wide-ranging conversation on Iran, NATO, and the future of Western power.We explore the question at the heart of today’s conflicts: who is actually winning? Against the backdrop of rising tensions with Iran and a shifting global order, Stringer challenges the idea that military strikes alone can deliver lasting outcomes, arguing that without a clear political end state, even successful operations risk achieving very little.The discussion looks at the limits of air power and modern warfare, and why technological superiority is no substitute for coherent strategy. Stringer explains how interventions can shape events in the short term, but cannot create stability on their own, raising serious questions about recent Western actions in the Middle East.We also examine the state of NATO and Western defence more broadly. Stringer warns that capabilities have declined significantly, with the UK and its allies falling behind in readiness and resilience, even as threats become more immediate and complex.Finally, the conversation turns to the bigger picture. From Iran and global energy security to the role of allies and so-called middle powers, this episode asks whether the West is entering a period of strategic drift and what it would take to reverse that trajectory.A clear-eyed and thought-provoking discussion on war, power, and the future of the West.Don't forget to check out our merch store: https://www.thebrinkmerch.com/Chapters00:00 Introduction 02:36 Stringer’s Military Background & Experience05:04 The Libya Campaign Explained07:51 Libya: Did Air Power Really Work?09:00 Why You Can’t “Bomb Your Way To Victory”15:39 Iran Today: What Does “Success” Look Like?19:26 Was War With Iran Inevitable?20:16 Can Air Power Ever Deliver Regime Change?25:51 Trump’s War Rhetoric & Its Consequences28:07 Social Media, War & Political Messaging31:21 The Problem With US Global Leadership35:49 Has The US Always Controlled NATO?38:07 Europe’s Military Weakness Explained40:31 Will Things “Go Back To Normal” After Trump?41:57 A Fundamental Shift In Global Power43:26 Has The UK Fallen Behind On Defence?
36. Why do feminists have a problem with Jews? | Zoe Strimpel
42:33||Season 1, Ep. 36In this episode of The Brink, Andrew and Jake discuss modern feminism, anti-Semitism, and the contradictions in contemporary culture with journalist and academic Zoe Strimpel.Strimpel shares her shocking experience visiting an anti-Semitic art exhibit in Margate, describing the disturbing imagery and rhetoric. She challenges the artist, raising questions about political expression, hate, institutions, and the normalisation of extreme ideas.The conversation explores how modern feminist movements have evolved and sometimes lost sight of their original aims. Strimpel argues that while feminism has made gains, its contemporary form is entangled with identity politics, victimhood narratives, and ideologies that undermine individual agency and social cohesion. The episode examines how these ideas intersect with attitudes towards Israel, the West, and liberal democracy.A central theme is the paradox of modern progressive movements: how feminist strands that claim to champion women’s rights can align with ideologies and regimes that oppose them. Strimpel traces a recurring pattern of anti-Semitism within feminist spaces, arguing that this is not new but increasingly visible.The conversation explores deeper cultural questions, such as the decline of family formation, changing attitudes to relationships and sexuality, and whether modern societies can sustain long-term fulfilment. Strimpel challenges assumptions about power, freedom, and gender, arguing that Western liberalism, despite its flaws, remains the most successful framework for human flourishing, especially for women.Watch the full uncut interview HERE: https://open.substack.com/pub/thebrinkpodcast/p/why-do-feminists-have-a-problem-with?r=63dafp&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=trueChapters00:00 Introduction02:59 Inside the Gallery: “This Was Next Level”05:21 Nazi Imagery and Blood Libels 07:46 Confronting the Artist and Crowd Intimidation10:41 Calling the Police and Institutional Failure13:37 Civil Society Complicity and Cultural Silence17:55 Why Progressive Women Support Hamas20:42 Feminism and Jihadism: An Impossible Alliance21:06 The History of Anti-Semitism in Feminism23:24 Class, Elites and Anti-Jewish Sentiment24:17 Why Moral Clarity on Israel Is Rejected25:00 Identity Politics and the Corruption of Feminism27:46 Cognitive Dissonance in Western Activism28:28 The “Problem With Women” in Modern Politics31:54 Victimhood Culture and Feminist Identity33:01 Hypocrisy in Modern Feminism36:55 The Backlash to Good Slut37:56 Bonnie Blue and the Limits of Liberal Society40:07 Sexual Freedom vs Social Collapse41:40 Family, Community and the Future of Society
34. “You Can’t Even Debate This” UK’s Islamism Problem, with former ambassador to Saudi Sir John Jenkins
46:01||Season 1, Ep. 34Watch the full uncut interview HERE: https://open.substack.com/pub/thebrinkpodcast/p/you-cant-even-debate-this-uks-islamism?r=63dafp&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=trueIn this episode of The Brink, Andrew and Jake are joined by former British diplomat and intelligence expert John Jenkins for a deep dive into the influence of Islamism, the Muslim Brotherhood, and the growing challenges facing Britain and the West.The conversation begins with the controversy surrounding public religious displays in Britain, and whether questions around cultural dominance and the use of public space can still be debated openly. Jenkins argues that these are legitimate issues, but increasingly difficult to discuss without accusations shutting down the conversation.Drawing on his 2015 government review, he explains how Islamism differs from Islam, and why movements like the Muslim Brotherhood present a long-term ideological challenge to Western liberal democracies. The discussion explores how these ideas operate not just politically, but through social networks, charities, universities, and community structures.The episode also examines the concept of “creeping influence” within public life, from changing social norms to the role of identity and integration in Britain. Jenkins stresses that the problem is not simple or singular, but part of a broader ideological ecosystem that interacts with wider cultural and economic factors.Turning to foreign policy, the conversation shifts to Iran, with Jenkins arguing that Western governments have consistently misunderstood the nature of the regime. He critiques decades of policy shaped by wishful thinking, warning that Iran operates as a revolutionary state with global ambitions and deep links to militant networks.Finally, the discussion focuses on what Britain should do next. Jenkins outlines a clear approach: restore open debate, follow the money behind extremist networks, rebuild institutional expertise, and confront subversive activity before it escalates into violence.A wide-ranging and provocative conversation about ideology, security, and the future of the West.Don't forget to check out our merch store: https://www.thebrinkmerch.com/Chapters 00:00 Introduction02:49 Who Is Sir John Jenkins? Background and Experience03:26 Is Public Religious Display a Political Signal?05:21 Why Islamism Challenges Western Liberal Democracy07:48 Islam as Religion vs Islamism as Political System08:59 Can Islam Be Compatible With Western Democracy?12:01 Islamism as a Totalising Ideology14:41 The Muslim Brotherhood’s Long-Term Strategy17:33 Why Debate on Islamism Is Being Shut Down18:50 Social Media, Intimidation and Closed Debate19:34 Universities, DEI and Ideological Monoculture21:33 The Muslim Brotherhood as a Global Network24:20 Follow the Money: Financing Islamist Movements27:52 Integration, Identity and Segregation in Britain30:17 Economic Growth vs Cultural Fragmentation31:04 Mosques, Preaching and Inflammatory Rhetoric33:03 The Rise of a Global Muslim Identity34:40 Iran Strategy: Where the West Got It Wrong36:45 The Nuclear Deal, Wishful Thinking and Reality40:41 Foreign Office Failures and Loss of Expertise42:29 Is Iran a Revolutionary State and Active Threat?