Share

cover art for Can't Win Them All

The Average Fan: A Hartford Athletic Podcast

Can't Win Them All

Ep. 28
•

Hartford Athletic just walked into the most electric home atmosphere in club history and still came up short in the USL Cup final. Oliver, Perrin, and Sam break down what went wrong, why the loss felt so brutal, and what the team has to clean up before a massive road test against Pittsburgh.


Perrin, fresh off a whirlwind solo tour, brings a unique perspective from the road - from New York and DC to Kentucky, St. Louis, Louisville, and Hartford. He shares what it was like chasing matches in tiny venues, massive stadiums, and even a Red Robin in Pennsylvania.


Oliver also explains why Hartford’s performance was both encouraging and frustrating at the same time: they controlled long stretches, outshot Louisville, and still lacked the final decisive moment. Perrin adds the outsider’s eye, comparing the energy in Hartford to the broader landscape he’s been documenting across American soccer - where some clubs have a real foundation to build on, and others still feel like they’re fighting for basic awareness.

The Average Fan Podcast is produced by and partnered with The Blazing Musket

More episodes

View all episodes

  • 29. Playoff Push

    01:02:15||Ep. 29
    Hartford Athletic are in the playoffs, but the real question is whether they can fix the cracks before the games that matter most. Sam and Oliver break down the team’s frustrating run, the defensive lapses, and why Samuel Careaga's return could completely change the ceiling of this squad. The episode closes with a bigger look at the changing expectations around Hartford Athletic and what it now means when simply making the playoffs is no longer enough

  • 27. Home Cupping

    01:04:11||Ep. 27
    Hartford Athletic are 90 minutes away from silverware, but the biggest threat to their USL Cup hopes might be the questions they still have to answer. Can Brendan Burke trust his back line after Britton Fischer’s red card? Is Michee peaking at exactly the right time? And does Louisville City have enough firepower to punish every mistake again?Sam and Oliver break down the 2-2 draw that served as a tense, windy preview for the final, including the penalty decisions, Hartford’s missed early chances, and the midfield battle that could decide Sunday. They dig into Fischer’s season-long rise and recent wobble and what Hartford must change if it wants to lift another trophy at Trinity Health Stadium.The conversation also gets into the bigger picture around Hartford Athletic, from roster health questions on Arturo Ordonez, Samuel Careaga, and Emmanuel Samadia to the club’s lingering off-field challenges with supporters, attendance, ticket prices, and front-office turnover.

  • 26. The Vegas Flu and Previewing Lou

    01:00:25||Ep. 26
    Hartford Athletic just survived a rotated road test in Las Vegas, and now the real pressure starts. Before a home USL Cup final match, Hartford will play Lou City in USL Championship play.Sam Lattof and Oliver Scholes break down the 1-1 draw against the Lights, why the late push still mattered, and how a heavily changed lineup held the line through a brutal stretch of fixtures.Oliver also tackles a bigger issue in American soccer: why clubs charge for open tryouts, who that excludes, and whether Hartford should be leading differently. Then the conversation turns to next season's Northeast Division, with Portland Hearts of Pine entering the USL W League and instantly raising the stakes for everyone else.

  • 25. Hartford On Fire

    48:48||Ep. 25
    Join us as we dive into the latest episode of The Average Fan Podcast, where we discuss Hartford Athletic's incredible run. Hartford is on fire, currently one of the hottest teams in the league, and we break down their recent matches against Tampa Bay and Jacksonville. With nine unbeaten games, can they keep the momentum going against Las Vegas Lights?

  • 24. Double Cup

    01:07:12||Ep. 24
    Join us for a special episode of the Average Fan Podcast as we dive into the soccer journey of our guest, Perrin! Discover how he fell in love with the sport and his experiences attending matches across New England. Additionally, we recap Hartford's win over Colorado and upcoming matches against Tampa Bay and Jacksonville.

  • 23. Barry Coffey Is On Fire

    01:11:34||Ep. 23
    Join us for the latest episode of the Average Fan Podcast as we dive into the exciting world of Hartford Athletic!In this episode, we discuss the return of $2 beers and $1 hot dogs at games, the team's recent performance, and the impact of key players like Antony Siaha and Barry Coffey. We also preview the upcoming USL Cup semifinal against Colorado Springs Switchbacks and reflect on Brendan Burke's journey as head coach.

  • 22. Making Moves

    51:54||Ep. 22
    In this episode, we explore Hartford Athletic's recent performances, roster moves, and upcoming matches. Oliver Scholes shares insights on team dynamics and player development.

  • 21. The Sadat Anaku Show

    01:01:41||Ep. 21
    Join us as we dive into the latest episode of the Average Fan Podcast, where we discuss Hartford Athletic's recent performances, including their thrilling 4-2 victory over Charlotte and the upcoming match against Miami FC!What's your biggest takeaway from Hartford's recent games? Drop your thoughts in the comments!Follow us on Instagram
Copyright The Blazing Musket
Hosted with ❤️ by Acast