Share

cover art for Successful but not good with Andy & David

Sutton United Talk Time on Podcast - The Sutton Podcast

Successful but not good with Andy & David

The season is done… but what was it? Success or disappointment?


Join Mike, David and Andy as we look back on a rollercoaster year for Sutton United. From a nightmare start and the departure of Steve Morison, to Chris Agutter coming in and steadying the ship, there’s plenty to unpack.


We get into the big question: does finishing 14th represent a solid achievement… or is it a sign of decline after a decade of progress?


There’s a lot in this one:


Why survival genuinely mattered this season

The strange “14th highest ever vs worst in 10 years” debate

What actually changed under Agutter

The impact of key players like Kai Jennings and Jake Taylor

Why discipline and mentality held us back

Playing out from the back vs mixing it up

And whether fans (all of us included) need to rethink how we react


We also talk about expectations. Sutton United isn’t the same club it was 10 years ago, but it’s not one of the big boys in this league either. So where do we actually sit?


And most importantly… what needs to change next season?


Whether you’ve followed Sutton for decades or only joined during the League Two years, this is a proper reflection on where we are and where we’re going.


Chapters


0:00 Intro and initial reactions

3:15 Was survival enough?

7:30 14th place: success or decline?

11:45 How the club has grown off the pitch

15:20 Pre-season optimism vs reality

20:10 Morison out, Agutter in

25:35 First impressions of Aggie

30:15 The run where it clicked

35:40 Key players and turning points

40:20 Mental fragility and inconsistency

44:50 Discipline and penalties

50:15 Style of play debate

55:40 What next season should look like

1:00:30 Fans, criticism and social media

1:05:07 Final thoughts


What did you make of the season?

Was survival enough, or did you expect more?


Drop your thoughts in the comments, and don’t forget to like and subscribe for more Sutton United content.


#SuttonUnited #NationalLeague #SuttonPodcast #FootballPodcast #NonLeagueFootball #SeasonReview

More episodes

View all episodes

  • Rebuilding Sutton United with Chris Agutter

    01:26:52|
    Welcome to the season finale of Sutton United Talk Time on Podcast as manager Chris Agutter sits down for an in-depth reflection on his first six months at the club. From the tactical shifts to the intense physical demands of the National League, Agi pulls back the curtain on what it really takes to lead the Us and his ambitious plans for the future.In this extensive interview, we dive into the challenges of inheriting a squad mid-season and the massive 130 percent increase in physical load required to compete. Agi discusses his recruitment philosophy, emphasising why character and experience are his top priorities for the summer window. We also tackle the big questions about discipline on the pitch, the philosophy of playing out from the back, and those unforgettable away days that defined the campaign.Whether you are interested in the tactical breakdown of our defensive improvements or want to hear about the long-term vision of reaching League One, this episode covers it all. Agi shares personal highlights from the season and explains why he is never satisfied with just a draw. It is a must-watch for every Sutton fan looking ahead to a massive preseason and a new era at the VBS Community Stadium.Chapters0:00 Intro and Season Wrap Up5:00 Reflecting on the First Six Months10:00 Understanding the Sutton United Identity15:00 The Challenge of Player Fitness and Load20:00 Shifting the Mentality from Accepting Defeat25:00 Squad Depth and Budget Realities30:00 Being Honest with Players and Building Culture35:00 Balancing Short Term Goals with the Big Picture40:00 The Importance of Preseason Intensity45:00 Taking Players to Dark Places in Training50:00 Recruitment Strategy for the New Season55:00 Why Experience is Non-Negotiable1:00:00 Addressing Discipline and Defensive Solidity1:05:00 The Philosophy of Playing Out from the Back1:10:00 Creating Overloads and Tactical Flexibility1:15:00 Personal Highlights: Gateshead and Scunthorpe1:20:00 Looking Ahead to the Next Three Years1:25:00 Final Thoughts and Wrap Up1:26:53 Video EndMake sure to join the conversation! Like this video, subscribe to the channel, and let us know your favourite moment of the season in the comments. Stay connected with us on all social media platforms @SuttonPodcast.#SuttonUnited #NationalLeague #FootballPodcast #ChrisAgutter #TheUs
  • Sutton United: More Than Football with Karen & Charlie

    43:36|
    Welcome to a special edition of the Sutton United Talk Time Podcast.In this episode, we step away from the action on the pitch to focus on something just as important, the people, stories and community that make Sutton United what it is.Mike is joined by two inspiring guests, each showing in their own way how football can change lives.First up is Karen, who shares her incredible journey since discovering Parkinson’s walking football through the Sutton United Foundation. What started as simply getting involved has led to a life-changing moment, a call-up to represent England. Karen talks about what that means to her, how football has helped her manage Parkinson’s, and her mission to raise funds for an upcoming international tournament in Canada, including a major fundraising night at Sutton United.Later, Mike speaks with Charlie from the Fantastic Freddie Foundation, the club’s Charity of the Year. Charlie tells the powerful story behind the foundation and how it is creating real opportunities for young adults with disabilities. From DJ academies and festival performances to skydiving and flying experiences, the foundation is all about breaking down barriers and giving young people the chance to live their lives to the fullest.Together, these conversations highlight the real impact of football beyond the ninety minutes. Whether it is representing your country or creating opportunities for others, this is what community truly looks like.🔗 Get InvolvedSupport Karen’s fundraiser: https://gofund.me/479ab9ce9Learn more about The Fantastic Freddie Foundation: https://thefantasticfreddiefoundation.com/our-story⏱️ Chapters0:00 Intro and Welcome2:15 Catching Up with Karen: Parkinson’s Walking Football5:30 Growing the Community and Recent Tournaments8:45 The Road to St George’s Park12:15 The England Trial Experience15:00 Getting the Call: Joining the National Squad18:30 Fundraising for Canada: Quiz and Auction Night22:15 Amazing Auction Prizes for Sutton Fans25:45 How Football Helps Manage Parkinson’s Symptoms28:30 Introducing Charlie and the Fantastic Freddie Foundation31:15 Freddy’s Legacy: Breaking Barriers for Disabilities34:00 DJ Academy and Summer Festival Trips37:15 High Octane Adventures: Flying and Skydiving40:00 How to Volunteer and Support the Foundation42:30 Charity of the Year Highlights and Future Goals43:37 Final Thoughts and Wrap UpIf you enjoyed this episode, please like, subscribe and share to help us reach more fans.Join the conversation on social media @SuttonPodcast
  • Mental Fragility with Neil

    37:32|
    Sutton United fans… we need to talk about that Altrincham game.A bright start. A debut goal. A controlled first half.And then… three minutes that changed everything.In this episode, Mike and Neil break down a match that perfectly captures the story of Sutton’s season. From Jermaine Francis opening his account for the club to Dan Urpens stepping up on his full league debut, there were real positives to build on. But once again, the game slipped away quickly, raising the same question:👉 Is this bad luck… or mental fragility?⚽ MATCH DISCUSSIONWe dive into:A first half where Sutton looked comfortable and in controlThe turning point as two quick goals flipped the matchWhy conceding in quick succession keeps happeningAnd how one of the pre-match danger men, Olly Crankshaw, punished us twicePlus a brutally honest fan take that probably sums it up best:“The creativity we show in losing games from winning positions is nothing short of legendary…”Funny… but painfully accurate?🎤 AGI’S INTERVIEW – A MESSAGE SENTThis is where things get serious.The manager didn’t hold back post-match.He didn’t name names… but it was clear who he meant.So we ask:Is calling players out (without naming them) the right approach?Is this about standards, frustration, or something bigger?And who was that message really aimed at… the players, the fans, or the board?With talk of a major squad clear-out and bold expectations for next season, this feels like more than just a reaction to one game.🏆 AWARDS & THE BIGGER PICTUREWe also cover the end-of-season awards:Jake Taylor – Player of the YearSimper – Players’ Player & Goal of the SeasonJunior – Young PlayerKai – Supporters’ PlayerWhat do these tell us about the squad, recruitment, and the reliance on loan players?🔮 LOOKING AHEADFinal game vs Boreham WoodWill we see a reaction after that interview?Early thoughts on a summer rebuildAnd whether a top seven finish next season is realistic… or just talkPlus:Prediction League winner confirmed 🏆New fantasy format coming next season 🎮🎯 FINAL THOUGHTThis wasn’t just another defeat.👉 It felt like a breaking point.And the post-match interview might tell us more about next season… than this one.⏱️ CHAPTERS0:00 Intro and Hospitality Stories3:15 Dan Irpin's League Debut5:30 First Half Control and Francis’ Goal8:45 The Second Half Collapse12:15 Mental Fragility Debate16:00 Ref Decisions and Controversy19:30 Season Awards Round-Up23:15 Aggie’s Post-Match Interview27:45 Squad Rebuild and Expectations31:30 Boreham Wood Preview34:00 Prediction League + New Fantasy Game36:30 Final Thoughts💬 Is it mental fragility… or just one of those seasons?Let us know in the comments.👍 Like, share and subscribe to stay connected with all things Sutton United.#suttonunited #nationalleague #footballpodcast #gandergreenlane #nonleaguefootball
  • Got to be on it with Lynn & Jenny

    44:30|
    What is more frustrating… a team that cannot do it, or one you know can but just doesn’t consistently?In this episode of Sutton United Talk Time on Podcast, Mike is joined by Lynn and Jenny to break down recent matches, including Carlisle and the Surrey Senior Cup clash with Farnham.The conversation digs into Sutton United’s biggest challenge right now: consistency.“We’ve seen you do it… so why not every week?”With fewer game changers than other clubs, the margin for error is smaller, and every player needs to be performing at a high level.Lynn shares insights from following the team home and away, while Jenny brings her honest take on tactics, squad balance, and what is missing.👉 Like, subscribe, and share your thoughts👉 Follow Sutton Podcast across social media#SuttonUnited #NationalLeague #FootballPodcast
  • Wrong Sutton United with Claire & Alex

    38:24|
    What happens when a match official goes to the wrong city and your team can’t stop giving away penalties? You get a classic Sutton United Bank Holiday weekend!In this episode of the Sutton United (Surrey) Talk Time podcast, Mike Dowling is joined by Claire and Alex to recap a chaotic Easter period. We discuss the national news story of the official who ended up in Sutton Coldfield, the statistical anomaly of our 15 penalties conceded this season, and why our young squad is feeling the heat. As Claire puts it, "The only thing that has been consistent about this season is the inconsistencies". Alex adds that the resignation in the crowd during the Aldershot game was "just miserable", yet the team somehow found the grit to claw back a point.Guest Information: Claire: A regular contributor who brings the "Barbie Dreamhouse" energy and a keen eye for squad psychology.Alex: "Stato" who isn't afraid to call out the "ineptitude" when he sees it.If you enjoyed this deep dive, hit that subscribe button and give us a 5-star review! Follow the conversation on all socials @SuttonPodcast.
  • Unpredictable with Gabriel & Neil

    54:24|
    Is being a Sutton United fan the ultimate emotional test? Join host Mike Dowling alongside Gabriel and Neil as they navigate the extreme highs and lows of a packed six-game schedule. From the "nightmare" 5-0 defeat against Morecambe to a performance against league leaders Rochdale that left fans feeling "the angriest they've ever been" due to a sense of injustice—this episode covers it all.Episode Overview:We dive deep into the tactical shifts under Aggie, the "Olympico" goals, and the incredible 10-point haul from four away games. We also celebrate club legends with a look at the latest Hall of Fame inductions and debate whether a 12th-place finish would actually be a massive success given our start to the season.Notable Quotes:"It seemed to be all of the bad Sutton moments distilled into 25 minutes." — Neil"Aggie said... he’s never had a team that’s anywhere near as unpredictable as we are." — Mike DowlingGuest Information:Gabriel: Long-time supporter and match-day volunteer.Neil: Sutton United regular with a keen eye for tactical "playoff form."Love the show? Hit Subscribe, leave a review, and join the conversation with @SuttonPodcast!
  • I Don’t Want To Be 2-0 Up with Sarah & Rory

    32:55|
    Is 2–0 the most dangerous scoreline for Sutton United?In this episode of Sutton United Talk Time on Podcast, Mike is joined by Sarah and Rory to look back at three away matches for Sutton United in the National League.The trio discuss the frustrating draw at Yeovil, a resilient performance against Halifax, and a brilliant away win at Hartlepool. Along the way they break down key moments, tactical decisions, and standout performances including a remarkable defensive intervention from 18-year-old Junior.As Sarah joked during the conversation:“I said something didn’t I… I don’t want to be 2-0 up.”From defensive mistakes to moments of quality, this episode captures what it feels like to follow Sutton United through a demanding run of away fixtures.Sarah and Rory both travelled to the matches and bring the perspective of fans who experienced the games first-hand.If you enjoy Sutton United discussion, fan perspectives and honest match analysis, this episode is for you.👍 Like, subscribe and share with fellow Sutton fans.
  • We Wanted It More with Mark & Gabriel

    49:09|
    What changes when belief returns?After back-to-back home wins against Woking and Wealdstone, Sutton United finally feel like a team with direction. In this episode of Sutton United Talk Time on Podcast, Mike is joined by Gabriel and Mark to break down a dramatic 2-1 win with ten men against Woking and a composed 3-0 victory over Wealdstone.We discuss the red card resilience, the discipline debate, the tactical shift to a 4-2-2-2 shape, and why Lewis Simper might just be the heartbeat of this side again.“We wanted it as much as we wanted it in the last few games.”“That win improved the vibe around the ground.”Is momentum finally building? And what does it mean heading into Yeovil away?Subscribe for weekly Sutton United reaction and join the conversation.#SuttonUnited #SuttonPodcast #NationalLeague