Share

cover art for The Donna Noble Chronicles: The Fires of Pompeii (2008) with Clayton from 'Men Who Like Men Who Like Movies'

Review It Yourself

The Donna Noble Chronicles: The Fires of Pompeii (2008) with Clayton from 'Men Who Like Men Who Like Movies'

•

Welcome back to Review It Yourself: The Podcast with the sigh.

Film reviews for the eternally unimpressed.

Clayton from 'Men Who Like Men Who Like Movies' returns to continue The Donna Noble Chronicles. This week Sean and Clayton discuss The Fires of Pompeii (2008).


Discussion Points:

-Peeking behind the podcast curtain.

-The production values of this episode.

-"It's Doctor Who, I'm not exactly going to sit here and moan about it"-Sean shows a shocking lack of self-awareness.

-Trivia and facts about the Ancient Roman city of Pompeii.

-Clayton and Sean's opinions differ greatly regarding the new series of Doctor Who (2024), particulary costumes.

-The dynamic between The Doctor and Donna Noble.

-Marcus Nonius Balbus was a prominent figure in Herculaneum, nearby Pompeii.

-The CGI stone 'Transformers' in this episode.

-Treading the line between entertainment and being respectful to a disaster.

-The moral dilemma at the heart of this episode.

-Sean and Clayton discuss the new series of Doctor Who (2024) and their opposing opinions.

-Clayton brings controversial Indiana Jones opinion, whilst Sean shocks with his Jurassic Park opinion.


Raised Questions:

-How many times does Sean mention that he's been to Pompeii?

-What does Veni, Vidi, Vici mean?

-Why did size matter to the Romans?

-Does the TARDIS perception filter apply to clothes?

-Do you agree with Clayton that the Thirteenth Doctor dressed "like a toddler"?

-Do you miss when the Doctor had some "bite" to his character?

-Does it get chilly in Italy?

-Do you ever skip to the loo?

-Does the Gladiator II (2024) trailer make the film look like a pound-shop version of Gladiator (2000)?

-Could this episode have worked without the Pyrovillian monsters?

-Is the Chief Augur just a "Roman Mystic Meg"?

-What was the drinking age in Ancient Rome? [Apparently there was no age restriction].

-Is this peak Doctor Who?


Sean Recommends:

-Pompeii: The Last Day (BBC Docu-Drama 2003).

-Pompeii: The New Dig (BBC Series 2024).

-Torchwood (2006-2011).

-Jurassic Park: The Lost World (1997).


Clayton Recommends:

-Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (2008).

-Jurassic Park III (2001).


Apologies for some audio issues during this recording, we were using a different recording platform than normal. Lesson learned!

Thanks for Listening!


Thank you to the following for their contributions:

-Brendan and Jamie from 'The Sense Sphere' YouTube Channel.

-Brandon from 'Cinnammon Toast Crunch' YouTube Channel.

-Jon Youlden.

-Rachael from 'Chat About It Don't Shout About It' YouTube Channel.

-Satsu from 'Chatsunami' podcast.

-Luke from 'The Nerdstalgic Podcast'.

-Marc from 'Mr & Mrs Who Podcast' (contributions will be used in a future episode).


Thanks for Listening!


Review It Yourself is now on YouTube!

Find us here:

Twitter: @YourselfReview

Instagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ReviewItYourself⁠

More episodes

View all episodes

  • The Holiday (2006) Christmas Special with Clayton & Shawn from 'Men Who Like Men Who Like Movies'

    01:29:29|
    A classic episode as Sean, Clayton and Shawn dive into one of the most beloved Christmas films of all time: The Holiday (2006). Eyelid kissing, across-the-pond relationships and characters 'so English it hurts' combine to make this episode unmissable.Sean takes some time to teach Clayton and Shawn some chocolate-based English phrases.Who moved where, after the credits roll?Chapters:0:08 Christmas Special Introduction2:01 Jude Law's Charisma3:06 Love Actually vs. The Holiday9:10 Characters and Their Arcs12:37 Jack Black's Unexpected Charm21:53 Unrequited Love Reflections23:51 Iris's Transformation43:55 The Power of Friendship55:36 Emotional Climax of the Film1:12:09 Fluffy Christmas Movie Expectations1:16:13 Sweet Treats and Chocolate1:22:23 Wrapping Up the YearThanks for Listening!Find us here: X: @YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021

  • Defend It Yourself 26: Rocky IV (1985) with Dr. Erica Canela

    01:02:29|
    This [film] is 87 minutes of awesome, pure awesome! My Love for this film is so strong!Doctor Erica Canela joins Sean to discuss nothing to do with history. Opting for something completely different, Erica guests to defend the incredibly montage-filled Rocky IV (1985).Chapters:0:04 Introduction to Rocky IV4:49 The Essence of Rocky IV30:24 The Stakes of the Fight41:34 Training Montage Showdown51:02 The Final Showdown58:30 Reflection and ConclusionThanks for Listening!Find us here: X: @YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021

  • The War Game (1966 BBC Pseudo-Documentary Film) with co-host Sarah

    01:21:10|
    'The blast wave from a thermonuclear weapon has been likened to an enormous door, slamming in the depths of hell'-Narrator, The War Game.Sean and Sarah go from very silly (Sean has been eating too many Brandy-infused Mince Pies) to incredibly serious whilst discussing one of the most harrowing films they've ever seen: The 1966 BBC Nuclear War pseudo-documentary programme, The War Game. Banned from TV broadcast until 1984, when it was show alongside Threads (1984) this is a must-see film.A harrowing film showing a nuclear strike on the South of England, infused with British humour alongside horrific details of the impact of radiation, this is peak British Television.Please Note: This podcast episode contains one use of the term ‘coloured’. This is quoted directly from the film purely as part of a historical discussion and review of the film, and is not meant to cause any offence/distress. It highlights the 1960's society, which was still grappling with racial and social prejudice, and allows us to discuss the film in it's historical context.References:The V2 attack on Woolworths in London, occurred on Saturday 25th November 1944, and killed 168 people.Chapters:0:03 Welcome to the Podcast1:16 A Heavy Discussion, a Silly Start!1:56 The War Game3:48 The Impact of Nuclear War10:26 British Responses to Nuclear Threats16:32 Society's Fragility23:00 Exploring the Horrors25:43 The Psychological Toll29:10 The Aftermath of Destruction33:09 The Reality of Survival37:27 Triage and Resource Allocation42:28 The Bleak Future45:45 Children of the Fallout49:11 The Illusion of Hope53:42 Historical Context and Reflection57:54 Cautionary Tales1:01:37 Preparing for the Unknown1:06:14 The Limits of Survival1:08:21 Closing Thoughts and ReflectionsThanks for Listening!Find us here: X: @YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021

  • Titanic: Answers from the Abyss (1999 TV Documentary) with Ryan 'The Dalek Man' Wade

    01:34:35|
    What do you get when two Titanic enthusiasts get together to geek out over one of the staples of 1990's Titanic documentary: Answers from the Abyss (1999)?You get nerdy chaos.Sean is joined by Ryan 'The Dalek Man' Wade this time around. Ryan brings his insight into the documentary, the Titanic disaster and lesson learned from the tragedy... when Sean let's him get a word in that is.Chapters:1:29 Introduction to Titanic Enthusiasts15:09: A piece of Titanic (allegedly) fell off a truck37:36 Captain Smith's Role in the Titanic Disaster37:48 Exploring Titanic's Lifeboats and Safety Measures42:37 Theories on Titanic's Final Moments44:13 Investigating the Stern's Implosion and Explosion47:10 Titanic's Stern: A Hidden Tragedy49:46 Eyewitness Accounts and Historical Misunderstandings51:30 The Debate on Titanic's Final Moments53:47 Theories on the Ship's Breakup57:13 The Iceberg's Impact: A Fatal Encounter1:00:02 Lifeboat Protocols and Miscommunication1:05:52 Societal Impact of the Titanic Disaster1:06:35 Lessons Learned from Titanic1:08:33 Modern Documentaries vs. Classic Approaches1:10:50 The Personal Side of Titanic Stories1:19:16 Current Titanic Exploration Challenges1:20:57 Ryan's Titanic Model Making Journey1:27:00 Future Titanic Podcast Plans1:32:22 Wrap-Up and FarewellThanks for Listening!Find us here: X: @YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021

  • 'The Dilemma of German Actors since 1945' (2025 Zeitgeist Article) with Historian, Author and Journalist Katja Hoyer and co-host Sarah

    01:05:11|
    Katja Hoyer, German-British Historian, Author and Journalist joins Sean and Sarah to discuss the dilemma facing German actors since 1945: whether to take Nazi roles or not.They examine 'memory politics' of the Second World War, the stereotypical Nazi portrayal seen in Hollywood over the years such as Wolf Kahler, through to modern German actors like Sandra Hüller, Daniel Brühl, Franka Potente, among others.From Star Wars, Commando Comics to Coronation Street, this episode truly examines a rarely-discussed issue in films with the trademark humour that you've come to expect from Sean and Sarah, whilst maintaining a respectful tone given the historical context.Question Raised:-How quickly did this issue rear it's head in post-war Germany?-Could a German family join Coronation Street?-How many films/television series does Sean mention?-When did the stereotypical Nazi villain begin?-What was the reaction to The Untergang [Downfall] in Germany?-Do all film villains have to be either German or well-spoken English characters?-Will German topics other than the Nazis ever be of interest to the international film scene?Books:-Der Brand [The Fire] by Jörg Friedrich, published in 2002. The Song that Sean was trying to think of for 'Deutschland 83':-"Major Tom (Coming Home)" by Peter Schilling.Our Guest:https://www.katjahoyer.uk/Read The Article Here:https://www.katjahoyer.uk/p/the-nazi-dilemma-facing-german-actorsChapters:0:05 Welcome to Review It Yourself0:46 Introducing Katja Hoyer2:29 The Inspiration Behind the Article5:08 German Actors and Nazi Stereotypes6:58 Portrayals in Film10:44 The Impact of Historical Memory11:10 The Modern German Actor16:18 The Balance of Typecasting17:57 The Complexity of Nazi Depictions20:34 Female Actors and Their Roles23:17 The Challenges of Representation33:22 The Role of Nationality in Acting36:46 The Future of German Cinema41:01 Shifting Perspectives in Film57:23 Cultural Stereotypes in Modern Media1:00:48 Upcoming Projects of Katja HoyerThanks for Listening!Find us here: X: @YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021

  • Preview It Yourself 10: Christopher Nolan's Odyssey (2026) with co-host Sarah

    26:57|
    Preview It Yourself Returns! Sean and Sarah watch what Sean thought was the teaser trailer for Christopher Nolan's Odyssey (2026), before discussing his filmography. It turned out to be a concept trailer. Never mind.Do you enjoy Nolan's films or endure them?Chapters:0:07 Introduction to Odyssey Trailer0:27 Thoughts on Matt Damon2:03 Concerns About the Cast4:42 Storytelling Challenges6:58 Nolan's Recent Films9:45 Adapting Epic Poetry14:25 Trailer Impressions16:35 Character Development Issues23:57 Anticipation and Apprehension25:33 Final Thoughts and Farewell*Sean meant King Ethelstan, not Ethelstad.Thanks for Listening!Find us here: X: @YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021

  • October Sky (1999) with Luke from 'The Howdy Beans Podcast'

    01:44:04|
    Luke from 'Howdy Beans' has never seen 'October Sky' (1999). Sean wasn't having it.Chapters:0:04 Hey Luke, where's my sigh?2:03 Housekeeping and Positivity3:29 Trivia About October Sky5:18 Introducing Homer Hickam11:11 The Influence of Sputnik27:01 The Role of Education33:25 The Father-Son Dynamic38:09 Understanding Each Other44:29 The Rocket Building Journey49:00 Homer's Growth and Learning50:56 The Tuskegee Airmen film portrayals52:38 Film Cameos and Trivia55:35 The Rocket Launches Begin1:00:45 Family Dynamics and Challenges1:06:25 The Last Rocket Launch1:10:10 Inspiration and Hope1:21:05 The State of Modern CinemaThanks for Listening!X:@YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021

  • Alien 3 (1992), Alien Resurrection (1997) & Alien Romulus (2024) with Paul from 'History Rage'

    01:12:42|
    In Space No-One Can Hear You Rage, or Argue Like Hell!Paul from 'History Rage' returns to continue the Alien series, with Alien 3 (1992), Alien: Resurrection (1997) and Alien: Romulus (2024).Will Sean and Paul agree on anything in this one?Listen in to find out...Chapters:0:05 Welcome to Review It Yourself26:03 The Flaws of Alien 3 (1992)26:18 A Dive into Alien Resurrection (1997)1:01:52 The Best of the Rest? Alien Romulus (2024)1:10:14 Anticipating the Future of the Franchise1:11:09 Closing Thoughts and FarewellsThanks For Listening!X: @YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021

  • 'A Cursed Collection of Haunted Dolls' (2025 Book) with Author Fiona Dowell and co-host Sarah

    01:03:49|
    Sean and Sarah are joined by Author Fiona Dodwell to discuss her new book 'A Cursed Collection of Haunted Dolls', to try and answer the question: Can dolls truly be haunted?The Book is Out Now!Our Guest:X (Twitter): @Angel_Devil982Instagram: Fiona_Dodwell_Chapters:0:04 Introduction to Haunted Dolls6:05 The Risks of Engaging with Spirits12:38 The Cultural Perspective on Haunted Objects16:56 The Online Market for Haunted Items21:36 The Human Connection to Objects29:23 Exploring Personal Paranormal Experiences32:50 The Influence of Horror on Reality36:29 Humour in the Paranormal46:22 Rehoming Haunted Objects53:00 Collecting Stories for the Next Book58:23 Open-Mindedness in Paranormal Beliefs1:02:33 Conclusion and Future DiscussionsThanks for Listening!X:@YourselfReviewInstagram: reviewityourselfpodcast2021