Share

cover art for Ep 63. Can we make public–private collaboration work this time?

Public Sector Executive Podcast

Ep 63. Can we make public–private collaboration work this time?

Season 1, Ep. 63

It would be naïve to say that major infrastructure projects in the UK have a successful history of being delivered on time and on budget. Whilst there are many good examples of projects that have been successful in this way, the UK is still underperforming when it comes to delivery, with one of the most notable examples – the High Speed 2 rail link – still causing controversy seven years on from its commencement.

In order to explore why major infrastructure projects are failing, and how the issue can be resolved, MIGSO-PCUBED’s David Whitmore joined us on the latest episode of the PSE Podcast. David outlined the evidence that exists to support claims that the nation is underperforming when it comes to infrastructure, saying:

“There’s quite a bit of evidence, unfortunately. Probably the main piece of evidence is that the Infrastructure and Projects Authority carries out an annual review of the performance of public sector projects in the public interest, and we’ve seen consistently over the 10-12 years that they’ve been doing that review, more red in the performance of the projects and less green.

“It’s not just that our baseline performance is worse than it was 25 years ago, it would appear to be getting worse every year.”

David was also asked about the UK’s place in the world, and whether an inability to deliver major infrastructure projects was a UK-specific issue. Bringing in the example of the far-east, David said:

“For me, it’s very much a UK issue – you might argue it’s a western world issue.

“If you take the example of the civil nuclear programme, that – for me- is probably the starkest example…  About 2007 we embarked on a new nuclear programme to build 16 gigawatts of additional capacity; around the same time, the UAE started a programme to build four nuclear reactors. No contest, we’ve got 100,000 engineers and we’ve built loads of nuclear reactors, clearly we’re going to win that race.

“But here we stand today, we’ve built zero gigawatts out of that 16, two of the three projects that started have failed and are no longer in existence… yet in the UAE – using Far East partners and forming relationships with South Korean companies – they’ve built their four reactors.”

To learn more about how major infrastructure projects can be delivered successfully, listen to the latest episode of the PSE Podcast now.

More episodes

View all episodes

  • 80. Ep 80. Social Housing Decarbonisation

    30:49||Season 1, Ep. 80
    In the latest episode of the Public Sector Executive podcast, we delve into the urgent challenge of decarbonisation in social housing, a topic that has become increasingly critical in the face of climate change and rising fuel poverty. The panel of expert guests includes Simon Myers, Executive Member for Housing at North Yorkshire Council, Steve Evans, Cabinet Member for City Housing at Wolverhampton Council, and Kate Atherton, Policy Officer for the National Housing Federation. Together, they explore the multifaceted approach required to create warmer, healthier, and more affordable homes across the UK.The discussion begins with an overview of the current landscape of social housing and the imperative for decarbonisation. As Kate Atherton highlights, funding certainty is paramount. Housing associations require stable capital grants to effectively plan and implement decarbonisation projects. The panel emphasises the need for the government to confirm funding streams, such as the Warm Home Social Housing Fund, to enable housing associations to meet their targets.Simon Myers shares insights from North Yorkshire, where the council has successfully secured £22 million for retrofitting projects. He discusses the challenges of merging different housing teams and managing the regulatory landscape while also addressing the affordability gap in housing. The importance of skilled workers in the supply chain is underscored, with both Simon and Kate recognising the potential for job creation in this sector.Public perception plays a crucial role in the acceptance of greener housing designs. The panel discusses strategies to engage communities and demonstrate the benefits of retrofitting. They acknowledge that while some residents may resist change, educating them about the advantages of energy-efficient homes is essential. Case studies of successful retrofitting projects serve as powerful testimonials to the positive impact of these initiatives.As the conversation unfolds, it becomes clear that balancing the needs of tenants with the goals of decarbonisation is a complex task. The panel discusses the importance of aligning interventions with planned maintenance work to minimise disruption for tenants. They also address the broader energy reforms that may inadvertently increase fuel bills for vulnerable households.The episode concludes with a call to action for continued collaboration among housing providers, local authorities, and the government. Sharing knowledge and experiences will be vital in overcoming the challenges ahead. With ambitious targets set for retrofitting homes, the panel remains optimistic about the future of social housing in the UK.This episode is a must-listen for anyone interested in the intersection of housing, sustainability, and social equity. Tune in to gain valuable insights and learn how we can work together to create a greener future for all.
  • 79. Ep 79. Social Care at Capacity

    44:30||Season 1, Ep. 79
    In episode 79 of the Public Sector Executive podcast, we tackled the critical challenges facing social care services in the UK, a sector grappling with rising demand, tightening budgets, and a workforce crisis. Experts including Ian Turner, OBE, Hulya Mustafa, Lee Rickles, and Jane Brightman, shed light on the structural and financial pressures that are impacting service delivery and the well-being of service users.As Ian Turner highlights, the landscape of social care has evolved dramatically over the past few decades, shifting from a focus on physical disabilities to a predominant need for support for individuals with complex conditions such as dementia. This shift necessitates a new approach to care that integrates prevention and innovation, particularly through digital technology.Jane Brightman discusses the workforce challenges that have emerged, especially with international recruitment becoming increasingly difficult. The social care workforce, largely comprised of women aged 45 and over, faces unique challenges that must be addressed to ensure they are supported and adequately compensated for their vital work.The conversation also delves into the role of digital innovation in transforming social care. Hulya Mustafa emphasises that while technology is not a panacea, it offers substantial opportunities to enhance service delivery and improve user outcomes. The integration of digital records and the use of technology for proactive care, such as falls prevention systems, are just a few examples of how the sector can evolve.However, the panel acknowledges that financial pressures are significant, with social care often receiving less funding compared to the NHS. Lee Rickles points out that this disparity creates a challenging environment for providers who are expected to implement new technologies and deliver quality care without adequate resources.As the discussion progresses, the panel underscores the importance of collaboration between health and social care sectors. By working together, they can create a more cohesive system that focuses on the needs of individuals, rather than operating in silos. This holistic approach is essential for addressing the complexities of care and ensuring that service users receive the support they need.In conclusion, this episode offers invaluable insights into the current state of social care in the UK and the urgent need for reform. The panel's collective expertise provides a roadmap for moving from survival to sustainability, highlighting the crucial role of government support, workforce development, and digital innovation in shaping the future of social care. 
  • 78. Ep 78. Mental Health and Youth Services

    43:38||Season 1, Ep. 78
    Young people are increasingly facing unprecedented pressures. Thanks to this, the conversation around mental health and youth services has never been more crucial. From the cost of living crisis to the pervasive influence of social media, today’s youth are navigating challenges that can severely impact their mental well-being. In the latest episode of the Public Sector Executive podcast, we delve into these pressing issues, exploring how public sector support can be reformed to better cater to the needs of young minds.One of the key topics discussed is the potential ban on social media for under-16s, inspired by recent initiatives in Australia. While some argue that such a ban could mitigate the negative effects of social media, others highlight the importance of teaching children to navigate the online world responsibly. The panelists emphasise that a complete ban may not be the solution, as it could lead to children finding alternative ways to access these platforms, thus creating a false sense of security.The role of parents in guiding their children through the complexities of the digital landscape is another focal point of the discussion. With many parents feeling overwhelmed by technology, it’s essential to foster an environment where open conversations about online safety can take place. Educating parents about the potential dangers and how to monitor their children's online activity is vital in ensuring a safer experience for young users.Cyberbullying remains a significant concern, with the panel agreeing that banning social media won’t eliminate the issue. Instead, a more holistic approach is needed—one that recognises the blurred lines between online and offline interactions. Schools, families, and communities must work together to create a supportive environment where young people feel safe to discuss their experiences and seek help.Early intervention strategies are highlighted as crucial in addressing mental health issues before they escalate. The panel argues for a more integrated approach to youth services, advocating for a system that prioritises long-term support over short-term fixes. By investing in early help services and fostering trusted relationships between young people and adults, we can create a foundation for healthier futures.As we conclude this episode, it becomes clear that addressing youth mental health requires a collective effort. By rethinking our approach to mental health services, prioritising education, and fostering open dialogue, we can better support our young people in navigating the complexities of their lives. Tune in to hear more insights from our expert panel and join the conversation around this vital topic.
  • 77. Ep 77. Libraries, Leisure and Loss

    42:48||Season 1, Ep. 77
    In an age where digital services are becoming the norm, the importance of civic infrastructure has never been more pronounced. In the latest episode of the PSE Podcast, guests delved into the critical role that libraries and other public spaces play in fostering community health, education, and social cohesion.The expert panel, featuring Sharon Sanders from the City of Bradford Metropolitan District Council, Ian Moore from Libraries Connected, and Ian Varra from Vision Redbridge Culture and Leisure, discusses how these spaces have evolved to meet the needs of diverse populations.One of the key themes of the episode is the concept of libraries as trusted spaces within communities. As more services move online, many residents still rely on physical locations to access essential services. Sharon Sanders emphasises that libraries are crucial for digital inclusion, providing a safe environment where individuals can seek support without feeling judged. This is especially vital for those who may not have access to technology or the internet at home.The discussion also highlights the innovative models that councils are adopting to sustain and reimagine public spaces. Ian Moore points out that libraries are transforming into inclusive community hubs, focusing on literacy, digital access, and wellbeing. By integrating various services, libraries can serve as a one-stop shop for residents, offering everything from employment support to cultural activities.Moreover, the panel addresses the importance of collaboration between local authorities and community organisations. Ian Varra shares insights on how his organisation has worked to break down silos, creating a more integrated approach to service delivery. This collaboration is essential for ensuring that resources are allocated effectively, particularly in times of financial pressure.As the conversation unfolds, the panellists explore the concept of social value in procurement. They argue that understanding the broader impact of libraries and community services is crucial for securing funding and support. By articulating the value these spaces bring to the community, stakeholders can advocate for sustainable investment in civic infrastructure.Ultimately, this episode serves as a reminder that libraries and public spaces are not just about books; they are vital community resources that promote social inclusion, digital access, and overall wellbeing. As we navigate the challenges of modern society, it is essential to recognise and support the evolving role of these spaces in our communities.
  • 76. Ep 76. AI and Machine Learning

    34:03||Season 1, Ep. 76
    In an era where technology is rapidly evolving, public services in the UK are not left behind. The latest podcast episode delves into the transformative power of artificial intelligence and how it is redefining service delivery across local councils. With the potential to save up to £45 billion annually, AI is emerging as a critical tool for enhancing efficiency and effectiveness in public services.Our expert panel, comprising leaders from various councils and organisations, discusses the myriad benefits that AI brings to the table. From smart chatbots that streamline customer interactions to automated administrative processes that reduce the burden on social workers, the applications of AI are vast and varied. Vic Pool, Executive Portfolio Holder for Transformation at West Berkshire Council, shares a compelling example of how AI has improved the efficiency of social care by automating the retrieval of legislative updates. This innovation allows social workers to focus more on client care rather than administrative tasks, ultimately enhancing service delivery.However, the discussion does not shy away from the challenges associated with AI adoption. Risks such as data security, bias, and the ethical implications of using AI in decision-making are critically examined. Tim Spiers from Cambridge County Council highlights the importance of managing these risks while embracing the opportunities that AI presents. The panel stresses the need for transparency and proper training to ensure that staff are equipped to use AI responsibly.Moreover, the conversation touches on the need for local governments to invest wisely in technology. With budgets often stretched thin, identifying the right tools that can deliver quick wins is essential. David Terrar of the Tech Industry Forum emphasises the importance of foundational technologies and processes over flashy new tools. This pragmatic approach is crucial for councils looking to maximise their investments in AI.As the episode unfolds, listeners are encouraged to consider the broader implications of AI in public services. The discussion highlights the potential for AI to not only improve efficiency but also to enhance the human element of service delivery. By freeing up staff from mundane tasks, AI can enable a shift from administration to care, ultimately benefiting the communities served.In conclusion, this episode is a must-listen for anyone interested in the intersection of technology and public service. It offers valuable insights into how AI can be harnessed to create a more efficient, effective, and responsive public sector. 
  • 75. Ep 75. EV Infrastructure

    29:47||Season 1, Ep. 75
    In the latest episode of the Public Sector Executive Podcast, experts delve into the world of electric vehicles.If you want to learn more about how EV infrastructure can be rolled out more successfully across the country, listen to episode 75 of the PSE Podcast now!
  • 74. Ep 74. Kate Hand - London Councils

    15:19||Season 1, Ep. 74
    In the latest episode, we explore the critical topic of climate financing with Kate Hand, Head of Climate Change at London Councils, who delivered an inspiring keynote at the Greening the Public Sector event. With a staggering £35 billion pipeline of projects, London is leading the way in developing innovative strategies to tackle climate change at the local level.Kate highlights the evolution of local climate financing over the past five years, detailing how boroughs have come together to create a robust framework for attracting investment. By understanding the assets under their control and identifying essential projects, councils are now in a position to tell a compelling story about their ambitions for a sustainable future.One of the key takeaways from Kate's insights is the importance of collaboration among boroughs. For the first time, councils can see all the projects in their neighbouring boroughs, fostering a spirit of shared learning and cooperation. This collaborative approach is vital for accelerating progress and ensuring that resources are used efficiently.Kate also discusses the need for long-term delivery models that can adapt to the evolving climate landscape. The shift from a net zero projects pipeline to a green growth pipeline exemplifies this approach, as it integrates climate initiatives into broader growth strategies. By focusing on delivering tangible benefits for communities, councils can garner the support and buy-in needed for successful climate action.Moreover, the episode addresses the financial realities that boroughs face, with many struggling to balance their budgets while investing in climate action. Kate emphasises the need for innovative financing solutions, such as aggregating smaller projects into larger portfolios that can attract investment. This strategy not only secures funding but also generates returns that can be reinvested into essential services.As we move forward, the conversation around climate financing must include diverse stakeholders, from climate officers to finance directors. By clarifying responsibilities and fostering collaboration, London can create a cohesive strategy that addresses both immediate needs and long-term sustainability goals.Tune in to this episode to hear more about how London Councils is navigating the complexities of climate financing and leading the charge towards a greener future.
  • 73. Ep 73. AI and Machine Learning

    33:30||Season 1, Ep. 73
    In this enlightening episode, we explore the transformative impact of AI and Machine Learning on public services in the UK. Hosted by Tanya Arnold, we explore how these technologies are transforming service delivery, improving efficiency, and generating substantial savings for local councils. Join our expert panel as they discuss the benefits, risks, and ethical considerations surrounding the adoption of AI in public sector operations.
  • 72. Ep 72. Educate to Deliver

    28:58||Season 1, Ep. 72
    In the fast-paced world of technology, the question arises: are we keeping our workforce equipped with the necessary digital skills? In the latest episode of the Public Sector Executive Podcast, a panel of experts tackled this pressing issue, discussing the importance of digital transformation in public services and the strategies needed to ensure staff are not left behind.The conversation featured prominent voices including Hillary Reid from Ayrshire College, Sarah Chamberlain from BCP Council, Laura Cooper from Norfolk County Council, and Penny Syddall from Dorset Council. Together, they explored how digital skills are crucial for successful transformation and how organisations can foster a culture of empowerment and inclusion.One of the key takeaways from the discussion was the role of 'digital champions' – individuals within organisations who possess the knowledge and experience to support their colleagues in navigating technology. Sarah Chamberlain highlighted the significance of these champions in demystifying technology, stating, 'Tech can be frightening to people. What we're really trying to do is make it a thing that belongs to all of us.' This approach aims to alleviate the anxiety often associated with digital tools and encourages a more collaborative atmosphere.The episode also addressed the importance of leadership in driving cultural change. Leaders must foster an environment where innovation and digital literacy are prioritised. As Penny Siddle pointed out, 'When we launched this project, we wondered if we would get pushback from services, but it helps frontline services do their role better.' By integrating digital skills training into everyday practices, organisations can enhance efficiency and improve service delivery.Moreover, the discussion touched upon the necessity of tailored training programmes that cater to the unique needs of staff. Laura Cooper emphasised the value of one-on-one support, stating, 'We take a very human first and empathetic approach to how we're working with our tech-terrified colleagues.' This personalised approach not only boosts confidence but also encourages employees to embrace new technologies rather than shy away from them.As we look to the future, the guests agreed that critical thinking will be an essential skill in navigating the digital landscape. With the rise of AI and automation, the ability to discern and question information will become increasingly important. This forward-thinking perspective is vital for ensuring that the workforce is not only skilled but also adaptable to the evolving demands of the digital age.