Share

Pilgrims Podcast
Game of Two Alves
Season 1, Ep. 240
•
Archie & Mark quiz Tom and Sam on Argyle’s eventually comfortable win over Alvechurch in the FA Cup 1st Round.
An underwhelming first half left the home fans with more questions than answers, but the Greens made no mistake dispatching their visitors with 4 second half goals.
Whilst order had already been restored, Tom Cleverley gave minutes to players with points to prove, in Ronan Curtis and Michael Baidoo and they each responded by filling the onion bag, with Baidoo in particular offering some hope that his Argyle story may yet go full circle.
More episodes
View all episodes

241. Steel Can’t Score
01:10:47||Season 1, Ep. 241Another heavy defeat, another game without a goal. Time for a head loss, or are the themes across our recent run so different that it's hard to define one? Archie is joined by Alex and Chris to dissect a game that was the joy of one goal 'better' than an infamous Wayne Rooney cluster.The first half, while not great, was far from bad. At least two clear-cut chances, multiple threatening attacks, leading in all the attacking stats (if that's your thing) and playing some great football. But one corner later and, at half-time, it's all been for nothing. Curtis escaping a certain red card was not capitalised on, but you wouldn't have been alone in thinking the second half could be positive.Instead, defensive errors and a continuation of our attacking profligacy meant things went from bad to worse. Even a flurry of late substitutions made little to no difference. 3-0 flattered the home side, but at the same time, after a run of league games in which we've conceded multiple goals and scored very few, if any, can we really complain? My brain hurts.Part 2 digs into that point in a little more detail. ForestGreenDean asks the panel what they would do if they were in a position to review the injury crisis. It's a varied debate that takes on the bigger challenges, with 21st-century super-fitness bumping up against the obvious fact that being without key players in key positions can never help. This moves further into the macro with a review of the season to date. Does the league position flatter or undermine the work done off the field? Is the head coach responsible when things are bad but not to be praised when things are good (and vice versa)? Are we all a little too reactive? Not one that will be resolved, but certainly worthy of discussion and debate.Next stop, lowly Peterborough at home and two more 'easy' games. What could possibly go wrong?
239. Hall0-0ween
01:12:04||Season 1, Ep. 239A nil-nil draw! A rarity in the modern game, but not without incident. Point gained or two dropped? Archie is joined by Chris, Dan and Mark to see if a lack of goals at either end can finally get the Pilgrims Podcast under an hour.It started well, with Argyle on the front foot after a late enforced change in goal, but with no goals to show for it. Some great football, especially from the reborn Amaechi, perhaps deserved something more. Then Reading had a couple of chances (including the clearest opportunity of the game) and, from there, it was a little stop-start. In amongst that, a couple of errors – the goalkeeper kicking his own post and Mitchell turning on the afterburners to recover from a mistake – went unpunished. 0-0 at half-time felt about right.The second half was scrappy, with both teams playing their part, as did the sudoku-loving, pub quiz-winning referee. A shot from acres of space that hit the post was about all either side had to show for a lot of effort and a lot of cancelling each other out. Praise for Mitchell and Joe Edwards rounds things off on a positive note. Maybe, every once in a while, a point at home is okay.Part 2 starts with a listener question relating to the screening (or not) of 3 pm kick-offs. Are we all, deep down, missing a pre-technology age of jumpers for goalposts and flat caps from the factory? Or are we all fighting a losing battle when, like it or not, legally or otherwise, anyone with a laptop can watch anything they want? Keep the questions coming; we really love answering them.Finally, thoughts turn to a home FA Cup tie against Alvechurch and, potentially, an extended run without games, subject to the international break. And Parkway live on TV! Who'd have thought it?A quick shout-out to a magnificent Argyle USA weekend in Plymouth, Massachusetts, and we're over an hour again.Typical.
238. Exclusive ft. Paul Berne Pt. 2
33:08||Season 1, Ep. 238In this Pilgrims Podcast exclusive, Archie and Tom sit down with Plymouth Argyle Chief Executive Paul Berne for Part Two of their special two-part interview.In Part Two, the conversation turns to the controversy surrounding Argyle’s women’s team, with Paul addressing the “sacked by email” headlines and explaining the financial realities behind the decision. He reflects on where the club could have handled things better, the public reaction that followed and the impact on the women’s side, as well as the challenges of rebuilding trust and support.The discussion then moves to the wider financial state of football, drawing on the latest Independent Football Regulator report to explore rising operating costs, increasing wages and the impact of parachute payments. Bringing things back to Argyle, he looks at the club’s five-year ambitions and whether the Championship football remains realistic in the ever-changing financial landscape, outlining the thinking behind recruitment, squad cost controls and January planning, as well as the potential for investment.
237. TC Takes a Punt
01:34:34||Season 1, Ep. 237Alex, Archie, Mark and Tom pour over Argyle’s success away at Cambridge in response to two straight defeats.A timely formation change was no silver bullet, as the defence was still complacent but Amaechi and Evans shone unshackled by the 442, and Cleverley’s men appeared to be effective in attack still despite one fewer player up the pitch - both from open play and set pieces.The panel discuss what the extra feather in the cap means for the team’s prospects going forward, and later dive into another listener’s question.
236. Exclusive ft. Paul Berne Pt. 1
32:09||Season 1, Ep. 236In this Pilgrims Podcast exclusive, Archie and Tom sit down with Plymouth Argyle Chief Executive Paul Berne for a special two-part interview.In Part One, they discuss Paul’s transition from a non-footballing career into the world of football and the public eye. Looking back on his first year as CEO, they explore the challenges of getting to grips with Argyle’s perilous financial situation so early in his tenure, as well as the major decision to stick with Tom Cleverley before subsequently appointing Derek Adams as Director of Football.Paul then talks in detail about the restructuring he oversaw and how it proved key to Argyle’s upturn in results last season. Bringing things up to the present day, he explains the thinking behind Derek Adams’ new role as Sporting Director and David Fox’s expanded role as Head of Football Operations and Recruitment, outlining their respective responsibilities and what the changes mean for the club going forward.Stay tuned for Part Two, which will be released on Wednesday morning, when the conversation turns to the Argyle’s women’s team, the current financial state of the club, the club’s transfer policy and the latest on potential investment.
235. Terrierable
01:09:49||Season 1, Ep. 235Tom, Mark and James discuss a third home defeat of the season for Argyle, and it was lucky that it was only 2-0 thanks to the brilliant Murphy Cooper.The panel discuss another failure to play against a back three, some poor individual displays, and confusing selections and tactical choices.
234. Our Lord & Xavier
01:28:59||Season 1, Ep. 234Having been in the stands twice in as many Saturdays, Archie is joined by Alex and Tom, with James Greenacre guesting also, to dissect another three points for Tom Cleverley's side at AFC Wimbledon's expense.With Archie having sat alongside Tom in the Moanflower, Alex as Arnie Pie In The Sky, and James in the away end wearing blue and yellow - the panel give their two pennies worth on an unusually flat atmosphere, a game in the balance between two imperfect sides, the Wombles' number nine and Argyle's makeshit and lack thereof, a super Cooper display and a beautifully bizarre winning goal from impact sub Xavier Amaechi to keep the Greens top of the League One table. James gives an update on goings on at Plymouth Albion, who are also leading the way in Rugby Union's National League One, and of whom he is now the CEO. There's also an update on whether anyone else is joining Tom and Archie on HMS Piss The League, and Alex throws a quiz into the mix. Geddon.
233. Eleyted: Summits Happening
01:19:27||Season 1, Ep. 233The best away team in the league are at it again with a convincing performance and 2-0 win in East London. Archie is joined by Chris, Mark, Sam and Seve to relish the details.The first half was a scrappy affair, with two changes enforced by contracts and injuries. Lots of Orient possession with very little threat slowly started to fade, with a couple of chances for Irow (not Eyebrow, Miami moron) giving a sense of what may be coming after half-time. Special praise for a solid back four, especially Ross, who belied his role as back-up with a confident performance.And it was Ross chaos (Chaross?) that led to a deserved opener in the second half. A good corner, some pinball and the easiest of finishes for Bim, in the right place at the right time. And within five minutes, a second that exemplified Argyle at their best: pressure, quick movement, a wonderful first-time cross and a header straight out of the Dixie Dean era. From that moment, it never really felt in doubt. Minutes for substitutes, including a reminder of Jack McKenzie’s existence, and, to use a hateful phrase, strong game management saw the game to its inevitable conclusion. A purring review of a purring performance and, after a baby break in Bavaria, it’s back for Part 2.Two great questions from TheGalah frame Part 2. The first explores the challenges of balancing first-team success with the development of youth players, and the second the future and current lowly position of the ladies’ team after coming so close to promotion last year. Wouldn’t be Argyle if we didn’t bring a little bit of DOOOOM to balance the frothy euphoria.Finally, thoughts turn to the Autoglass Papa Jersey Mike’s trip to Newport and how ‘seriously’ the club should take it, and the upcoming home game against Wimbledon.Can’t wait.