Share
Peter York's Culture Wars House Party
Joe Uscinski and Hugo Drochon: Who’s Afraid of the Great Replacement?
Season 3, Ep. 1
•
Joe Uscinski and Hugo Drochon started looking at conspiracies before they became de rigueur in 2016 and asked whether there are any links to democratic outcomes. Joe is a professor of political science at the University of Miami, and who says that conspiracy theories are "often for losers" (but let him explain ….) Hugo is an associate professor of political theory at the University of Nottingham, and he once bought a ticket to a David Icke show in the name of research. Before Brexit, his Cambridge team was already polling Britain's appetite for conspiracy, and the results made uncomfortable reading.
We trace the Great Replacement theory from a French château to Charlottesville to Parliament Square, and ask why one idea fits so many countries. Who is supposedly being replaced, by whom, and why? Who believes it, and who has thought it through? We also ask whether anyone can be argued out of it, or whether these beliefs sit in "a little black box" that facts never reach. And we reveal what 23% of respondents on both sides of the pond firmly believe in.
And I get some podcast advice to up my numbers – apparently David Icke can teach me a thing or two.
Please do check out my latest book, A Dead Cat On Your Table – available online and in all good book shops.
@peteryork.bsky.social
More episodes
View all episodes
19. Sarah Churchwell: American Myths, British Nostalgia and the Far Right
01:01:57||Season 2, Ep. 19Sarah Churchwell is an American cultural historian who has spent years unpicking the stories the United States tells about itself — from Gone with the Wind to The Great Gatsby — and noticing, with growing unease, how those myths echo in today’s politics. A professor of American literature and public understanding of the humanities at the School of Advanced Study, University of London, she argues that the American Revolution is “unfinished business” and for the last 40 years America has been running “an undeclared political experiment” and Donald Trump is “a symptom of what’s going wrong with America.”We trace the history from slavery to widespread segregation – not just in the south – and laws which the Nazis thought “went a little bit too far for them”, and on to judicial coups. So, what of us? Did America learn its white supremacism at our knee? Are we now following their playbook wrapping our imperial fantasies in Union Jacks, poppies and Dunkirk. And are we now learning “the lesson of Hungary”?Please do check out my latest book, A Dead Cat On Your Table – available online and in all good book shops.@peteryork.bsky.social18. Kate Ferguson: Before the Violence Starts
01:05:28||Season 2, Ep. 18Kate Ferguson co-founded Protection Approaches after working on genocide prevention in Rwanda — and noticing, with some alarm, that the warning signs looked oddly familiar back home. She's a foreign policy strategist working to stop mass violence before it starts, by raising the alarm on how identity grievance is weaponised to cause harm.She's just finished consulting 250 security and defence experts across Europe on the threats we face, and she comes bearing a dread trio — a homegrown far-right which has "breached thresholds of concern" including a "pogrom in Belfast"; Russian aggression; and a third that would have been unthinkable even a year ago — the United States itself, now "demonstrably practising from an authoritarian playbook."So what can be done? Should social cohesion be part of our critical infrastructure rather than a "nice to have"? Is the "hollowing out of the BBC" damaging to that cohesion? And is the point of politics to change the world — or is that an old trope?Please do check out my latest book, A Dead Cat On Your Table – available online and in all good book shops.@peteryork.bsky.social17. Peter Tatchell: Gay Liberation to the Trans Culture Wars - "Not Over by a Long Shot"
01:02:32||Season 2, Ep. 17Peter Tatchell is Britain's most recognisable gay rights activist. He traces five decades of culture wars: from a teenage firebrand in 1960s Australia, inspired by the Black civil rights movement, via Communist East Berlin, to today — and "why things are not over by a long shot."We talk about how LGBT+ rights, and especially trans rights, got turned into frontline ammunition in the modern culture wars. Who's really behind the anti-trans movement? Why Tatchell believes it's being steered from the right. And what the Supreme Court ruling actually says — as opposed to what you've been confidently told it says.Along the way, Tatchell explains why he thinks the hate and disinformation machine has gone into overdrive — and why he believes we are heading into a "very, very dark period" for democracy.Please do check out my latest book, A Dead Cat On Your Table – available online and in all good book shops.@peteryork.bsky.social16. Prof Rob Ford: Why the Radical Right Wins by Losing
01:08:47||Season 2, Ep. 16Rob Ford, professor of politics at Manchester University, has been a long-time watcher of the BNP, UKIP, Brexit and now Reform UK — explaining who these new right-wing insurgents really are, and why they're suddenly everywhere.We find out why "the numbers game matters", why he thinks we're in "the most unstable moment", and explore the great whirlpool of resentment that immigration only partly explains.Along the way: brand management, manufactured authenticity, and a cautionary tale about what happens when an ambitious academic reads his audience a little too well – "the brand has also become a prison."But there are reasons to be cheerful too — Farage's "Chitty Chitty Bang Bang" Reform model may be far less roadworthy than Trump's Rolls Royce.Please do check out my latest book, A Dead Cat On Your Table – available online and in all good book shops.@peteryork.bsky.social15. Professors Sam Friedman and Aaron Reeves: Myths and Realities of the British Elite
01:01:26||Season 2, Ep. 15Professors Sam Friedman and Aaron Reeves of the London School of Economics, authors of Born to Rule – a forensic, often very funny X‑ray of the British establishment, drawn from that venerable directory of importance, Who’s Who. They’ve tracked thousands of the people who matter to discover who really holds power, how they got it, and why they’d rather you thought they were “just ordinary”. We talk about the “elite within the elite” (how many do you reckon there are?); the three factions inside the elite who “are contesting what Britain should look like” – and how that’s shifting; the importance of being “meritocratically legitimate”; and how the privately educated Nigel Farage manages to pull it off.Please do check out my latest book, A Dead Cat On Your Table – available online and in all good book shops.@peteryork.bsky.social14. Gabriel Gatehouse: How the Weird Stuff Took Over Politics
01:06:32||Season 2, Ep. 14Gabriel Gatehouse is a former BBC international correspondent, a "Groucho Marx member" of the British establishment, and creator of The Coming Storm — the podcast and book that mapped the deep roots of American conspiracy culture from the Clinton wars to QAnon (was it kind of true?).We explore his view from fifteen turbulent months of Trump's second term — America as "empire in decline," Britain scrambling for new alliances — his unexpected detour into the "bonkers subject" of UFO documentaries, and what the Epstein files tell us about how power actually works at the very top.On Putin's view of Trump he's happy to speculate: "a useful idiot." On whether the weird stuff is still driving politics or has simply become Republican Party orthodoxy — that's where it gets complicated. Please do check out my latest book, A Dead Cat On Your Table – available online and in all good book shops.@peteryork.bsky.social13. Bonnie Greer on Trump, Power and "Post-America"
01:04:55||Season 2, Ep. 13Bonnie Greer is a Chicago‑born playwright, critic and public intellectual who has spent forty years decoding Britain from the inside—and America from a wary distance. From movies to Question Time, from Chicago to the upper reaches of British cultural life, she has watched the American dream and the British establishment at very close quarters. From Trump as a ‘mook’ to the politics of protecting “my stuff” and the possibilities of constitutional loopholes, Bonnie tells us how it is—what might really be happening to America, what the British never say out loud, and what it means to be standing on the edge of a “post‑America” world.Please do check out my latest book, A Dead Cat On Your Table – available online and in all good book shops.@peteryork.bsky.social12. Marci Shore on Fear, History, and the Future of US Democracy
51:40||Season 2, Ep. 12Professor Marci Shore is a Yale historian of Eastern Europe, a scholar of 20th‑century totalitarianism, and, in her own words, “an early panicker”. We trace her journey from the archive to the front line of political alarm: her Titanic feeling the morning after the 2016 election, and the “epistemological advantages” of studying fascism. We talk about the fantasy of America versus its reality, and whether this is the end of the affair with Europe. We unpack the new techniques of power, the shameless lack of concealment, and what history tells us about the moment we’re living through—why denial is the West’s most dangerous luxury, and whether there is still time to act.Please do check out my latest book, A Dead Cat On Your Table – available online and in all good book shops.@peteryork.bsky.social