Share

cover art for How much is too much sport on TV?

The 42FM

How much is too much sport on TV?

Season 2, Ep. 93
•

Sinead O’Carroll and Niall Kelly are in reflective form after a highly-anticipated sporting weekend fell flat.


The pair were left questioning their life choices after the All-Ireland hurling final, Open Championship and World Cup final, replete with half-time show, failed to deliver.


The expected buoyant mood which would carry through the week on foot of Super Sunday did not materialise. And if your mood is determined by the quality of sport on TV, do you need to reassess your priorities?


Or are we in too deep; in thrall to live sport on TV every weekend, and a lot of nights during the week? Are we forever destined to plan our lives around our favorite teams and games to a degree that has become all pervasive in the era of seasons that don’t end and more matches and events than ever being broadcast?

More episodes

View all episodes

  • The Lost Sportswriter: Vincent Hogan interview

    01:10:47|
    Sinead O’Carroll and Niall Kelly are joined by the much-admired sportswriter for a far-reaching chat.Vincent talks about the privilege and pressure of covering the Olympic games across the decades for the Irish Independent.And he explains how the GAA has changed - from being an organisation where a journalist such as himself could sit in a dug out for an All-Ireland final, to one where access is tightly controlled by cautious managers.Vincent explains what has been lost by the culture of secrecy, how it became harder to do the job to the desired standard, and why the reader and supporter of Gaelic games has suffered in that they do not know the players, in all of their colour and contradictions, like previous generations.Yet he remains an optimist, and says the best sports writers are at work today - and given just a little access, can turn around work which stands the test of time.
  • 103. Ireland-Israel: a fraught weekend, the aftermath and Part II

    54:58||Season 2, Ep. 103
    Sinéad O’Carroll is joined by David Sneyd, who has returned from a tumultuous few days in Debrecen with the Ireland football team.There is much to discuss, including the curious suggestion of this being a ‘media-created’ story.How will the team and Gavin Bazunu be received on Thursday night at the Aviva Stadium?Is there a chance that this Sunday’s game, Ireland’s ‘home’ tie with Israel in Serbia, could be boycotted by Ireland players? Or is the appetite for more tension-filled days and nights in the meantime not there?Also, did agents lean on players to fulfill the fixture last Sunday? Why was the game refereed so leniently? And was the football unimportant, or did it matter in the end?
  • 102. Ireland’s Nations League games against Israel

    49:10||Season 2, Ep. 102
    Ireland will play Israel twice in the coming weeks, despite widely articulated concern and protest over the fixtures. Niall Kelly and Sinead O’Carroll discuss the background to these games, how they came about, and why they will go ahead despite the misgivings of many supporters.The pair discuss previous stories that have been at the intersection of sport and news and politics and explain why this is by far the most contentious in recent decades.With Uefa, the FAI and Irish government opting against making a stand or ruling on the fixtures, the responsibility for protest has cascaded down to the players. We ask if it is fair or realistic for a professional footballer to become the face of dissent against these games going ahead and, as a consequence, the highest profile sporting opponent of Israel.We detail how the media has decided to cover the games, and the policy of The 42 and The Journal.
  • 101. Lowry or Trump: whose star shone brightest at the Irish Open?

    41:15||Season 2, Ep. 101
    Niall Kelly is back from Doonbeg to tell Sinéad O’Carroll about a golf tournament like few others.It was a bizarre weekend in Co Clare, which juxtaposed The US president and all of the associated security hardware and personnel with a run of four extraordinary rounds of golf from Shane Lowry.The Offaly man did not just defeat the field, he demolished it, 11 shots clear of second place.What will we think about in years to come when looking back on this Irish Open, the extraordinary entrance and presence of Donald Trump, or the immaculate links play from Lowry?
  • 100. Does the GAA have an AFL problem?

    45:19||Season 2, Ep. 100
    Declan Bogue joins Sinéad O’Carroll and Niall Kelly as the lure of Australia proves strong for many young footballers.The GAA, says Sinead, have been ‘getting their knickers in a twist’ about the prospect of yet more talented players swapping Ireland for a life of sunshine, flat whites and professionalism in Melbourne and other Australian cities. But should they?With Kobe McDonald signed up with St Kilda, and combines in Ireland attracting top talent, while AFL clubs continue to target successful U20 sides, what can be done? Not very much, suggest our panel, adding that a more pertinent question might be why would you even consider ways to prevent professional opportunities to young people?Are suggestions of limiting the flow of players essentially illegal? And is the idea of compensating clubs or counties antithetical to the GAA’s amateur ethos?And will the flow of players, in the men’s game at least, always be limited by the demand from Australia, where there are hundreds of thousands of players in the sport’s pyramid, most of them trained in the skills of the game from childhood?
  • 99. SNAP REACTION: Katie Taylor bows out with Croke Park fairytale victory

    22:13||Season 2, Ep. 99
    Niall Kelly, Sinéad O'Carroll and Gavan Casey provide immediate reaction from Croke Park after one of the greatest nights in the history of Irish sport.
  • 98. Who is the real Katie Taylor, and what does she mean to the Irish public?

    49:23||Season 2, Ep. 98
    Gavan Casey joins Sinead O’Carroll and Niall Kelly to discuss how Katie Taylor sold out Croke Park.At some point during the 20 years the Bray woman has been a public figure, she has gone from being widely respected to loved. But why is this the case for someone who has rarely bared her soul? Gavan makes the point that she has in fact done this time and again - in the ring. And in the process has displayed a purity of spirit that is at once alien to us and inspiring.He talks about the quiet aura Taylor carries, how people almost stand to attention when she enters a room.Gavan details the injury that has blighted her for years and explains why she would have been far further ahead of the field than she already is with a clean bill of health. And it was in overcoming that hindrance, while facing formidable opponents, that she became a singular figure that can move 80,000 tickets on a Saturday night at the spiritual home of Irish sport.
  • 97. How important is Troy Parrott’s Spanish transfer for Irish football?

    47:29||Season 2, Ep. 97
    Sinéad and Niall welcome The 42’s football correspondent David Sneyd to the show to reflect on arguably the biggest Irish transfer in years.With Parrott in line to make his Real Betis debut tonight, David charts the Dubliner’s path from Belvedere to Seville, and breaks down some of the key reasons why Betis won the race for the Irish star ahead of competition in England and beyond.Davd is also on hand to answer some of Sinéad and Niall’s most pressing questions.Where will the Irishman fit into former Manchester CIty and Real Madrid manager Manuel Pellegrini’s plans? How will he adapt to the step-up in quality from the Eredivisie to La Liga? And perhaps most importantly, what would represent a successful debut season in Spain for the 24-year-old?There’s also time to zoom out and take a broader look at the future of the Irish national team, the importance of sports psychology and the implications of Brexit for young players looking to reach the highest level.
  • 96. Will Katie Taylor’s Croke Park homecoming be shown on RTÉ?

    49:30||Season 2, Ep. 96
    With less than three weeks to go until Katie Taylor’s sold-out Croke Park homecoming, negotiations regarding the TV broadcast rights are still ongoing. Subscription broadcaster Dazn holds the exclusive rights for fight night – but could RTÉ or Virgin Media strike a late deal to ensure that this momentous night of Irish sport is broadcast free-to-air on terrestrial TV?Sinéad O’Carroll brings Niall Kelly up to speed on the latest state of play in the broadcast negotiations, which look set to come to a head this week, before the pod discusses the existing free-to-air legislation which designates certain sporting events as “of major importance to society”.What events rightly belong on the list, and where should the line be drawn between government intervention and encroaching on a vital revenue stream for sport’s governing bodies and stakeholders?And how does free-to-air legislation survive in a broadcasting landscape that’s becoming increasingly fractured and commercialised? Is it more important than ever or on borrowed time?