Share

cover art for Madison Murder Mystery

Nightmare Next Door

Madison Murder Mystery

Everyone in Madison, WI, is shocked when Joel Marino is stabbed to death in broad daylight. No one can imagine who'd want to do in this sociable salesman, and the predator seems one step ahead of police until an unexpected twist leads to capture.

More episodes

View all episodes

  • What to Listen to Next - Scorned: Love Kills

    40:26|
    This season of Nightmare Next Door is over, but we've got another ID podcast we think you'll like called Scorned: Love Kills.Scorned: Love Kills is shocking, true stories about the dark side of love. In every episode, listen to reporters, law enforcement and psychologists investigate crimes of betrayal and murder, with direct audio from ID’s hit TV show, Scorned: Love Kills. Listen to episode 1 of the new season now, and follow Scorned: Love Kills wherever you get your podcasts.
  • Murder in the Night

    41:08|
    A triple murder leaves 3 members of a church-going family dead, residents of Lancaster, Pennsylvania are shaken to their cores. With few clues at the crime scene, the search leads detectives on a wild goose chase.
  • Bloodshed in Biloxi

    41:53|
    Panic spreads through a Mississippi town when Lynette Jarrett disappears. With no body and little evidence, no one can solve this mystery. Only when a secret is revealed do detectives unravel a tale of deadly obsession that leads them to one greedy guy.
  • Death in the Dark

    43:23|
    When Audrey Giannotti is found shot to death in her basement apartment her family is horrified. Who would kill a hardworking mother in quiet Laureldale, PA? The cluttered crime scene points to a robbery gone wrong, police suspect someone close to Audrey.
  • The Art of Murder

    41:14|
    As 22-year-old Kristin Huggins is about to make her artistic debut she suddenly disappears. Soon it's clear that the painter from PA had a brush with disaster in nearby NJ. Despite their best efforts, it takes cops quite some time to catch her killer.
  • Small Town Secret

    41:14|
    When young Kari Nixon goes missing while on a snack run, no one in her upstate New York town can imagine why anyone would harm her. With no body and few clues, detectives struggle to solve the mystery until a twist leads police to an unlikely killer.
  • Highway to Hell

    41:25|
    When 18-year-old Lisa Kimmell goes missing on a desolate Wyoming highway, her family is frantic. But when a fisherman reels in a grisly discovery, the mystery takes a sinister turn and the search for a young girl becomes the hunt for an evil predator.
  • Fallen Star

    43:10|
    When beloved wife and mother Starr Harris is savagely murdered in the woods behind her home, the trees hide more than just the killer's identity. The cold-blooded killing rocks tiny Drummonds, TN, but soon determined cops uncover a smoking gun.