cover art for Who's going to win the "£2,000" debate?

The New Statesman podcast | politics, ideas and interviews

Who's going to win the "£2,000" debate?

Starmer and Sunak went head to head for the first time last night in their TV debate. Did we learn anything new? Not particularly. But the story dominating the headlines today is Sunak's claim that people would pay around £2,000 more in tax if Labour wins the election. He said that figure had been calculated by "independent Treasury officials". Starmer called this "garbage".

So who's telling the truth?

Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by political correspondent Freddie Hayward, and senior data journalist Ben Walker, who also takes us on a deep dive of the polls.

Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call


Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us

More episodes

View all episodes

  • How long is Starmer's "honeymoon" period?

    The new PM has been in office a couple of weeks, but you've already asked how long he's got.In our weekly "You Ask Us" episode, Hannah Barnes and Rachel Cunliffe answer listener questions on how long Keir Starmer has before the Conservatives can form a coherent opposition, how a Labour government will approach China, and the things that have surprised them about the new parliament so far.Submit a question for the New Statesman team to answer at, or if you're listening on Spotify scroll down and leave a reply on the episode page.Articles mentioned in this episode: David Muir: Taiwan at the edge of chaos
  • Will Labour's "Great British Energy" deliver?

    Clean energy by 2023? We're "pretty far off".Ed Miliband today made his first parliamentary speech as the new Energy Secretary, hailing the Labour government's progress on their energy plans. Central to their goal to reach clean energy by 2023 is their proposal for a new publicly owned energy firm, Great British Energy.Sustainability correspondent Megan Kenyon joins Hannah Barnes and Rachel Cunliffe on the New Statesman podcast to unpick Labour's energy plans and discuss whether or not GB Energy will actually be able to deliver.Read more: Britain will never be an energy superpower, by Helen Thompson
  • King's speech reveals Starmer's uncommon ambition

    "It's been a long time since we've had a government with this level of ambition" - George EatonBlack Rod has been summoned and the weighty wooden doors swung open on a new parliamentary year. At the State Opening of Parliament, Keir Starmer's government unveiled their ambitious legislative agenda through the King's speech, which introduced a bumper 39 bills. George Eaton and Rachel Cunliffe join Hannah Barnes on the New Statesman podcast to unpick the policy announcements and explore the opportunities and potential pitfalls Labour may face over the coming months.Read more: The King’s Speech is our first chance to inspect the moral code behind “Starmerism”
  • ADHD in the criminal justice system | Sponsored

    This episode was initiated and funded by Takeda UK Ltd.Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) affects millions worldwide, yet its presence within the criminal justice system is often misunderstood or overlooked. In this podcast we navigate the complex landscape where ADHD and the criminal justice system intercept; shedding light on the unique challenges and misconceptions faced by people with ADHD in prisons and the opportunities for improved care and support. From late diagnosis to repeated prison sentences, the impact of ADHD can shape outcomes in profound and often unrecognised ways. Host Emma Haslett is joined by Dr Tony Lloyd, the CEO of the ADHD Foundation; Sir Robert Buckland, the former Secretary of State for Justice and MP; Daley Jones, trustee at ADHD Liberty; and Sarah Templeton, an ADHD author and therapist, to explore the stories of those living at this intersection.This podcast was recorded and produced before the 2024 General Election was announced.
  • Andrew Marr: What if the Trump assassination attempt had succeeded?

    Donald Trump has been greeted like a messiah at the Republican National Convention. But what if that bullet had been an inch to the right?Just over 48 hours after narrowly escaping death from a gunman’s bullet, Trump has been confirmed as the Republican Party’s candidate for president in the upcoming election. He has named critic-turned-loyalist JD Vance as his running mate. Andrew Marr joins Hannah Barnes on the New Statesman podcast to discuss how the attempt on Trump's life has impacted his standing among Republicans - and why political assassinations "never work". They also discuss the implosion of the Welsh Labour government, and the King's Speech will reveal about the core beliefs of the Labour government.Read more: JD Vance - the new face of the Republican party, by Sohrab Ahmari Keir Starmer drop the two-child benefit cap?
  • Trump shooting: what the Democrats must do now

    Trump loyalists are blaming Democrats for inciting the assassination attempt on the former President. How should Dems respond?Republicans and Democrats alike have rightly condemned the shocking attack on former US President Donald Trump which left a bystander dead, two more injured and the presumptive Republican candidate bloodied but defiant.However Trump supporters have been quick to point to Democrats' use of language - describing Trump as a "threat to American democracy", for example - as inciteful of violence.On this episode, Hannah Barnes is joined by the journalist and lawyer Jill Filipovic, global affairs editor Katie Stallard and author and documentarian Phil Tinline to discuss how Democrats should respond to this accusation - which, as Jill says, is "not just hypocritical, it's like a through-the-looking-glass made up universe". Read more: The attempted assassination of Donald Trump, by Katie Stallard
  • What does Labour's "growth worth having" actually mean?

    Labour want to distinguish themselves from Boris Johnson's "levelling up". What are they planning instead?Hannah Barnes, Rachel Cunliffe and Freddie Hayward answer listener questions on Labour's growth strategy, and whether the new government's plans will impact individuals' personal finances.They also discuss the new "rising star" Labour MPs to look out for, and whether polling during election campaigns impacts the final result.Articles mentioned in this episode: Labour's next generation: the new MPs to watch Eaton interviews Torsten Bell Labour MP Yuan Yang on the deep class anxiety in China Yang: Democracy begins with us MP Sarah Sackman on the tensions between her Labour values and her Jewish identity
  • The Conservative party's very public nervous breakdown

    The Conservative party are scrapping it out to have their visions of the future of the party heard and things are getting messy.Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by Rachel Cunliffe, associate political editor, and Freddie Hayward, political correspondent. Read: Kemi Badenoch is the early front-runner for the Tory leadershipSign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us
  • How will global affairs define the Starmer era?

    Today is the day we see our Labour government on the world stage for the first time. Starmer is in Washington today for the 75th summit of the Nato defence alliance. Ahead of the summit Starmer has met with President Joe Biden and praised the UK-US special relationship. Starmer has also told reporters that his plan to raise defence spending to 2.5% was “cast iron” - but has not committed to a timeline.In an increasingly volatile world, how will global affairs define the Starmer era?Read: Why foreign affairs will define the Starmer eraSign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us