Share

cover art for Ep. 92: Mysterious Illnesses, Part I and a Murdered Athalia, Part II

Mystery Murdery Thingy

Ep. 92: Mysterious Illnesses, Part I and a Murdered Athalia, Part II

In Episode 92, Mario covers the tragic universe of mysteries surrounding rare diseases. After covering some basics, he focuses on the stories of the people dealing with rare diseases and conditions. Chloe finishes her two-parter on the gruesome killing of Athalia Ponsell Lindsley who was murdered in broad daylight in 1970s St. Augustine, FL. She focuses, in Part II, on the trial and an even more mysterious murder months after the first.


Thanks for listening y’all! We super appreciate it!


Mario & Chloe

Team Mystery

More episodes

View all episodes

  • Ep. 99: The Death of Kenneka Jenkins and Another Murdered Family

    49:03|
    In Episode 99, Mario fulfills a fan request and covers the baffling and tragic death of Kenneka Jenkins in Chicago in 2017. Kenneka was found in a freezer in an unused kitchen a hotel in Rosemont, IL. Chloe covers the Bricca family murder, which was a horrific murder of an entire family in Cincinnati, OH in 1966.Thanks for listening y’all! We super appreciate it!Mario & ChloeTeam Mystery
  • Ep. 98: Two Dead in Kent and Who Was the Monster of Florence?

    01:04:34|
    In Episode 98, Chloe covers the multifaceted mysteries surrounding the double homicide of Alan Leppard and Brenda Long in Kent, England in the early 1990's. Much about these tragic killings remains very much mysterious. Mario finishes his two-parter on the infamous Monster of Florence killings, which terrorized the Tuscan countryside between 1974 and 1985. He focuses on the long running investigation and the two main theories that have emerged over the decades.Thanks for listening y’all! We super appreciate it!Mario & ChloeTeam Mystery
  • Ep. 97: A Monster in Florence and Who Was Teri Deneka?

    01:08:49|
    In Episode 97, Mario begins a personal two-parter on one of the most gruesome and infamous series of killings in Italian true crime history, The Monster of Florence. In the first part, he details the crimes themselves including some horrifying details of the Monster's modus operandi. Next time he'll cover the massive investigation that ensued. Chloe covers a baffling double homicide committed by Teri Deneka who killed herself in 2014. While her acts are not in question, her motive and other important details surrounding her crimes are still a confounding mystery.Thanks for listening y’all! We super appreciate it!Mario & ChloeTeam Mystery
  • Ep. 96: A Missing Agatha and the Mysterious Life and Death of Masaccio

    43:21|
    In Episode 96, Chloe details the mysterious disappearance of the famed mystery writer Agatha Christie whose whereabouts were unknown for over a week in December 1926. The real reason behind her absence remains a mystery. Mario talks about the mysterious Masaccio, a seminal artist of the early Italian Renaissance. He may have been murdered but much about his life and death remains very much mysterious.Thanks for listening y’all! We super appreciate it!Mario & ChloeTeam Mystery
  • Ep. 95: A Murdered Lasantha and Two Killed on Lake Oconee

    52:19|
    In Episode 95, Mario covers the brutal murder of journalist Lasantha Wickrematunge in Sri Lanka in 2009 who was a leader of the independent press and may have been killed for his outspoken views. Chloe talks about the gruesome slaying of Shirley and Russell Dermond, an elderly couple living near Lake Oconee, GA, in 2014.Thanks for listening y’all! We super appreciate it!Mario & ChloeTeam Mystery
  • Ep. 94: A Maniac in Volga and Missing in Vortex Spring

    44:22|
    In Episode 94, Mario talks about another unsolved serial killer, the Volga Maniac who was active in the Volga and Ural regions of Russia in 2012-2013 and may be active again. Chloe covers a confounding missing person case, the disappearance of Ben McDaniel while underwater cave diving in Vortex Springs in 2010.Thanks for listening y’all! We super appreciate it!Mario & ChloeTeam Mystery
  • Ep. 93: Missing in Death Valley and Rare Diseases, Part II

    01:11:56|
    In Episode 93, Chloe discusses the so-called Death Valley Germans case. In 1996, a family of four German tourists went into Death Valley and never came out. She explores what's been found out and what remains a mystery. Mario continues his two-parter about the many mysteries surrounding rare diseases. This time he talks about some of the people helping to solve these mysteries and the mysteries surrounding a number of rare cancer cases in Waycross, GA in the mid-2010s. Thanks for listening y’all! We super appreciate it!Mario & ChloeTeam Mystery
  • Ep. 91: Eight Dead in Craig and a Murdered Athalia

    01:12:39|
    In Episode 91, Mario ends a personal two-parter while Chloe starts one. Mario finished his series on murder in Alaska by detailing what's widely considered the worst mass murder in modern Alaska history, the killing of eight people aboard the Investor in Craig, AK in 1982. Chloe begins her telling of the gruesome slaying of Athalia Ponsell Lindsley in St. Augustine, FL in 1974. She focuses on Athalia's life and killing in part I.Thanks for listening y’all! We super appreciate it!Mario & ChloeTeam Mystery