Share

cover art for My Killer Father: The Green Hollow Murders Recap (Paramount +, 2026)

Murder She Watched

My Killer Father: The Green Hollow Murders Recap (Paramount +, 2026)

Season 1, Ep. 65
•

Kyla and I are heading to the remote hills of Iowa to unpack the absolute nightmare that is "My Killer Father: The Green Hollow Murders" (Paramount+, 2026). For decades, locals whispered about the "Monster of Green Hollow," but now his daughter is breaking the silence. She’s alleging that her father didn't just kill dozens of women—including three of his own wives—but that he forced her and her siblings to help hide the bodies in an old well on their property. 

We’re deep-diving into the truth behind this Paramount+ true crime documentary and looking at how a secret this big stays buried in a small town for so long.


We discuss:

  • The Daughter's Testimony: We discuss the chilling reality of living with a serial killer and the trauma of the Green Hollow property.

  • The Evidence: Breaking down the search for remains in the well and why the Iowa authorities are just now catching up.

  • The film itself: Our unfiltered thoughts on the production, the siblings' story, and the "Monster" himself.

JOIN MURDER CLUB

Want more content? Join the club for ad-free episodes and bonus deep-dives.

SUPPORT THE SHOW & MERCHCONNECT WITH US



More episodes

View all episodes

  • 83. Murder 101 (Amazon Prime, 2026)

    01:05:48||Season 1, Ep. 83
    Amye is joined by Dr. Adam to discuss the 2026 Amazon Prime docuseries, Murder 101.A case that haunted Tennessee's best detectives for decades is cracked wide open with the help of some unlikely investigators: Mr. Alex Campbell’s high school sociology class.Please check out Dr. Adam’s podcast here: https://open.spotify.com/show/5RLa60djZ76O33cJbR6qDHFollow him on social media here: https://www.instagram.com/thesisterwivesprofessorJOIN MURDER CLUBWant more content? Join the club for ad-free episodes and bonus deep-dives.Patreon: patreon.com/murdershewatchedNewsletter: Stay updated with The Detective’s Lounge (it's free!): murdershewatched.substack.comSUPPORT THE SHOW & MERCHMerch: Grab your gear at littlemissrecap.threadless.comCameo: Get a personal shoutout from me (or "Michael Peterson"): cameo.com/amyearcherReality TV: Catch my other show, Little Miss Recap, at littlemissrecap.comCONNECT WITH USInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodFacebook Group: Couch Detectives CommunityYouTube: Watch the recapsEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.com

  • 82. A Toxic Love Story (Netflix, 2026): CraigsList, Revenge, and Disney Adults

    55:00||Season 1, Ep. 82
    Amye is joined by Kyla to recap and review the Netflix documentary, A Toxic Love Story. The film unravels the infamous real-life Anaheim Craigslist case involving a newlywed U.S. Marshal, his new wife, and his ex-fiancée, exploring a twisted revenge plot and a sophisticated web of lies. JOIN MURDER CLUBWant more content? Join the club for ad-free episodes and bonus deep-dives.Patreon: patreon.com/murdershewatchedNewsletter: Stay updated with The Detective’s Lounge (it's free!): murdershewatched.substack.comSUPPORT THE SHOW & MERCHMerch: Grab your gear at littlemissrecap.threadless.comCameo: Get a personal shoutout from me (or "Michael Peterson"): cameo.com/amyearcherReality TV: Catch my other show, Little Miss Recap, at littlemissrecap.comCONNECT WITH USInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodFacebook Group: Couch Detectives CommunityYouTube: Watch the recapsEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.com

  • 81. Worst Neighbor Ever S1:EP4 The Executor

    43:55||Season 1, Ep. 81
    Amye is joined by Kyla to recap and review Worst Neighbor Ever S1:EP4 The ExecutorWhen Charles' neighbors report him missing, suspicion immediately falls on Caroline, who claims to be managing his estate while actually concealing a grisly crime.JOIN MURDER CLUBWant more content? Join the club for ad-free episodes and bonus deep-dives.Patreon: patreon.com/murdershewatchedNewsletter: Stay updated with The Detective’s Lounge (it's free!): murdershewatched.substack.comSUPPORT THE SHOW & MERCHMerch: Grab your gear at littlemissrecap.threadless.comCameo: Get a personal shoutout from me (or "Michael Peterson"): cameo.com/amyearcherReality TV: Catch my other show, Little Miss Recap, at littlemissrecap.comCONNECT WITH USInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodFacebook Group: Couch Detectives CommunityYouTube: Watch the recapsEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.com

  • 80. Worst Neighbor Ever S1:EP3 Fear They Neighbor

    48:07||Season 1, Ep. 80
    Amye is joined by Kyla to recap and review Worst Neighbor Ever S1:EP3 Fear They NeighborMiles and Melina thought they had found their dream home, but a nightmare unfolds when evicted neighbour Jamal launches a relentless harassment campaign.JOIN MURDER CLUBWant more content? Join the club for ad-free episodes and bonus deep-dives.Patreon: patreon.com/murdershewatchedNewsletter: Stay updated with The Detective’s Lounge (it's free!): murdershewatched.substack.comSUPPORT THE SHOW & MERCHMerch: Grab your gear at littlemissrecap.threadless.comCameo: Get a personal shoutout from me (or "Michael Peterson"): cameo.com/amyearcherReality TV: Catch my other show, Little Miss Recap, at littlemissrecap.comCONNECT WITH USInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodFacebook Group: Couch Detectives CommunityYouTube: Watch the recapsEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.com

  • 79. Worst Neighbor Ever S1:EP2 Midwest Meltdown (Netflix, 2026)

    45:09||Season 1, Ep. 79
    Amye is joined by Kyla to recap and review Worst Neighbor Ever S1:EP2 Midwest MeltdownAfter a quiet Indiana suburb is rocked by a massive explosion, investigators begin to question the motives of neighbour Moncy and her new boyfriend Mark.JOIN MURDER CLUBWant more content? Join the club for ad-free episodes and bonus deep-dives.Patreon: patreon.com/murdershewatchedNewsletter: Stay updated with The Detective’s Lounge (it's free!): murdershewatched.substack.comSUPPORT THE SHOW & MERCHMerch: Grab your gear at littlemissrecap.threadless.comCameo: Get a personal shoutout from me (or "Michael Peterson"): cameo.com/amyearcherReality TV: Catch my other show, Little Miss Recap, at littlemissrecap.comCONNECT WITH USInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodFacebook Group: Couch Detectives CommunityYouTube: Watch the recapsEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.com

  • 78. Worst Neighbor Ever S1:EP1 She Finally Snapped (Netflix, 2026)

    45:19||Season 1, Ep. 78
    Amye is joined by Kyla to recap and review Worst Neighbor Ever S1:EP1 She Finally SnappedMoving to Kentucky to be near family, Shawna and David Scott never expected to run into Frances Zaayer, an old family friend who has just bought the house directly across the street.JOIN MURDER CLUBWant more content? Join the club for ad-free episodes and bonus deep-dives.Patreon: patreon.com/murdershewatchedNewsletter: Stay updated with The Detective’s Lounge (it's free!): murdershewatched.substack.comSUPPORT THE SHOW & MERCHMerch: Grab your gear at littlemissrecap.threadless.comCameo: Get a personal shoutout from me (or "Michael Peterson"): cameo.com/amyearcherReality TV: Catch my other show, Little Miss Recap, at littlemissrecap.comCONNECT WITH USInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodFacebook Group: Couch Detectives CommunityYouTube: Watch the recapsEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.com

  • 77. FREE PREVIEW: Making a Murderer S2:EP4 Welcome to Wisconsin

    39:38||Season 1, Ep. 77
    Enjoy this free preview of our bonus content. To sign up for the rest, click here: patreon.com/murdershewatchedAmye and Kyla recap Making a Murderer S2:EP4 Welcome to WisconsinFeeling cautiously optimistic, Brendan and his family await important news about his case. Kathleen files a motion for a new round of scientific testing.JOIN MURDER CLUBWant more content? Join the club for ad-free episodes and bonus deep-dives.Patreon: patreon.com/murdershewatchedNewsletter: Stay updated with The Detective’s Lounge (it's free!): murdershewatched.substack.comSUPPORT THE SHOW & MERCHMerch: Grab your gear at littlemissrecap.threadless.comCameo: Get a personal shoutout from me (or "Michael Peterson"): cameo.com/amyearcherReality TV: Catch my other show, Little Miss Recap, at littlemissrecap.comCONNECT WITH USInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodFacebook Group: Couch Detectives CommunityYouTube: Watch the recapsEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.com

  • 76. The Menendez Brothers (Netflix, 2024)

    01:16:03||Season 1, Ep. 76
    Amye and Amanda recap and discuss the 2024 Netflix documentary, The Menendez BrothersPLEASE NOTE: This episode originally aired on my reality tv podcast, Little Miss Recap in 2024.**Trigger Warning: This episode touches on such topics as: murder, rape, sexual assault, pedophilia, and suicidal ideation. New evidence has come to light in the case of the Menendez conviction, prompting the LA district attorney to announce he is “looking” at the sentencing of Erik and Lyle Menendez after the two men have served over 30 years in prison for the 1st degree murder of their parents. This documentary includes the voices of both brothers telling parts of their story publicly for the first time. JOIN MURDER CLUBWant more content? Join the club for ad-free episodes and bonus deep-dives.Patreon: patreon.com/murdershewatchedNewsletter: Stay updated with The Detective’s Lounge (it's free!): murdershewatched.substack.comSUPPORT THE SHOW & MERCHMerch: Grab your gear at littlemissrecap.threadless.comCameo: Get a personal shoutout from me (or "Michael Peterson"): cameo.com/amyearcherReality TV: Catch my other show, Little Miss Recap, at littlemissrecap.comCONNECT WITH USInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodFacebook Group: Couch Detectives CommunityYouTube: Watch the recapsEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.com

  • 75. Maternal Instinct (Netflix, 2026): The Horrifying True Story of Taylor Parker

    01:25:27||Season 1, Ep. 75
    Amye is joined by Kyla to discuss the 2026 Netflix documentary, Maternal Instinct. On October 9th, 2020, police found Taylor Parker on the side of a Texas highway claiming to have just given birth to the non-responsive infant in her lap. What happened next was the unweaving of a year’s worth of lies and deceit which ended in the senseless death of Reagan Simmons-Hancock and her unborn daughter. JOIN MURDER CLUBWant more content? Join the club for ad-free episodes and bonus deep-dives.Patreon: patreon.com/murdershewatchedNewsletter: Stay updated with The Detective’s Lounge (it's free!): murdershewatched.substack.comSUPPORT THE SHOW & MERCHMerch: Grab your gear at littlemissrecap.threadless.comCameo: Get a personal shoutout from me (or "Michael Peterson"): cameo.com/amyearcherReality TV: Catch my other show, Little Miss Recap, at littlemissrecap.comCONNECT WITH USInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodFacebook Group: Couch Detectives CommunityYouTube: Watch the recapsEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.com