Murder She Watched

Mary Payne Gilbert from Pink Shade joins me to discuss the 2026 Netflix documentary: Should I Marry a Murderer?Dr. Caroline Muirhead meets the man of her dreams and falls in love quickly, only to discover he and his twin brother are involved in the tragic death of cyclist Tony Parsons. We discuss:Caroline’s Erratic Behavior: What motivated this intelligent, beautiful woman to keep returning to this bad situation? Was it just his hotness or something more? Sandy and Robert McKellar’s Role in Tony Parson’s Death: Exactly what went down that night in 2017 when the McKellar brothers came across Tony Parsons on a dark, deserted road? Witness Protection: The protections afforded to witnesses in the UK seem wildly different than those in the US. We discuss viewing this documentary through an American lens. JOIN MURDER CLUBWant more content? Join the club for ad-free episodes and bonus deep-dives.Patreon: patreon.com/murdershewatchedNewsletter: Stay updated with The Detective’s Lounge (it's free!): murdershewatched.substack.comSUPPORT THE SHOW & MERCHMerch: Grab your gear at littlemissrecap.threadless.comCameo: Get a personal shoutout from me (or "Michael Peterson"): cameo.com/amyearcherReality TV: Catch my other show, Little Miss Recap, at littlemissrecap.comCONNECT WITH USInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodFacebook Group: Couch Detectives CommunityYouTube: Watch the recapsEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.com

Jodi Weber from Caught in My Web joined me back in 2024 to talk about the newly released HBO docu series, The Truth About Jim. Directed and Produced by Skye Borgman, The Truth About Jim is the story of Sierra Barter confronting generations of trauma and secrets to investigate whether her step-grandfather Jim Mordecai was a serial killer who committed the Santa Rosa hitchhiker murders.NOTE: This is a replay from my reality TV podcast, Little Miss Recap. This originally aired in 2024.JOIN MURDER CLUBWant more content? Join the club for ad-free episodes and bonus deep-dives.Patreon: patreon.com/murdershewatchedNewsletter: Stay updated with The Detective’s Lounge (it's free!): murdershewatched.substack.comSUPPORT THE SHOW & MERCHMerch: Grab your gear at littlemissrecap.threadless.comCameo: Get a personal shoutout from me (or "Michael Peterson"): cameo.com/amyearcherReality TV: Catch my other show, Little Miss Recap, at littlemissrecap.comCONNECT WITH USInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodFacebook Group: Couch Detectives CommunityYouTube: Watch the recapsEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.com

Kyla and I are heading to the remote hills of Iowa to unpack the absolute nightmare that is "My Killer Father: The Green Hollow Murders" (Paramount+, 2026). For decades, locals whispered about the "Monster of Green Hollow," but now his daughter is breaking the silence. She’s alleging that her father didn't just kill dozens of women—including three of his own wives—but that he forced her and her siblings to help hide the bodies in an old well on their property. We’re deep-diving into the truth behind this Paramount+ true crime documentary and looking at how a secret this big stays buried in a small town for so long.We discuss:The Daughter's Testimony: We discuss the chilling reality of living with a serial killer and the trauma of the Green Hollow property.The Evidence: Breaking down the search for remains in the well and why the Iowa authorities are just now catching up.The film itself: Our unfiltered thoughts on the production, the siblings' story, and the "Monster" himself.JOIN MURDER CLUBWant more content? Join the club for ad-free episodes and bonus deep-dives.Patreon: patreon.com/murdershewatchedNewsletter: Stay updated with The Detective’s Lounge (it's free!): murdershewatched.substack.comSUPPORT THE SHOW & MERCHMerch: Grab your gear at littlemissrecap.threadless.comCameo: Get a personal shoutout from me (or "Michael Peterson"): cameo.com/amyearcherReality TV: Catch my other show, Little Miss Recap, at littlemissrecap.comCONNECT WITH USInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodFacebook Group: Couch Detectives CommunityYouTube: Watch the recapsEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.com

Amye is joined by Becca to recap and discuss Betrayal: Secrets and Lies S1:EP5 The Kentucky ConmanLibby's perfect life implodes when she discovers her husband's shady real-estate deals, and he threatens to take her down with him.Want more content? Join murder club below:Join Murder Club and get this episode ad free and bonus content by signing up for Patreon at: www.patreon.com/murdershewatchedCheck out my reality TV podcast: www.littlemissrecap.comGet in touch with me:Facebook group: www.facebook.com/groups/couchdetectivesInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.comGet our FREE newsletter, The Detective’s Lounge https://murdershewatched.substack.com/Order a Cameo:(from “Michael Peterson” or Amye): https://www.cameo.com/amyearcherCatch us on Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@MurderSheWatchedPodWant some Murder She Watched Merch? Grab it at: https://littlemissrecap.threadless.com/

Amye is joined by Becca to recap and discuss the 2020 Netflix docuseries, Tiger King. In this episode we discuss S1:EP1, Not Your Average JoeJoe Exotic, the gun-toting operator of an Oklahoma big cat park, is accused of hiring someone to murder his chief rival, Carole Baskin.To continue listening to the series, join murder club below:Join Murder Club and get this episode ad free and bonus content by signing up for Patreon at: www.patreon.com/murdershewatchedCheck out my reality TV podcast: www.littlemissrecap.comGet in touch with me:Facebook group: www.facebook.com/groups/couchdetectivesInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.comOrder a Cameo:(from “Michael Peterson” or Amye): https://www.cameo.com/amyearcherCatch us on Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@MurderSheWatchedPodWant some Murder She Watched Merch? Grab it at: https://littlemissrecap.myshopify.com/

Amye is joined by Becca to recap and discuss Betrayal: Secrets and Lies S1:EP4 The New Year IntruderTRIGGER WARNING:Death of a child, sexual assault, kidnapping, and other dark stuff. Morgan and Rodney were high school sweethearts. But after Rodney's love turned into manipulation, Morgan found herself face-to-face with a monster.Want more content? Join murder club below:Join Murder Club and get this episode ad free and bonus content by signing up for Patreon at: www.patreon.com/murdershewatchedCheck out my reality TV podcast: www.littlemissrecap.comGet in touch with me:Facebook group: www.facebook.com/groups/couchdetectivesInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.comOrder a Cameo:(from “Michael Peterson” or Amye): https://www.cameo.com/amyearcherCatch us on Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@MurderSheWatchedPodWant some Murder She Watched Merch? Grab it at: https://littlemissrecap.myshopify.com/

Amye is joined by Brian to recap and discuss the 2026 Netflix documentary, Untold: The Shooting at Hawthorne Hill A heated dispute between an equestrian trainer and his student spirals into a grisly act of violence in this twisty true-crime documentary.You can find Brian’s podcast here: https://creators.spotify.com/pod/profile/midnightbluesix/You can find Brian’s store here:https://www.etsy.com/shop/Nifty50ApparelWant more content? Join murder club below:Join Murder Club and get this episode ad free and bonus content by signing up for Patreon at: www.patreon.com/murdershewatchedCheck out my reality TV podcast: www.littlemissrecap.comGet in touch with me:Facebook group: www.facebook.com/groups/couchdetectivesInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.comOrder a Cameo:(from “Michael Peterson” or Amye): https://www.cameo.com/amyearcherCatch us on Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@MurderSheWatchedPodWant some Murder She Watched Merch? Grab it at: https://littlemissrecap.myshopify.com/

Amye is joined by Becca to discuss Betrayal: Secrets and Lies S1:EP3 The Bible Study Kidnapper (HULU, 2026)A woman finds herself ensnared in an FBI investigation after her husband takes desperate measures to keep his financial troubles a secret.Here is a link to watch the docuseries on Fandango: https://athome.fandango.com/content/browse/details/The-Disappearance-of-Susan-Cox-Powell-Season-1/1100636Want bonus episodes and ad-free listening? Join Murder Club and get this episode ad free and bonus content by signing up for Patreon at: www.patreon.com/murdershewatchedCheck out my reality TV podcast: www.littlemissrecap.comGet in touch with me:Facebook group: www.facebook.com/groups/couchdetectivesInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.comOrder a Cameo:(from “Michael Peterson” or Amye): https://www.cameo.com/amyearcherCatch us on Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@MurderSheWatchedPodWant some Murder She Watched Merch? Grab it at: https://littlemissrecap.myshopify.com/

Amye is joined by Keisha from The Libra Lounge with Keisha to discuss the 2022 Netflix documentary Crime Scene: The Texas Killing FieldsThe Texas Killing Fields is a 3-part 2022 Netflix docuseries (directed by Jessica Dimmock) exploring the unsolved murders of young women found in a League City, Texas oil field near I-45 during the 80s/90s. The series highlights the search for justice by victims' families, specifically Tim Miller, amid suspicions of a serial killer and potential law enforcement failures.And there is a recent break in the case so listen to the end!Check Keisha out on her podcast: The Libra Lounge with KeishaWant bonus episodes and ad-free listening? Join Murder Club and get this episode ad free and bonus content by signing up for Patreon at: www.patreon.com/murdershewatchedCheck out my reality TV podcast: www.littlemissrecap.comGet in touch with me:Facebook group: www.facebook.com/groups/couchdetectivesInstagram: @murdershewatchedpodEmail: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.comOrder a Cameo:(from “Michael Peterson” or Amye): https://www.cameo.com/amyearcherCatch us on Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@MurderSheWatchedPodWant some Murder She Watched Merch? Grab it at: https://littlemissrecap.myshopify.com/