Share

cover art for Is MIDNIGHT worth all of the drama? Mickey-Jo's review of Todrick Hall's controversial Off-Broadway musical

MickeyJoTheatre

Is MIDNIGHT worth all of the drama? Mickey-Jo's review of Todrick Hall's controversial Off-Broadway musical

•

After first seeing an earlier iteration of the show in London, Mickey-Jo headed to the Daryl Roth Theatre in New York to see Todrick Hall's MIDNIGHT.


The new Off-Broadway musical, written, directed and choreographed by Todrick, has been generating conversation offstage due to its slavery-era narrative.


Mickey-Jo is sharing some thoughts on the show itself, its material and performances as well as its wider context.


check out Mickey-Jo's brand new substack newsletter: www.mickeyjotheatre.substack.com


00:00 | introduction

02:37 | synopsis / controvery

11:11 | the big plot twist

20:26 | material / performances

31:33 | creative choices / conclusion

About Mickey-Jo:

As one of the leading voices in theatre criticism on a social platform, Mickey-Jo is pioneering a new medium for a dwindling field. His YouTube channel: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠MickeyJoTheatre⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ is the largest worldwide in terms of dedicated theatre criticism, where he also share features, news and interviews as well as lifestyle content for over 95,000 subscribers. With a viewership that is largely split between the US and the UK he has been fortunate enough to be able to work with PR, Marketing, and Social Media representatives for shows in New York, London, Edinburgh, Hamburg, Toronto, Sao Pãolo, and Paris. His reviews and features have also been published by WhatsOnStage, for whom he was a panelist to help curate nominees for their 2023 and 2024 Awards as well as BroadwayWorldUK, Musicals Magazine and LondonTheatre.co.uk. Instagram/TikTok/X: @MickeyJoTheatre

More episodes

View all episodes

  • why you should see GIANT in cinemas | what you should know about the West End and Broadway play

    17:39|
    The Award winning play GIANT is coming to cinemas worldwide from Thursday 19th November. Check out this new episode to learn more about the play and why Mickey-Jo recommends that you should check it out.check out Mickey-Jo's weekly substack newsletter: www.mickeyjotheatre.substack.com 00:00 | introduction 02:11 | overview 06:34 | the recording 10:30 | performances 15:19 | conclusion
  • the worst songs in musical theatre... | a stagey debate part 2 ft Kate Reinking​

    34:43|
    We've all thought about it before - that one song in a great musical that you just don't love listening to, or seeing it onstage. For the second time this year, Mickey-Jo sat down with one of his closest friends, Kate Reinking, with whom he disagrees about theatre constantly, to debate some of the worst songs in some of the best and most popular musicals. Check out which numbers we chose from shows including Hamilton, Hadestown, Anything Goes, The Lost Boys, Operation Mincemeat, Evita, Suffs, West side Story, Paddington, The Last 5 Years, and more...
  • In The Heights (New York City Center) - ★★★★★ REVIEW

    36:48|
    As part of Mickey-Jo’s most recent trip to New York, he caught the Annual Gala Presentation at New York City Center - a revival of IN THE HEIGHTS!The popular musical first premiered two decades ago and features a brand new cast of rising stars.Find out what Mickey-Jo thought of the show and its performances, and whether it ought to transfer immediately to Broadway...•00:00 | introduction02:09 | material 08:47 | creative choices 21:43 | performances 34:09 | conclusion
  • Mickey-Jo saw Skylar Astin and Sarah Hyland in CABARET | thoughts on the musical revival's new West End cast

    21:19|
    Mickey-Jo was recently invited to attend a gala night at the West End production of CABARET, currently running at the Kit Kat Club at the Playhouse Theatre in London. The production, which has been directed by Rebecca Frecknall and originally starred Eddie Redmayne and Jessie Buckley has recently welcomed new stars Sarah Hyland and Skylar Astin. Check out Mickey-Jo's thoughts on what the production is like with these brand new stars as well as the continuing supporting cast... 00:00 | introduction 03:00 | Sarah as Sally 08:12 | Skylar as the Emcee 13:05 | the supporting cast 19:53 | conclusion
  • what Mickey-Jo is seeing and skipping on Broadway | the shows Mickey-Jo is watching on his Fall 2026 Theatre trip

    22:07|
    Mickey-Jo is on his way back to New York to see as many of the new Fall Broadway and Off-Broadway arrivals as possible. Among his most anticipated shows are The Fantasticks, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, In the Heights, School Girls, We'll See, Here There Are Blueberries, and Annie at Goodspeed Opera House. Find out which shows he will definitely be seeing (and reviewing) as well as what his is still considering and avoiding... sign up to Mickey-Jo’s weekly substack newsletter: www.mickeyjotheatre.substack.com00:00 | introduction 01:43 | Musicals 09:08 | Plays 17:09 | Off-Broadway Musicals 21:07 | conclusion
  • Martin Guerre (The Old Vic Theatre, London) - ★★★ REVIEW

    29:45|
    A new reworking of the musical MARTIN GUERRE is currently being produced at the Old Vic Theatre, with the show reconceived as a chamber piece over a single act. The musical is written by Alain Boublil and Claude-Michel Schönberg, who created the musicals Les Misérables and Miss Saigon, with new material from Annabel Mutale Reed & Paul Hodge. Check out the full review ro find out what Mickey-Jo thought of this bold new production, the star turn at its centre from Liv Andrusier, and the impact of keeping vital secrets from your audience... sign up to Mickey-Jo's weekly substack newsletter: www.mickeyjotheatre.substack.com00:00 | introduction 02:30 | differences 11:35 | the material 16:16 | creative choices 23:19 | performances 27:51 | conclusion
  • will THE NOTEBOOK be a hit in London? | thoughts on the Broadway musical's 2027 West End transfer

    16:44|
    It was announced recently that the musical adaptation of THE NOTEBOOK would arrive in London's West End in 2027. The show, which ran for less than a year on Broadway will play at the soon to be renamed Judi Dench Theatre (currently the Shaftesbury), with full casting to be announced. As well as recapping the details shared so far, Mickey-Jo is sharing his thoughts on whether the musical will find greater critical and commercial success in London... sign up to Mickey-Jo's weekly substack newsletter: www.mickeyjotheatre.substack.com00:00 | introduction01:54 | what do we know?08:49 | will it be a hit?15:54 | conclusion
  • is the GLEE reboot a great idea?! | thoughts on the return of the landmark TV series and Broadway

    17:09|
    It has recently been confirmed that the cultural landmark TV series GLEE will return to screens. Members of the original cast have either teased or confirmed their involvement, though there is much we still don't know about what this reboot will look like. Today, Mickey-Jo is sharing his thoughts about whether or not he thinks the Glee Reboot will be a success, which musicals they are likely to pay tribute to, and whether the show's casting could prove to be a great thing for Broadway's box offices... check out Mickey-Jo's brand new substack newsletter: www.mickeyjotheatre.substack.com00:00 | introduction 02:14 | what do we know? 06:57 | who will be in it? 12:00 | good for Broadway? 16:06 | conclusion