Share

cover art for Let's Talk About the Tricky Racial Metaphors of 'Carnival Row'

Low Key

Let's Talk About the Tricky Racial Metaphors of 'Carnival Row'

Season 1, Ep. 40

Fae! Pucks! Critches! This week on the "Low Key" podcast, we talk about these and other words we think might be racial slurs in the world of "Carnival Row," Amazon's unique take on bigotry and immigration.


The new series examines a star-crossed relationship between a human detective named Philo (Orlando Bloom) and a winged fae named Vignette (Cara Delevigne) that is filled with metaphors we're trying very hard to follow. The show creates a vast and complex fictional world, then populates it with storylines that seem oddly reminiscent of things happening in America today.


Every week on "Low Key," we look for pop culture subtleties, often through a racial lens, so "Carnival Row" was kind of made for us. It's filled with nuance, and rewards viewers for patience and close attention. Our favorite subplot involves the "there goes the neighborhood" arrival or the mysterious puck Mr. Agreus (David Gyasi), who draws the intense interest of privileged neighbor (and master to Vignette) Imogen Spurnrose (Tamzin Merchant).


We're also caught very off-guard by a subplot involving fae fetishist Jonah Breakspear (Arty Froushan), son of the eminent Absalom Breakspear (Jared Harris). Whether you like "Carnival Row" or not -- and we do -- it's a lot of fun to talk about.


Here are some of the main points of our conversation, with timestamps:


5:30: Apologies to Downton Abbey


7:05: Praise for Tamzin Merchant


8:45: “If you were to make like an eight-episode porn scene where sex only happened in the seventh episode? If you have the dedication to watch that kind of pornography, you’ve got it. ‘Carnival Row’ has it.” 


16:38: Some thoughts on the precarious Spurnrose situation


17:10: “The only-person-to-survive thing felt unnecessary.”


30:00: A pretty big spoiler


36:51: Someone yells "YEAH!" a little too loud


If you like us, subscribe. If you don't, check out the "Shoot This Now" or "Meanwhile in the Multiverse" podcasts.

More episodes

View all episodes

  • The Goofiest Parts of Superman=The Best Parts of Superman

    01:12:12|
    Also in this episode, we investigate: Is Jesus woke?
  • 'Straw is No Exit for Black Women'

    53:40|
    Tyler Perry's Straw has a misleading title — because it isn't a straw that breaks the camel's back in the film about a single mom (Taraji P. Henson) driven to extremes, but an absolutely nightmarish event that is only revealed in the film's insane final act.In this episode, Aaron, Keith and Tim talk about whether the movie takes place in hell, great movie twists and why they work — from Fight Club to The Sixth Sense — and the correct way to pronounce San Pedro.We wrap up by praising Tubi's Flew'd Out and the works of fantasy author Brandon Sanderson.
  • The Edgelord Games of Mountainhead

    38:42|
    What is the message of Mountainhead? Aaron and Tim talk about the film as a condemnation of the gamification of everything in Jesse Armstrong's Succession successor.
  • We Like Murderbot Well Enough

    46:19|
    Murderbot is a security droid who is happy to just watch his shows, and so are we. Without being security droids.
  • Magazine Dreams and the Return of Jonathan Majors

    53:49|
    Sometimes we talk about movies that are a good hang. Elijah Bynum's Magazine Dreams is not one of them, but it is a fascinating watch with an astonishing performance by Jonathan Majors. At one point it looked like he could win an Oscar for the role — before legal troubles nearly ended his career. Now Magazine Dreams is part of a comeback attempt.
  • Sinners Doesn't Have All the Answers

    01:19:08|
    We talk about the excellent of Sinners, the bad version of Sinners, and letting the right and wrong ones in.
  • Common Side Effects! Righteous Gemstones! A 1979 Jack the Ripper Movie!

    56:08|
    Due to various calamities we couldn't find time to watch the same show or movie this week, so instead Aaron, Keith and Tim are just listing off a bunch of cool stuff they like and recommend. We also discuss great Disney sequels, the Righteous Gemstones, hip-hop Percocet era, and why Frozen 2 is, no kidding, the wokest movie ever.
  • Mickey 17 Review

    32:28|
  • When Your Younger Self Attacks Your Older Self

    01:14:12|
    THE SUBSTANCE is almost a perfect partner to the last film we discussed, A DIFFERENT MAN. It's about aging and beauty standards, but also the kindnesses and harms we do to our future selves.