Share

cover art for Let's Talk About the Tricky Racial Metaphors of 'Carnival Row'

Low Key

Let's Talk About the Tricky Racial Metaphors of 'Carnival Row'

Season 1, Ep. 40
•

Fae! Pucks! Critches! This week on the "Low Key" podcast, we talk about these and other words we think might be racial slurs in the world of "Carnival Row," Amazon's unique take on bigotry and immigration.


The new series examines a star-crossed relationship between a human detective named Philo (Orlando Bloom) and a winged fae named Vignette (Cara Delevigne) that is filled with metaphors we're trying very hard to follow. The show creates a vast and complex fictional world, then populates it with storylines that seem oddly reminiscent of things happening in America today.


Every week on "Low Key," we look for pop culture subtleties, often through a racial lens, so "Carnival Row" was kind of made for us. It's filled with nuance, and rewards viewers for patience and close attention. Our favorite subplot involves the "there goes the neighborhood" arrival or the mysterious puck Mr. Agreus (David Gyasi), who draws the intense interest of privileged neighbor (and master to Vignette) Imogen Spurnrose (Tamzin Merchant).


We're also caught very off-guard by a subplot involving fae fetishist Jonah Breakspear (Arty Froushan), son of the eminent Absalom Breakspear (Jared Harris). Whether you like "Carnival Row" or not -- and we do -- it's a lot of fun to talk about.


Here are some of the main points of our conversation, with timestamps:


5:30: Apologies to Downton Abbey


7:05: Praise for Tamzin Merchant


8:45: “If you were to make like an eight-episode porn scene where sex only happened in the seventh episode? If you have the dedication to watch that kind of pornography, you’ve got it. ‘Carnival Row’ has it.” 


16:38: Some thoughts on the precarious Spurnrose situation


17:10: “The only-person-to-survive thing felt unnecessary.”


30:00: A pretty big spoiler


36:51: Someone yells "YEAH!" a little too loud


If you like us, subscribe. If you don't, check out the "Shoot This Now" or "Meanwhile in the Multiverse" podcasts.

More episodes

View all episodes

  • What OBSESSION Can Teach Us About Dating

    01:16:24|
    Obsession, the horror phenomenon from Curry Barker, has good things to tell us about dating, friendship and all relationships.
  • COHERENCE: How to Blow Minds on a $50K Budget

    01:13:30|
    COHERENCE, a 2013 sci-fi film from writer-director James Ward Byrkit, is a model of low-budget filmmaking.As studios look for the next OBSESSION, they might want to see what's possible on a $50,000 budget, when scrappy filmmakers and performers imagine big.
  • "The Bluff" Is Unexpected Pirate Fun

    38:26|
    Welcome once again to the pod. This week, the guys review a regular ol' popcorn on your couch pirate movie, Amazon Prime's The Bluff. There's betrayal, blood-soaked action, and booty to be plundered, just like you'd expect.
  • One Battle After Another "Vive La Revolution?"

    59:48|
  • What We're Excited for in 2026: Industry, The Pitt, They Will Kill You... and Doomsday?

    59:52|
    We share what we're excited to see in 2026, including Industry, The Pitt, They Will Kill You, and maybe — just maybe — Avengers: Doomsday.But first, Aaron has some thoughts on Stranger Things.And then team makes an announcement about Maggie Gyllenhaal's The Bride.And we talk about shows that overstay their welcome — and some of the best shows we've ever seen, including Breaking Bad, Battlestar Galactica, and The Righteous Gemstones. Pictured: Myha'la in Industry Season 4.
  • How Eddie Murphy Changed Comedy and the World

    49:04|
    "Hippies are bad people who pretend to be good and punks are good people who pretend to be bad"Photo from Being Eddie. Netflix
  • Dads Watch Kids Movies: THE WITCHES

    37:54|
    Jim Henson meets Roald Dahl in THE WITCHES. Let's talk about whether it holds up, whether it would work for modern kids, and why we wouldn't mind watching it again and again and again.A must-see if you love movies with dead parents, kids turning into mice, and of course... witches.TLDR: "I love this movie."—Keith
  • Highest 2 Lowest Needs More Highs and Lows

    46:51|
    One of the greatest directors ever reunites with one of the greatest actors ever to make one of the most OK films
  • WEAPONS: Can It Be All So Simple? (Spoilers, spoilers, spoilers)

    31:20|
    A VERY spoiler-filled discussion of Zack Cregger's wonderful WEAPONS.Please don't listen to this one without seeing the movie, OK?