Share

cover art for Mikaere Oketopa: The "killer" who was never there (Part 1)

Long Story Short

Mikaere Oketopa: The "killer" who was never there (Part 1)

Season 1, Ep. 2
•

After a 22-year-old woman is found murdered in the grounds of a school, police swiftly ID three key suspects.

There’s just one problem: one of them says he was fast asleep on the other side of town at the time of the killing. And his co-accused swear they never met him. So why was Michael October (also known as Mikaere Oketopa) jailed all the same?

In part one of this two-part series, Adam Dudding and Eugene Bingham kick the tyres of a baffling and disturbing murder investigation.

____________


If you value this kind of storytelling and want to help us keep making it, you can become a Long Story Short supporter at LSSpodcast.com. You’ll get early, ad-free access to episodes, as well as some subscriber-only bonus content every season.


Also, don't forget to sign up to our FREE FORTNIGHTLY NEWSLETTER, so you’ll hear from us each time a new story drops, along with podcast recommendations and stray thoughts

More episodes

View all episodes

  • 3. Eugene and Gene Thomas (part 2): Three trials for murder

    45:56||Season 2, Ep. 3
    Secret recordings. Disputed forensic tests. Three murder trials. The prosecution of John Barlow for killing father and son businessmen Eugene and Gene Thomas is anything but straightforward. Adam and Eugene (Bingham) dig through court files and trial coverage, following the case all the way to the Privy Council. They weigh the Crown and defence accounts of what happened in that Wellington office. Can the prosecution make a conviction stick? Or has Barlow been wrongly accused?
  • 2. Eugene and Gene Thomas (part 1): A boardroom double murder

    48:17||Season 2, Ep. 2
    A cleaner finds father and son Eugene and Gene Thomas dead in their downtown Wellington office one evening in 1994. They’d been due to meet business acquaintance and gun collector John Barlow, but he tells police the meeting never went ahead. Then his story starts to unravel. A crucial clue sends police searching the city’s refuse tip, where a discovery convinces them they have their man. But the arrest of John Barlow is not the end of this case – not by a long shot, as Adam and Eugene (Bingham) explain.
  • 1. Mercy mistress, mercy: The strange death of Peter Plumley-Walker

    51:10||Season 2, Ep. 1
    In 1989, a jetboat skipper spots something snagged on a submerged tree, just downstream from the picturesque Huka Falls. It’s the body of a 51-year-old cricket umpire, Peter Plumley-Walker – bound hand and foot. Police soon figure out Plumley-Walker was last seen at a bondage session with a young sex worker and her boyfriend. But was his death a terrible accident – or murder?Adam Dudding and Eugene Bingham revisit a sensational case involving secret witnesses, duelling pathologists and three murder trials that had the nation transfixed.
  • From the archives: an episode of Out of My Mind

    39:21||Season 1
    Season two of Long Story Short is sooooooooo close – but in the meantime, check out this episode from a series Adam and Eugene made for Stuff a few years back, called Out of My Mind. Each episode of this series is one person who has struggled with their mental health, talking openly about their lived experience and their path to recovery. This episode is called Angels and Demons, and the voice you’ll hear is Egan Bidois, who was institutionalised after seeing and hearing things that no one else could perceive; but who then found a remarkable way to navigate the world – and thrive.This is the last of three “inter-season” bonus eps.The first episode of Season Two of Long Story Short is coming very very soon!* Content warning: Strong language; discussion of suicide.* If you want to talk to a trained counsellor, call or text for free to 1737.
  • Inter-season special: Dame Juliet Gerrard interview

    46:36||Season 1
    The countdown to new Long Story Short eps continues, but in the meantime Eugene and Adam caught up with Dame Juliet Gerrard, former chief science adviser to PM Jacinda Ardern (as well as two other PMs called Chris). We first met Dame Juliet when doing interviews for the podcast Quarantine Nation, about NZ’s experience of the Covid pandemic. She was a great interview subject back then, so when we heard she’d written a whole book about her time advising the government on matters scientific, we had to read it, and then after reading it we had to talk to her. Luckily, we hit record, so now you can listen to that conversation.Links to stuff in the episode- Dame Juliet’s book: https://aucklanduniversitypress.co.nz/front-row-seat/- Stuck: How Vaccine Rumours Start and Why They Don’t Go Away: global.oup.com/academic/product/stuck-9780190077242- You Are Here: A Field Guide for Navigating Polarized Speech, Conspiracy Theories, and Our Polluted Media Landscape: https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262361378/you-are-here/Other Long Story Short LinksSign up for our free newsletter: https://lss-newsletter.netlify.app/Follow us on Instagram: @lsspodcastnzBecome a supporter: lsspodcast.com
  • From the archives: a bonus ep from our 2022 podcast True Story

    47:41||Season 1
    We’re busy making season two of Long Story Short, but in the meantime, check out this episode from a series we made a few years back when we were working at Stuff, called True Story. This episode was called The Great Macron War, and it’s a story about language, online feuds and dirty deeds done in the dead of the night. Thanks to Stuff for letting us showcase this from their amazing podcast archives, and if you want to hear more of the True Story series, go to https://www.stuff.co.nz/truestory. We have a couple more treats coming up on this feed, then in late October, Long Story Short’s Season Two begins!
  • 7. Sounds Like Murder: The Scott Watson case (Part 2)

    50:37||Season 1, Ep. 7
    Scott Watson has spent more than two decades in prison for the murders of Olivia Hope and Ben Smart – crimes he has always denied committing.In part two of this series, Eugene Bingham and Adam Dudding investigate the holes in the case, the troubling circumstances surrounding key witness Guy Wallace, Eugene's encounter with a secret witness, and the long-running campaign to free Scott Watson.
  • 6. Sounds Like Murder: The Scott Watson case (Part 1)

    43:34||Season 1, Ep. 6
    The disappearance of Olivia Hope and Ben Smart from a party on New Year's Eve, 1997, sparked one of New Zealand's biggest and most controversial police investigations.Their bodies were never found, but detectives believe they found the killer: Scott Watson.In part one of this two-part series, Eugene Bingham and Adam Dudding examine the critical evidence – hairs from a tiger-print blanket, hotly disputed eyewitness accounts, and the hunt for a mysterious missing ketch.
  • 5. Censors Gone Wild: The movie that broke the purity police's brain

    40:53||Season 1, Ep. 5
    In 1967, a film was released that was so shocking, so arousing, and so full of rude words that the NZ censor banned men and women from sitting together when watching it.Adam Dudding and Eugene Bingham get out the popcorn and investigate what happened when the movie of James Joyce’s high-art novel Ulysses arrived downunder. It's tale of pearl-clutching, patriarchy and a punch-up in a projector-room.(Content warning: there are, unavoidably, quite a few rude words)