Share

cover art for Professor Russell Napier: The equity index fund is a dangerous product

Investors' Chronicle

Professor Russell Napier: The equity index fund is a dangerous product

The outbreak of Covid-19 sparked a transformation in monetary policy, according to Professor Russell Napier, with governments now effectively controlling money supply. Combine this with a decoupling between the West and China and Napier thinks investors must brace for a period of prolonged inflation. 


In this interview, Napier tells the IC’s Mary McDougall what a new era of financial repression might mean for investors, why he thinks China is not investable and where he thinks the best value is in equity markets. He also explains why he thinks it's time to invest with active fund managers over index funds and what he thinks are the most common mistakes that private investors make. 


Napier is a consultant, investor, historian, writer and Honorary Professor at both Heriot-Watt University and The University of Stirling. He’s advised institutions on asset allocation since the mid ‘90s and is chairman of Mid Wynd International Investment Trust. He's written two books: Anatomy of the Bear: Lessons from Wall St’s Four Great Bottoms and The Asian Financial Crisis 1995-98: Birth of the Age of Debt.


He also runs a course in finance called ‘The Practical History of Financial Markets’ and is keeper of The Library of Mistakes, a charitable venture he set up in Edinburgh in 2014. 


Time stamps


01:10 Takeaways from the launch of The Library of Mistakes

03:16 Outlook for inflation and money supply

06:05 Diminishing role of central banks

07:40 What indicators investors should look at

08:48 Outlook for equities

10:26 Implications of financial repression

13:48 Role of tax 

15:27 Impact of deglobalisation

18:20 Is China investable?

21:10 Companies that benefit from deglobalisation

23:40 Index funds vs active managers

28:28 Categorising by country vs sector

31:38 Suggestions for novice investors

33:18 Research of Hendrik Bessembinder

34:45 Infrastructure and property

38:29 Re-equitisation

41:42 Problems with the search for yield

44:20 Biggest personal mistake

46:00 Most common mistakes made by private investors






Investors' Chronicle has supported private investors in the UK for over 160 years by highlighting rewarding investment opportunities.


Investors' Chronicle is a service by the Financial Times.

More episodes

View all episodes

  • Labour’s social media plans, house prices and legal stocks: Companies and Markets Show

    26:46|
    This week’s show begins with Labour’s decision to force tech giants to give more prominence to traditional news broadcasters on social media, to help battle misinformation. Valeria Martinez discusses what this quick-fire solution to get younger people to engage with older news outlets means for investors and the companies involved.We then turn to Britain’s housing market as the cost of homes crept up in June. Hugh Moorhead dives into whether it’s showing signs of meaningful recovery, regional trends and how affordability pressures are affecting buyers. Hugh also talks through housebuilder Vistry’s dramatic share price plunge this week.Finally, Julian Hofmann discusses the success of legal firm Knights after it released positive results this week. With its acquisition-led strategy proving fruitful and cash generation benefiting shareholders, Julian explores how it’s growing without resorting to borrowing.Time stamps: 00:00 Introduction03:39 Broadcasters13:18 Outlook for Britain's housing market19:34 Knights results Listen to more podcasts from Investors’ Chronicle on Apple, Spotify and YouTube
  • What is the gender health gap – and how to beat it

    24:44|
    The gender health gap is an issue which affects far more than just wellbeing; it impacts your career, earnings and long-term financial stability.In this episode of Women and Wealth, funds editor Val Cipriani and personal finance editor Holly McKechnie walk you through why women experience poorer health than men, how it is a systemic issue of under-investment in women’s healthcare and what this means for your finances. The duo explore how the menopause and conditions such as endometriosis affect your earnings and pension pot. Holly and Val also explain how employers can improve support and offer practical steps women can take to protect their pockets from sudden or long-term illness.Women and Wealth is the monthly podcast series from Investors’ Chronicle. You can listen to and watch the episodes alongside our other podcasts on Acast, Apple, Spotify or YouTube.If you have any questions you’d like Val and Holly to answer, email womenandwealth@ft.comTimestamps 00:00 Introduction 01.19 What the gender health gap is and how it impacts your finances11.46 Impact of menopause and endometriosis on a your working life15: 51 Practical things to improve your financial security24:13 Outro
  • AI vs recruiters, another IPO and farming stocks

    35:28|
    In this week’s episode, we turn to Britain’s recruitment stocks. Valeria Martinez looks at the impact of AI on hiring demand, which is hitting share prices, and also discusses the perennial question: is the new technology a concern or an opportunity?Next, we cast our ears to Italian tech buyout specialist, and Baillie Gifford favourite, Bending Spoons, following its Nasdaq debut earlier this week. Val Cipriani dives into its growth strategy and what the IPO means for investors and the likes of Scottish Mortgage.Lastly, Julian Hofmann looks at agricultural supplier Wynnstay (WYN), after it announced positive results despite headwinds for the farming sector. Julian explores how the company is navigating volatile fertiliser prices, cutting costs, and the reasons to be optimistic.Timestamps00:00 Introduction04:20 AI vs the recruitment sector15:12 Bending Spoons25:03 Wynnstay resultsListen to more podcasts from Investors’ Chronicle on Apple, Spotify and YouTube
  • Ocado, asset managers and Telecom Plus: Companies and Markets Show

    29:08|
    This week, we begin with online grocer Ocado (OCDO) following reports of a CEO switch. Julian Hofmann dives into what a potential change at the top will mean for the FTSE 250 company that has struggled to deliver despite decades of investing in its technology. Next, we turn to Liontrust Asset Management (LIO), where, despite another year of poor results, it reported an early completion for its acquisition of River Global. Christopher Akers explores the positive response to the news and whether M&A offers a road to recovery.Lastly, we look at Telecom Plus (TEP), better known as Utilities Warehouse, after it slashed dividend payouts and cut forecasts. Julian is back to discuss the provider’s plans to kick-start customer growth and considers whether investors are right to have confidence in the turnaround. Timestamps00:00 Intro06:33 Ocado12:17 Liontrust Asset Management20:08 Telecom PlusListen to more podcasts from Investors’ Chronicle on Apple, Spotify and YouTube
  • AO World, wealth managers & Castings: Companies and Markets Show

    31:15|
    This week, we begin proceedings with a look at the contrasting fortunes of two UK wealth managers: Aim-traded Tatton Asset Management (TAM) continues to reap rewards from its dominance of the model portfolio market. But its older rival, Rathbones (RAT), ran into trouble this week when it announced it would temporarily stop accepting investments from some higher-risk clients following a review by the regulator. Chris Akers is with us to shed some light on both situations.After that we look at online retailer AO World (AO.), which continues to make a better fist than it once did of operating in an environment of shaky consumer confidence. Erin Withey will talk about the company’s growth strategy and its plans to return money to shareholders.Lastly we turn to Castings (CGS), the 190-year old foundry operator that sells into the HGV market. Mark Robinson is here to analyse its recent results and to consider whether this is a turnaround situation.Timestamps00:00 Intro01:03 Wealth Managers09:47 AO World20:22 CastingsListen to more podcasts from Investors’ Chronicle on Apple, Spotify and YouTube
  • Meeting with Fevara’s CEO: Lee and the IC

    44:04|
    Fevara (FVA:127p) may be new in name, but its roots and expertise stretch back more than a century through the former Carr’s Group. In the wake of this major transformation, the livestock supplements company’s focus is now on improving farming productivity through its advanced animal feed technology and supplements, and overseas expansion.Alongside chief executive Joshua Hoopes, Alex Newman and Lord Lee delve into the company’s strategy both at home and in South America. They cover Fevara’s lofty ambitions in Brazil – its acquisitions so far, the competitive advantages of the country, and the company’s targets for long-term growth. They also discuss why Hoopes believes Fevara can continue growing despite structural changes across the agricultural sector, and issues concerning sustainability and the climate crisis.The trio also explore shareholder returns, dividend policy and the outlook for global cattle markets.Let us know your thoughts, or if you have any questions or any suggestions for future guests, by emailing alex.newman@ft.comTimestamps00:00 Intro02:48 Fevara’s transformation07:00 Fevara’s feed supplements17:18 Why Brazil is Fevara’s biggest growth opportunity27:39 Sustainability, emissions and the future of cattle farming38:04 Lord Lee’s latest portfolio movesListen to more podcasts from Investors’ Chronicle by clicking here or heading to Apple, Spotify and YouTube
  • Investing in photonics, GSK and new opportunities in venture capital: Companies and Markets Show

    33:03|
    This week’s show dives straight into safety and equipment maker Halma (HLMA), which reported its full-year results on Thursday morning. It may be time to re-evaluate the company’s description as one of the FTSE 100’s least newsworthy businesses – it has been reaping the rewards of the AI boom. But with increased interest comes heightened expectations, and perhaps this is why its shares tumbled by 15 per cent on the day of the results. Mark Robinson digs into the details on whether this ‘quality stock’ is more volatile than it once was.We then turn to big pharma giant GSK (GSK). The drugmaker made its largest deal in over a decade earlier this week with the acquisition of US cancer biotech Nuvalent. Julian Hofmann takes a look at the $11bn deal and what it means for the future of the pharmaceutical company.Finally we discuss venture capital trust Molten Ventures (GROW), whose investments in the likes of fintech Revolut and microsatellite operator ICEYE have helped boost its returns. Mark is back to explore its portfolio and looks at whether the trust is morphing into something different.Timestamps00:00 Introduction01:22 Halma14:47 GSK23:06 Molten Ventures32:25 OutroListen to more podcasts from Investors’ Chronicle on Apple, Spotify and YouTube
  • Investing in British Water, Nick Train & CMC: Companies and Markets Show

    36:01|
    This week’s show dives straight into trading platform CMC Markets, after its promise of an imminent inflection point sent its shares soaring to the top of the FTSE All-Share leaderboard on Thursday. Julian Hofmann discusses the business’s full-year figures, its big future plans and whether it’s becoming a more reliable investment.We then turn to this week’s Big Read on how to tap into Britain’s mammoth water plan; the £100bn strategy to shore up and hopefully improve the dismal state of the country’s infrastructure. Will it succeed? And will it lead to new business for contractors and those working on new technologies? Hugh Moorhead has the answers.Finally, we take a look at beleaguered fund manager Nick Train’s latest attempts to encourage investors to stick by him during a period of significant underperformance. Holly McKechnie tells us what changes are being made to Finsbury Growth & Income Trust (FGT).Read more here:How investors can tap into Britain’s waterworks planWill Nick Train’s Finsbury Growth turnaround plan work?CMC Markets’ shares jump on upgraded outlookTimestamps00:00 Intro01:08 CMC13:33 Britain’s waterworks29:15 Nick Train’s new strategyListen to more podcasts from Investors’ Chronicle on Apple, Spotify and YouTube
  • ‘Bottlenecks are the best way to benefit from AI’: Ali Unwin of Polar Capital Technology

    46:30|
    Polar Capital Technology Trust (PCT) is one of the most popular and best-performing tech-focused funds available to DIY investors, having built up its record and fan base long before the likes of AI and ‘Magnificent Seven’ became everyday terms. And deputy manager Ali Unwin has been part of that story since 2021, helping investors access the best and brightest, and yet-to-be-discovered names in the tech world.Val Cipriani sits down with Ali to discuss the fund’s approach in the changing AI space, how to go find the right companies when traditional ways to value stocks are stretched, a world beyond the likes of Nvidia, and plenty more.