Share
I Could Murder A Podcast
The Legend of The Flying Dutchman
Season 13, Ep. 13
•
For centuries, sailors have told stories of a mysterious ship doomed to roam the oceans forever.
The legend of the Flying Dutchman is one of the oldest and most chilling maritime myths ever recorded. Said to appear during violent storms and thick sea fog, the ghostly vessel became a terrifying omen for crews crossing dangerous waters.
From whispered sightings in the 1700s to reports involving royal passengers, experienced captains, and entire crews, the story has refused to disappear. Some believed it was a warning of disaster. Others claimed the ship was cursed, trapped between life and death for eternity.
But where did the legend begin? Was there ever a real ship behind the tale, or did fear and isolation at sea create the perfect ghost story?
In this episode, we explore the origins of the Flying Dutchman, the most famous sightings throughout history, and why this phantom ship still haunts popular culture today.
Perfect listening for a dark night at sea…
For HUNDREDS of more cases (and to request your own), visit icmap.co.uk now and sign up for free!
Presented by Tom Norris & Ben Carter
Written by Ben Carter
Produced by Dan J Lambert
Edited by Ben Bonsey
More episodes
View all episodes
6. Michele Anne Harris: A 9/11 Murder Mystery
01:16:16||Season 14, Ep. 6As America reeled from the attacks of September 11, 2001, Michele Anne Harris disappeared from upstate New York.Her estranged husband, Cal Harris, became the focus of the investigation and would eventually face four murder trials. He was convicted twice, both convictions were overturned, and in 2016 he was found not guilty.Michele has never been found, leaving behind one of New York’s most extraordinary unsolved mysteries.5. The Yoghurt Shop Murders
01:05:51||Season 14, Ep. 5In December 1991, four teenage girls were found murdered inside a burning yoghurt shop in Austin, Texas.The investigation that followed became one of America’s most notorious cold cases, involving false confessions, overturned convictions and decades of unanswered questions. Then, more than 30 years later, new DNA evidence finally pointed investigators towards a suspect.This is the disturbing story of the Yoghurt Shop Murders and the extraordinary investigation that followed.4. Britain’s Youngest Killer: Mary Bell
01:17:41||Season 14, Ep. 4In 1968, Newcastle was shaken by a case almost impossible to comprehend. Mary Bell was just 10 years old when four-year-old Martin Brown and three-year-old Brian Howe were killed.By the age of 11, Bell had been convicted of both killings, becoming one of the youngest killers in British history. But behind the headlines was an extraordinarily troubled childhood and a case that still raises uncomfortable questions about violence, responsibility and whether a child can truly understand the consequences of their actions.3. Iryna: The Girl On The Train
01:02:19||Season 14, Ep. 3Iryna Zarutska fled the war in Ukraine hoping to build a new life in America. On August 22, 2025, the 23-year-old boarded a light-rail train in Charlotte, North Carolina, on her way home from work.Minutes later, she was fatally attacked without warning. Police arrested Decarlos Brown Jr., a complete stranger who had been sitting behind her.The case of Iryna Zarutska would quickly raise troubling questions about public safety, mental health and whether this tragedy could have been prevented.2. From YouTuber to Murderer: Stephen McCullagh
01:06:30||Season 14, Ep. 2When Natalie McNally was found murdered in her home, her boyfriend appeared to have the perfect alibi: he had been livestreaming on YouTube all night. But investigators soon discovered that the six-hour broadcast had been recorded days earlier.This is the disturbing case of a calculated murder, a carefully staged online alibi and the digital evidence that exposed the truth.1. A Fatal Fetal Abduction: Taylor Parker
01:09:27||Season 14, Ep. 1ICMAP IS BACK. AND WE’RE BACK FOREVER.That’s right. From now on, you can expect a brand new I Could Murder A Podcast episode EVERY. SINGLE. WEEK. Until the end of time.We’re ridiculously excited to be back and we want you involved. Send us your case requests, share the show with your mates, leave a comment, hit like wherever you can and help us spread the word.No more waiting for the next series. ICMAP is now ALWAYS ON.For nearly a year, Taylor Parker convinced those around her that she was pregnant. She wore a fake bump, staged ultrasounds and even held a gender reveal.But as her supposed due date approached, the lie became impossible to maintain.In October 2020, Parker murdered 21-year-old Reagan Simmons-Hancock, who was 35 weeks pregnant, and attempted to take her unborn baby as her own.For extra content, bonus episodes and discount codes for merch, visit: www.icmap.co.uk12. Josef Mengele: “The Angel Of Death”
01:36:15||Season 13, Ep. 12HOLY SH*T?! Join the soft drink REVOLUTION! 🎉 Get 10% off using code ICMAP OR £5 off your first order using code ICMAP5: https://uk.holy.com/icmapDuring World War II, one name became closely associated with the horrors of Auschwitz: Josef Mengele.A trained physician and officer within the Nazi regime, Mengele carried out a series of so-called medical experiments on prisoners, actions that have since become some of the most widely condemned in modern history.After the war ended, he evaded capture for decades, moving across continents while international efforts to locate him continued. His disappearance, and the years he spent in hiding, added another layer to a story already defined by cruelty and unanswered questions.In this episode, we examine his early life, his role during the war, the global manhunt that followed, and how his legacy continues to shape discussions around ethics, accountability, and justice.11. The Feral Child: "Genie", Locked Away For 13 Years...
01:26:42||Season 13, Ep. 11Support ICMAP... HOLY SH*T?! Join the soft drink REVOLUTION! 🎉 Get 10% off using code ICMAP OR £5 off your first order using code ICMAP5: https://uk.holy.com/icmapIn 1970, authorities in California made a discovery that would go on to become one of the most widely studied and debated cases in modern psychology.A young girl, later known as Genie, had spent most of her childhood in extreme isolation, cut off from the outside world during her most important developmental years.When she was finally found, her condition raised profound questions about language, human development, and the long-term effects of deprivation. Scientists, doctors, and researchers became deeply involved in her case, hoping to better understand what happens when a child grows up without normal social interaction.But alongside the scientific interest came ethical concerns, controversy, and ongoing debate about how her case was handled.In this episode, we explore Genie’s early life, her discovery, the intense attention that followed, and the lasting questions her story continues to raise today...