I Could Murder A Podcast

Christa Pike became one of the youngest women ever sentenced to death in the United States after the 1995 case involving 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer.More than 30 years later, the Christa Pike case returned to the headlines after an attempt to carry out her execution went badly wrong, reigniting debate around Tennessee’s death penalty and the long legal battle surrounding her sentence.In this episode, I Could Murder A Podcast explores the full Christa Pike story, from the crime that put her on death row to the appeals, controversy and extraordinary events surrounding the failed execution.

McKamey Manor, America's most controversial horror experience, promised to push participants to their absolute breaking point through hours of psychological torment and physical endurance.Guests signed lengthy waivers before entering, but former participants later alleged they were subjected to waterboarding, restraints, simulated drowning and abuse, with some claiming their pleas to stop were ignored.Was it an extreme horror attraction built on consent, or something far more sinister? Founder Russ McKamey faced a Tennessee Attorney General investigation following the allegations, while a Hulu documentary brought renewed scrutiny to the experience...Join us as we enter McKamey Manor...

The year is 1871. The American Wild West is in full swing. Rural parts of the country remain almost entirely lawless, and, deep in the unforgiving heart of the Southeast Kansas Prairie, a lone traveller slowly guides his horse through a sea of eight-foot tall grass as he makes his way towards a remote wooden cabin… For the traveller, the cabin was the first thing he had seen in days - and he and his horse could finally switch off and take some well-earned rest. He had made his way along the Great Osage Trail, covering hundreds of miles where hundreds of men had vanished before him…During his travels, he saw no sign of outlaws, horse-thieves or highwaymen and, instead, was greeted by a charming frontier family and the offer of a warm, home-cooked meal… THIS was The Bender Family - and that warm, home-cooked meal that he was promised would very quickly become his last… The traveller and his horse were never seen again and he was far from their last victim… Welcome to The Devil’s Inn: this is the terrifying true story of The Bloody Benders…

For years, families trusted Robert Bush and Legacy Independent Funeral Directors with their loved ones.Then, in 2024, police entered the Hull premises and uncovered a horrifying reality. Bodies had been left for months, families had been given the wrong ashes, funeral plans had been misused and charity donations had been stolen.Bush eventually pleaded guilty to 67 offences and was sentenced to 20 years in prison, leaving hundreds of families questioning what had really happened to their loved ones.

On May 25, 1979, six-year-old Etan Patz left his New York home to walk to the school bus stop alone for the first time.He never made it.His disappearance became one of the most famous missing child cases in American history and helped transform the way missing children were publicised across the country. Decades later, Pedro Hernandez was convicted of Etan’s kidnapping and murder, but Etan’s body has never been found.

In 1892, Andrew and Abby Borden were found brutally murdered inside their Massachusetts home.Their daughter Lizzie was arrested and put on trial, but despite becoming one of the most infamous murder suspects in American history, she was acquitted.More than 130 years later, the case remains officially unsolved. So what really happened inside the Borden house, and did Lizzie actually get away with murder?

As America reeled from the attacks of September 11, 2001, Michele Anne Harris disappeared from upstate New York.Her estranged husband, Cal Harris, became the focus of the investigation and would eventually face four murder trials. He was convicted twice, both convictions were overturned, and in 2016 he was found not guilty.Michele has never been found, leaving behind one of New York’s most extraordinary unsolved mysteries.

In December 1991, four teenage girls were found murdered inside a burning yoghurt shop in Austin, Texas.The investigation that followed became one of America’s most notorious cold cases, involving false confessions, overturned convictions and decades of unanswered questions. Then, more than 30 years later, new DNA evidence finally pointed investigators towards a suspect.This is the disturbing story of the Yoghurt Shop Murders and the extraordinary investigation that followed.